Skip to main content

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND CASE STUDIES: Building Green Infrastructure via Citizen Participation: A Six-Year Study in the Shepherd Creek (Ohio)

  • Audrey L. Mayer (a1), William D. Shuster (a2), Jake J. Beaulieu (a3), Matthew E. Hopton (a3), Lee K. Rhea (a3), Allison H. Roy (a4) and Hale W. Thurston (a3)...

Green infrastructure at the parcel scale provides critical ecosystem goods and services when these services (such as flood mitigation) must be provided locally. Here we report on an approach that encourages suburban landowners to mitigate impervious surfaces on their properties through a voluntary auction mechanism. We used an economic incentive to place rain gardens and rain barrels onto parcels in a 1.8-km2 watershed near Cincinnati, Ohio. A comprehensive hydrologic, water-quality, and ecological monitoring campaign documented environmental conditions before and after treatment. In 2007 and 2008, we engaged private landowners through a reverse auction to encourage placement of one rain garden and up to four rain barrels on their property. The program led to the installation of 83 rain gardens and 176 rain barrels onto more than 20% of the properties, and preliminary analyses indicate that the overall discharge regime was altered by the treatments. The length of the study (six years) may have precluded observation of treatment effects on water quality and aquatic biological communities, as we would expect these conditions to respond more slowly to management changes. These distributed storm-water installations contributed to ecosystem services such as flood protection, water supply, and water infiltration; provided benefits to the local residents; and reduced the need for larger, expensive, centralized retrofits (such as deep tunnel storage).

Environmental Practice 14:57–67 (2012)

Corresponding author
Audrey L. Mayer, Michigan Technological University, School of Forest Resources and Environmental Science & Department of Social Sciences, 1400 Townsend Drive, Houghton, MI 49931; (phone) 1-906-487-3448; (e-mail)
Hide All
Ab Razak, I.A., and Christensen, E.R.. 2001. Water Quality before and after Deep Tunnel Operation in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Water Research 35(11):26832692.
Altor, A. 2010. Green Roofing in Indiana: Case Studies and Design Notes. Journal of Green Building 5(3):5068.
Angier, J.T., and McCarty, G.W.. 2008. Variations in Base-flow Nitrate Flux in a First-Order Stream and Riparian Zone. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 44(2):367380.
Bardenheier, B.H. 2009. PROC MIXED: Macro to Assess Fixed and Random Effects for Significance Using the Likelihood Ratio Test and the Approximate Mixture Method. Paper SC-013. In SAS Conference Proceedings: Southeast SAS Users Group, Birmingham, Alabama, October 25–27, 2009. SAS Institute Users Group International (SUGI), Cary, NC, 7 pp. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
Bernot, M.J., Sobota, D.J., Hall, R.O. Jr., Mulholland, P.J., Dodds, W.K., Webster, J.R., Tank, J.L., Ashkenas, L.R., Cooper, L.W., Dahm, C.N., Gregory, S.V., Grimm, N.B., Hamilton, S.K., Johnson, S.L., McDowell, W.H., Meyer, J.L., Peterson, B., Poole, G.C., Valett, H.M., Arango, C., Beaulieu, J.J., Burgin, A.J., Crenshaw, C., Helton, A.M., Johnson, L., Merriam, J., Niederlehner, B.R., O'Brien, J.M., Potter, J.D., Sheibley, R.W., Thomas, S.M., Wilson, K.. 2010. Inter-regional Comparison of Land-Use Effects on Stream Metabolism. Freshwater Biology 55(9):18741890.
Box, G.E.P., Jenkins, G.M., and Reinsel, G.C.. 1994. Time Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control. Prentice Hall, Englewood, NJ, 598 pp.
Brabec, E., Schulte, S., and Richards, P.L.. 2002. Impervious Surfaces and Water Quality: A Review of Current Literature and Its Implications for Watershed Planning. Journal of Planning Literature 16(4):499514.
Bunn, S.E., and Davies, P.M.. 2000. Biological Processes in Running Waters and Their Implications for the Assessment of Ecological Integrity. Hydrobiologia 422423:6170.
Colón-Gaud, C., Whiles, M.R., Brenes, R., Kilham, S.S., Lips, K.R., Pringle, C.M., Connelly, S., and Peterson, S.D.. 2010. Potential Functional Redundancy and Resource Facilitation between Tadpoles and Insect Grazers in Tropical Headwater Streams. Freshwater Biology 55(10):20772088.
The Conservation Fund. 2011. Green Infrastructure. The Conservation Fund, Arlington, VA. (accessed August 18, 2011).
Davis, A.P., Hunt, W.F., Traver, R.G., and Clar, M.. 2009. Bioretention Technology: Overview of Current Practice and Future Needs. Journal of Environmental Engineering 135(3):109117.
Dreher, D. 2009. Chicago Wilderness Green Infrastructure Vision: Challenges and Opportunities for the Built Environment. Journal of Green Building 4(3):7288.
Erickson, D.L. 2006. MetroGreen: Connecting Open Space in North American Cities. Island Press, Washington, DC, 333 pp.
Faith, D.P., Humphrey, C.L., and Dostine, P.L.. 1991. Statistical Power and BACI Designs in Biological Monitoring: Comparative Evaluation of Measures of Community Dissimilarity Based on Benthic Macroinvertebrate Communities in Rockhole Mine Creek, Northern Territory, Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 42(5):589602.
Fletcher, T.D., Walsh, C.J., Bos, D., Nemes, V., RossRakesh, S., Prosser, T., Hatt, B.E., and Birch, R.. 2011. Restoration of Stormwater Retention Capacity at the Allotment-Scale through a Novel Economic Instrument. Water Science and Technology 64(2):494502.
Gilroy, K.L., and McCuen, R.H.. 2009. Spatio-temporal Effects of Low Impact Development Practices. Journal of Hydrology 367(3-4):228236.
Hawthorne, M. 2011. Feds Probe Chronic Sewage Overflows into Lake, Streams. Chicago Tribune, March 19, 2011.
Klepal, C. 2001. The Big Drain for Flash Floods. Cincinnati Enquirer, August 12, 2001, p. 1.
Konrad, C.P., and Booth, D.B.. 2005. Hydrologic Changes in Urban Streams and Their Ecological Significance. American Fisheries Society Symposium 47:157177. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
Marzolf, E.R., Mulholland, P.J., and Steinman, A.D.. 1994. Improvements to the Diurnal Upstream-Downstream Dissolved-Oxygen Change Technique for Determining Whole-Stream Metabolism in Small Streams. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 51(7):15911599.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment. 2003. Ecosystems and Human Well-being: A Framework for Assessment. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Series. Island Press, Washington, DC, 245 pp. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
Mulholland, P.J., Fellows, C.S., Tank, J.L., Grimm, N.B., Webster, J.R., Hamilton, S.K., Martiâ, E., Ashkenas, L., Bowden, W.B., Dodds, W.K., McDowell, W.H., Paul, M.J., and Peterson, B.J.. 2001. Inter-biome Comparison of Factors Controlling Stream Metabolism. Freshwater Biology 46(11):15031517.
Mysiak, J., Guipponi, C., and Rosato, P.. 2005. Towards the Development of a Decision Support System for Water Resource Management. Environmental Modelling and Software 20(2):203214.
Nimick, D.A., Gammons, C.H., and Parker, S.R.. 2011. Diel Biogeochemical Processes and Their Effect on the Aqueous Chemistry of Streams: A Review. Chemical Geology 283(1-2):317.
Oberndorfer, E., Lundholm, J., Bass, B., Coffman, R.R., Doshi, H., Dunnett, N., Gaffin, S., Köhler, M., Liu, K.K.Y., and Rowe, B.. 2007. Green Roofs as Urban Ecosystems: Ecological Structures, Functions, and Services. BioScience 57(10):823833.
Parikh, P., Taylor, M., Hoagland, T., Thurston, H., and Shuster, W.. 2005. Application of Market Mechanisms and Incentives to Reduce Stormwater Runoff: An Integrated Hydrologic, Economic, and Legal Approach. Environmental Science and Policy 8(2):133144.
Pataki, D.E., Carreiro, M.M., Cherrier, J., Grulke, N.E., Jennings, V., Pincetl, S., Pouyat, R.V., Whitlow, T.H., and Zipperer, W.C.. 2011. Coupling Biogeochemical Cycles in Urban Environments: Ecosystem Services, Green Solutions, and Misconceptions. Frontiers in Ecology and Environment 9(1):2736.
Pincetl, S. 2010. From the Sanitary City to the Sustainable City: Challenges to Institutionalizing Biogenic (Nature's Services) Infrastructure. Local Environment 15(1):4358.
Polasky, S., Caldarone, G., Duarte, T.K., Goldstein, J., Hannahs, N., Ricketts, T., and Tallis, H.. 2011. Putting Ecosystem Service Models to Work: Conservation, Management, and Trade-offs. In Natural Capital: Theory and Practice of Mapping Ecosystem Services, Kareiva, P., Tallis, H., Ricketts, T.H., Daily, G.C. and Polasky, S., eds. Oxford University Press, New York, 249263.
Shuster, W., Bonta, J., Thurston, H., Warnemuende, E., and Smith, D.R.. 2005. Impacts of Impervious Surface on Watershed Hydrology: A Review. Urban Water Journal 2(4):263275.
Shuster, W.D., Morrison, M.A., and Thurston, H.W.. 2010. Seasonal and Situational Impacts on the Effectiveness of a Decentralized Stormwater Management Program in the Reduction of Runoff Volume (Cincinnati OH; USA). In NOVAtech 2010, Lyon, France, June 27–July 1, 2010. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
Shuster, W.D., and Rhea, L.K.. In review. Hydrologic Implications of Parcel-Level Stormwater Management at the Catchment Scale (Ohio, USA). Journal of Hydrology.
Spatari, S., Yu, Z., and Montalto, F.A.. 2011. Life Cycle Implications of Urban Green Infrastructure. Environmental Pollution 159(8-9):21742179.
Testa, S. III, Shields, F. D. Jr., and Cooper, C.M.. 2011. Macroinvertebrate Response to Stream Restoration by Large Wood Addition. Ecohydrology 4(5):631643.
Thurston, H., Goddard, H.C., Szlag, D., and Lemberg, B.. 2003. Controlling Stormwater Runoff with Tradable Allowances for Impervious Surfaces. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 129(5):409418.
Thurston, H.W., Roy, A.H., Shuster, W.D., Cabezas, H., Morrison, M.A., and Taylor, M.A.. 2008. Using Economic Incentives to Manage Stormwater Runoff in the Shepherd Creek Watershed, Part I. EPA/600/R-08/129. US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, 58 pp. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
Thurston, H.W., Taylor, M.A., Shuster, W.D., Morrison, A.H. Roy and M.A.. 2010. Using a Reverse Auction to Promote Household Level Stormwater Control. Environmental Science & Policy 13(5):405414.
United Nations (UN). 2010. World Urbanization Prospects: The 2009 Revision. UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, New York. (accessed 9 August 2011).
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 1999. Preliminary Data Summary of Urban Stormwater Best Management Practices. EPA-821-R-99-012. USEPA, Washington, DC, 216 pp. Available at (accessed February 12, 2012).
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 2009. Managing Stormwater with Low Impact Development Practices: Addressing Barriers to LID. EPA-901-F-09-003. USEPA New England, Boston, 7 pp. (accessed February 12, 2012).
Van De Meene, S.J., and Brown, R.R.. 2009. Delving into the “Institutional Black Box”: Revealing the Attributes of Sustainable Urban Water Management Regimes. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 45(6):14481464.
Walsh, C.J., Fletcher, T.D., and Ladson, A.R.. 2005. Stream Restoration in Urban Catchments through Re-designing Stormwater Systems: Looking to the Catchment to Save the Stream. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24(3):690705.
Walsh, C.J., Roy, A.H., Feminella, J.W., Cottingham, P.D., Groffman, P.M., and Morgan, R.P.. 2005. The Urban Stream Syndrome: Current Knowledge and the Search for a Cure. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24(3):706723.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Practice
  • ISSN: 1466-0466
  • EISSN: 1466-0474
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-practice
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 92 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 478 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th March 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.