Skip to main content

Failure of hand disinfection with frequent hand washing: a need for prolonged field studies

  • Juhani Ojajärvi (a1), Paavo Mäkelä (a1) and Ilari Rantasalo (a1)

In a prolonged field trial a 4% chlorhexidine digluconate detergent scrub (HibiscrubR), that had earlier proved to be an effective hand disinfectant, was studied in hospital wards. Finger tips were found to harbour more bacteria than the hand dorsum and the samples collected from them yielded more information on the bacteriological and dermatological effects of hand disinfectants in practice.

In wards with a relatively low hand-washing frequency (less than 20 times in 8 hours) the bacteriological results resembled those obtained by in-use tests with volunteers. In the neonatal unit where the hand washing frequency was remarkably high, even occasionally over 100 times/8 h shift, an increase in the bacterial colony counts of the majority of the staff was recorded both before and after hand washing already after using the preparation for 1 week. Age, occupation and hand-washing frequency all correlated with the bacteriological results. Twenty-seven out of 37 persons complained of side effects such as wounds of finger tips and redness or heavy drying of the skin. Wounds, particularly on finger tips, resulted in the failure of disinfection. An increase in bacterial counts was sometimes noted without any dermatological or subjective changes. Drying of the skin was complained of less often when no increase in skin bacteria occurred.

After the changeover of washing practice to a detergent followed by a rinse with spirit solution containing chlorhexidine and glycerol a decrease was recorded in the bacterial counts. It is concluded that more attention should be paid to long-term testing of hand washing and disinfection methods to ensure optimum final results in practice. It is obvious that the knowledge obtained from short time in-use testing cannot be applied to all conditions of use.

Hide All
Ayliffe G. A. J., Babb J. R., Bridges K., Lilly H. A., Lowbury E. J. L., Varney J. & Wilkins M. D. (1975). Comparison of two methods for assessing the removal of total organisms and pathogens from the skin. Journal of Hygiene 75, 259.
Brunn J. N., Bøe J. & Solberg C. O. (1968). Disinfection of the hands of ward personnel. A comparison of six disinfectants. Acta medica scandinavica 184, 417.
Brunn J. N. & Solberg C. O. (1973). Hand carriage of gram-negative bacilli and Staphylococcus aureus. British Medical Journal ii, 580.
Cooley W. W. & Lohnes P. R. (1962). Multivariate Procedures for Behavioral Sciences. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
France D. R. (1968). Survival of Candida albicans in hand creams. New Zealand Medical Journal 67, 552.
Hall L. B. & Hartnett M. J. (1964). Measurement of the bacterial contamination on surfaces in hospitals. Public Health Reports 79, 1021.
Joress S. M. (1962). A study of disinfection of the skin: A comparison of Povidone–Iodine with other agents for surgical scrubs. Annals of Surgery 155, 296.
Knights H. T. & Harvey J. (1964). Hand creams containing hexachlorophene and cross infection with gram-negative bacteria. New Zealand Medical Journal 63, 653.
Lowbury E. J. L. & Lilly H. A. (1960). Disinfection of the hands of surgeons and nurses. British Medical Journal i, 1445.
Lowbury E. J. L. & Lilly H. A. (1973). Use of 4% chlorhexidine detergent solution (Hibiscrub) and other methods of skin disinfection. British Medical Journal i, 510.
Lowaury E. J. L., Lilly H. A. & Bull J. P. (1960). Disinfection of the skin of operation sites. British Medical Journal ii, 1039.
Lowbury E. J. L., Lilly H. A. & Bull J. P. (1964 a). Disinfection of hands: Removal of transient organisms. British Medical Journal ii, 230.
Lowbury E. J. L., Lilly H. A. & Bull J. P. (1964 b). Methods for disinfection of hands and operation sites. British Medical Journal ii, 531.
Lilly H. A. & Lowbury E. J. L. (1971). Disinfection of the skin: An assessment of some new preparations. British Medical Journal iii, 674.
Lilly H. A. & Lowbury E. J. L. (1974). Disinfection of the skin with detergent preparations of Irgasan DP 300 and other antiseptics. British Medical Journal iv, 372.
Morse L. J. & Schonbeck L. E. (1968). Hand lotions – a potential nosocomial hazard. New England Journal of Medicine 278, 376.
Ojajärvi J. (1976). An evaluation of antiseptics used for hand disinfection in wards. Journal of Hygiene 76, 75.
Poland M. K. (1968). The interaction of detergents and the human skin. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 19, 3.
Rubenstein A. D. & Morse L. J. (1967). Study reveals hand lotions may be source of gramnegative bacteria. New England Journal of Medicine 277, 472.
Spiegel M. R. (1961). Theory and Problems of Statistics. New York: Schaum Publishing Co.
Wilson P. E. (1970). A comparison of methods for assessing the value of antibacterial soaps. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 33, 574.
Walter C. W. (1965). Disinfection of hands. American Journal of Surgery 109, 691.
Walter C. W. & Kundsin R. B. (1969). The bacteriologic study of surgical gloves from 250 operations. Surgery, Gynecology and Obstetrics 129, 949.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Epidemiology & Infection
  • ISSN: 0950-2688
  • EISSN: 1469-4409
  • URL: /core/journals/epidemiology-and-infection
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 9 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 244 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.