Skip to main content

Discussion of ‘Metamorphic PT and retrograde path of high-pressure Barrovian metamorphic zones near Cairn Leuchan, Caledonian orogen, Scotland’

  • D. R. Viete (a1), G. J. H. Oliver (a2) and S. A. Wilde (a3)

D. R. Viete, G. J. H. Oliver and S. A. Wilde comment: First, we would like to commend Aoki et al. (2013) on a careful study and thought-provoking manuscript. Their interpretation of the Barrovian metamorphism as a fundamentally retrograde feature offers a refreshing alternative to the more conventional ‘peak-metamorphic’ models.

Hide All
Aoki, K., Windley, B. F., Maruyama, S. & Omori, S. 2013. Metamorphic PT and retrograde path of high-pressure Barrovian metamorphic zones near Cairn Leuchan, Caledonian orogen, Scotland. Geological Magazine, published online 13 August 2013. doi:
Ashcroft, W. A., Kneller, B. C., Leslie, A. G. & Munro, M. 1984. Major shear zones and autochthonous Dalradian in the north-east Scottish Caledonides. Nature 310, 760–2.
Baker, A. J. 1985. Pressures and temperatures of metamorphism in the eastern Dalradian. Journal of the Geological Society 142, 137–48.
Baker, A. J. 1986. Eclogitic amphibolites from the Grampian Moines. Mineralogical Magazine 50, 217–21.
Barrow, G. 1893. On an intrusion of muscovite-biotite gneiss in the southeastern Highlands of Scotland and its accompanying metamorphism. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society 49, 330–58.
Barrow, G. 1912. On the geology of Lower Dee-side and the southern Highland Border. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association 23, 274–90.
Baxter, E. F., Ague, J. J. & DePaolo, D. J. 2002. Prograde temperature-time evolution in the Barrovian type-locality constrained by Sm/Nd garnet ages from Glen Clova, Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society 159, 7182.
Brewer, T. S., Storey, C. D., Parrish, R. R., Temperley, S. & Windley, B. F. 2003. Grenvillean age decompression of eclogites in the Glenelg-Attadale Inlier, NW Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society 160, 565–74.
Chew, D. M., Daly, J. S., Page, L. M. & Kennedy, M. J. 2003. Grampian orogenesis and the development of blueschist-facies metamorphism in western Ireland. Journal of the Geological Society 160, 911–24.
Chew, D. M., Graham, J. R. & Whitehouse, M. J. 2007. U-Pb zircon geochronology of plagiogranites from the Lough Nafooey (= Midland Valley) arc in western Ireland: constraints on the onset of Grampian orogeny. Journal of the Geological Society 164, 747–50.
Clark, C., Fitzsimmons, I. C. W., Healy, D. & Harley, S. L. 2011. How does the continental crust get really hot? Elements 7, 235–40.
Connolly, J. A. D. 2005. Computation of phase equilibria by linear programming: a tool for geodynamic modeling and its application to subduction zone decarbonization. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236, 524–31.
Daly, J. S. 1996. Pre-Caledonian history of the Annagh Gneiss Complex, north-western Ireland, and correlation with Laurentia-Baltica. Irish Journal of Earth Sciences 15, 518.
Daly, J. S. & Flowerdew, M. J. 2005. Grampian and late Grenville events recorded by mineral geochronology near a basement-cover contact in north Mayo, Ireland. Journal of the Geological Society 162, 163–74.
Dewey, J. F. 2005. Orogeny can be very short. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102, 15286–93.
England, P. C. & Thompson, A. B. 1984. Pressure-temperature-time paths of regional metamorphism I. Heat transfer during the evolution of regions of thickened crust. Journal of Petrology 25, 894928.
Fettes, D. J., Graham, C. M., Harte, B. & Plant, J. A. 1986. Lineaments and basement domains: an alternative view of Dalradian evolution. Journal of the Geological Society 143, 453–64.
Fettes, D. J., Leslie, A. G., Stephensons, D. & Kimbell, S. F. 1991. Disruption of Dalradian stratigraphy along the Portsoy Lineament from new geological and magnetic surveys. Scottish Journal of Geology 27, 5773.
Flowerdew, M. J. & Daly, J. S. 2005. Sm-Nd mineral ages and P-T constraints on the pre-Grampian high grade metamorphism of the Slishwood Division, north-west Ireland. Irish Journal of Earth Sciences 23, 107–23.
Goodman, J. A. D. 1994. The Portsoy-Duchray Hill Lineament: a review of the evidence. Geological Magazine 130, 407–15.
Harley, S. L. 1998. On the occurrence and characterization of ultrahigh-temperature metamorphism. In What Drives Metamorphism and Metamorphic Reactions? (eds Treloar, P. J. & O'Brien, P. J.), pp. 81107. Geological Society of London, Special Publication no. 138.
Holland, T. J. B. & Powell, R. 1998. An internally consistent thermodynamic data set for phases of petrological interest. Journal of Metamorphic Geology 16, 309–43.
Johnson, M. R. W. & Strachan, R. A. 2006. A discussion of possible heat sources during nappe stacking: the origin of the Barrovian metamorphism within the Caledonian thrust sheets of NW Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society 163, 579–82.
Kennedy, M. J. & Menuge, J. F. 1992. The Inishkea Division of NW Mayo: Dalradian cover rather than pre-Caledonian basement. Journal of the Geological Society 149, 167–70.
MacAteer, C. A., Daly, J. S., Flowerdew, M. J., Whitehouse, M. J. & Kirkland, C. L. 2010. A Laurentian provenance for the Dalradian rocks of north Mayo, Ireland, and evidence for an original basement-cover contact with the underlying Annagh Gneiss Complex. Journal of the Geological Society 167, 1033–48.
Max, M. D. & Long, C. B. 1985. Pre-Caledonian basement in Ireland and its cover relationships. Geological Journal 20, 341–66.
Max, M. D. & Sonet, J. 1979. A Grenville age for pre-Caledonian rocks in NW Co. Mayo, Ireland. Journal of the Geological Society 136, 379–82.
Oliver, G. J. H., Chen, F., Buchwaldt, R. & Hegner, E. 2000. Fast tectonometamorphism and exhumation in the type area of the Barrovian and Buchan zones. Geology, 28, 459–62.
Oliver, G. J. H., Wilde, S. A. & Wang, Y. 2008. Geochronology and geodynamics of Scottish granitoids from the late Neoproterozoic break-up of Rodinia to Paleozoic collision. Journal of the Geological Society 165, 661–74.
Pfiffner, O. A. & Ramsay, J. G. 1982. Constraints on geological strain rates: argumentd from finite strain states of natural rocks. Journal of Geophysical Research B 87, 311–21.
Pidgeon, R. T., Fufaro, A., Kennedy, A. K., Nemchin, A. A., van Bromswjk, W. & Todt, W. A. 1994. Calibration of zircon standards for the Curtin SHRIMP II. US Geological Survey Circular 1107, 251.
Powell, R. & Holland, T. J. B. 1988. An internally consistent dataset with uncertainties and correlations: 3. Applications to geobarometry, worked examples and a computer program. Journal of Metamorphic Geology 6, 173204.
Ramsay, D. M. & Sturt, B. A. 1979. The status of the Banff Nappe. In The Caledonides of the British Isles - Reviewed (eds Harris, A. L., Holland, C. H. & Leake, B. E.), pp. 145–51. Geological Society of London, Special Publication no. 8.
Read, H. H. 1927. The igneous and metamorphic history of Cromar, Deeside, Aberdeenshire. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 55, 317–53.
Read, H. H. 1928. The highland schists of middle Deeside and east Glen Muick. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 55, 755–72.
Read, H. H. 1955. The Banff Nappe: an interpretation of the structure of the Dalradian rocks of north-east Scotland. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association 66, 129.
Rivers, T. 1997. Lithotectonic elements of the Grenville province: review and tectonic implications. Precambrian Research 86, 117–54.
Sanders, I. S., Daly, J. S. & Davies, G. R. 1987. Late-Proterozoic high-pressure granulite facies metamorphism in the north-east Ox Inlier, north-west Ireland. Journal of Metamorphic Geology 5, 6985.
Sanders, I. S., van Calsteren, P. W. C. & Hawkesworth, C. J. 1984. A Grenville Sm-Nd age for the Glenelg eclogite in north-west Scotland. Nature 312, 439–40.
Sturt, B. A., Ramsay, D. M., Pingle, I. R. & Teggin, D. E. 1977. Precambrian gneisses in the Dalradian sequence of northeast Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society 134, 41–4.
Sutton, J. S. & Max, M. D. 1969. Gneisses in the north-western part of County Mayo, Ireland. Geological Magazine 106, 284–90.
Toksöz, M. N. & Bird, P. 1977. Modelling of temperatures in continental convergences zones. Tectonophysics 41, 181–93.
Viete, D. R., Oliver, G. J. H., Fraser, G. L., Forster, M. A. & Lister, G. S. 2013. Timing and heat sources for the Barrovian metamorphism, Scotland. Lithos 177, 148–63.
Viete, D. R., Richards, S. W., Lister, G. S., Oliver, G. J. H. & Banks, G. J. 2010. Lithospheric-scale extension during Grampian orogenesis in Scotland. In Continental Tectonics and Mountain Building: The Legacy of Peach and Horne (eds Law, R. D., Butler, R. W. H., Holdsworth, R. E., Krabbendam, M. & Strachan, R. A.), pp. 121–60. Geological Society of London, Special Publication no. 335.
Vilà, M., Fernández, M. & Jiménez-Munt, I. 2010. Radiogenic heat production variability of some common lithological groups and its significance to lithospheric thermal modelling. Tectonophysics 490, 152–64.
Yuen, D. A., Fleitout, L., Schubert, G. & Froidevaux, C. 1978. Shear deformation zones along major transform faults and subducting slabs. Geophysical Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society 54, 93119.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Geological Magazine
  • ISSN: 0016-7568
  • EISSN: 1469-5081
  • URL: /core/journals/geological-magazine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed