Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

The Ethnic Implications of Preferential Voting

  • John Coakley and Jon Fraenkel
Abstract

Around the turn of the century, political developments in Northern Ireland, Fiji and Papua New Guinea encouraged claims that preferential voting systems could steer polities in the direction of ‘moderate’ multi-ethnic government. Sixteen years later, we have a longer time period and larger volume of data to reassess these verdicts. This article investigates ballot transfer and party vote–seat share patterns in the seven deeply divided polities with some experience of preferential voting for legislative elections or direct presidential elections (Northern Ireland, Fiji, Papua New Guinea, Estonia, Sri Lanka, Bosnia-Herzegovina and Southern Rhodesia). We find little support for centripetalist claims that such systems encourage ‘moderate’ parties. We argue that where district magnitude is low, where voters are required to rank preferences and where ticket voting prevails, departures from vote–seat proportionality may favour ‘moderate’ parties, but such heavily engineered systems may simply advantage the larger parties or yield erratic outcomes.

Copyright
Footnotes
Hide All
*

John Coakley is a Professor in the School of History, Anthropology, Philosophy and Politics, Queen’s University Belfast, and Professor Emeritus, University College Dublin. Contact email: j.coakley@qub.ac.uk.

John Fraenkel is a Professor in the School of History, Philosophy, Political Science and International Relations, Victoria University of Wellington. Contact email: jon.fraenkel@vuw.ac.nz.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
ARK (2016), Northern Ireland Election Results, www.ark.ac.uk/elections/.
Barkan, J. (1995), ‘Elections in Agrarian Societies’, Journal of Democracy, 6(4): 106116.
Belloni, R. (2004), ‘Peacebuilding and Consociational Electoral Engineering in Bosnia and Herzegovina’, International Peacekeeping, 11(2): 334353.
Belloni, R. (2007), State Building and International Intervention in Bosnia (London: Routledge).
Bose, S. (2002), Bosnia after Dayton: Nationalist Partition and International Intervention (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Chandra, K. (2005), ‘Ethnic Parties and Democratic Stability’, Perspectives on Politics, 3(2): 235252.
Coakley, J. (2009), ‘The Political Consequences of the Electoral System in Northern Ireland’, Irish Political Studies, 24(3): 253284.
Dinnen, S. (1998), ‘Weakness and Strength – State, Society and Order in Papua New Guinea’, in P. Dauvergne (ed.), Weak and Strong States in Asia-Pacific Societies (London: Allen and Unwin): 38–59.
Elliott, S. (1973), Northern Ireland Parliamentary Election Results 1921–1972 (Chichester: Political Reference Publications).
Elliott, S. and Wilford, R.A. (1983), The 1982 Northern Ireland Assembly Election (Glasgow: Centre for the Study of Public Policy, University of Strathclyde).
Endersby, J.W. and Towle, M.J. (2014), ‘Making Wasted Votes Count: Turnout, Transfers, And Preferential Voting in Practice’, Electoral Studies, 33(1): 144152.
Evans, G. and O’Leary, B. (2000), ‘Northern Irish Voters and the British--Irish Agreement: Foundations of a Stable Consociational Settlement?’, Political Quarterly, 71(1): 78101.
Fiji Elections Office (1999), Elections ’99: Results by the Count (Suva: Government Printer).
Fiji Elections Office (2001), General Elections 2001: Results by the Count (Suva: Government Printer).
Fiji Elections Office (2006), Election Results by the Count, 2006 (Suva: Government Printer).
Fraenkel, J. (2001), ‘The Alternative Vote System in Fiji: Electoral Engineering or Ballot-rigging?’, Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 39(1): 131.
Fraenkel, J. (2015a), ‘The Remorseless Power of Incumbency in Fiji’s September 2014 Election’, Round Table, 104(2): 151164.
Fraenkel, J. (2015b), ‘“Equal Rights for Every Civilized Man South of the Zambesi”: Electoral Engineering in Southern Rhodesia 1957–65’, Journal of Southern African Studies, 41(6): 11671180.
Fraenkel, J. and Grofman, B. (2004), ‘A Neo-Downsian Model of the Alternative Vote as a Mechanism for Mitigating Ethnic Conflict in Plural Societies’, Public Choice, 121(3–4): 487506.
Fraenkel, J. and Grofman, B. (2006a), ‘Does the Alternative Vote Foster Moderation in Ethnically Divided Societies? The Case of Fiji’, Comparative Political Studies, 39(5): 623651.
Fraenkel, J. and Grofman, B. (2006b), ‘The Failure of the Alternative Vote as a Tool for Ethnic Moderation in Fiji: A Rejoinder to Horowitz’, Comparative Political Studies, 39(5): 663666.
Fraenkel, J. and Grofman, B. (2007), ‘The Merits of Neo-Downsian Modelling of the Alternative Vote: A Reply to Horowitz’, Public Choice, 133(1–2): 111.
Fraenkel, J. and Grofman, B. (2014), ‘The Borda Count and its Real World Alternatives: Comparing Scoring Rules in Nauru and Slovenia’, Australian Journal of Political Science, 49(2): 186205.
Gallagher, M. (1978), ‘Party Solidarity, Exclusivity and Inter-Party Relationships in Ireland, 1922–1977: The Evidence of Transfers’, Economic and Social Review, 10(1): 122.
Guelke, A. (2012), Politics in Deeply Divided Societies (Cambridge: Polity).
Hirczy de Miño, W. and Lane, J.-E. (1996), ‘STV in Malta: Some Surprises’, Representation, 34(1): 2128.
Horowitz, D.L. (1985), Ethnic Groups in Conflict (Berkeley: University of California Press).
Horowitz, D.L. (1989), ‘Incentives and Behaviour in the Ethnic Politics of Sri Lanka and Malaysia’, Third World Quarterly, 10(4): 1835.
Horowitz, D.L. (1991), A Democratic South Africa? Constitutional Engineering in a Divided Society (Berkeley: University of California Press).
Horowitz, D.L. (2001), ‘The Northern Ireland Agreement: Clear, Consociational and Risky’, in J. McGarry (ed.), Northern Ireland and the Divided World: Post-Agreement Northern Ireland in Comparative Perspective (Oxford: Oxford University Press): 109136.
Horowitz, D.L. (2002a), ‘Constitutional Design: Proposals Versus Processes’, in A. Reynolds (ed.), The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management, and Democracy (Oxford: Oxford University Press): 1536.
Horowitz, D.L. (2002b), ‘Explaining the Northern Ireland Agreement: The Sources of an Unlikely Constitutional Consensus’, British Journal of Political Science, 32(2): 193220.
Horowitz, D.L. (2004), ‘The Alternative Vote and Ethnic Moderation: A Reply to Fraenkel and Grofman’, Public Choice, 121(3–4): 507516.
Horowitz, D.L. (2006), ‘Strategy Takes a Holiday: Fraenkel and Grofman on the Alternative Vote’, Comparative Political Studies, 39(5): 652662.
ICG (International Crisis Group) (1998), ‘Changing the Logic of Bosnian Politics’, ICG Discussion Paper on Electoral Reform, 10 March.
Jansen, H. (2004), ‘The Political Consequences of the Alternative Vote: Lessons from Western Canada’, Canadian Journal of Political Science, 37(3): 647669.
Ketan, J. (2004), The Name Must Not Go Down; Political Competition and State–Society Relations in Mount Hagen, Papua New Guinea (Suva: Institute of Pacific Studies, USP).
Lakeman, E. (1955), Voting in Democracies: A Study of Majority and Proportional Electoral Systems (London: Faber).
Laponce, J. (1957), ‘The Protection of Minorities by the Electoral System’, Western Political Quarterly, 10(2): 318339.
Lardeyret, G. (1991), ‘The Problem with PR’, Journal of Democracy, 2: 3035.
Lawrence, R.J., Elliott, S. and Laver, M.J. (1975), The Northern Ireland General Elections of 1973, Cmnd 5851 (London: HMSO).
Lijphart, A. (1977), Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration (New Haven: Yale University Press).
Lijphart, A. (1985), ‘Power-Sharing in South Africa’, Policy Papers in International Affairs, 24 (Berkeley: Institute of International Studies, University of California).
Lijphart, A. (1991), ‘The Alternative Vote: A Realistic Alternative for South Africa?’, Politikon, 18(2): 91101.
Mackenzie, W.J.M. (1954), ‘Representation in Plural Societies’, Political Studies, 2(1): 5469.
Manning, C. and Antić, M. (2003), ‘Lessons from Bosnia and Herzegovina: The Limits of Electoral Engineering’, Journal of Democracy, 14(3): 4559.
Mansergh, N. (1936), The Government of Northern Ireland: A Study in Devolution (London: George Allen and Unwin).
May, R. (2006), ‘Political Parties in Papua New Guinea’, in R. Rich, L. Hambly and M. Morgan (eds), Political Parties in the Pacific Islands (Canberra: Pandanus): 83102.
May, R.J., Wheen, K. and Haley, N. (2011), ‘Assessing the Shift to Limited Preferential Voting’, in R.J. May, R. Anere, N. Haley and K. Wheen (eds), Election 2007: The Shift to Limited Preferential Voting in Papua New Guinea (Port Moresby: National Research Institute (PNG) and Canberra: State, Society and Governance in Melanesia Program, Australian National University): 193205.
McAllister, I. (1975), ‘The 1975 Northern Ireland Convention Election’, University of Strathclyde Occasional Paper 14 (Glasgow: Survey Research Centre).
McGarry, J. and O’Leary, B. (2006), ‘Consociational Theory, Northern Ireland’s Conflict, and its Agreement, Part 2: What Critics of Consociationalism Can Learn from Northern Ireland’, Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics, 41(2): 249277.
McGarry, J. and O’Leary, B. (2009), ‘Power Shared after the Deaths of Thousands’, in R. Taylor (ed.), Consociational Theory: McGarry and O’Leary and the Northern Ireland Conflict (London: Routledge): 1584.
Mietzner, M. (2008), ‘Comparing Indonesia’s Party Systems of the 1950s and the Post-Suharto Era: From Centrifugal to Centripetal Inter-Party Competition’, Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 39(3): 431453.
Mitchell, P. (2014), ‘The Single Transferable Vote and Ethnic Conflict: The Evidence from Northern Ireland, 1982–2007’, Electoral Studies, 33(1): 246257.
Mitchell, P., Evans, G. and O’Leary, B. (2009), ‘Extremist Outbidding in Ethnic Party Systems is Not Inevitable: Tribune Parties in Northern Ireland’, Political Studies, 57(2): 397421.
Palley, C. (1978), Constitutional Law and Minorities (London: Minority Rights Group), (Report no. 36).
Papua New Guinea Electoral Office (1973), Report of the Chief Electoral Officer on the 1972 House of Assembly General Election (Port Moresby: Government Printer).
Passmore, G.C. and Mitchell, M.T. (1963), Sourcebook of Parliamentary Elections and Referenda in Southern Rhodesia, 18981962 (Salisbury: Department of Government, University College of Rhodesia and Nyasaland).
Punnett, R.M. (1987), ‘The Alternative Vote with Optional Use of Preferences: Some Irish Lessons for Britain and Australia’, Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 25(1): 2643.
Reilly, B. (2001), Democracy in Divided Societies: Electoral Engineering for Conflict Management (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Reilly, B. (2002), ‘Back to the Future? The Political Consequences of Electoral Reform in Papua New Guinea’, Journal of Pacific History, 37(2): 239253.
Reilly, B. and Reynolds, A. (2000), Electoral Systems and Conflict in Divided Societies (Washington, DC: National Academy Press).
Reynolds, A. (1995), ‘Constitutional Engineering in South Africa’, Journal of Democracy, 6(1): 8699.
Reynolds, A., Reilly, B. and Ellis, A. with others (2006), Electoral System Design: The New International IDEA Handbook (Stockholm: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance).
Salamey, I. and Pearson, F. (2005), ‘The Crisis of Federalism and Electoral Strategies in Iraq’, International Studies Perspectives, 6(2): 190207.
Sartori, G. (1968), ‘Political Development and Political Engineering’, in J.D. Montgomery and A.O. Hirschman (eds), Public Policy, Vol. 17 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press) 261298.
Sharman, C., Sayers, A.M. and Miragliotta, N. (2002), ‘Trading Party Preferences: The Australian Experience of Preferential Voting’, Electoral Studies, 21(4): 543560.
Standish, B. (1978), ‘The “Big Man” Model Reconsidered: Power and Stratification in Chimbu’, Institute of Applied Social and Economic Research Discussion Paper 22 (Boroko, Papua New Guinea): 1–43.
Stone, D. (1976), ‘The Political Turning Point: The Birth of the National Coalition Government’, in D. Stone (ed.), Prelude to Self-Government: Electoral Politics in Papua New Guinea 1972 (Canberra: Australian National University): 529538.
Strathern, A. (1993), ‘Violence and Political Change in Papua New Guinea’, Pacific Studies, 16(4): 4160.
Taagepera, R. (1990), ‘The Baltic States’, Electoral Studies, 9(4): 303311.
Taagepera, R. (1996), ‘STV in Transitional Estonia’, Representation, 34(1): 2936.
Territory of Papua and New Guinea (1964), Statistical Returns Showing the Voting Within Each Open and Special Electorate in Relation to the General Election for the House of Assembly (Port Moresby: Government Printer).
Territory of Papua and New Guinea (1968), Report of the Chief Electoral Officer on the House of Assembly Election, 1968 (Port Moresby: Government Printer).
Wilford, R. (2010), ‘Northern Ireland: The Politics of Constraint’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63(1): 134155.
Wimmer, A. (2003–4), ‘Democracy and Ethno-religious Conflict in Iraq’, Survival, 45(4): 111134.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Government and Opposition
  • ISSN: 0017-257X
  • EISSN: 1477-7053
  • URL: /core/journals/government-and-opposition
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed