Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Global Shifts and the Limits of the EU’s Transformative Power in the European Periphery: Comparative Perspectives from Hungary and Turkey

  • Ziya Öniş and Mustafa Kutlay
Abstract

This article highlights the weakening of the EU’s transformative capacity in the broader European periphery in a rapidly shifting global order, with reference to Hungary and Turkey. Although Hungary is an ‘insider’ and Turkey a relative ‘outsider’, their recent experiences display strikingly similar patterns, raising important concerns about the EU’s leverage. Under the influence of strong nationalist-populist leaders backed by powerful majorities, both countries have been moving in an increasingly illiberal direction, away from well-established EU norms. The article proposes an analytical framework based on a combination of push and pull factors that are driven by changing global political economy dynamics, which explains the EU’s declining appeal in its periphery, not only in reference to the internal dynamics of European integration and its multiple crises, but also the appeal of illiberal versions of strategic capitalism employed by rising powers, which serve as reference points for the elites of several states in diverse geographic settings.

Copyright
Footnotes
Hide All
*

Ziya Öniş is Professor of International Political Economy in the Department of International Relations at Koç University, Istanbul. Contact email: zonis@ku.edu.tr.

Mustafa Kutlay is Assistant Professor of International Political Economy in the Department of Political Science and International Relations at TOBB University of Economics and Technology, Ankara. Contact email: mkutlay@etu.edu.tr.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Acemoğlu, D. and Robinson, J. (2012), Why Nations Fail? (London: Penguin Books).
Acemoğlu, D. and Üçer, M. (2015), The Ups and Downs of Turkish Growth, 2002–2015: Political Dynamics, the European Union and the Institutional Slide, NBER Working Paper 21608, October.
Ágh, A. (2016), ‘The Decline of Democracy in East-Central Europe: Hungary as a Worst-case Scenario’, Problems of Post-Communism, 63(5–6): 277–87.
Aktar, C. (2015), ‘AB ve Erdoğan, Hayal Dünyası’, Taraf, 17 October.
Alpan, B. and Diez, T. (2014), ‘The Devil is in the “Domestic”? European Integration Studies and the Limits of Europeanization in Turkey’, Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 16(1): 110.
Aydın-Düzgit, S. (2006), Seeking Kant in the EU’s Relations with Turkey (Istanbul: TESEV Publications).
Bader, J., Grävingholt, J. and Kästner, A. (2010), ‘Would Autocracies Promote Autocracy? A Political Economy Perspective on Regime-type Export in Regional Neighbourhoods’, Contemporary Politics, 16(1): 81100.
Batory, A. (2016), ‘Populists in Government? Hungary’s “System of National Cooperation”’, Democratization, 23(2): 283303.
Berberoğlu, E. (2013), ‘EU Not a Must for Turkey: PM Erdoğan’, Hurriyet Daily News, 6 February.
Blyth, M. (2013), Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Bohle, D. (2014), ‘Post-Socialist Housing Meets Transnational Finance: Foreign Banks, Mortgage Lending, and the Privatization of Welfare in Hungary and Estonia’, Review of International Political Economy, 21(4): 913948.
Bonatti, L. and Fracasso, A. (2013), ‘The German Model and the European Crisis’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 51(6): 10231039.
Börzel, T.A. and Risse, T. (2000), When Europe Hits Home: Europeanization and Domestic Change, European Integration Online Paper (EIoP) 4(15).
Börzel, T.A. and Risse, T. (2009), The Transformative Power of Europe: The European Union and the Diffusion of Ideas, KFG Working Paper 1.
Bremmer, I. (2010), The End of the Free Market (New York: Portfolio).
Byrne, A. and Oliver, C. (2015), ‘Hungary’s Russian-Built Energy Plants Rebuked’, Financial Times, 19 November.
Bulut, Y. (2014a), ‘Türkiye, Avrupa Birliği Projesinin ‘Alternatifi’ Olabilir’, Star, 15 January.
Bulut, Y. (2014b), ‘2023 Büyük Türkiye Doktrini Yazılmaya Başlandı’, Star, 11 August.
Cengiz, F. (2014), ‘The Future of Democratic Reform in Turkey: Constitutional Moment or Constitutional Process?’, Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics, 49(4): 682703.
Christiansen, T., Jørgensen, K.E. and Wiener, A. (1999), ‘The Social Construction of Europe’, Journal of European Public Policy, 6(4): 528544.
Csaba, L. (2012), ‘Hungary and the Eurozone Crisis: A Comedy of Errors?’, Yearbook of the Institute of East-Central Europe, 10(5): 3344.
Csaba, L. (2013), ‘Growth, Crisis Management and the EU: The Hungarian Trilemma’, Mitteilungen, 53(3): 155169.
Dandashly, A. (2015), ‘The EU Response to Regime Change in the Wake of the Arab Revolt: Differential Implementation’, Journal of European Integration, 37(1): 3756.
Davutoğlu, A. (2011), ‘Dışişleri Bakanı Sayın Davutoğlu’nun IV. Büyükelçiler Konferansı Vesilesiyle Trakya Üniversitesi’nde Yaptığı Konuşma’, speech, Trakya University, Edirne, 29 December, www.mfa.gov.tr/disisleri-bakani-sayin-ahmet-davutoglu_nun-iv_-buyukelciler-konferansi-vesilesiyle-trakya-universitesi-balkan-kongre-merkezi_nde.tr.mfa.
Davutoğlu, A. (2013), ‘Dışişleri Bakanı Sayın Ahmet Davutoğlu’nun Dış Ekonomik İlişkiler Kurulu Tarafından Düzenlenen Toplantıda Yaptıkları Konuşma’, speech, Istanbul, 9 March, www.mfa.gov.tr/disisleri-bakani-sayin-ahmet-davutoglu_nun-dis-ekonomik-iliskiler-kurulu-tarafindan-duzenlenen-toplantida-yaptiklari-konusma_-9.tr.mfa.
Davutoğlu, A. (2015), ‘Başbakan Davutoğlu’nun 17 Mart Tarihli TBMM Grup Toplantısı’, speech, TBMM, Ankara, 17 March, www.akparti.org.tr/site/haberler/basbakan-davutoglunun-17-mart-tarihli-tbmm-grup-toplantisi-konusmasinin-tam/72422#1.
Demirtaş, B. (2015), ‘Turkish Foreign Policy towards the Balkans: A Europeanized Foreign Policy in a De-Europeanized National Context?’, Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 17(2): 123140.
Diamond, L. (2015), ‘Facing up to the Democratic Recession’, Journal of Democracy, 26(1): 141155.
Diez, T. (2005), ‘Constructing the Self and Changing Others: Reconsidering “Normative Power Europe”’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 33(3): 613636.
Dinçer, O. B. and Kutlay, M. (2013), ‘The Arab Spring: A Game Changer in Turkey–EU Relations?’, Perspectives on European Politics and Society, 14(4): 418430.
The Economist (2012), ‘The Rise of State Capitalism’, 21 January.
Erdoğan, R.T. (2012), ‘Başbakan Erdoğan’ın 6 Kasım Tarihli TBMM Grup Toplantısı’, speech, TBMM, Ankara, 6 November, www.akparti.org.tr/site/haberler/basbakan-erdoganin-6-kasim-tarihli-tbmm-grup-toplantisi-konusmasinin-tam-me/33218#1.
Erdoğan, R.T. (2013), ‘Başbakan Erdoğan’ın 22 Ekim Tarihli TBMM Grup Toplantısı’, speech, TBMM, Ankara, 22 October, www.akparti.org.tr/site/haberler/basbakan-erdoganin-22-ekim-tarihli-tbmm-grup-toplantisi-konusmasinin-tam-me/53477#1.
Erdoğan, R.T. (2015), ‘Erdoğan: Avrupa Ölen Her Mültecinin Vebaline Ortaktır’, speech, 3 September, www.bbc.com/turkce/haberler/2015/09/150903_erdogan.
Ferguson, N. (2011), Civilization: The West and the Rest (New York: Penguin Books).
Freedom House (2015), ‘Freedom in the World 2015’, https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2015#.WS6HWlKZP-Y.
Füle, S. (2011), ‘Speech on the Recent Events in North Africa’, Committee on Foreign Affairs, European Parliament, Brussels, 28 February, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-11-130_en.htm.
Gambarotto, F. and Solari, S. (2015), ‘The Peripheralization of Southern European Capitalism Within the EMU’, Review of International Political Economy, 22(4): 788812.
Gat, A. (2007), ‘The Return of Authoritarian Great Powers’, Foreign Affairs, 86: 5969.
Grant, C. (2011), A New Neighborhood Policy for the EU, CER Policy Brief, 11 March.
Graziano, P.R. and Vink, M.P. (2006) (eds), Europeanization: New Research Agendas (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).
Hall, P.A. (2012), ‘The Economics and Politics of the Euro Crisis’, German Politics, 21(4): 355371.
Helleiner, E. (2010), ‘A Bretton Woods Moment? The 2007–2008 Crisis and the Future of Global Finance’, International Affairs, 86(3): 619636.
Hollis, R. (2012), ‘No Friend of Democratization: Europe’s Role in the Genesis of the “Arab Spring”’, International Affairs, 88(1): 8194.
İdiz, S. (2015), ‘Merkel’s Visit Strikes Cynical Chord in Turks’, Hurriyet Daily News, 20 October.
Ikenberry, G.J. (2010), ‘The Liberal International Order and its Discontents’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 38(3): 509521.
Jenne, E.K. and Mudde, C. (2012), ‘Hungary’s Illiberal Turn: Can Outsiders Help?’, Journal of Democracy, 23(3): 147155.
Johnson, J. and Barnes, A. (2015), ‘Financial Nationalism and its International Enablers: The Hungarian Experience’, Review of International Political Economy, 22(3): 535569.
Jones, E. (2015), ‘Getting the Story Right: How You Should Choose between Different Interpretations of the European Crisis (And Why You Should Care)’, Journal of European Integration, 37(7): 817832.
Kagan, R. (2003), Of Power and Paradise: America and Europe in the New World Order (New York: Alfred A. Knopf).
Kagan, R. (2008), The Return of History and the End of Dreams (New York: Knopf).
Keating, J. (2015), ‘Here’s Why Eastern Europe is so Much More Antagonistic to Syria’s Refugees than Western Europe’, The Slate, 14 September.
Keyman, E.F. and Aydın-Düzgit, S. (2013), EU–Turkey Relations and the Stagnation of Turkish Democracy, Global Turkey in Europe, Working Paper 02.
Kornai, J. (2015), ‘Hungary’s U-Turn’, Capitalism and Society, 10(1): 124.
Körösenyi, A. (1999), Government and Politics in Hungary (Budapest: Central European University Press).
Krastev, I. (2015), ‘Eastern Europe’s Compassion Deficit’, New York Times, 8 September.
Krugman, P. (2012), End this Depression Now! (New York: W.W. Norton & Company).
Kupchan, C. (2012), No One’s World: The West, the Rising Rest, and the Coming Global Turn (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Leonard, M. (2005), Why Europe Will Run the 21st Century (London and New York: Fourth Estate).
Manners, I. (2002), ‘Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 40(2): 235258.
Mastenbroek, E. and Kaeding, M. (2006), ‘Europeanization Beyond the Goodness of Fit: Domestic Politics in the Forefront’, Comparative European Politics, 4(4): 331354.
Matthijs, M. (2014), ‘Mediterranean Blues: The Crisis in Southern Europe’, Journal of Democracy, 25(1): 101115.
Matthijs, M. and Blyth, M. (2015), The Future of the Euro (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Menon, A. (2014), ‘Divided and Declining? Europe in a Changing World’, Journal of Common Market Studies, Annual Review, 52: 524.
Müftüler-Baç, M. (2008), ‘Turkey’s Accession to the European Union: The Impact of the EU’s Internal Dynamics’, International Studies Perspectives, 9(2): 201219.
Nathan, A. (2015), ‘China’s Challenge’, Journal of Democracy, 26(1): 156170.
New Europe (2016), ‘Erdogan Threatened to Flood Europe with Refugees’, New Europe, 9 February.
Newton, J. (2015), ‘Poland’s New PM Says the Country Will Not Accept an EU Quota of 4,500 Refugees in the Wake of the Paris Terror Attacks’, Daily Mail, 25 November.
Niblett, R. (2015), Britain, Europe and the World: Rethinking the UK’s Circles of Influence, Chatham House Research Paper, October.
Öniş, Z. (2008), ‘Turkey–EU Relations: Beyond the Current Stalemate’, Insight Turkey, 10(4): 3550.
Öniş, Z. (2015), ‘Monopolising the Center: The AKP and the Uncertain Path of Turkish Democracy’, International Spectator, 50(2): 2241.
Öniş, Z. (2016a), ‘Democracy in Uncertain Times: Inequality and Democratic Development in the Global North and Global South’, METU Studies in Development, 43(1): 317336.
Öniş, Z. (2016b), ‘Turkey’s Twin Elections and the AKP’s Comeback’, Journal of Democracy, 27(2): 141154.
Öniş, Z. and Güven, A.B. (2011), ‘The Global Economic Crisis and the Future of Neoliberal Globalization: Rupture vs. Continuity’, Global Governance, 17(4): 469488.
Öniş, Z. and Kutlay, M. (2013), ‘Rising Powers in a Changing Global Order: Political Economy of Turkey in the Age of BRICs’, Third World Quarterly, 34(8): 14091426.
Öniş, Z. and Yılmaz, Ş. (2016), ‘Turkey and Russia in a Shifting Global Order: Cooperation, Conflict and Asymmetric Interdependence in a Turbulent Region’, Third World Quarterly, 37(2): 7196.
Orban, V. (2014), ‘Full Text of Viktor Orban’s Speech at Baile Tuşnad’, speech, Baile Tuşnad, 26 July, http://budapestbeacon.com/public-policy/full-text-of-viktor-orbans-speech-at-baile-tusnad-tusnadfurdo-of-26-july-2014/10592.
Orban, V. (2015), ‘We are Protecting Europe’s Values’, 17 October, www.kormany.hu/en/the-prime-minister/news/we-are-protecting-europe-s-values.
Özbudun, E. (2014), ‘AKP at the Crossroads: Erdoğan’s Majoritarian Drift’, South European Society and Politics, 19(2): 155167.
Özel, I. (2015), Reverting Structural Reforms in Turkey: Towards an Illiberal Economic Governance? Global Turkey in Europe, Policy Brief 22, May.
Phinnemore, D. (2015), ‘Crisis-Ridden, Battered and Bruised: Time to Give Up on the EU?’, Journal of Common Market Studies, Annual Review, 53: 6174.
Prodi, R. (2000), ‘Shaping the New Europe’, speech, European Parliament, Strasbourg, 15 February, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-00-41_en.htm.
Reid, T.R. (2005), The United States of Europe: The New Superpower and the End of American Supremacy (London: Penguin Books).
Rodrik, D., Subramanian, A. and Trebbi, F. (2002), Institutions Rule: The Primacy of Institutions over Geography and Integration in Economic Development, NBER Working Paper 9305, November.
Saatçioğlu, B. (2016), ‘Turkey and the EU: Strategic Rapprochement in the Shadow of the Refugee Crisis’, E-International Relations, 21 January.
Schimmelfenning, F. and Sedelmeier, U. (2005) (eds), The Europeanization of Central and Eastern Europe (Cornell: Cornell University Press).
Smale, A. (2016), ‘Stance on Migrants Leaves Merkel Isolated at Home and in Europe’, New York Times, 22 January.
Strange, G. (2014), Towards a New Political Economy of Development: States and Regions in the Post-Neoliberal World (Basingstoke: Palgrave).
Tocci, N. and Cassarino, J. (2011), Rethinking the EU’s Mediterranean Policies Post-1/11, IAI Working Paper 1106, March.
Traynor, I. (2012), ‘Hungary Prime Minister Hits Out at EU Interference in National Day Speech’, Guardian, 15 March.
Vachudova, A.M. (2005), Europe Undivided: Democracy, Leverage, Integration After Communism (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Vollaard, H. (2014), ‘Explaining European Disintegration’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 52(5): 11421159.
Watkins, S. (2012), ‘Another Turn of the Screw’, New Left Review, 75: 513.
Webber, D. (2014), ‘How Likely is it that the European Union Will Disintegrate? A Critical Analysis of Competing Theoretical Perspectives’, European Journal of International Relations, 20(2): 341365.
Whitman, R.G. and Juncos, A.E. (2014), ‘Challenging Events, Diminishing Influence? Relations with the Wider Europe’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 52: 157169.
Williams, M. (2014) (ed.), The End of the Developmental State? (New York: Routledge).
Yaka, Ö. (2016), ‘Why Not EU? Dynamics of the Changing Turkish Attitudes towards EU Membership’, Journal of Contemporary European Studies, 24(1): 149170.
Yılmaz, G. (2015), ‘From Europeanization to De-Europeanization? The Europeanization Process of Turkey in 1999–2014’, Journal of Contemporary European Studies, 24(1): 86100.
Youngs, R. (2015), ‘Exploring Non-Western Democracy’, Journal of Democracy, 26(4): 140154.
Zielonka, J. (2014), Is the EU Doomed? (London: Polity Press).
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Government and Opposition
  • ISSN: 0017-257X
  • EISSN: 1477-7053
  • URL: /core/journals/government-and-opposition
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed