Skip to main content
×
×
Home

A European late starter: lessons from the history of reform in Irish health care

  • Maev-Ann Wren (a1) and Sheelah Connolly (a1)
Abstract

The Irish health care system is unusual within Europe in not providing universal, equitable access to either primary or acute hospital care. The majority of the population pays out-of-pocket fees to access primary health care. Due to long waits for public hospital care, many purchase private health insurance, which facilitates faster access to public and private hospital services. The system has been the subject of much criticism and repeated reform attempts. Proposals in 2011 to develop a universal health care system, funded by Universal Health Insurance, were abandoned in 2015 largely due to cost concerns. Despite this experience, there remains strong political support for developing a universal health care system. By applying an historical institutionalist approach, the paper develops an understanding of why Ireland has been a European outlier. The aim of the paper is to identify and discuss issues that may arise in introducing a universal healthcare system to Ireland informed by an understanding of previous unsuccessful reform proposals. Challenges in system design faced by a late-starter country like Ireland, including overcoming stakeholder resistance, achieving clarity in the definition of universality and avoiding barriers to access, may be shared by countries whose universal systems have been compromised in the period of austerity.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Correspondence to: The Economic and Social Research Institute, Whitaker Square, Sir John Rogerson’s Quay, Dublin 2, Ireland. Email: maev-ann.wren@esri.ie
References
Hide All
Amarach Research (2015), The Future of Ireland, Dublin, Ireland: OMD Ireland.
Bal, R. and Zuiderent-Jerak, T. (2011), ‘The practice of markets in Dutch health care: are we drinking from the same glass?’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 6(1): 139145.
Barrington, R. (1987), Health, Medicine and Politics in Ireland 1900–1970, Dublin: Institute of Public Administration.
Breen, R., Hannan, D., Rottman, D. and Whelan, C. (1990), Understanding Contemporary Ireland: State, Class and Development in the Republic of Ireland, Dublin: Gill and MacMillan.
Brick, A., Nolan, A., O’Reilly, J. and Smith, S. (2010), Resource Allocation, Financing and Sustainability in Health Care: Evidence for the Expert Group on Resource Allocation and Financing in the Health Sector, Dublin, Ireland: The Economic and Social Research Institute.
Browne, N. (1989), Against the Tide, Dublin: Gill and Macmillan.
Busse, R., Schreyögg, J. and Gericke, C. (2007), ‘Analyzing Changes in Health Financing Arrangements in High-Income Countries: A Comprehensive Framework Approach’. Health, Nutrition and Population (HNP) Discussion Paper, The World Bank.
Catholic Church (1963), Peace on Earth: Encyclical Letter of Pope John XXIII, London: Catholic Truth Society.
Central Statistics Office (2016), Ireland’s System of Health Accounts, Annual Results 2014, Dublin: Central Stastics Office.
Council of the European Union (2006), Council Conclusions on Common Values and Principles in EU Health Systems, Brussels: Council of the European Union.
Crouch, C. (1993), Industrial Relations and European State Traditions, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Dail Debates (2012), Speech by Minister of State, Roisin Shortall, in Motion of Confidence in the Minister for Health, Houses of the Oireachtas, Dáil Eireann Debate Volume 773 No. 2, http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates. Accessed August 23rd 2016.
Dail Debates (2016), ‘Role of the Committee on the Future of Healthcare’, http://www.oireachtas.ie/parliament/oireachtasbusiness/committees_list/future-of-healthcare/role/ [20 August 2016].
Daly, M. (1981), Social and Economic History of Ireland, Dublin: The Educational Company.
Department of Health (2014), ‘The Path to Universal Healthcare: White Paper on Universal Health Insurance’. Dublin, Ireland: Department of Health.
Department of Health (2015), Statement by Minister Varadkar Following Cabinet Discussion on UHI. Dublin, Ireland: Department of Health.
Department of Health (2016), ‘Progress on the first year of our three-year Statement of Strategy 2015–2017’, Annual Report 2015. Dublin, Ireland: Department of Health.
Department of the Taoiseach (2011), Programme for Government 2011–2016, Dublin, Ireland: Department of the Taoiseach.
Department of the Taoiseach (2016), A Programme for a Partnership Government, Dublin, Ireland: Department of the Taoiseach.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990), The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Cambridge: Polity Press.
Fine Gael (2009), ‘FairCare: Fine Gael Proposals to Reform the Health Service and Introduce Universal Health Insurance’. Fine Gael.
Fitzgerald, J. (2006), ‘Lessons From 20 Years of Cohesion’, in S. Mundschenk, M. H. Stierle, U. Stierle von Schütz and I. Traistaru (eds), Competitiveness and Growth in Europe: Lessons and Policy Implications of the Lisbon Strategy, Mannheim: ZEI, 66100.
Foot, M. (1973), Aneurin Bevan; Volume II 1945–1960, London: Davis-Poynter.
Gallagher, M. and Marsh, M. (2016), How Ireland Voted 2016: The Election that Nobody Won, Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
Garvin, T. (1999), ‘Democratic Politics in Independent Ireland’, in J. Coakley and M. Gallagher (eds), Politics in the Republic of Ireland, London: Routledge, 311323.
Goodey, C. (2015), ‘Why GPs oppose free care for children under 6’, http://nagp.ie/news-media/why-gps-oppose-free-care-for-children-under-6 [28 July 2016].
Houses of the Oireachtas Committee on the Future of Healthcare (2017), ‘Sláintecare Report’. Dublin, Ireland: Houses of the Oireachtas.
Hsiao, W. C., Knight, A. G., Kappel, S. and Done, N. (2011), ‘What other states can learn from Vermont’s bold experiment: embracing a single-payer health care financing system’, Health Affairs (Millwood), 30(7): 12321241.
Irish Medical Organisation (2010), ‘IMO Position Paper on Universal Health Coverage’. Dublin: IMO.
Kennedy, K., Giblin, T. and McHugh, D. (1988), The Economic Development of Ireland in the Twentieth Century, London: Routledge.
Kringos, D., Boerma, W., Bourgueil, Y., Cartier, T., Dedeu, T., Hasvold, T., Hutchinson, A., Lember, M., Oleszczyk, M., Rotar Pavlic, D., Svab, I., Tedeschi, P., Wilm, S., Wilson, A., Windak, A., Van der Zee, J. and Groenewegen, P. (2013), ‘The strength of primary care in Europe: an international comparative study’, British Journal of General Practice, 63(616): e742e750.
Kutzin, J. (2012), ‘Anything goes on the path to universal health coverage? No’, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2012(90): 867868.
Kutzin, J. (2013), ‘Health financing for universal coverage and health system performance: concepts and implications for policy’. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, World Health Organization, 91(8): 602611.
The Labour Party (2011), Labour’s Plan for Fair Health Care, Dublin: The Labour Party.
Leahy, P. (2017), ‘FG and FF insist recommendations on healthcare be amended’. The Irish Times, 29 May 2017. https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/fg-and-ff-insist-recommendations-on-healthcare-be-amended-1.3099576 [30 May 2017].
Loughlin, E. (2016a), ‘Labour minister Kathleen Lynch says Fine Gael stalled free GP care plans’. Irish Examiner, 6 January 2016. http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/labour-minister-kathleen-lynch-says-fine-gael-stalled-free-gp-care-plans-374549.html [5 May 2016]
Loughlin, L. (2016b), ‘Legislation by consensus will be better: Regina Doherty’. Irish Examiner, 9 May 2016. http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/legislation-by-consensus-will-be-better-regina-doherty-398331.html [10 May 2016].
Lu, J. and Hsiao, W. C. (2003), ‘Does universal health insurance make health care unaffordable? Lessons from Taiwan’, Health Affairs, 22(3): 7788.
Lynch, F. (2014), Letter to Mr David Moloney, Assistant Secretary, Department of Public Expenditure and Reform. Released under Freedom of Information, Dublin, Ireland: Department of Health.
Mair, P. (1999), ‘Party competition and the changing party system’, in J. Coakley and M. Gallagher (eds), Politics in the Republic of Ireland, London: Routledge, 127151.
Mathauer, I. and Nicolle, E. (2011), ‘A global overview of health insurance administrative costs: what are the reasons for variations found?’, Health Policy, 102(2–3): 235246.
Mikkers, M. and Ryan, P. (2014), ‘“Managed competition” for Ireland? The single versus multiple payer debate’, BMC Health Services Research, 14(1): 442.
MillwardBrown (2016), Health Insurance Authority – A review of private health insurance in Ireland, The Health Insurance Authority, http://www.hia.ie/publication/consumer-surveys [21 August 2017]
O’Connell, T., Rasanathan, K. and Chopra, M. (2014), ‘What does universal health coverage mean?’, Lancet, 383: 277279.
O’Connor, N. (2017), ‘Harris considers leasing maternity hospital land in U-turn on controversy’. Irish Independent, 1 May 2017. https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/health/harris-considers-leasing-maternity-hospital-land-in-uturn-on-controversy-35668350.html [2 May 2017]
O’Connor, N. and O’Regan, E. (2017), ‘Varadkar and Harris insist tax reliefs here to stay’. Irish Independent, 7 April 2017. https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/politics/varadkar-and-harris-insist-tax-reliefs-here-to-stay-35601938.html [8 April 2017].
O’Regan, E. (2014), ‘Opposition grows to plan for universal healthcare’. Irish Independent, 7 April 2014.
O’Reilly, D., O’Dowd, T., Galway, K. J., Murphy, A. W., O’Neill, C., Shryane, E., Steele, K., Bury, G., Gilliland, A. and Kelly, A. (2007), ‘Consultation charges in Ireland deter a large proportion of patients from seeing the GP: results of a cross-sectional survey’, European Journal of General Practice, 13(4): 231236.
Pierson, P. and Skocpol, T. (2002), ‘Historical Institutionalism in Contemporary Political Science’, in I. Katznelson and H.V. Milner (eds), Political Science: State of the Discipline, New York: W.W. Norton, 693721.
Prosser, T. (2010), ‘EU Competition Law and Public Services’, in E. Mossialos, G. Permanand, R. Baetan and T. Hervey (eds), Health Systems Governance in Europe: The Role of European Union Law and Policy, Cambridge University Press, 315336.
Rosenau, P. V. and Lako, C. J. (2008), ‘An experiment with regulated competition and individual mandates for universal health care: the new Dutch health insurance system’, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 33(6): 10311055.
Ruane, F. (2010), ‘Report of the expert group on resource allocation and financing in the health sector’. Dublin, Ireland: Department of Health and Children.
Ryan, P., Thomas, S. and Normand, C. (2009), ‘Translating Dutch: challenges and opportunities in reforming health financing in Ireland’, Irish Journal of Medical Science, 178(3): 245248.
Skocpol, T. (1979), States and Social Revolutions : A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia and China, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skocpol, T. (2008), ‘Bringing the state back in: retrospect and prospect’, Scandinavian Political Studies, 31(2): 109124.
Smith, S. and Normand, C. (2011), ‘Equity in health care: the Irish perspective’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 6: 205217.
Taylor, M. G. (1987), ‘Health Insurance and Canadian Public Policy – the seven decisions that created the Canadian heath insurance system and their outcomes’. Toronto, Ontario, The Institute of Public Administration of Canada/McGill-Queen’s University Press.
Thomas, S., Normand, C. and Smith, S. (2006), Social Health Insurance:Options for Ireland, Dublin: The Adelaide Hospital Society.
Thomas, S., Normand, C. and Smith, S. (2008), Social Health Insurance: Further Options for Ireland, Dublin: The Adelaide Hospital Society.
Thomas, S., Ryan, P. and Normand, C. (2010), Effective Foundations for the Financing and Organisation of Social Health Insurance in Ireland, Dublin, Ireland: The Adelaide Hospital Society.
Thomson, S., Jowett, M., Mladovsky, P., Evetovits, T., Figueras, J., Nolan, A. and Normand, C. (2012), Health System Responses to Financial Pressures in Ireland: Policy Options in an International Context, Brussels, Belgium: World Health Organisation and European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies.
Thomson, S., Busse, R., Crivelli, L., van de Ven, W. and Van de Voorde, C. (2013), ‘Statutory health insurance competition in Europe: a four-country comparison’, Health Policy, 109(3): 209225.
Thomson, S., Foubister, T. and Mossialos, E. (2009), Financing Health Care in the European Union: Challenges and Policy Response, Denmark: World Health Organisation.
Tussing, A. D. and Wren, M. (2006), How Ireland Cares: The Case for Health Care Reform, Dublin: New Island.
Whyte, J. H. (1980), Church and State in Modern Ireland 1923–1979, 2nd edn, Dublin: Gill and Macmillan.
World Health Organization (WHO) (2010), ‘The world health report: health systems financing: the path to universal coverage’. Geneva: WHO Press, World Health Organization.
Wren, M. (2003), Unhealthy State – Anatomy of a Sick Society, Dublin: New Island.
Wren, M. and Connolly, S. (2016), ‘Challenges in achieving universal healthcare in Ireland’, Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute Budget Perspectives, 2017(1): 128.
Wren, M., Connolly, S. and Cunningham, N. (2015), ‘An examination of the potential costs of Universal Health Insurance in Ireland’, Research Series Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute.
Wren, M., Connolly, S. and Cunningham, N. (2016), ‘An approach to estimating the effects of financing system change on Irish healthcare expenditure’, Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland, XLV: 115.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Health Economics, Policy and Law
  • ISSN: 1744-1331
  • EISSN: 1744-134X
  • URL: /core/journals/health-economics-policy-and-law
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed