Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The reimbursement of new medical technologies in German inpatient care: What factors explain which hospitals receive innovation payments?

  • Patricia Ex (a1), Verena Vogt (a1), Reinhard Busse (a1) and Cornelia Henschke (a1)

Abstract

Most hospital payment systems based on diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) provide payments for newly approved technologies. In Germany, they are negotiated between individual hospitals and health insurances. The aim of our study is to assess the functioning of temporary reimbursement mechanisms. We used multilevel logistic regression to examine factors at the hospital and state levels that are associated with agreeing innovation payments. Dependent variable was whether or not a hospital had successfully negotiated innovation payments in 2013 (n = 1532). Using agreement data of the yearly budget negotiations between each German hospital and representatives of the health insurances, the study comprises all German acute hospitals and innovation payments on all diagnoses. In total, 32.9% of the hospitals successfully negotiated innovation payments in 2013. We found that the chance of receiving innovation payments increased if the hospital was located in areas with a high degree of competition and if they were large, had university status and were private for-profit entities. Our study shows an implicit self-controlled selection of hospitals receiving innovation payments. While implicitly encouraging safety of patient care, policy makers should favour a more direct and transparent process of distributing innovation payments in prospective payment systems.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Correspondence to. Email: patricia.ex@campus.tu-berlin.de

References

Hide All
Altenstetter, C (1996) Regulating healthcare technologies and medical supplies in the European Economic Area. Health Policy 35, 3352.
Augurzky, B, Pilny, A and Wübker, A (2015) Krankenhäuser in privater Trägerschaft 2015. RWI 89. Essen: RWI.
Banaszak-Holl, J, Zinn, S and Mor, V (1996) The impact of market and organizational characteristics on nursing care facility service innovation: a resource dependency perspective. Health Services Research 31, 97117.
Bäumler, M (2013) Which non-clinical factors influence the use of innovative implants? The example of drug-releasing coronary stents in patients with acute myocardial infarction: a multilevel regression analysis. Das Gesundheitswesen 75, 822831.
Bech, M, Christiansen, T, Dunham, K, Lauridsen, J, Lyttkens, CH, McDonald, K and McGuire, A (2009) The influence of economic incentives and regulatory factors on the adoption of treatment technologies: a case study of technologies used to treat heart attacks. Health Economics 18, 11141132. Available online at doi:10.1002/hec.1417
Black, W (1990) The CE plane: a graphic representation of cost-effectiveness. Medical Decision Making 10, 212214.
Blank, J and Valdmanis, VG (2015) Technology diffusion in hospitals: a log odds random effects regression model. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management 30, 246259.
Blum, K and Offermanns, M (2009) Anspruch und Realität von Budgetverhandlungen zur Umsetzung medizintechnischer Innovationen: Gutachten des Deutschen Krankenhausinstituts im Auftrag des Bundesverbandes Medizintechnologie. Unpublished manuscript, last modified January 2016. Available online at https://www.bvmed.de/download/gutachten-innovationstransfer-nub.pdf
Bölt, U and Graf, T (2012) 20 Jahre Krankenhausstatistik. Statistisches Bundesamt, Wirtschaft und Statistik.
Bonastre, J, Chevalier, J, van der Laan, C, Delibes, M and de Pouvourville, G (2014) Access to innovation: is there a difference in the use of expensive anticancer drugs between French hospitals? Health Policy 116, 162169.
Callea, G, Cavallo, MC, Tarricone, R and Torbica, A (2017) Learning effect and diffusion of innovative medical devices: the case of transcatheter aortic valve implantation in Italy. Journal of Comparative Effectiveness Research 6, 279292.
Castro, MF, Calogero, G, Pignataro, G and Rizzo, I (2014) The effects of reimbursement mechanisms on medical technology diffusion in the hospital sector in the Italian NHS. Health Policy 115, 215229. Available online at doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2013.12.004
Cohen, J (2010) Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, 3rd edn. [Nachdr.]. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Available online at http://reference-tree.com/book/applied-multiple-regression-correlation-analysis-for-the-behavioral-sciences?utm_source=gbv&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=collaboration
Daidone, S and D'Amico, F (2009) Technical efficiency, specialization and ownership form: evidences from a pooling of Italian hospitals. Journal of Productivity Analysis 32, 203216.
Dayhoff, DA and Cromwell, J (1993) Measuring differences and similarities in hospital caseloads: a conceptual and empirical analysis. Health Services Research 28, 293312.
Drummond, M, Sculpher, M, Claxton, K, Stoddart, G and Torrance, GW (2015) Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes, 4th edn. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
Farley, DE and Hogan, C (1990) Case-mix specialization in the market for hospital services. Health Services Research 25, 757783.
Federal Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds (2016). Neue Untersuchungs- und Behandlungsmethoden (NUB). Available online at https://www.gkv-spitzenverband.de/krankenversicherung/krankenhaeuser/drg_system/neue_untersuchungs_und_behandlungsmethoden_nub/neue_untersuchungs_und_behandlungsmethoden_nub.jsp (Accessed 22 January 2016).
Greenhalgh, T, Robert, G, Macfarlane, F, Bate, P and Kyriakidou, O (2004) Diffusion of innovations in service organizations: systematic review and recommendations. The Milbank Quarterly 82, 581629.
Greer, AL (1985) Adoption of medical technology: the hospital's three decision systems. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 1, 669680.
Hatz, HM, Schreyögg, J, Torbica, A, Boriani, G and Blankart, CRB (2017) Adoption decisions for medical devices in the field of cardiology: results from a European survey. Health Economics 26(suppl. 1), 124144.
Henschke, C, Bäumler, M, Weid, S, Gaskins, M and Busse, R (2010) Extrabudgetary (‘NUB’) payments: a gateway for introducing new medical devices into the German inpatient reimbursement system? Journal of Management & Marketing in Healthcare 3, 119133.
Herwartz, H and Strumann, C (2012) On the effect of prospective payment on local hospital competition in Germany. Health Care Management Science 15, 4862.
Institut für das Entgeltsystem im Krankenhaus (2015) Verfahrenseckpunkte: Anfragen nach § 6 Abs. 2 KHEntgG (Neue Untersuchungs- und Behandlungsmethoden). Available online at http://www.g-drg.de/cms/Neue_Untersuchungs-_und_Behandlungsmethoden_NUB/Verfahrenseckpunkte (Accessed January 2016).
Kesteloot, K and Voet, N (1998) Incentives for cooperation in quality improvement among hospitals? The impact of the reimbursement system. Journal of Health Economics 17, 701728.
Kim, H-S, Kim, Y-H, Woo, J-S and Hyun, S-J (2015) An analysis of organizational performance based on hospital specialization level and strategy type. PLoS ONE 10, e0132257.
Kimberly, JR and Evanisko, MJ (1981) Organizational innovation: the influence of individual, organizational, and contextual factors on hospital adoption of technological and administrative innovations. Academy of Management Journal 24, 689713.
Klauber, J, Geraedts, M, Friedrich, J and Wasem, J (2015) Krankenhaus-Report 2015: Schwerpunkt Strukturwandel. Stuttgart: F.K. Schattauer.
Knieps, F (2009) Competition in healthcare – political intentions: [Wettbewerb im Gesundheitswesen – politische Intentionen]. Zeitschrift fur Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualitat im Gesundheitswesen 103, 615619; discussion 619–20.
Lee, RH and Waldman, DM (1985) The diffusion of innovations in hospitals. Some econometric considerations. Journal of Health Economics 4, 373380.
Lettieri, E and Masella, C (2009) Priority setting for technology adoption at a hospital level: relevant issues from the literature. Health Policy 90, 8188.
Levaggi, R, Moretto, M and Pertile, P (2014) Two-part payments for the reimbursement of investments in health technologies. Health Policy 115, 230236.
Lindlbauer, I and Schreyögg, J (2014) The relationship between hospital specialization and hospital efficiency: do different measures of specialization lead to different results? Health Care Management Science 17, 365378.
Loskamp, N, Genett, T, Schaffer, D and Schulze-Ehring, F (2017) Medizinisch-technischer Fortschritt als Ergebnis des Systemwettbewerbs zwischen GKV und PKV: Die Rolle der privaten Krankenversicherung (PKV).
Martelli, N and van den Brink, H (2014) Special funding schemes for innovative medical devices in French hospitals: the pros and cons of two different approaches. Health Policy 117, 15.
McCullough, JS (2008) The adoption of hospital information systems. Health Economics 17, 649664.
Mitchell, DG, Parker, L, Sunshine, JH and Levin, DC (2002) Body MR imaging and CT volume: variations and trends based on an analysis of Medicare and fee-for-service health insurance databases. AJR (American Journal of Roentgenology) 179, 2731.
Nolting, H-D, Zich, K, Deckenbach, B, Gottberg, A, Lottmann, K, Klemperer, D, Grote-Westrick, M and Schwenk, U (2011) Faktencheck Gesundheit: Regionale Unterschiede in der Gesundheitsversorgung. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Robinson, JC and Luft, HS (1985) The impact of hospital market structure on patient volume, average length of stay, and the cost of care. Journal of Health Economics 4, 333356.
Rogers, E (2003) Diffusion of Innovations, 5th edn. Free Press trade paperback edition. Social Science. New York, London, Toronto, Sydney: Free Press.
Romeo, AA, Wagner, JL and Lee, RH (1984) Prospective reimbursement and the diffusion of new technologies in hospitals. Journal of Health Economics 3, 124.
Rye, CB and Kimberly, JR (2007) The adoption of innovations by provider organizations in health care. Medical Care Research and Review 64, 235278.
Sáenz-Royo, C, Gracia-Lázaro, C and Moreno, Y (2015) The role of the organization structure in the diffusion of innovations. PLoS ONE 10, e0126076.
Scheller-Kreinsen, D, Quentin, W and Busse, R (2011) DRG-based hospital payment systems and technological innovation in 12 European countries. Value in Health 14, 11661172.
Schmid, A and Ulrich, V (2012) Konzentration und Marktmacht bei Krankenhäusern [concentration and market power in the hospital sector]. Gesundh ökon Qual manag 17, 1822.
Schreyögg, J, Bäuml, M, Krämer, J, Dette, T, Busse, R and Geissler, A (2014) Forschungsauftrag zur Mengenentwicklung nach § 17b Abs. 9 KHG.
Sethi, RKV, Henry, AJ, Hevelone, ND, Lipsitz, SR, Belkin, M and Nguyen, LL (2013) Impact of hospital market competition on endovascular aneurysm repair adoption and outcomes. Journal of Vascular Surgery 58, 596606.
Sorenson, C and Drummond, M (2014) Improving medical device regulation: the United States and Europe in perspective. The Milbank Quarterly 92, 114150.
Sorenson, C and Kanavos, P (2011) Medical technology procurement in Europe: a cross-country comparison of current practice and policy. Health Policy 100, 4350.
Sorenson, C, Drummond, M and Wilkinson, G (2013) Use of innovation payments to encourage the adoption of new medical technologies in the English NHS. Health Policy and Technology 2, 168173.
Sorenson, C, Drummond, M, Torbica, A, Callea, G and Mateus, C (2015) The role of hospital payments in the adoption of new medical technologies: an international survey of current practice. Health Economics, Policy, and Law 10, 133159.
Tiemann, O and Schreyögg, J (2009) Effects of ownership on hospital efficiency in Germany. BuR Business Research Journal 2, 115145.
Tiemann, O, Schreyögg, J and Busse, R (2012) Hospital ownership and efficiency: a review of studies with particular focus on Germany. Health Policy 104, 163171.
Torbica, A and Cappellaro, G (2010) Uptake and diffusion of medical technology innovation in Europe: What role for funding and procurement policies? Journal of Medical Marketing 10, 6169.
Varabyova, Y, Blankart, CR, Greer, AL and Schreyögg, J (2017) The determinants of medical technology adoption in different decisional systems: a systematic literature review. Health Policy 121, 230242.
Weng, R-H, Huang, J-A, Kuo, Y-H, Huang, C-Y and Huang, Y-C (2011) Determinants of technological innovation and its effect on hospital performance. African Journal of Business Management 5, 43144327.
White, C, Reschovsky, JD and Bond, AM (2014) Understanding differences between high- and low-price hospitals: implications for efforts to rein in costs. Health Affairs (Project Hope) 33, 324331.
Wilke, M (2007) Studie: Stellenwert der Innovationsentgelte für Deutsche Krankenhäuser. Unpublished manuscript, last modified January 2016. Available online at webarchiv.medizincontroller.de/info/Studie_innovationsentgelte.pdf
Wilkinson, G and Drummond, M (2014) Impact of reimbursement policies on the adoption of medical devices in an outpatient setting. Health Policy and Technology 3, 281286.
Willemé, P and Dumont, M (2015) Machines that go ‘ping’: medical technology and health expenditures in OECD countries. Health Economics 24, 10271041.
Zwanziger, J, Melnick, GA and Simonson, L (1996) Differentiation and specialization in the California Hospital Industry 1983 to 1988. Medical Care 34, 361372.

Keywords

JEL classification

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed