Skip to main content

Anthropology on trial: exploring the laws of anthropological expertise

  • Olaf Zenker (a1)

This paper explores the role of anthropological expertise in shaping the outcome of legal proceedings under conditions of cultural diversity. Taking the state-driven land-restitution process in post-apartheid South Africa as its point of reference, the text reflects upon the work of anthropological experts in a number of cases and shows how their theoretical and political stances shaped the trajectories of their legal engagements. Pointing towards frictions that emerge in acts of translation between the seemingly objectivist rhetoric evoked in court and more relativist and subjectivist stances within the academy, the paper revisits and problematises debates around strategic essentialism. Sketching instead the contours of a ‘recursive anthropology’ that expresses itself in terms of a post-positivist universalism, the paper turns on the author's use of his own expertise in support of a White land claim, probing – and critically reflecting upon – the practical potential of a form of expertise grounded in such a recursive anthropology.

Corresponding author
Hide All
Albert, Hans (1968/1985) Treatise on Critical Reason. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berzborn, Susanne (2004) ‘Haushaltsökonomie, soziale Netzwerke und Identität: Risikominimierende Strategien von Pastoralisten und Lohnarbeitern im Richtersveld, Südafrika’. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Cologne.
Berzborn, Susanne (2006) Ziegen und Diamanten: Sicherung des Lebensunterhalts im ländlichen Südafrika. Berlin: LIT.
Berzborn, Susanne (2007) ‘Identity Politics in the Richtersveld Land Claim, South Africa’ in Bollig, Michael, Bubenzer, Olaf, Vogelsang, Ralf and Wotzka, Hans-Peter (eds) Aridity, Change and Conflict in Africa: Proceedings of an International ACACIA Conference Held at Königswinter, Germany, October 1–3, 2003. Köln: Heinrich-Barth-Institut, 295310.
Boltanski, Luc (2011) On Critique: A Sociology of Emancipation. Cambridge: Polity.
Bourdieu, Pierre (1989) ‘Social Space and Symbolic Power’, Sociological Theory 7(1): 1425.
Boynton, Graham (1997) Last Days in Cloud Cuckooland: Dispatches from White Africa. New York: Random House.
Clifford, James and Marcus, George E. (eds.) (1986) Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography. Berkeley/Los Angeles/London: University of California Press.
Cruywagen, Dennis (2014) Brothers in War and Peace: Constand and Abraham Viljoen and the Birth of the New South Africa. Cape Town: Zebra Press.
De Beer, Frik C. (2003) ‘Determining the Merits of Land Claims: A Challenge for the Anthropologist’, Anthropology Southern Africa 26(3&4): 131142.
De Beer, Frik C. (2006) ‘The Roots and Complexity of the Land Issue and of Land Claims in South Africa’, Anthropology Southern Africa 29(1&2): 2434.
Driessen, Patrick A. (1983) ‘The Wedding of Social Science and the Courts: Is the Marriage Working?’, Social Science Quarterly 64: 476493.
Geertz, Clifford (1983) Local Knowledge: Fact and Law in Comparative Perspective: Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology. New York: Basic, 167234.
Good, Anthony (2007) Anthropology and Expertise in the British Asylum Courts. London: Routledge-Cavendish.
Hacking, Ian (1999) The Social Construction of What? Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Henare, Amiria J.M., Holbraad, Martin and Wastell, Sari (2007) Thinking through Things: Theorising Artefacts Ethnographically. London: Routledge.
Herzfeld, Michael (2010) ‘Essentialism’ in Barnard, Alan and Spencer, Jonathan (eds) The Routledge Encyclopedia of Social and Cultural Anthropology, 2nd edn. London/New York: Routledge, 234236.
Holbraad, Martin (2012) Truth in Motion: The Recursive Anthropology of Cuban Divination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hymes, Dell H. (1972/1999) Reinventing Anthropology. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Johnston, Pamela Louise (1987) ‘Court-Appointed Scientific Expert Witnesses: Unfettering Expertise’, Berkeley Technology Law Journal 2(2): 249280.
Jonas, Hans (1984) The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kandel, Randy F. (1992) ‘How Lawyers and Anthropologists Think Differently’ in Kandel, Randy F. (ed.) Double Vision: Anthropologists at Law. Washington: American Anthropological Association, 14.
Kuhn, Thomas S. (1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kuper, Adam (2003) ‘The Return of the Native (and Comments and Reply)’, Current Anthropology 44(3): 389402.
Latour, Bruno (2004) ‘Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern’, Critical Inquiry 30(2): 225248.
Low, Setha M. and Merry, Sally Engle (2010) ‘Engaged Anthropology: Diversity and Dilemmas: An Introduction to Supplement 2’, Current Anthropology 51(S2): S203S226.
Luhmann, Niklas (1991) ‘Sthenographie und Euryalistik’ in Gumbrecht, Hans Ulrich and Pfeiffer, K. Ludwig (eds) Paradoxien, Dissonanzen, Zusammenbrüche: Situationen offener Epistemologien. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 5882.
Luhmann, Niklas (1995) Social Systems. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Luhmann, Niklas (2004) Law as a Social System. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Phillips, Anne (2010) ‘What's Wrong with Essentialism?Distinktion: Scandinavian Journal of Social Theory 11(1): 4760.
Popper, Karl R. (1959) The Logic of Scientific Discovery. New York: Basic Books.
Quadri, Kafayat Motilewa, Kadaouf, Hunud Abia, Jan, Mohammad Naqib Ishan, Wahab, Mohd. Iqbal Abdul and Ahamat, Haniff (2015) ‘Adquisitorial: The Mixing of Two Legal Systems’, International Journal of Humanities and Management Sciences 3(1): 3136.
Quine, William van Orman (1953) From a Logical Point of View: Nine Logico-Philosophical Essays. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Rigby, Peter and Sevareid, Peter (1992) ‘Lawyers, Anthropologists, and the Knowledge of Fact’ in Kandel, Randy F. (ed.) Double Vision: Anthropologists at Law. Washington: American Anthropological Association, 521.
Robins, Steven (2008) From Revolution to Rights in South Africa: Social Movements, NGOs & Popular Politics after Apartheid. Woodbridge/Scottsville: James Currey/University of Kwazulu-Natal Press.
Rottenburg, Richard (2005) ‘Code-Switching, or Why a Metacode Is Good to Have’ in Czarniawska, Barbara and Sevon, Guje (eds) Global Ideas: How Ideas, Objects and Practices Travel in the Global Economy. Malmö: Författarna och Liber AB, 259274.
Sen, Amartya (1985) Commodities and Capabilities. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Sen, Amartya (1999) Development as Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Shapere, Dudley (1984) Reason and the Search for Knowledge: Investigations in the Philosophy of Science. Dordrecht: Reidel.
Slabbert, Frederik van Zyl (2006) The Other Side of History: An Anecdotal Reflection on Political Transition in South Africa. Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball Publishers.
Sparks, Allister Haddon (2003) Tomorrow Is Another Country: The Inside Story of South Africa's Negotiated Settlement. Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball Publishers.
Spiegel, Andrew D. and Becker, Heike (2015) ‘South Africa: Anthropology or Anthropologies?’, American Anthropologist 117(4): 754760.
Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty (1988) In Other Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics. New York: Methuen.
Thuen, Trond (2004) ‘Anthropological Knowledge in the Courtroom: Conflicting Paradigms’, Social Anthropology 12(3): 265287.
Van Der Walt, Lirieka Meintjes (2006) ‘Comparative Method: Comparing Legal Systems and/or Legal Cultures?’, Speculum Juris 1: 5164.
Van Dyk, Silke (2012) ‘Poststrukturalismus: Gesellschaft: Kritik: über Potenziale, Probleme und Perspektiven’, Prokla 167(2): 185210.
Weber, Max (1921/1978) Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Zammito, John H. (2004) A Nice Derangement of Epistemes: Post-Positivism in the Study of Science from Quine to Latour. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Zenker, Olaf (2010) ‘Language Matters: Reflexive Notes on Representing the Irish Language Revival in Catholic West Belfast’ in Zenker, Olaf and Kumoll, Karsten (eds) Beyond Writing Culture: Current Intersections of Epistemologies and Representational Practices. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books, 121138.
Zenker, Olaf (2011) ‘Autochthony, Ethnicity, Indigeneity and Nationalism: Time-Honouring and State-Oriented Modes of Rooting Individual-Territory-Group-Triads in a Globalising World’, Critique of Anthropology 31(1): 6381.
Zenker, Olaf (2012) ‘The Juridification of Political Protest and the Politicisation of Legalism in South African Land Restitution’ in Eckert, Julia, Donahoe, Brian, Strümpell, Christian and Biner, Zerrin Özlem (eds) Law against the State: Ethnographic Forays into Law's Transformations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 118146.
Zenker, Olaf (2013) Irish/ness Is All Around Us: Language Revivalism and the Culture of Ethnic Identity in Northern Ireland. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books.
Zenker, Olaf (2014) ‘New Law against an Old State: Land Restitution as a Transition to Justice in Post-Apartheid South Africa?’, Development and Change 45(3): 502523.
Zenker, Olaf (2015a) ‘De-Judicialization, Outsourced Review and All-Too-Flexible Bureaucracies in South African Land Restitution’, Cambridge Journal of Anthropology 33(1): 8196.
Zenker, Olaf (2015b) ‘South African Land Restitution, White Claimants and the Fateful Frontier of Former KwaNdebele’, Journal of Southern African Studies 41(5): 10191034.
Zenker, Olaf and Kumoll, Karsten (eds) (2010a) Beyond Writing Culture: Current Intersections of Epistemologies and Representational Practices. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books.
Zenker, Olaf and Kumoll, Karsten (2010b) ‘Prologue: Opening Doors beyond Writing Culture’, in Zenker, Olaf and Kumoll, Karsten (eds) Beyond Writing Culture: Current Intersections of Epistemologies and Representational Practices. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books, 138.
Zimmermann, Reinhard and Visser, Daniel (1996) ‘Introduction: South African Law as a Mixed Legal System’ in Zimmermann, Reinhard and Visser, Daniel (eds) Southern Cross: Civil Law and Common Law in South Africa. Oxford/New York: Clarendon Press/Oxford University Press, 130.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Journal of Law in Context
  • ISSN: 1744-5523
  • EISSN: 1744-5531
  • URL: /core/journals/international-journal-of-law-in-context
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed