Skip to main content Accesibility Help
×
×
Home

Beyond anarchy: logics of political organization, hierarchy, and international structure

  • Meghan Mcconaughey (a1), Paul Musgrave (a2) and Daniel H. Nexon (a3)
Abstract

Many scholars now argue for deemphasizing the importance of international anarchy in favor of focusing on hierarchy – patterns of super- and subordination – in world politics. We argue that only one kind of vertical stratification, governance hierarchy, actually challenges the states-under-anarchy framework. But the existence of such hierarchies overturns a number of standard ways of studying world politics. In order to theorize, and identify, variation in governance structures in world politics, we advocate a relational approach that focuses on three dimensions of hierarchy: the heterogeneity of contracting, the degree of autonomy enjoyed by central authorities, and the balance of investiture between segments and the center. This generates eight ideal-typical forms: national-states and empires, as well as symmetric and asymmetric variants of federations, confederations, and conciliar systems. We argue that political formations – governance assemblages – with elements of these ideal types are likely ubiquitous at multiple scales of world politics, including within, across, and among sovereign states. Our framework suggests that world politics is marked by a heterarchy of nested and overlapping political structures. We discuss broad implications for international-relations theory and comparative politics, and illustrate our approach through an analysis of contemporary China and the evolution of the British ‘Empire’ in the 19th and 20th centuries.

Copyright
Corresponding author
References
Hide All
Abbott, Kenneth W., Genschel, Philipp, Snidal, Duncan, and Zangl, Bernhard. 2016. “Two Logics of Indirect Governance: Delegation and Orchestration.” British Journal of Political Science 46(4):719729.
Acuto, Michele, and Curtis, Simon. eds. 2014. Reassembling International Theory. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Adler-Nissen, Rebecca. 2014. “Stigma Management in International Relations: Transgressive Identities, Norms, and Order in International Society.” International Organization 68(1):143176.
Agranoff, Robert. 1999. Accommodating Diversity: Asymmetry in Federal States. Baden-Baden: Nomos-Verlag-Ges.
Barder, Alexander D. 2015. “International Hierarchy”. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Accessed 14 April 2018, http://internationalstudies.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190846626.001.0001/acrefore-9780190846626-e-95.
Barkawi, Tarak, and Laffey, Mark. 2002. “Retrieving the Imperial: Empire and International Relations.” Millennium 31(1):109127.
Barkey, Karen. 2008. Empire of Difference: The Ottomans in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Barkey, Karen, and Godart, Frédéric C.. 2013. “Empires, Federated Arrangements, and Kingdoms: Using Political Models of Governance to Understand Firms’ Creative Performance.” Organization Studies 34(1):79104.
Barnett, Michael, and Duvall, Raymond. 2005. “Power in International Politics.” International Organization 59(1):3975.
Bartlett, Robert. 1993. The Making of Modern Europe. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Bednar, Jenna. 2008. The Robust Federation: Principles of Design. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Bell, Duncan. 2007. “The Victorian Idea of a Global State.” In Victorian Visions of Global Order, edited by Duncan Bell. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Bogdanor, Vernon. 2001. Devolution in the United Kingdom. Oxford: Oxford Paperbacks.
Boli, John, and Thomas, George M.. 1999. Constructing World Culture: International Nongovernmental Organizations Since 1875. Redwood City, CA: Stanford University Press.
Boucoyannis, Deborah. 2007. “The International Wanderings of a Liberal Idea, or Why Liberals Can Learn to Stop Worrying and Love the Balance of Power.” Perspectives on Politics 5(4):703727.
Bousquet, Antoine, and Curtis, Simon. 2011. “Beyond Models and Metaphors: Complexity Theory, Systems Thinking and International Relations.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 24(1):4362.
Burbank, Jane, and Cooper, Frederick. 2010. Empires in World History: Power and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Burnham, Peter. 1991. “Neo-Gramscian Hegemony and the International Order.” Capital & Class 15(3):7392.
Butcher, Charles R., and Griffiths, Ryan D.. 2017. “Between Eurocentrism and Babel: A Framework for the Analysis of States, State Systems, and International Orders”. International Studies Quarterly 61(2):328356.
Cerny, Philip G. 1995. “Globalization and the Changing Logic of Collective Action.” International Organization 49(4):595625.
Chase, Ivan D. 1980. “Social Process and Hierarchy Formation in Small Groups: A Comparative Perspective.” American Sociological Review 45(6):905924.
Cooley, Alexander. 2005. Logics of Hierarchy: The Organization of Empires, States, and Military Occupation. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Cooley, Alexander, and Nexon, Daniel H.. 2013. “The Empire Will Compensate You: The Structural Dynamics of the U.S. Overseas Basing Network.” Perspectives on Politics 11(4):10341050.
Deudney, Daniel. 2007. Bounding Power: Republican Security Theory From the Polis to the Global Village. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Deudney, Daniel H. 1995. “The Philadelphian System: Sovereignty, Arms Control, and Balance of Power in the American States-Union, Circa 1787–1861.” International Organization 49(2):191228.
Dickovick, J. Tyler, and Eaton, Kent H.. 2013. “Latin America’s Resurgent Centre: National Government Strategies After Decentralisation.” The Journal of Development Studies 49(11):14531466.
Donnelly, Jack. 2009. “Rethinking Political Structures: From ‘Ordering Principles’ To ‘Vertical Differentiation’ – and Beyond.” International Theory 1(1):4986.
Donnelly, Jack. 2015. “The Discourse of Anarchy in IR.” International Theory 7(3):393425.
Doyle, Michael W. 1986. Empires. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Drezner, Daniel W. 2014. The System Worked: How the World Stopped Another Great Depression. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Ebbinghaus, Bernhard. 2003. “Ever Larger Unions: Organisational Restructuring and Its Impact on Union Confederations.” Industrial Relations Journal 34(5):446460.
Elazar, Daniel J. 1987. Exploring Federalism. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.
Emont, Jon. 2016. “China Goes All Out To Win Favor With Indonesian Muslims.” Washington Post, July 1. Last Accessed 15 April 2018, https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-goes-all-out-to-curry-favor-with-indonesian-muslims/2016/06/30/caee52d4-3e08-11e6-9e16-4cf01a41decb_story.html?utm_term=.6b2e742d7091.
Erikson, Emily. 2013. “Formalist and Relationalist Theory in Social Network Analysis.” Sociological Theory 31(3):219242.
Fabbrini, Sergio, and Brunazzo, Marco. 2003. “Federalizing Italy: The Convergent Effects of Europeanization and Domestic Mobilization.” Regional & Federal Studies 13(1):100120.
Farrell, Henry, and Newman, Abraham L.. 2014. “Domestic Institutions Beyond the Nation-State: Charting the New Interdependence Approach.” World Politics 66(2):331363.
Ferguson, Yale H., and Mansbach, Richard W.. 1996. Polities: Authority, Identities, and Change. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
Filippov, Mikhail, Ordeshook, Peter C., and Shvetsova, Olga. 2004. Designing Federalism: A Theory of Self-sustainable Federal Institutions. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Finnemore, Martha. 1996. National Interests in International Society. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Fravel, M. Taylor. 2008. Strong Borders, Secure Nation: Cooperation and Conflict in China’s Territorial Disputes. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Galtung, Johan. 1971. “A Structural Theory of Imperialism.” Journal of Peace Research 8(2):81117.
Go, Julian. 2008. “Global Fields and Imperial Forms: Field Theory and the British and American Empires.” Sociological Theory 26(3):201229.
Goddard, Stacie E. 2009. “Brokering Change: Networks and Entrepreneurs in International Politics.” International Theory 1(2):249281.
Goddard, Stacie E., and Nexon, Daniel H.. 2005. “Paradigm Lost? Reassessing Theory of International Politics.” European Journal of International Relations 11(1):961.
Goddard, Stacie E., and Nexon, Daniel H.. 2016. “The Dynamics of Global Power Politics: A Framework for Analysis.” Journal of Global Security Studies 1(1):418.
Goode, J. Paul. 2004. “The Push for Regional Enlargement in Putin’s Russia.” Post-Soviet Affairs 20(3):219257.
Grossman, Guy, and Lewis, Janet I.. 2014. “Administrative Unit Proliferation.” American Political Science Review 108(1):196217.
Guzzini, Stefano. 2013. Power, Realism and Constructivism. Abingdon-on-Thames: Routledge.
Hameiri, Shahr, and Jones, Lee. 2016. “Rising Powers and State Transformation: The Case of China.” European Journal of International Relations 22(1):7298.
Hobson, John M. 2014. “The Twin Self-Delusions of IR: Why ‘Hierarchy’ and Not ‘Anarchy’ Is the Core Concept of IR.” Millennium 42(3):557575.
Hobson, John M., and Sharman, J. C.. 2005. “The Enduring Place of Hierarchy in World Politics: Tracing the Social Logics of Hierarchy and Political Change.” European Journal of International Relations 11(1):6398.
Hooghe, Liesbet, and Marks, Gary. 2003. “Unraveling the Central State, But How? Types of Multi-Level Governance.” American Political Science Review 97(2):233243.
Hui, Victoria Tin-bor. 2004. “Toward a Dynamic Theory of International Politics: Insights From Comparing Ancient China and Early Modern Europe.” International Organization 58(1):175205.
Hutchings, Ross. 2006. “Empire and the State: A Critical Theoretical Assessment.” Australian Journal of International Affairs 60(3):429438.
Ikenberry, G. John. 2001. After Victory : Institutions, Strategic Restraint, and the Rebuilding of Order After Major Wars. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ikenberry, G. John. 2004. “Liberalism and Empire: Logics of Order in the American Unipolar Age.” Review of International Studies 30(4):609630.
Immerwahr, Daniel. 2016. “The Greater United States: Territory and Empire in U.S. History.” Diplomatic History 40(3):373.
Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus, and Nexon, Daniel H.. 1999. “Relations Before States: Substance, Process, and the Study of World Politics.” European Journal of International Relations 5(3):291332.
Kalmo, Hent, and Skinner, Quentin. 2010. Sovereignty in Fragments: The Past, Present and Future of a Contested Concept. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Kaufman, Stuart J., Little, Richard, and Wohlforth, William Curti. 2007. The Balance of Power in World History. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
Krasner, Stephen D. 1999. Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Lake, David A. 1996. “Anarchy, Hierarchy, and the Variety of International Relations.” International Organization 50(1):133.
Lake, David A. 1999. Entangling Relations: American Foreign Policy in Its Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Lake, David A. 2009. Hierarchy in International Relations. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Lanoszka, Alexander. 2013. “Beyond Consent and Coercion: Using Republican Political Theory to Understand International Hierarchies.” International Theory 5(3):382413.
Larson, Welch, Deborah, and Shevchenko, Alexei. 2010. “Status Seekers: Chinese and Russian Responses to US Primacy.” International Security 34(4):6395.
Le Gales, Patrick. 2008. “Territorial Politics in France: Le calme avant la tempête.” In Developments in French Politics, edited by Patrick Le Gales, Jonah Levy, and Alastair Cole, 156171. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Lemke, Douglas. 2004. “Great Powers in the Post-Cold War World: A Power Transition Perspective.” In Balance of Power: Theory and Practice in the 21st Century, edited by T. V. Paul, J. J. Wirtz, and M. Fortmann, 5275. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Levy, Jacob T. 2007. “Federalism, Liberalism, and the Separation of Loyalties.” American Political Science Review 101(3):459477.
Long, Tom. 2015. Latin America Confronts the United States: Asymmetry and Influence. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
MacDonald, Paul K. 2009. “Those Who Forget Historiography Are Doomed to Republish It: Empire, Imperialism and Contemporary Debates About American Power.” Review of International Studies 35(1):4567.
MacDonald, Paul K. 2014. Networks of Domination: The Social Foundations of Peripheral Conquest in International Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
MacDonald, Paul K. 2018. “Embedded Authority: A Relational Network Approach to Hierarchy in World Politics.” Review of International Studies, 44(1): 128150.
McNamara, Kathleen R. 2015. The Politics of Everyday Europe: Constructing Authority in the European Union. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mansergh, Nicholas. 1952. Survey of British Commonwealth Affairs: Problems of External Policy, 1931-1939. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Mattern, Janice Bially, and Zarakol, Ayşe. 2016. “Hierarchies in World Politics.” International Organization 70(3):623654.
McCourt, David M. 2016. “Practice Theory and Relationalism as the New Constructivism.” International Studies Quarterly 60(3):475.
McDonald, Patrick J. 2015. “Great Powers, Hierarchy, and Endogenous Regimes: Rethinking the Domestic Causes of Peace.” International Organization 69(3):557588.
McGregor, Richard. 2010. The Party: The Secret World of China’s Communist Rulers. New York, NY: Harper.
McIntyre, William David. 2009. The Britannic Vision: Historians and the Making of the British Commonwealth of Nations, 1907-48. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke.
Menon, Anand, and Schain, Martin. 2006. Comparative Federalism: The European Union and the United States in Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press on Demand.
Milne, David. 1991. “Equality or Asymmetry: Why Choose?.” In Options for a New Canada, edited by Ronald Watts, and Douglas Brown, 285–307. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Motyl, Alexander J. 1999. “Why Empires Reemerge: Imperial Collapse and Imperial Revival in Comparative Perspective.” Comparative Politics 31(2):127145.
Motyl, Alexander J. 2001. Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
Musgrave, Paul, and Nexon, Daniel H.. 2018. “Defending Hierarchy from the Moon to the Indian Ocean: Symbolic Capital and Political Dominance in Early Modern China and the Cold War.” International Organization, forthcoming.
Neumann, Iver B. 1999. Uses of the Other: “The East” in European Identity Formation. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Neumann, Iver B., and Sending, Ole Jacob. 2010. Governing the Global Polity: Practice, Mentality, Rationality. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Nexon, Daniel H. 2009. The Struggle for Power in Early Modern Europe: Religious Conflict, Dynastic Empires, and International Change. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Nexon, Daniel H., and Neumann, Iver B.. 2018. “Hegemonic-Order Theory: A Field-Theoretic Account.” European Journal of International Relations, forthcoming.
Nexon, Daniel H., and Wright, Thomas. 2007. “What’s At Stake in the American Empire Debate.” American Political Science Review 101(2):253271.
Parent, Joseph. 2011. Uniting States: Voluntary Union in World Politics. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Paul, Thazha V., Larson, Deborah Welch, and Wohlforth, William C.. 2014. Status in World Politics. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Pratt, Simon Frankel. 2017. “A Relational View of Ontological Security in International Relations.” International Studies Quarterly 61(1):7885.
Rector, Chad. 2009. Federations : The Political Dynamics of Cooperation. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Riker, William H. 1964. Federalism: Origin, Operation, Significance. Boston: Little, Brown.
Rodden, Jonathan. 2004. “Comparative Federalism and Decentralization: On Meaning and Measurement.” Comparative Politics 36(4):481500.
Sassen, Saskia. 2006. Territory, Authority, Rights: From Medieval to Global Assemblages. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Savage, Jesse Dillon. 2011. “The Stability and Breakdown of Empire: European Informal Empire in China, the Ottoman Empire and Egypt.” European Journal of International Relations 17(2):161185.
Sending, Ole Jacob, and Neumann, Iver B.. 2006. “Governance to Governmentality: Analyzing NGOs, States, and Power.” International Studies Quarterly 50(3):651.
Shirk, Susan L. 2007. China: Fragile Superpower: How China’s Internal Politics Could Derail Its Peaceful Rise. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Shirk, Susan L. 2014. “The Domestic Context of Chinese Foreign Security Policies.” In Oxford Handbook of the International Relations of Asia, edited by Saadia M. Pekkanen, John Ravenhill, and Rosemary Hill. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Sigmund, Paul E. 1962. “The Influence of Marsilius of Padua on XVth-Century Conciliarism.” Journal of the History of Ideas 23(3):392402.
Simmel, Georg. 1971. On Individuality and Social Forms. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Skumsrud Andersen, Morten. 2016. “Semi-Cores in Imperial Relations: The Cases of Scotland and Norway.” Review of International Studies 42(1):178203.
Smith, David E. 1991. “Empire, Crown, and Canadian Federalism.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 24(3):451473.
Spruyt, Hendrik. 1996. The Sovereign State and Its Competitors: An Analysis of Systems Change. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Stepan, Alfred C. 1999. “Federalism and Democracy: Beyond the US Model.” Journal of Democracy 10(4):1934.
Swenden, Wilfried. 2002. “Asymmetric Federalism and Coalition-Making in Belgium.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism 32(3):67.
Sylvan, David, and Majeski, Stephen. 2009. U.S. Foreign Policy in Perspective: Clients, Enemies, and Empire. London, UK: Routledge.
Tarlton, Charles D. 1965. “Symmetry and Asymmetry as Elements of Federalism: A Theoretical Speculation.” The Journal of Politics 27(4):861874.
Terrill, Ross. 2004. The New Chinese Empire: And What It Means for the United States. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Thompson, Lanny. 2002. “The Imperial Republic: A Comparison of the Insular Territories Under U.S. Dominion After 1898.” Pacific Historical Review 71(4):535574.
Tilly, Charles. 1997. “How Empires End.” In After Empire: Multiethnic Societies and Nation-Building, edited by Karen Barkey, and M. von Hagen, 1–11. Boulder, CO: Westview.
Tilly, Charles. 1998. “International Communities, Secure or Otherwise.” In Security Communities, edited by E. Adler, and M. Barnett, 397412. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tilly, Charles. 2003. The Politics of Collective Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Towns, Ann. 2009. “The Status of Women as a Standard of ‘Civilization’.” European Journal of International Relations 15(4):681706.
Trigger, Bruce G. 2003. Understanding Early Civilizations: A Comparative Study. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Wagner, R. Harrison. 2007. War and the State: The Theory of International Politics. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Waltz, Kenneth. 1979. Theory of international relations. Reading, MA: Addison-Webley.
Ward, Steven. 2017. “Lost in Translation: Social Identity Theory and the Study of Status in World Politics.” International Studies Quarterly, 61(4): 821834.
Watts, Ronald. 1996. Comparing Federal Systems in the 1990s. Kingston: Queen’s University Press.
Watts, Ronald L. 1998. “Federalism, Federal Political Systems, and Federations.” Annual Reviews of Political Science 1:117137.
Weber, Katja. 1997. “Hierarchy Amidst Anarchy: A Transaction Costs Approach to International Security Cooperation.” International Studies Quarterly 41(2):321340.
Weinberg, Joe. 2016. “European Union Member States in Cross-National Analyses: The Dangers of Neglecting Supranational Policymaking.” International Studies Quarterly 60(1):91106.
Wendt, Alexander, and Friedheim, Daniel. 1995. “Hierarchy Under Anarchy: Informal Empire and the East German State.” International Organization 49(4):689721.
Wibbels, Erik. 2005. Federalism and the Market: Intergovernmental Conflict and Economic Reform in the Developing World. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Wildavsky, Aaron B. 1967. American Federalism in Perspective: Readings. Boston: Little, Brown.
Wohlforth, William C. 2009. “Unipolarity, Status Competition, and Great Power War.” World Politics 61(1):2857.
Ziblatt, Daniel. 2006. Structuring the State: The Formation of Italy and Germany and the Puzzle of Federalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Zuber, Christina Isabel. 2011. “Understanding the Multinational Game: Toward a Theory of Asymmetrical Federalism.” Comparative Political Studies 44(5):546571.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Theory
  • ISSN: 1752-9719
  • EISSN: 1752-9727
  • URL: /core/journals/international-theory
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed