Skip to main content Accessibility help

What's it like to be a state? An argument for state consciousness

  • Adam B. Lerner (a1)


Questions of consciousness pervade the social sciences. Yet, despite persistent tendencies to anthropomorphize states, most International Relations scholarship implicitly adopts the position that humans are conscious and states are not. Recognizing that scholarly disagreement over fundamental issues prevents answering definitively whether states are truly conscious, I instead demonstrate how scholars of multiple dispositions can incorporate a pragmatic notion of state consciousness into their theorizing. Drawing on recent work from Eric Schwitzgebel and original supplementary arguments, I demonstrate that states are not only complex informationally integrated systems with emergent properties, but they also exhibit seemingly genuine responses to qualia that are irreducible to individuals within them. Though knowing whether states possess an emergent ‘stream’ of consciousness indiscernible to their inhabitants may not yet be possible, I argue that a pragmatic notion of state consciousness can contribute to a more complete understanding of state personhood, as well as a revised model of the international system useful to multiple important theoretical debates. In the article's final section, I apply this model to debate over the levels of analysis at which scholarship applies ontological security theory. I suggest the possibility of emergent state-level ontological insecurity that need not be understood via problematic reduction to individuals.


Corresponding author

Corresponding author. Email:


Hide All
Arfi, Badredline, and Kessler, Oliver. 2018. “Forum: Social Theory Going Quantum-Theoretic? Questions, Alternatives and Challenges.” Millennium: Journal of International Studies 47(1):67141.
Avramides, Anita. 2019. “Other Minds.” Edited by Edward N. Zalta. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Bartelson, Jens. 1998. “Second Natures: Is the State Identical with Itself?European Journal of International Relations 4(3):295326.
Beck, Ulrich. 1997. The Reinvention of Politics: Rethinking Modernity in the Global Social Order. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Bergstrom, Rochelle L., and McCaul, Kevin D.. 2004. “Perceived Risk and Worry: The Effects of 9/11 on Willingness to Fly.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology 34(9):1846–56.
Blalock, Garrick, Kadiyali, Vrinda, and Simon, Daniel H.. 2009. “Driving Fatalities After 9/11: A Hidden Cost of Terrorism.” Applied Economics 41(14):1717–29.
Bleiker, Roland, and Hutchison, Emma. 2008. “Fear No More: Emotions and World Politics.” Review of International Studies 34(S1):115–35.
Block, Ned. 1983. “Troubles with Functionalism.” In Readings in Philosophy of Psychology, vol. 1, edited by Block, Ned, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Chalmers, David J. 1997. The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory. Philosophy of Mind Series. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chalmers, David J. 2010. The Character of Consciousness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Charland-Verville, Vanessa, Vanhaudenhuyse, Audrey, Laureys, Steven, and Gosseries, Olivia. 2015. “The Scientific Study of Coma and Related States.” In The Constitution of Phenomenal Consciousness: Toward a Science and Theory, edited by Miller, Steven M., 293309. 92. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Christophe, Véronique, and Rimé, Bernard. 1997. “Exposure to the Social Sharing of Emotion: Emotional Impact, Listener Responses and Secondary Social Sharing.” European Journal of Social Psychology 27(1):3754.
Crawford, Neta C. 2014. “Institutionalizing Passion in World Politics: Fear and Empathy.” International Theory 6(03):535–57.
Croft, Stuart. 2012. “Constructing Ontological Insecurity: The Insecuritization of Britain's Muslims.” Contemporary Security Policy 33(2):219–35.
Dennett, Daniel C. 1993. Consciousness Explained. London: Penguin Books.
Dennett, Daniel C. 2016. “Illusionism as the Obvious Default Theory of Consciousness.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 23(11–12):6572.
Dretske, Fred I. 1997. Explaining Behavior: Reasons in a World of Causes. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Durkheim, Émile. 1998. The Division of Labour in Society. Edited by Coser, Lewis and Halls, W. D.. Theoretical Traditions in the Social Sciences. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Edkins, Jenny. 2002. “Forget Trauma? Responses to September 11.” International Relations 16(2):243–56.
Feest, Uljana. 2014. “Phenomenal Experiences, First-Person Methods, and the Artificiality of Experimental Data.” Philosophy of Science 81(5):927–39.
Ferguson, Yale H., and Mansbach, Richard W.. 1991. “Between Celebration and Despair: Constructive Suggestions for Future International Theory.” International Studies Quarterly 35(4):363.
Fernyhough, Charles. 1996. “The Dialogic Mind: A Dialogic Approach to the Higher Mental Functions.” New Ideas in Psychology 14(1):4762.
Figdor, Carrie. 2018. Pieces of Mind: The Proper Domain of Psychological Predicates. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Franklin, Stan. 2001. Artificial Minds. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Frankish, Keith. 2016. “Illusionism as a Theory of Consciousness.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 23(11–12):1139.
Freud, Sigmund. 1939. Moses and Monotheism. Translated by Jones, Katherine. New York: Vintage Books, 1967.
Freud, Sigmund. 1957. “Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego.” In Standard Edition, vol. 18. London: Hogarth Press.
Giacino, Joseph T., Ashwal, Stephen, Childs, Nancy, Cranford, Ronald, Jennett, Bryan, Katz, Douglas I., Kelly, James P., Rosenberg, Jay H., Whyte, John, and Zafonte, Ross D.. 2002. “The Minimally Conscious State: Definition and Diagnostic Criteria.” Neurology 58(3):349–53.
Giddens, Anthony. 1991. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Gilpin, Robert G. 1984. “The Richness of the Tradition of Political Realism.” International Organization 38(02):287.
Haberman, Maggie, and Sanger, David E.. 2018. “‘It Won't Happen’, Donald Trump Says of North Korean Missile Test.” The New York Times, August 7, 2018, sec. World.
Hall, Todd H., and Ross, Andrew A. G.. 2015. “Affective Politics After 9/11.” International Organization 69(4):847–79.
Hall, T. H., and A, Ross. 2019. “Rethinking affective experience and popular emotions: World War I and the construction of group emotion in International Relations.” Political Psychology 40, 13571372.
Hansen, Lene. 2006. Security as Practice: Discourse Analysis and the Bosnian War. New York: Routledge.
Hareli, Shlomo, and Rafaeli, Anat. 2008. “Emotion Cycles: On the Social Influence of Emotion in Organizations.” Research in Organizational Behavior 28(January):3559.
Huddy, Leonie, and Feldman, Stanley. 2011. “Americans Respond Politically to 9/11: Understanding the Impact of the Terrorist Attacks and Their Aftermath.” American Psychologist 66(6):455–67.
Huebner, Bryce. 2014. Macrocognition: A Theory of Distributed Minds and Collective Intentionality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hutchison, Emma. 2016. Affective Communities in World Politics: Collective Emotions After Trauma. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Huysmans, Jef. 1998. “Security! What Do You Mean?: From Concept to Thick Signifier.” European Journal of International Relations 4(2):226–55.
Hyslop, Alec. 2014. “Other Minds.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2018 Edition), edited by Zalta, Edward N..
Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus. 2008. “Foregrounding Ontology: Dualism, Monism, and IR Theory.” Review of International Studies 34(01):129153.
Jackson, Patrick Thaddeus. 2016. “Fundamental Grounding.” Perspectives on Politics 14(4):1153–57.
Kahler, Miles. 1998. “Rationality in International Relations.” International Organization 52(4):919–41.
Kammerer, François. 2015. “How a Materialist Can Deny That the United States is Probably Conscious – Response to Schwitzgebel.” Philosophia 43(4):1047–57.
Kelsen, Hans. 1924. “The Conception of the State and Social Psychology – With Special Reference to Freud's Group Theory.” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 5:138.
Kinnvall, Catarina. 2004. “Globalization and Religious Nationalism: Self, Identity, and the Search for Ontological Security.” Political Psychology 25(5):741–67.
Krasner, Stephen D. 1982. “Regimes and the Limits of Realism: Regimes as Autonomous Variables.” International Organization 36(02):497.
Laing, Ronald D. 1960. The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity and Madness. London: Pelican.
Le Bon, Gustave. 1897. The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind. New York: The MacMillan Company.
Lebow, Richard Ned. 2016. National Identities and International Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lerner, Adam B. 2019. “The Uses and Abuses of Victimhood Nationalism in International Politics.” European Journal of International Relations. online pages are 126.
List, Christian. 2018. “What is it Like to Be a Group Agent?Noûs 52(2):295319.
Lomas, Peter. 2005. “Anthropomorphism, Personification and Ethics: A Reply to Alexander Wendt.” Review of International Studies 31(2):349–55.
McDougall, William. 1920. The Group Mind. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons.
McSweeney, Bill. 1999. Security, Identity and Interests: A Sociology of International Relations. Cambridge Studies in International Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mearsheimer, John J. 2009. “Reckless States and Realism.” International Relations 23(2):241–56.
Mercer, Jonathan. 2006. “Human Nature and the First Image: Emotion in International Politics.” Journal of International Relations and Development 9(S3):288303.
Mercer, Jonathan. 2010. “Emotional Beliefs.” International Organization 64(1):131.
Mercer, Jonathan. 2014. “Feeling Like a State: Social Emotion and Identity.” International Theory 6(3):515–35.
Mitzen, Jennifer. 2006. “Ontological Security in World Politics: State Identity and the Security Dilemma.” European Journal of International Relations 12(3):341–70.
Morgan, G.Scott, Daniel C.Wisneski, and Linda J.Skitka, . 2011. “The Expulsion from Disneyland: The Social Psychological Impact of 9/11.” American Psychologist 66(6):447–54.
Myers, David G. 2001. “Do We Fear the Right Things?APS Observer 14(10). This is an online column available at
Nagel, Thomas. 1974. “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?The Philosophical Review 83(4):435.
Overgaard, Morten. 2006. “Book Review Essay: Consciousness Studies: The View from Psychology.” British Journal of Psychology 97(3):425–38.
Park, Robert E. 1921. “Sociology and the Social Sciences: The Social Organism and the Collective Mind.” American Journal of Sociology 27(1):121.
Pettit, Philip. 2010. “Groups with Minds of Their Own.” In Social Epistemology: Essential Readings, edited by Goldman, Alvin and Whitcomb, Dennis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pettit, Philip. 2018. “Consciousness Incorporated.” Journal of Social Philosophy 49(1):1237.
Pick, Daniel. 1995. “Freud's ‘Group Psychology’ and the History of the Crowd.” History Workshop Journal 40:3961.
Rimé, Bernard. 2009. “Emotion Elicits the Social Sharing of Emotion: Theory and Empirical Review.” Emotion Review 1(1):6085.
Ringmar, Erik. 1996. “On the Ontological Status of the State.” European Journal of International Relations 2(4):439–66.
Rossdale, Chris. 2015. “Enclosing Critique: The Limits of Ontological Security.” International Political Sociology 9(4):369–86.
Sasley, Brent E. 2011. “Theorizing States’ Emotions.” International Studies Review 13(3):452–76.
Saurette, Paul. 2006. “You Dissin Me? Humiliation and Post 9/11 Global Politics.” Review of International Studies 32(3):495522.
Schiff, Jacob. 2008. “‘Real’? As If! Critical Reflections on State Personhood.” Review of International Studies 34(2):363–77.
Schwitzgebel, Eric. 2012. “Why Tononi Should Think That the United States Is Conscious.” The Splintered Mind (blog). March 23, 2012.
Schwitzgebel, Eric. 2015. “If Materialism is True, the United States is Probably Conscious.” Philosophical Studies 172(7):1697–721.
Schwitzgebel, E., 2016. “Phenomenal consciousness, defined and defended as innocently as I can manage.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 23(11–12), pp.224235. Vancouver
Schwitzgebel, Eric. 2016b. “Is the United States Phenomenally Conscious? Reply to Kammerer.” Philosophia 44(3):877–83.
Searle, John R. 1980. “Minds, Brains, and Programs.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3(03):417.
Searle, John R. 1984. Minds, Brains, and Science. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Silver, Roxane Cohen. 2002. “Nationwide Longitudinal Study of Psychological Responses to September 11.” JAMA 288(10):1235.
Smith, Sophie. 2018. “Democracy and the Body Politic from Aristotle to Hobbes.” Political Theory 46(2):167–96.
Solomon, Ty. 2012. “‘I Wasn't Angry, Because I Couldn't Believe it was Happening’: Affect and Discourse in Responses to 9/11.” Review of International Studies 38(4):907–28.
Steele, Brent J. 2008. Ontological Security in International Relations: Self-Identity and the IR State. London: Routledge.
Steele, Brent J., and Homolar, Alexandra. 2019. “Introduction: Ontological Insecurities and the Politics of Contemporary Populism.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 32(3):214–21.
Subotić, Jelena. 2015. “Narrative, Ontological Security, and Foreign Policy Change.” Foreign Policy Analysis 12(4):610627.
Tajfel, Henri. 1974. “Social Identity and Intergroup Behaviour.” Information (International Social Science Council) 13(2):6593.
Thiessen, Marc A. 2018. “Opinion: Trump Should Get Even Tougher with North Korea.” Washington Post, May 24, 2018.
Tononi, Giulio. 2004. “An Information Integration Theory of Consciousness.” BMC Neuroscience 5(1):42.
Trotter, Wilfred. 2005. Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War. London: T. F. Unwin Ltd.
Virmal, Ram. 2009. “Meanings Attributed to the Term ‘Consciousness’: An Overview.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 16(5):927.
Waltz, Kenneth N. 1979. Theory of International Politics. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Wendt, Alexander. 2004. “The State as Person in International Theory.” Review of International Studies 30(02):289316.
Wendt, Alexander. 2015. Quantum Mind and Social Science: Unifying Physical and Social Ontology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wight, Colin. 2004. “State Agency: Social Action Without Human Activity?Review of International Studies 30(2):269–80.
Wight, Colin. 2006. Agents, Structures and International Relations: Politics as Ontology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


What's it like to be a state? An argument for state consciousness

  • Adam B. Lerner (a1)


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed