Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Inter-plot competition in variety trials of field beans (Vicia faba L.)

  • R. A. Kempton (a1) and G. Lockwood (a1)

Four trials were carried out to investigate the effect of inter-plot competition on seed yield and plant height of field beans using experimental designs balanced for neighbours. One trial tested four varieties ranging in final height from 25 to 100 cm and sown in four-row plots with 30 cm spacing between rows and one blank row between plots. When grown between plots of a dwarf variety, the plot yield of the tallest variety was increased by 20% compared with its pure stand yield: a complementary reduction in yield was shown by the dwarf variety when grown between plots of the tall. The effect on the yield of the inner rows of the plot was somewhat smaller than that of the outer rows but still significant. Another trial with six commercial varieties differing in final height by less than 15 cm showed no differential effects of inter-varietal competition on yield. In two trials with six varieties of widely differing heights planted with 50 cm spacing between rows, but no gap between plots, plot yield was strongly affected by the neighbouring variety in the trial with single-row plots, while yields from the four-row trial showed a large interaction between variety and inner and outer row position, again indicative of inter-variety competition. The yield response to competition could be described by a common linear regression on the excess height of plot neighbours: there was little evidence of varietal differences in sensitivity or aggressiveness.

Plant height showed a positive response to height of plot neighbours in all four trials, whilst in the single-row trial, the ratio of grain yield to total dry-matter production (harvest index) was negatively related to excess height of neighbours.

The results suggest that, when testing varieties differing in height by more than 20 cm, at least two buffer rows, e.g. six-row plots with the centre two rows harvested, are required to obtain a true comparison of pure-stand yield. Alternatively, when this procedure would result in an unacceptable use of resources, one of the statistical models adapted in this paper may be used to adjust variety yields for pure stands.

Hide All
Austin R. B. & Blackwell R. D. (1980). Edge and neighbour effects in cereal yield trials. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 94, 731734.
Bond D. A., Fyfe J. L. & Toynbee-Clarke G. (1966). Yields of mixtures of single-cross hybrid field beans (Viciafaba L.) with one of the parental inbred lines. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 67, 235237.
Cannell M. G. R., Njuguna C. K., Ford E. D., Smith R. & Ross-Parker H. M. (1977). Variation in yield among competing individuals within mixed genotype stands of tea: a selection problem. Journal of Applied Ecology 14, 969985.
Finney D. J. & Outhwaite A. D. (1956). Serially balanced sequences in bioassay. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 145, 493507.
Fischer R. A. (1979). Are your results confounded by intergenotypic competition? In Proceedings of the Vth International Wheat Genetics Symposium, vol. 2, pp. 767777. New Delhi, 1978.
Freeman G. H. (1979). Some two-dimensional designs balanced for nearest neighbours. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B 41, 8895.
Gomez K. A. (1972). Border effects in rice experimental plots. II. Varietal competition. Experimental Agriculture 8, 295298.
Jensen N. F. & Federer W. T. (1964). Adjacent row competition in wheat. Crop Science 4, 641645.
Kempton R. A. (1982). Adjustment for competition between varieties in plant breeding trials. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 98, 599611.
Le Clerg E. L., Leonard W. H. & Clark A. G. (1962). Field Plot Technique. Minneapolis: Burgess.
Omar M. & Hawtin G. (1980). Plot technique studies on Faba beans. III. Border effects for different plot designs. Faba Bean Information Service 2, 1516.
Sjödin S. (1971). Induced morphological variation in Viciafaba L. Hereditas 67, 155180.
Thompson R. & Taylor H. (1982). Prospects for Vicia faba L. in Northern Europe. Outlook on Agriculture 11, 127133.
Williams E. J. (1962). The analysis of competition experiments. Australian Journal of Biological Science 15, 509525.
Williams R. M. (1952). Experimental designs for serially correlated observations. Biometrika 39, 152167.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The Journal of Agricultural Science
  • ISSN: 0021-8596
  • EISSN: 1469-5146
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-agricultural-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 4 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 69 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.