Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c47g7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T15:22:19.569Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

J. Edgar Hoover and the “Red Summer” of 1919

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2009

Mark Ellis
Mark Ellis
Affiliation:
Mark Ellis is Lecturer in American History, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G1 1XQ, Scotland.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

J. Edgar Hoover directed the Bureau of Investigation (BI), later renamed the Federal Bureau of Investigation, from 1924 until his death in 1972. His autocratic style of management, self-mythologising habits, reactionary political opinions and accumulation of secret files on real, imagined and potential opponents have been widely documented. The views and methods he advocated have been variously attributed to values he absorbed as he grew up and to certain peculiarities of his personality. Most biographers trace his rapid rise to prominence in the BI to his aptitude for investigating alien enemies during World War I, and radicals during the subsequent Red Scare. He was centrally involved in the government's response to the alleged threat of Bolshevism in America, and, although he later denied it, he co-ordinated the notorious Palmer raids of January 1920, in which thousands of aliens were rounded up and several hundred were deported.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 28 , Issue 1 , April 1994 , pp. 39 - 59
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Powers, Richard Gid, Secrecy and Power: The Life of J. Edgar Hoover (London: Hutchinson, 1987)Google Scholar stresses environmental influences on Hoover, J. Edgar. Theoharis, Athan G. and Cox, John Stuart, The Boss: J. Edgar Hoover and the Great American Inquisition (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1988)Google Scholar employ psychological insights from Adorno, Theodor W. et al. , The Authoritarian Personality (New York: Harper, 1950)Google Scholar. See Wreszin, Michael, “‘Gee But I'd Like to be a G-Man,’” Reviews in American History, 20 (06 1992), 258–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For critical accounts of Hoover's work in the Red Scare, see Powers, , Secrecy and Power, 57–127Google Scholar; Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 51–70Google Scholar; Gentry, Curt, J. Edgar Hoover: The Man and the Secrets (New York: Norton, 1991), 75–105Google Scholar; Belknap, Michael R., “The Mechanics of Repression: J. Edgar Hoover, the Bureau of Investigation and the Radicals, 1917–1925,” Crime and Social Justice, 7 (Summer 1977), 49–58Google Scholar. For a sympathetic account, see de Toledano, Ralph, J. Edgar Hoover: The Man in His Time (New Rochelle, N.Y.: Arlington House, 1973), 47–65Google Scholar. On Hoover's denial of involvement in the Palmer raids, see Messick, Hank, John Edgar Hoover (New York: David McKay, 1972), 14–18Google Scholar; Kahn, Albert E., High Treason: The Plot Against the People (Croton-on-the-Hudson, N.Y.: The Hour Publishers, 1950), 14–19Google Scholar.

2 Johnson, James Weldon, Along This Way (New York: Viking, 1933), 168Google Scholar.

3 General Intelligence Bulletins of Radical Activities, in Files OG 374217, OG 208369, OG 202600–1628, OG 202600–1778X, Bureau of Investigation Records, Record Group (RG) 65, National Archives (NA), Washington, DC; U.S. Senate, Investigation Activities of the Department of Justice, 66th Cong., 1st sess., 15 11 1919, 13, 161–87Google Scholar.

4 Powers, , Secrecy and Power, 9Google Scholar.

5 Ibid., 10–68; Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 19–56Google Scholar; Whitehead, Don, The FBI Story: A Report to the People (New York: Random House, 1956), 41–53Google Scholar.

6 Ellis, Mark, “Federal Surveillance of Black Americans During the First World War,” Immigrants and Minorities, 12 (03 1993), 1–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to 1957 (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1960), 218Google Scholar; Rudwick, Elliott M., Race Riot at East St. Louis, July 2, 1917 (New York: Atheneum, 1972)Google Scholar. Secretary's Report for June 1919, Board of Directors File, Papers of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC. Seligmann, Herbert J., “Protecting Southern Womanhood,” Nation, 108 (14 06 1919), 938Google Scholar.

8 Josephus Daniels to Arthur Capper, 26 June 1919, Letterbook 103, Papers of Josephus Daniels, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC; Reports and correspondence in Files 26283–2588, 26395/746, Records of the Office of the Secretary of the Navy, General Correspondence 1916–20, RG 80, NA; Reports and correspondence in Files 10218–348, 10218–376, Records of the Military Intelligence Division, RG 165, NA.

9 Abernethy, Lloyd M., “The Washington Race War of July, 1919,” Maryland Historical Quarterly, 58 (12 1963), 309–24Google Scholar; Crisis, 18 (09 1919), 243Google Scholar.

10 Reports of W. W. Wright, N. A. Joyce, H. P. Alden, E. O. Irish, F. C. Baggarly, P. M. Kemon, M. E. Tucker, 22 July–9 Aug. 1919, File OG 369936, RG 65, NA.

11 Robert A. Bowen, “Radicalism and Sedition Among the Negroes as Reflected in Their Publications,” 2 July 1919, File OG 359561, RG 65, NA. See also Bowen's reports and correspondence in Files 47732, B–236, B–240 RG 28 (Entry 40), NA. Bowen claimed that blacks showed “increasing defiance and organized alignment with the most destructive forces of our political life today. ” He found the black man “rapidly being made strongly race conscious and class conscious,” so that “his way of salvation is felt to lie not in the conformity to the law but in defiance and antagonism of it, while of popular opinion he is encouraged to become increasingly more insolently scornful. It is not in my opinion an attitude that the government can safely ignore.” Bowen's later reports were passed by the Post Office to the Justice Department, where Hoover came to rely on them.

12 New York Times, 28 July 1919. The federal official spoke of “an agitation which involves the I.W.W., Bolshevism and the worst features of other extreme radical movements. It appeals to the ignorant and seeks openly to create a feeling of resentment among certain negro elements that may lead to results that all good citizens will deplore unless it is stopped. That the movement is making headway there is no doubt. Reports from all parts of the country show this to be the case.” The last sentence suggests that an official central to government intelligence was speaking.

13 New York Times, 28 July 1919.

14 Tuttle, William M. Jr, “Labor Conflict and Racial Violence: The Black Worker in Chicago, 1894–1919,” Labor History, 10 (Summer 1969), 408–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tuttle, , “Contested Neighborhoods and Racial Violence: Prelude to the Chicago Race Riot of 1919,” Journal of Negro History, 55 (1970), 266–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tuttle, , Race Riot: Chicago in the Red Summer of 1919 (New York: Atheneum, 1978), 3–64Google Scholar; Gosnell, Harold F., Negro Politicians: The Rise of Negro Politics in Chicago (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1967), 36–62Google Scholar.

15 F. Burke to E. J. Brennan, 19 July 1919, File OG 369914, RG 65, NA.

16 Reports of E. J. Brennan, J. Spolansky, A. H. Loula, J. P. Folsom, M. Kitchin, 29 July–7 Aug. 1919, ibid.

17 “What the South Thinks of Northern Race Riots,” Literary Digest, 62 (16 08 1919), 17–18Google Scholar; New York Tribune, 29 July 1919; Boston Herald, 30 July 1919; New York Times, 29 July 1919.

18 Rudwick, , Race Riot at East St. Louis, 137, 262Google Scholar; A. Mitchell Palmer to Joseph P. Tumulty, 26 Dec. 1919, Case File 152, Papers of Woodrow Wilson, Library of Congress, Washington, DC; New York Times, 31 July 1919.

19 Powers, , Secrecy and Power, 66–68, 74–77, 96–100Google Scholar.

20 F. Burke to Maj. Raymond Pullman, 15 Aug. 1919, File OG 372102, RG 65, NA.

21 F. Burke to E. J. Brennan, 13 Aug. 1919, File OG 369914, RG 65, NA.

22 F. Burke to J. J. McLaughlin, 9 Aug. 1919, File OG 161973, ibid.

23 Report of M. J. Davis, 24 June 1919, File OG 341761, ibid.

24 C. S. Smith to Attorney General, 25 June 1919, File OG 185161, ibid.; Reports of M. J. Davis, 12 July 1919, W. M. Offley, 14 July 1919, File BS 198940, ibid.; J. T. Suter to W. M. Offley, 12 July 1919, File OG 5523, ibid.

25 J. E. Hoover to A. Caminetti, 13 Aug. 1919, File OG 18; 161, ibid.

26 Louis F. Post to Attorney General, 16 Aug. 1919, DJ Central File 198940, RG 60, NA; J. E. Hoover to H. S. Ridgeley, 11 Oct. 1919, ibid.; Hoover to G. F. Ruch, 25 Aug. 1919, File OG 341761, RG 65, NA; F. Burke to J. A. Baker, 15 Aug. 1919, File OG 185161, ibid.; W. H. Lamar to F. Burke, 1 Aug. 1919, and F. Burke to Baker, 18 Aug. 1919, File OG 359561, ibid.; Report of F. B. Faulhaber, 19 Aug. 1919, File OG 208369, ibid.; Report of M. J. Davis, 28 Aug. 1919, File OG 185161, ibid.; Reports of agents Wolff and Peyronnin, Sept.-Oct. 1919, File BS 198940, ibid.; J. E. Hoover to G. F. Ruch, 2; Aug. 1919, File OG 341761, ibid.

27 J. E. Hoover to G. F. Ruch, 8 June 1920, File BS 198940, ibid.Martin, Tony, Race First: The Ideological and Organizational Struggles of Marcus Garvey and the Universal Negro Improvement Association (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1976), 191–200Google Scholar; Hill, Robert A., “‘The Foremost Radical Among his Race: ’ Marcus Garvey and the Black Scare, 1918–1921,” Prologue, 16 (Winter 1984), 214–31Google Scholar.

28 F. Burke to J. A. Baker, 11 Aug. 1919, and J. E. Hoover to A. U. Craig, 12 Aug. 1919 File OG 258421, RG 65, NA; Reports of Agent C-C (Craig), 3 Sept–30 Sept. 1919, in Files OG 185161, OG 208369, OG 369936, ibid; J. E. Hoover, memorandum, 3 Oct. 1919, File OG 374217, ibid.

29 Congressional Record, 66th Cong., 1st sess., 25 Aug. 1919, 4302–5. James F. Byrnes to A. Mitchell Palmer, 25 Aug. 1919, DJ Central File 9–12–725, RG 60, NA.

30 New York Times, 26, 27 Aug. 1919.

31 R. P. Stewart to J. F. Byrnes, 12 Sept. 1919, DJ Central File 9–12–725, RG 60, NA; F. P. Caffey to Attorney General, 3 Nov. 1919, 10 Dec. 1919, ibid.; Stewart to Byrnes, 14 Nov. 1919, ibid.; Hoover to B. A. Matthews, 3 Dec. 1919, ibid.; Bureau Chief to Lamb, 4 Oct. 1919, File OG 258421, RG 65, NA; J. E. Hoover, memoranda on Radical Division work, 10, 18 Oct. 1919, File OG 374217, ibid.

32 F. Burke to J. H. Daly, 29 Sept. 1919, File OG 292778, RG 65, NA; Reports of J. H. Daly, 4, 18, 25 Oct. 1919, ibid.; Reports of S. W. Dillingham, 7, 9 Oct. 1919, ibid.; Omaha World-Herald, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31 Sept. 1919; Lawson, Michael L., “Omaha, A City in Ferment: Summer of 1919,” Nebraska History, 58 (Fall 1977), 395–417Google Scholar.

33 Crisis, 19 (12 1919), 56–62Google Scholar; White, Walter F., “‘Massacring Whites’ in Arkansas,” Nation, 109 (6 12 1919), 715–16Google Scholar; McCool, B. Boren, Union, Reaction, and Riot: Biography of a Rural Race Riot (Memphis: Memphis State University Press, 1970)Google Scholar. The highest official estimate of the number of blacks killed near Elaine was twenty-six. The true figure may have been four or five times greater. The Works Projects Administration's Arkansas: A Guide to the State (New York: Hastings House, 1941), 341Google Scholar, states “probably more than 100 Negroes lost their lives.” A white Arkansan gave the number killed as 856. See Dunaway, L. Sharpe, What a Preacher Saw Through a Key-Hole in Arkansas (Little Rock: Parke-Harper, 1925), 101–17Google Scholar.

34 Charles H. Brough to A. S. Burleson, 17 Oct. 1919, File OG 20770, RG 65, NA; E. M. Allen to David Y. Thomas, 4 Jan. 1920, Papers of David Yancey Thomas, Special Collections, University of Arkansas Library; Capt. J. B. Campbell to Intelligence Officer, Camp Pike, Ark., 2 Oct. 1919, File 10218–372, RG 165, NA.

35 F. Burke to McElveen, 2, 4, 6, 7 Oct. 1919, File OG 373159, RG 65, NA; Reports of McElveen, 7, 10, 11 Oct. 1919, ibid.; McElveen to Burke, 9 Oct., 30 Dec. 1919, ibid.; Reports of C. M. Walser 10, 12 Oct. 1919, ibid.; Walser to Burke, 4 Nov. 1919, ibid.; Report of C. R. Maxey, 10 Oct. 1919, ibid. See also material in DJ Central File 158260, RG 60, NA. A. Mitchell Palmer to Joseph P. Tumulty, 26 Dec. 1919, Case File 152, Papers of Woodrow Wilson, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.

36 J. E. Hoover, memorandum, 18 Oct. 1919, File OG 374217, RG 65, NA.

37 Nashville Banner, 4 Oct. 1919; New York Times, 5 Oct. 1919.

38 Murray, Robert K., Red Scare: A Study in National Hysteria, 1919–1920 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1955), 124–56, 166–77, 195–96Google Scholar; Senate Resolution 213, 17 Oct. 1919, 66th Cong., 1st sess.; New York Times, 19 Oct. 1919.

39 Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 58Google Scholar; Robert A. Bowen, “ Radicalism and Sedition Among the Negroes as Reflected in Their Publications,” 28 Oct. 1919, File OG 3056, RG 65, NA. See Investigation Activities of the Department of Justice, 167–81. Authorship is attributed to Hoover or Palmer by Powers, Secrecy and Power, 68–69, 128; Kornweibel, Theodore Jr, No Crystal Stair: Black Life and the Messenger, 1917–1928 (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1975), 76–79Google Scholar; Cohen, William, “Riots, Racism, and Hysteria: The Response of Federal Investigative Officials to the Race Riots of 1919,” Massachusetts Review, 13 (Summer 1972), 382–83Google Scholar; Waskow, Arthur I., From Race Riot to Sit-In, 1919 and the 1960s (Gloucester, Mass.: Peter Smith, 1975), 189–92Google Scholar; de Toledano, , J. Edgar Hoover, 56Google Scholar; Lowenthal, Max, The Federal Bureau of Investigation (New York: William Sloane Associates, 1950), 120–29Google Scholar.

40 Investigation Activities, 13, 162, 172.

41 Ibid., 162.

42 Ibid., 328.

43 J. E. Hoover to R. P. Stewart, 7 Nov. 1919, DJ Central File 158260–1, RG 60, NA; Col. A. B. Coxe to J. E. Hoover, 13 Dec. 1919, DJ Central File 202600, ibid.; Brig. Gen. M. Churchill to Hoover, 16 Dec. 1919, ibid.; T. J. Spellacy to E. K. Jones, 2 Jan. 1920, ibid.; Spellacy to H. C. Lyman, 8 Jan. 1920, ibid.; Chicago Daily News, 5 Nov. 1919. Hoover often passed off others' writing as his own. See Gentry, , J. Edgar Hoover, 81Google Scholar.

44 Congressional Record, 66th Cong., 1st sess., 19 Nov. 1919, 8818–21. Sedition, Syndicalism, Sabotage, and Anarchy, Hearings before Committee on Judiciary, House of Representatives, on Resolutions 10210, 10235, 10379, 10614. 10616, 10650, 11089, 66th Cong., 1st sess., 11, 16 Dec. 1919, 6–13.

45 Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 84–85, 92–94, 106–7, 111–199Google Scholar; Elliff, John T., The Reform of FBI Intelligence Operations (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979), 15–19Google Scholar; Powers, Richard Gid, G-Men: Hoover's FBI in American Popular Culture (Carbondale, Ill.: Southern Illinois University Press, 1983), passimGoogle Scholar; Donner, Frank, “How J. Edgar Hoover Created His Intelligence Powers,” Civil Liberties Review, 3 (02–03 1977), 34–51Google Scholar.

46 O'Reilly, Kenneth, “Racial Matters”: The FBI's Secret File on Black America, 1960–72 (New York: Free Press, 1989), 16–29, 31–47Google Scholar; Washburn, Patrick S., A Question of Sedition: The Federal Government's Investigation of the Black Press During World War II (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986)Google Scholar.

47 Keller, William W., The Liberals and J. Edgar Hoover: Rise and Fall of a Domestic Intelligence State (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989), 73–78Google Scholar.

48 Powers, , Secrecy and Power, 329–31, 417Google Scholar; Hoover, J. Edgar, Masters of Deceit (New York: Henry Holt, 1958), 243Google Scholar; Hoover, , “Red Fascism in the United States Today,” American Magazine (02 1947), 24–25, 87–90Google Scholar. Remarks before Pennsylvania Society and Society of Pennsylvania Women, New York, 12 Dec. 1965, in Hoover, , J. Edgar Hoover on Communism (New York: Random House, 1969), 130–31Google Scholar. The FBI produced reports for Eisenhower entitled “The Communist Party and the Negro” in 1953 and 1956 and “The Nation of Islam” in 1960.

49 Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 354–60Google Scholar; Ungar, Sanford, FBI (Boston: Little, Brown, 1975), 419Google Scholar; Garrow, David J., The FBI and Martin Luther King, Jr: From ‘Solo’ to Memphis (New York: W. W. Norton, 1981), 151–58Google Scholar. See also Keller, , The Liberals and J. Edgar Hoover, 103–10Google Scholar; Sorrentino, Frank M., Ideological Warfare: The FBI's Path Toward Power (Port Washington, N.Y.: Associated Faculty Press, 1985), 107–34Google Scholar. In 1962, King's name was added to the Bureau's Emergency Detention list of people to be arrested in the event of war. See Powers, , Secrecy and Power, 371Google Scholar.

50 Garrow, , FBI and Martin Luther King, 119–20Google Scholar; Blackstock, Nelson, COINTELPRO: The FBI's Secret War on Political Freedom (New York: Vintage, 1976)Google Scholar; O'Reilly, Kenneth, Hoover and the Un-Americans: The FBI, HUAC, and the Red Menace (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1983), 370Google Scholar.

51 Hoover, Masters of Deceit, foreword.

52 Reports and correspondence in Files BS 202600–35 and BS 61–44, RG 65, NA; O'Reilly, , Hoover and the Un-Americans, 95–96, 197–98, 210Google Scholar; O'Reilly, , “Racial Matters,” 69–70, 73, 134–35, 144–47, 155, 168, 255, 326–27Google Scholar; Garrow, , FBI and Martin Luther King, 53, 61–62, 66, 130–51Google Scholar; Ungar, , FBI, 104–10, 115–18, 134–39, 148–50, 159–72, 284–85Google Scholar; Theoharis, and Cox, , The Boss, 357–60Google Scholar.

53 O'Reilly, Kenneth, “The FBI and the Politics of the Riots, 1964–1968,” Journal of American History, 75 (06 1988), 91–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

54 Statement before National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 18 Sept. 1968, in Hoover, , Hoover on Communism, 132Google Scholar. See also Hoover's 1968 FBI appropriation testimony, ibid., 131–32.