Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

UNNATURAL DEATHS AMONG NUNS AND MONKS: IS THERE A BIOLOGICAL FORCE BEHIND MALE EXTERNAL CAUSE MORTALITY?

  • MARC LUY (a1)
Summary
Summary

It is still unclear if and how biological factors contribute to excess male mortality due to ‘external causes’ (accidents, injuries, homicides and suicides). Sex hormones and reproductive roles are supposed to drive sex differences in behaviours increasing the male external cause mortality risk. This study analyses the external cause mortality of Catholic nuns and monks from three Bavarian cloisters whose similar environments allow the impact of biological factors to be isolated from a number of confounding causes. Using obituaries, entries in the profession books of religious orders and cemetery registers 2533 deaths of nuns and monks could be linked to a specific cause of death for the years 1946–2005, of which 69 belong to the group of external cause deaths. External cause mortality of the Bavarian cloistered and the West German general population has been compared by means of standardized mortality rates (SMRs) for ages 45 onwards using the European age standard for the age groups 45–64, 65–74 and 75+. Whereas nuns show statistically significantly lower external cause mortality than the general female population, monks' external cause mortality parallels or even exceeds that of general population males. These findings contradict the reproductive role hypothesis and provide some evidence for the sex hormones hypothesis.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Adler F. & Adler H. M. (1975) Sisters in Crime: The Rise of the New Female Criminal. McGraw-Hill, New York.
Barford A., Dorling D., Davey Smith G. & Shaw M. (2006) Life expectancy: women now on top everywhere. British Medical Journal 332, 808.
Barrow J. G., Quinlan C. B., Cooper G. R., Whitner V. S. & Goodloe M. H. R. (1960) Studies in atherosclerosis. III. An epidemiologic study of atherosclerosis in Trappist and Benedictine monks: a preliminary report. Annals of Internal Medicine 52, 368377.
Bartusch D. R. J., Lynam D. R., Moffitt T. E. & Silva P. A. (1997) Is age important? Testing a general versus developmental theory of antisocial behavior. Criminology 35, 1349.
Behm H. & Vallin J. (1980) Mortality differentials among human populations. In Preston S. H. (ed.) Biological and Social Aspects of Mortality and the Length of Life. Ordina Editions, Liège, pp. 1137.
Cameron H. M. & McGoogan E. (1981) A prospective study of 1152 hospital autopsies. Part I: inaccuracies in death certification. Journal of Pathology 133, 273283.
Carey A. D. & Lopreato J. (1995) The biocultural evolution of the male–female mortality differential. Mankind Quarterly 36, 328.
Caspi A., Begg D., Dickson N., Harrington H., Langley J., Moffitt T. E. & Silva P. A. (1997) Personality differences predict health-risk behaviors in young adulthood: evidence from a longitudinal study. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 73, 10521063.
Daly M. & Wilson M. (2001) Risk-taking, intrasexual competition, and homicide. Nebraska Symposium on Motivation 47, 136.
Donovan J. E. & Jessor R. (1985) Structure of problem behavior in adolescence and young adulthood. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 53, 890904.
Fecher C. J. (1927) Decline of tuberculosis death rates among sisters. America 38, 5860.
Fox J. & Hartnagel T. F. (1979) Changing social roles and female crime in Canada: a time series analysis. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 16, 96104.
Fraumeni J. F., Lloyd J. W., Smith E. M. & Wagoner J. K. (1969) Cancer mortality among nuns: role of marital status in etiology of neoplastic disease in women. Journal of the National Cancer Institute 42, 455468.
Grasmick H. G., Tittle C. R., Bursik R. J. Jr & Arneklev B. J. (1993) Testing the core empirical implications of Gottfredson and Hirschi's general theory of crime. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 30, 529.
Hagan J. (1989) Structural Criminology. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ.
Hemström Ö. (1999) Does the work environment contribute to excess male mortality? Social Science and Medicine 49, 879894.
Hindelang M. J., Gottfredson M. R. & Garofalo J. (1978) Victims of Personal Crime: An Empirical Foundation for a Theory of Personal Victimization. Ballinger, Cambridge, MA, USA.
Hirschi T. (1969) Causes of Delinquency. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
Holinger P. C. & Klemen E. H. (1982) Violent deaths in the United States 1900–1975: relationships between suicide, homicide and accidental deaths. Social Science and Medicine 16, 19291938.
Jessor R. (1991) Risk behavior in adolescence: a psychosocial framework for understanding and action. Journal of Adolescent Health 12, 597605.
Junger M. & Tremblay R. E. (1999) Self-control, accidents and crime. Criminal Justice and Behavior 26, 485501.
Kinlen L. J. (1982) Meat and fat consumption and cancer mortality. A study of strict religious orders in Britain. Lancet 1, 946949.
Kivelä S-L. (1985) Relationship between suicide, homicide and accidental deaths among the aged in Finland in 1951–1979. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 72, 155160.
Kolodziej H., Lopuszanska M. & Jankowska E. A. (2008) Decrease in sex difference in premature mortality during system transformation in Poland. Journal of Biosocial Science 40, 297312.
Leigh J. P. (1988) Odds ratios of work-related deaths in United States workers. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 45, 158166.
Luy M. (2003) Causes of male excess mortality: insights from cloistered populations. Population and Development Review 29, 647676.
McCullagh E. P. & Lewis L. A. (1960) A study of diet, blood lipids and vascular disease in Trappist monks. New England Journal of Medicine 263, 569574.
Madigan F. C. (1957) Are sex mortality differences biologically caused? Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 35, 202223.
Madigan F. C. & Vance R. B. (1957) Differential sex mortality: a research design. Social Forces 35, 193199.
Maxim P. S. & Keane C. (1992) Gender, age, and the risk of violent death in Canada. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 29, 329345.
Mishra S. & Lalumière M. (2009) Is the crime drop of the 1990s in Canada and the USA associated with a general decline in risky and health-related behavior? Social Science and Medicine 68, 3948.
Modelmog D., Rahlenbeck S. & Trichopoulos D. (1992) Accuracy of death certificates: a population-based, complete-coverage, one-year autopsy study in east Germany. Cancer Causes and Control 3, 541546.
Nathanson C. A. (1984) Sex differences in mortality. Annual Review of Sociology 10, 191213.
Osgood D. W., Johnston L. D., O'Malley P. M. & Bachman J. G. (1988) The generality of deviance in late adolescence and early adulthood. American Sociological Review 53, 8193.
Porterfield A. L. (1960) Traffic fatalities, suicide, and homicide. American Sociological Review 25, 897901.
Retherford R. D. (1975) The Changing Sex Differential in Mortality. Greenwood Press, Westport, London.
Snowdon D. A. (2001) Aging with Grace. What the Nun Study Teaches us about Leading Longer, Healthier, and more Meaningful Lives. Bantam Books, New York, Toronto, London, Sydney, Auckland.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1961) Statistisches Jahrbuch für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland 1960. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart, Mainz.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1966) Statistisches Jahrbuch für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland 1965. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart, Mainz.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1976) Statistisches Jahrbuch 1975 für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart, Mainz.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1981) Statistisches Jahrbuch 1980 für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart, Mainz.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1986) Statistisches Jahrbuch 1985 für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Kohlhammer, Stuttgart, Mainz.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1991) Statistisches Jahrbuch 1990 für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Metzler-Poeschel, Stuttgart.
Statistisches Bundesamt (1996) Statistisches Jahrbuch 1995 für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Metzler-Poeschel, Stuttgart.
Trovato F. & Heyen N. B. (2006) A varied pattern of change of the sex differential in survival in the G7 countries. Journal of Biosocial Science 38, 169182.
Vallin J. (2006) Mortality, sex, and gender. In Caselli G., Vallin J. & Wunsch G. (eds) Demography: Analysis and Synthesis. Volume II. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Boston, Heidelberg, London, New York, Oxford, Paris, San Diego, San Francisco, Singapore, Sydney, Tokyo, pp. 177194.
Waldron I. (1983a) The role of genetic and biological factors in sex differences in mortality. In Lopez A. D. & Ruzicka L. T. (eds) Sex Differentials in Mortality: Trends, Determinants and Consequences. Australian National University Press, Canberra, pp. 141164.
Waldron I. (1983b) Sex differences in human mortality: the role of genetic factors. Social Science and Medicine 17, 321333.
Waldron I. (1985) What do we know about causes of sex differences in mortality? A review of the literature. Population Bulletin of the United Nations 18, 5976.
Waldron I. (1991) Effects of labor force participation on sex differences in mortality and morbidity. In Frankenhaeuser M., Lundberg U. & Chesnay M. (eds) Women, Work, and Health. Plenum Press, New York, London, pp. 1738.
Wallner B. & Machatschke I. H. (2009) The evolution of violence in men: the function of central cholesterol and serotonin. Progress in Neuro-Psychopharmacology & Biological Psychiatry 33, 391397.
Wingard D. L. (1984) The sex differential in morbidity, mortality, and lifestyle. Annual Review of Public Health 5, 433458.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Biosocial Science
  • ISSN: 0021-9320
  • EISSN: 1469-7599
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-biosocial-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 4
Total number of PDF views: 18 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 176 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.