Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-5nwft Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-20T04:11:14.367Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Violence and Social Memory in Twentieth-Century Belfast: Stories of Buck Alec Robinson

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 August 2014

Sean O'Connell
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the life and commemoration of Buck Alec Robinson. A feared loyalist killer in 1920s Belfast, in more recent times he has featured as a lion-keeping “character” on wall murals and in tourist guide books. Robinson is employed as a case study to investigate two separate but, in this case, interlinked historiographical debates. The first involves Norbert Elias's analysis of the decline of violence. The second relates to discussion of the analysis of social memory in working-class communities, with violence being placed therein. The article supports historical assessments suggesting that the “civilizing offensive” had an uneven impact. That point is usually made in the context of working-class men. This article extends it to political elites in Belfast and probes their flirtations with violent hard men. The case is made that it is a mistake to assume the “civilizing” dynamic is to be understood as a teleological or top-down process.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 53 , Issue 3 , July 2014 , pp. 734 - 756
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Northern Ireland Tourist Board, Famous Faces of North Belfast (Belfast, 2008), 38Google Scholar.

2 Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (PRONI): HA/5/2192 Alexander Robinson. Particulars of Persons Arrested under Regulation 23 of Civil Authorities (Special Powers) Act, 6 October 1922; Representations Against Internment Order, Alexander Robinson (no date).

3 Ibid. Petition of Alexander Robinson, 23 October 1922; Previous convictions of Alexander Robinson, 23 October 1922.

4 Social memory is understood as the process by which members of a community understand their society in relation to its past. It provides a set of “frames” through which individuals make sense of their own recollections. See Connerton, Paul, How Societies Remember (Cambridge, 1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fentress, James and Wickham, Chris, Social Memory (Oxford, 1992)Google Scholar.

5 Davies, Andrew, “Street Gangs, Crime and Policing in Glasgow during the 1930s: The Case of the Beehive Boys,” Social History 23, no. 3 (October 1998): 251–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Davies, Andrew, “Youth Gangs, Masculinity and Violence in Late Victorian Manchester and Salford,” Journal of Social History 38, no. 2 (Autumn 1998): 349–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar; White, Jerry, The Worst Street in North London: Campbell Bunk, Islington, between the Wars (London, 1986)Google Scholar.

6 Jenks, Chris and Lorentzen, Justin J., “The Kray Fascination,” Theory, Culture and Society 14, no. 3 (1997): 87–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Samuel, Raphael and Thompson, Paul, eds., The Myths We Live By (London, 1990), 9Google Scholar.

8 Waters, C., “Representations of Everyday Life: L.S. Lowry and the Landscape of Memory in Post War Britain,” Representations 65 (Winter 1999): 121–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Waters, C. “Autobiography, Nostalgia and the Changing Practices of Working-Class Self-hood,” in Singular Continuities: tradition, nostalgia and identity in modern British culture, ed. Behlmer, G. K. et al. (Stanford, CA, 2000), 178–95Google Scholar.

9 Bourke, J., Working-Class Cultures in Britain, 1890–1960: Gender, Class and Ethnicity (London, 1994), 137Google Scholar.

10 Jones, Ben, “The Uses of Nostalgia: Autobiography, Community Publishing and Working Class Neighbourhoods in Post-war England,” Cultural and Social History 7, no. 3 (September 2010): 335–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Elias, Norbert, The Civilising Process, 2 vols. Published in English as: vol. 1, The History of Manners, trans. Jephcott, Edmund (Oxford, 1978)Google Scholar; and vol. 2, State Formation and Civilisation, trans. Jephcott, Edmund (Oxford, 1982)Google Scholar.

12 Archer, John E., “‘Men Behaving Badly?’ Masculinity and the Uses of Violence, 1850–1900,” in Everyday Violence in Britain, 1850–1950, ed. de Cruze, Shani (Harlow, 2000), 41–54Google Scholar; Weiner, Martin, Men of Blood: Violence, Manliness, and Criminal Justice in Victorian England (Cambridge, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Tosh, John, “Masculinities in an Industrializing Society, 1800–1914,” Journal of British Studies 44, no. 2 (April 2005): 331CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 On the civilizing offensive, see Wood, J. Carter, Violence and Crime in Nineteenth Century England: The Shadow of Our Refinement (London, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Mennell, Stephen, The American Civilizing Process (Cambridge, 2007), 12Google Scholar.

16 Ibid., 127.

17 Ulster Folk and Transport Museum [UFTM]: Interview R83 11—Alexander Robinson; Interview R83 118—Alexander Robinson; Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie.

18 Hirst, Catherine, Religion, Politics and Violence in Nineteenth-Century Belfast (Dublin, 2002)Google Scholar; Hepburn, A. C., A Past Apart: Studies in the History of Catholic Belfast, 1850–1950 (Belfast 1996)Google Scholar, chap 10.

19 Jones, Emrys, A Social Geography of Belfast (Oxford 1960), 138Google Scholar.

20 Hepburn, A Past Apart, 48–54, 176–78.

21 http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1911/Antrim/Dock_Ward/Vere_Street/ (accessed 5 May 2009). On untrained midwives, see Roberts, Elizabeth, A Woman's Place: An Oral History of Working-Class Women, 1890–1940 (Oxford, 1984), 106Google Scholar.

22 Hepburn, A Past Apart, 110.

23 Lynch, J., A Tale of Three Cities: Comparative Studies in Working Class Life (London, 1998), 35Google Scholar.

24 Parkinson, A., Belfast's Unholy War (Dublin, 2004), 12–13Google Scholar. The rounded nature of some of these figures reflects the difficulty of collecting accurate figures from the chaotic depiction of events in the contemporary sources.

25 Bew, Paul, Gibbon, Peter, and Patterson, Henry., Northern Ireland, 1921–1996: Political Forces and Social Classes (London 1996), 25Google Scholar.

26 Wilson, Tim, “The Most Terrible Assassination That Has Yet Stained the Name of Belfast: The McMahon Murders in Context,” Irish Historical Studies 37, no. 145 (May 2010): 95–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Clarke, W., Guns in Ulster (Eastbourne, 2002), 9Google Scholar.

28 PRONI.HA/5/2192: Petition of Alexander Robinson, 23 October 1922. For the controversial history of the Special Constabulary, see Ryder, Chris, The Fateful Split: Catholics and the Royal Ulster Constabulary (London, 2004)Google Scholar.

29 [Belfast] Newsletter, 7 October 1995.

30 PRONI, CAB 6/92 Ulster Protestant Association, February 1923.

31 Graham, Joe, Belfast, Born, Bred and Buttered (Belfast, 2005)Google Scholar; for recent academic assessments, see Wilson, “The Most Terrible Assassination”; Lynch, Robert, “The People's Protectors? The Irish Republican Army and the ‘Belfast Pogrom,’ 1920–1922,” Journal of British Studies 72, no. 2 (April 2008): 375–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Parkinson, Belfast's Unholy War, 280–81, 297.

33 Bew, Paul, Gibbon, Peter, and Patterson, Henry, Northern Ireland, 1921–1996: Political Forces and Social Classes (Manchester, 1996), 26–27Google Scholar.

34 Parkinson, Belfast's Unholy War, 280.

35 PRONI: HA/5/2193 Frederick Pollock.

36 PRONI: HA/5/2223 Robert Craig. Letter from Inspector General of RUC to Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs (no date); Representation Against Internment Form, 30 November 1922.

37 UFTM: Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie (1984); UFTM: Interview R83 118—Alexander Robinson (1983). Robinson's claim about Grant, made during a 1983 for the Ulster Folk and Transport Museum, appears to be supported by genealogical searches (they were second cousins).

38 PRONI: HA/5/2220 Robert Waddell. Typed copy of UPA document (no date).

39 PRONI: HA/5/2223 Letter to J. Taylor Esq. Ministry of Home Affairs, from William Grant, 17 January 1923.

40 Bill Banks was the subject of a piece of documentary fiction by Thomas Wright in 1868. The essay is analyzed in Bailey, Peter, “‘Will the Real Bill Banks Please Stand Up?’ Towards a Role Analysis of Mid-Victorian Working Class Respectability,” Journal of Social History 12, no. 3 (Spring 1979): 336–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 PRONI: HA/5/2192 Alexander Robinson. Particulars of Persons Arrested under Regulation 23 of Civil Authorities (Special Powers) Act (6 October 1922); Representations Against Internment Order, Alexander Robinson.

42 Ibid. Persons recommended for internment; Office of District Inspector, Belfast D District to RUC Commissioner's Office, 2 October 1922.

43 Northern Whig, 30 August 1922; cited in Parkinson, Unholy War in Belfast, 303.

44 PRONI: HA/5/2192 Alexander Robinson. Persons recommended for internment; Office of District Inspector, Belfast D District to RUC Commissioner's Office, 21 October 1922; Parkinson, Belfast's Unholy War, 305.

45 UFTM: Interview R83 11—Alexander Robinson.

46 PRONI: HA/5/2194 Alexander Robinson. Untitled minutes, 24 October 1922; Memo: District Inspector, D Division to City Commissioner, Internee Alexander Robinson, 25 October 1922.

47 PRONI: HA/5/2194 Alexander Robinson. Untitled minutes, 5 September 1922.

48 Ibid., District Inspector's Office, Belfast D Division, Alexander Robinson “Buck Alec,” 20 July 1923.

49 Belfast Telegraph, 7 April 1927.

50 UFTM: Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie.

51 Irish News, 10 October 1995.

52 Campbell, John, “A Fighting Legend of York Street,” Lurigethan: Journal of the North Belfast History Workshop 2, no. 1 (1980): 13Google Scholar.

53 Ibid.

54 Davies, Andrew, “The Scottish Chicago? From ‘Hooligans’ to ‘Gangsters’ in Interwar Glasgow,” Cultural and Social History 4, no. 4 (December 2007): 512CrossRefGoogle Scholar. As late as the 1960s, the Kray twins utilized the motif of the American gangster in their self-dramatization. See Jenks and Lorentzen, “The Kray Fascination,” 100.

55 There are also parallels here with Glasgow hard men. James Gilzean provided the inspiration for the Weekly Record's series “A Scot in Chicago's Gangland,” in 1930, introducing terms such as “Big Shots” and “rackets” to Glasgow. See Davies, Andrew, City of Gangs: Glasgow and the Rise of the British Gangster (London, 2013), 191Google Scholar.

56 UFTM: Interview R83 61—Alexander Robinson.

57 UFTM: Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie.

58 UFTM: Interview R83 135—Fred Heatley, 1983.

59 Information provided by informant on condition of anonymity.

60 Belfast Newsletter, 27 August 1943.

61 UFTM: Interview R83 119—Alexander Robinson, 1983; Ball, V., “Observations on lion-breeding in the gardens of the Royal Zoological Society of Ireland,” Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy 28 (1880–86) 723–58Google Scholar.

62 For local discussion of these stories see http://www.belfastforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=87.0 (accessed 10 April 2014).

63 UFTM: Interview R83 61—Alexander Robinson.

64 Campbell, “Fighting Legend,” 16.

65 Belfast Telegraph, 25 August 1952.

66 Ibid., 14 February 1952.

67 Davies, Andrew, “Glasgow's ‘Reign of Terror’: Street Gangs, Racketeering and Intimidation in the 1920s and 1930s,” Contemporary British History 21, no. 4 (Winter 2007): 405–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

68 Interview conducted with ex-docker (who requested anonymity), 22 June 2009.

69 UFTM: Interview R83 61—Alexander Robinson.

70 Interview with ex-docker. Irish Times, 19 July 1949.

71 Similar criminal rivalries produced serious violence in other UK cities. See Bean, J. P., Gang Wars in Sheffield (Sheffield, 1981)Google Scholar; Shore, H., “Criminality and Englishnes in the Aftermath: The Racecourse Wars of the 1920s,” Twentieth Century British History 22, no. 4 (2011): 47–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

72 Ibid.

73 The Sun, 20 July 1984. Cited in Dick Hobbs, Doing the Business: Entrepreneurship, the Working Class, and Detectives in the East End of London (Oxford, 1989), 54.

74 UFTM: Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie.

75 Interview with ex-docker.

76 For an informed exposition of the system, see See Campbell, John's novel The Disinherited (Belfast 2006)Google Scholar.

77 Belfast Telegraph, 7 March 1959.

78 http://www.belfastcity.gov.uk/publicart/default2.aspx?id=107 (accessed 21 February 2010).

79 Newsletter, 10 October 1995.

80 Ibid., 7 October 1995.

81 Irish News, 10 October 1995.

82 Newsletter, 10 October 1995. Before the paramilitary ceasefires of 1994, fewer Catholics may have been willing to attend the funeral.

83 Newsletter, 10 October 1995.

84 Ayers, P., “The Making of Men: Masculinities in Interwar Liverpool,” in Working out Gender: Perspectives from Labour History, ed. Walsh, M. (London, 1999)Google Scholar.

85 White, The Worst Street in North London, 95.

86 Davies, “Youth Gangs,” 356.

87 Smyth, Denis, Sailortown: The Story of a Dockside Community (Belfast, 1990), 37–38Google Scholar.

88 For a similar perspective on the redevelopment of a major working-class Protestant community, see Weiner, Ron, The Rape and Plunder of the Shankill: Community Action, the Belfast Experience (Belfast, 1976)Google Scholar. For more recent commemorations of Sailortown, see http://www.sailortown.org.

89 During the 1980s he produced a local newspaper, the Dockworker, with this aim.

90 North Belfast News, 31 July 2009.

91 http://readerswrite.rushlightmagazine.com (assessed 27 July 2009).

92 Feldman, Formations of Violence, 53–54.

93 Ibid., 49–50.

94 Galway, James, James Galway: An Autobiography (Bath, 1980), 25–29Google Scholar.

95 For discussion on this, see Giles, J., “‘Playing Hard to Get’: Working Class Women, Sexuality and Respectability in Britain, 1918–40,” Women's History Review 1, no. 2 (1992): 239–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

96 Blood, May, Watch My Lips, I'm Speaking! (Dublin, 2007), 23–27Google Scholar. Other female autobiographers include Hughes, Maggie May, Memories (Belfast, 1992)Google Scholar; Sheehan, Patricia, And So I Did: A Northern Irish Memoir (Haverford, PA, 2004)Google Scholar.

97 Lawrence, Jon, “Forging a Peaceable Kingdom: War, Violence, and Fear of Brutalization in Post–First World War Britain,” Journal of Modern History 75, no. 3 (September 2003): 576CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Dolan, Anne, “Killing and Bloody Sunday, November 1920,” Historical Journal 49, no. 3 (September 2006): 789–810CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

98 Lawrence, “Forging a Peaceable Kingdom,” 561.

99 Ibid., 1.

100 Ibid., 560, 589.

101 Beiner, G., “Between Trauma and Triumphalism: The Easter Rising, the Somme, and the Crux of Deep Memory in Modern Ireland,” Journal of British Studies 46, no. 2 (April 2007): 382CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hepburn, A. C., “The Belfast Riots of 1935,” Social History 15, no. 1 (1990): 75–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 I am grateful to Professor Graham Walker for information on Robinson's role in 1949. Bruce, Steve, Paisley: Religion and Politics in Northern Ireland (Oxford 2007), 71CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

103 Ibid., 10 October 1995.

104 For an insightful treatment of this theme see Beiner, “Between Trauma and Triumphalism,” 366–89.

105 Bruce, Paisley, 227.

106 Ibid., 71, 222.

107 Leonard, Jane, “‘English Dogs’ or ‘Poor Devils’? The Dead of Bloody Sunday Morning,” in Terror in Ireland, 1916–1923, ed. Fitzpatrick, David (Dublin, 2012), 103Google Scholar.

108 Dolan, “Killing and Bloody Sunday,” 794.

109 Ibid., 795–96. The assessment of whether the IRA's victims were British agents is from Leonard, “English Dogs,” 103.

110 McBride, I., “Memory and National Identity in Modern Ireland,” in History and Memory in Modern Ireland (Cambridge, 2001), 27Google Scholar.

111 Beiner, “Between Trauma and Triumphalism,” 371–76.

112 Alessandro Portelli, The Death of Luigi Trastulli and Other Stories: Form and Meaning in Oral History (New York, 1991), 51.

113 UFTM: Interview R84 106—Sally Robinson and Agnes Neasie.

114 Dolan, “Killing and Bloody Sunday,” 807–08.