Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Optimistic expectations about communication explain children's difficulties in hiding, lying, and mistrusting liars*

  • OLIVIER MASCARO (a1), OLIVIER MORIN (a2) and DAN SPERBER (a3)
Abstract
Abstract

We suggest that preschoolers’ frequent obliviousness to the risks and opportunities of deception comes from a trusting stance supporting verbal communication. Three studies (N = 125) confirm this hypothesis. Three-year-olds can hide information from others (Study 1) and they can lie (Study 2) in simple settings. Yet when one introduces the possibility of informing others in the very same settings, three-year-olds tend to be honest (Studies 1 and 2). Similarly, four-year-olds, though capable of treating assertions as false, trust deceptive informants (Study 3). We suggest that children's reduced sensitivity to the opportunities of lying, and to the risks of being lied to might help explain their difficulties on standard false belief tasks.

Copyright
Corresponding author
e-mail: oliver.mascaro@gmail.com
Footnotes
Hide All
*

This research was supported by a PhD grant from the Direction Générale de l'Armement, by a grant from the Agence nationale de la recherche (grant number: ANR-14-ACHN-0020, PRAGmatics and Trust In Commnication in eArly Life), and by a grant from the European Research Council (grant number: ERC-2013-SyG, Constructing Social Minds: Communication, Coordination and Cultural Transmission, ERC, grant agreement n° [609819]). Data collection was also supported by the Centre for the Study of the Mind in Nature from the University of Oslo. The authors thank the members of the Naturalism in Human Sciences (NaSH) research group of the Jean Nicod Institute, as well as the children, parents, and teachers of the schools that participated in the study.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
R. M. Baillargeon , R. Scott & Z. He (2010). False belief understanding in infants. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14, 110–8.

S. Baron-Cohen , A. M. Leslie & U. Frith (1985). Does the autistic child have a ‘theory of mind’. Cognition 21(1), 3746.

K. Begus & V. Southgate (2012). Infant pointing serves an interrogative function. Developmental Science 15(5), 611–7.

B. Bergstrom , B. Moehlmann & P. Boyer (2006). Extending the testimony problem: evaluating the truth, scope, and source of cultural information. Child Development 77(3), 531–8.

D. M. Bowler , J. Briskman , N. Gurvidi & M. Fornells-Ambrojo (2005). Understanding the mind or predicting signal-dependent action? Performance of children with and without autism on analogues of the false-belief task. Journal of Cognition and Development 6(2), 259–83.

J. Bradmetz & R. Schneider (1999). Is Little Red Riding Hood afraid of her grandmother? Cognitive vs. emotional response to a false belief. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 17(4), 501–14.

J. Call & M. Tomasello (1999). A nonverbal false belief task: the performance of children and great apes. Child Development 70(2), 381–95.

S. Carlson , L. Moses & H. Hix (1998). The role of inhibitory processes in young children's difficulties with deception and false belief. Child Development 69(3), 672–91.

D. J. Carroll , I. A. Apperly & K. J. Riggs (2007). The executive demands of strategic reasoning are modified by the way in which children are prompted to think about the task: evidence from 3-to 4-year-olds. Cognitive Development 22(1), 142–8.

S. Choi (1988). The semantic development of negation: a cross-linguistic longitudinal study. Journal of Child Language 15(3), 517–31.

N. L. Couillard & A. L. Woodward (1999). Children's comprehension of deceptive points. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 17, 515–21.

A. D. Evans & K. Lee (2013). Emergence of lying in very young children. Developmental Psychology 49(10), 1958–63.

J. H. Flavell , S. G. Shipstead & K. Croft (1978). Young children's knowledge about visual perception: hiding objects from others. Child Development 49, 1208–11.

Global Deception Research Team. (2006). A world of lies. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 37(1), 6074.

G. Grosse , T. C. Scott-Phillips & M. Tomasello (2013). Three-year-olds hide their communicative intentions in appropriate contexts. Developmental Psychology 49(11), 2095–101.

S. Hala & J. Russell (2001). Executive control within strategic deception: A window on early cognitive development? Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 80(2), 112–41.

G. D. Heyman , L. Sritanyaratana & K. E. Vanderbilt (2013). Young children trust in overtly misleading advice. Cognitive Science 37, 646–67.

P. Hummer , H. Wimmer & G. Antes (1993). On the origin of truth-functional negation. Journal of Child Language 20, 607–18.

V. K. Jaswal , A. A. Carrington Croft , A. R. Setia & C. A. Cole (2010). Young children have a specific, highly robust bias to trust testimony. Psychological Science 21, 1541–7.

B. Knudsen & U. Liszkowski (2012). 18-month-olds predict specific action mistakes through attribution of false belief, not ignorance, and intervene accordingly. Infancy 17(6), 672–91.

M. A. Koenig , F. Clément & P. L. Harris (2004). Trust in testimony. Psychological Science 15, 694–8.

M. A. Koenig & C. H. Echols (2003). Infants’ understanding of false labeling events: the referential roles of words and the speakers who use them. Cognition 87(3), 179208.

Á. M. Kovács , T. Tauzin , E. Téglás , G. Gergely & G. Csibra (2014). Pointing as epistemic request: 12-month-olds point to receive new information. Infancy 19(6), 543–57.

M. Krehm , K. H. Onishi & A. Vouloumanos (2014). I see your point: infants under 12 months understand that pointing is communicative. Journal of Cognition and Development 15(4), 527–38.

S. Leekam , J. Perner , L. Healey & C. Sewell (2008). False signs and the non-specificity of theory of mind: evidence that preschoolers have general difficulties in understanding representations. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 26(4), 485–97.

A. M. Leslie & P. Polizzi (1998). Inhibitory processing in the false belief task: two conjectures. Developmental Science 1(2), 247–53.

M. Lewis , C. Stanger & M. W. Sullivan (1989). Deception in 3-year-olds. Developmental Psychology 25(3), 439–43.

A. Martin , K. H. Onishi & A. Vouloumanos (2012). Understanding the abstract role of speech in communication at 12 months. Cognition 123(1), 5060.

O. Mascaro & O. Morin (2015). Epistemology for beginners: two- to five-year-old children's representation of falsity. PloS one 10(10), e0140658.

O. Mascaro & D. Sperber (2009). The moral, epistemic, and mindreading components of children's vigilance towards deception. Cognition 112(3), 367–80.

N. McGuigan & M. J. Doherty (2002). The relation between hiding skill and judgment of eye direction in preschool children. Developmental Psychology 38(3), 418–27.

A. P. Melis , J. Call & M. Tomasello (2010). 36-month-olds conceal visual and auditory information from others. Developmental Science 13(3), 479–89.

P. Newton , V. Reddy & R. Bull (2000). Children's everyday deception and performance on false-belief tasks. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 18(2), 297317.

R. D. Pea (1982). Origins of verbal logic: spontaneous denials by two- and three-year-olds. Journal of Child Language 9(3), 597626.

J. Perner , U. Frith , A. M. Leslie & S. R. Leekam (1989). Exploration of the autistic child's theory of mind: knowledge, belief, and communication. Child Development 60, 689700.

J. Perner & J. Roessler (2012). From infants’ to children's appreciation of belief. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 16, 519–25.

J. Peskin (1996). Guise and guile: children's understanding of narratives in which the purpose of pretense is deception. Child Development 67(4), 1735–51.

J. Peskin & V. Ardino (2003). Representing the mental world in children's social behavior: playing hide-and-seek and keeping a secret. Social Development 12(4), 496512.

A. Polak & P. L. Harris (1999). Deception by young children following noncompliance. Developmental Psychology 35(2), 561–8.

H. Rakoczy & M. Tomasello (2009). Done wrong or said wrong? Young children understand the normative directions of fit of different speech acts. Cognition 113(2), 205–12.

P. Rubio-Fernández & B. Geurts (2013). How to pass the false-belief task before your fourth birthday. Psychological Science 24(1), 2733.

T. Ruffman , D. R. Olson , T. Ash & T. Keenan (1993). The ABCs of deception: Do young children understand deception in the same way as adults? Developmental Psychology 29(1), 7487.

J. Russell , N. Mauthner , S. Sharpe & T. Tidswell (1991). The ‘windows task’ as a measure of strategic deception in preschoolers and autistic subjects. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 9(2), 331–49.

M. A. Sabbagh , L. J. Moses & S. Shiverick (2006). Executive functioning and preschoolers’ understanding of false beliefs, false photographs, and false signs. Child Development 77(4), 1034–49.

R. M. Scott , Z. He , R. Baillargeon & D. Cummins (2012). False-belief understanding in 2·5-year-olds: evidence from two novel verbal spontaneous-response tasks. Developmental Science 15(2), 181–93.

R. M. Scott & E. Roby (2015). Processing demands impact 3-year-olds’ performance in a spontaneous-response task: new evidence for the processing-load account of early false-belief understanding. PloS one 10(11), e0142405.

A. Sinclair (1996). Young children's practical deceptions and their understanding of false belief. New Ideas in Psychology 14(2), 157–73.

B. Sodian (1991). The development of deception in young children. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 9, 173–88.

B. Sodian & U. Frith (1992). Deception and sabotage in autistic, retarded and normal children. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 33(3), 591605.

H. J. Song , K. H. Onishi , R. Baillargeon & C. Fisher (2008). Can an agent's false belief be corrected by an appropriate communication? Psychological reasoning in 18-month-old infants. Cognition 109(3), 295315.

D. Sperber (2001). An evolutionary perspective on testimony and argumentation. Philosophical Topics 29, 401–13.

C. Stern & W. Stern (1999 [1914]). Recollection, testimony, and lying in early childhood, trans. J. T. Lamiell . Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

L. Surian & A. M. Leslie (1999). Competence and performance in false belief understanding: a comparison of autistic and normal 3-year-old children. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 17(1), 141–55.

V. Talwar & K. Lee (2002). Emergence of white-lie telling in children between 3 and 7 years of age. Merrill Palmer Quarterly 48(2), 160–81.

V. Talwar & K. Lee (2008). Social and cognitive correlates of children's lying behavior. Child Development 79(4), 866–81.

K. E. Vanderbilt , G. D. Heyman & D. Liu (2014). In the absence of conflicting testimony young children trust inaccurate informants. Developmental Science 17(3), 443–51.

A. Vouloumanos , A. Martin & K. H. Onishi (2014). Do 6-month-olds understand that speech can communicate? Developmental Science 17(6), 872–9.

A. Vouloumanos , K. H. Onishi & A. Pogue (2012). Twelve-month-old infants recognize that speech can communicate unobservable intentions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 109(32), 12933–37.

H. M. Wellman , D. Cross & J. Watson (2001). Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: the truth about false belief. Child Development 72(3), 655–84.

H. Wimmer & J. Perner (1983). Beliefs about beliefs: representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception. Cognition 13(1), 103–28.

A. A. Yazdi , T. P. German , M. A. Defeyter & M. Siegal (2006). Competence and performance in belief-desire reasoning across two cultures: the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth about false belief? Cognition 100(2), 343–68.

K. Austin , A. Theakston , E. Lieven & M. Tomasello (2014). Young children's understanding of denial. Developmental Psychology 50(8), 2061–70.

M. Siegal & K. Beattie (1991). Where to look first for children's knowledge of false beliefs. Cognition 38(1), 112.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Child Language
  • ISSN: 0305-0009
  • EISSN: 1469-7602
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-child-language
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 34
Total number of PDF views: 124 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 401 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 17th October 2016 - 18th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.