Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-4hhp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-06T12:29:33.771Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Policy or window dressing? Exploring the impact of poverty reduction strategies on poverty among the Canadian provinces

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 March 2020

Charles Plante Open the ORCID record for Charles Plante [Opens in a new window]
Charles Plante*
Affiliation:
Department of Sociology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
*
CONTACT Charles Plante charles.plante@mail.mcgill.ca Room 712, Leacock Building, 855 Sherbrooke Street West Montreal, Quebec H3A 2T7
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Poverty reduction strategies (PRS) have become a popular instrument for addressing poverty globally. According to their proponents, PRS focus and coordinate poverty reduction efforts in order to overcome traditional economic and socio-demographic obstacles and reduce poverty unconditionally. According to their detractors, however, governments use PRS as ‘window dressing’ to gloss over unsuccessful and/or partial poverty reduction efforts. In Canada, all ten provinces have committed to adopting PRS. In this study, I identify the timing of the introduction of PRS action plans and explore whether they have tended to coincide with changes in provincial poverty levels. I find that more often than not levels have actually dropped before rather than after the introduction of PRS. This suggests that governments may have indeed used PRS as window dressing – but to showcase and claim credit for poverty reduction successes.

Keywords

Poverty reduction strategysocial policycredit claiminggovernmentCanadaprovinces
Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy , Volume 35 , Issue 1: SI: Recent Social Policy in Canada and the United States , February 2019 , pp. 112 - 136
Copyright
Copyright © 2018 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Atkinson, A. B. (1987). On the measurement of poverty. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 55(4), 749–764.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkinson, A. B., Cantillon, B., Marlier, E., & Nolan, B. (2005). Taking forward the EU social inclusion process. Luxembourg: Luxembourg Presidency of the Council of the European Union.Google Scholar
Barata, P., & Murphy, C. (2011). Foundations for social change: Reflections on Ontario's poverty reduction strategy. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 16–30.Google Scholar
Béland, D., & Daigneault, P.-M. (2015). Welfare reform in Canada: Provincial social assistance in comparative perspective. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Benbow, S., Gorlick, C., Forchuk, C., Ward-Griffin, C., & Berman, H. (2016). Ontario's poverty reduction strategy: A critical discourse analysis. The Canadian Journal of Nursing Research=Revue Canadienne de Recherche En Sciences Infirmieres, 48(3–4), 100–109.Google ScholarPubMed
Bernard, P., & Saint-Arnaud, S. (2004). More of the same? The position of the four largest Canadian provinces in the world of welfare regimes (F49). Ottawa, ON: Canadian Policy Research Networks Inc. (CPRN).Google Scholar
Bonoli, G. (2012). Blame avoidance and credit claiming revisited. In Bonoli, G. & Natali, D. (Eds.), The politics of the new welfare state (pp. 93–110). Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brady, D. (2003). Rethinking the sociological measurement of poverty. Social Forces; a Scientific Medium of Social Study and Interpretation, 81, 715–751.Google Scholar
CBC News. (2016, February 24). Saskatchewan's poverty reduction strategy released. CBC News.Google Scholar
CEPE. (2009). Taking the measure of poverty: Proposed indicators of poverty, inequality and social exclusion to measure progress in Quebec. Quebec: Centre d’étude sur la pauvreté et l'exclusion sociale.Google Scholar
Cohen, M. G., & Klein, S. (2011). Poverty reduction in British Columbia?: How ‘the best place on earth’ keeps people poorest. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 58–75.Google Scholar
Collin, C. (2007). Poverty reduction strategies in the United Kingdom and Ireland (PRB 07-28E). Library of Parliament.Google Scholar
Craig, D., & Porter, D. (2003). Poverty reduction strategy papers: A new convergence. World Development, 31(1), 53–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dufour, P. (2011). Anti-poverty policies and the adoption of bill 112 in Quebec: A change of path? Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 45–57.Google Scholar
Emery, J. C. H. (2013). Labour shortages in Saskatchewan. SPP Research Paper, 6(4), 1–30.Google Scholar
Evans, B., & Mitchell, A. (2011). Poverty reduction strategies: What a difference an economic crisis makes. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, I–XI.Google Scholar
Fernando, S., & Earle, B. (2011). Linking poverty reduction and economic recovery: Supporting community responses to austerity in Ontario. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 31–44.Google Scholar
Ferreira, F. H. G., & Ravallion, M. (2008). Global poverty and inequality: A review of the evidence. Washington, DC: The World Bank. WPS4623.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferrera, M., Matsaganis, M., & Sacchi, S. (2002). Open coordination against poverty: The new EU ‘social inclusion process’. Journal of European Social Policy, 12(3), 227–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flanagan, K. (2015). The state of social assistance in prince Edward Island. In Béland, D. & Daigneault, P.-M. (Eds.), Welfare reform in Canada: Provincial social assistance in comparative perspective (pp. 255–272). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Fraser, D. C. (2016). “Community not happy with province's poverty reduction strategy.” Regina Leader-Post, February 25.Google Scholar
GoC. (2018). Opportunity for all: Canada's first poverty reduction strategy. Ottawa: Government of Canada.Google Scholar
GoMB. (2009). All aboard: Manitoba's poverty reduction strategy. Winnipeg: Government of Manitoba.Google Scholar
GoMB. (2012). All aboard: Manitoba's poverty reduction strategy. Winnipeg: Government of Manitoba.Google Scholar
GoNB. (2009). Overcoming poverty together: The new Brunswick economic and social inclusion plan. Fredericton: Government of New Brunswick.Google Scholar
GoNB. (2014). Overcoming poverty together: The new Brunswick economic and social inclusion plan 2014–2019. Fredericton: Government of New Brunswick.Google Scholar
GoNL. (2006). Reducing poverty: An action plan for newfoundland and Labrador. St. John's: Government of Newfoundland and Labrador.Google Scholar
GoNS. (2009). Preventing poverty. Promoting prosperity: Nova Scotia's poverty reduction strategy. Halifax: Government of Nova Scotia.Google Scholar
GoON. (2008). Breaking the cycle: Ontario's poverty reduction strategy. Toronto: Government of Ontario.Google Scholar
GoON. (2014). Realizing our potential: Ontario's poverty reduction strategy 2014–2019. Toronto: Government of Ontario.Google Scholar
GoPE. (2012). Prince Edward Island social action plan to reduce poverty. Charlottetown: Government of Prince Edward Island.Google Scholar
GoQC. (2004). Reconciling freedom and social justice: A challenge for the future: Government action plan to combat poverty and social exclusion. Québec: Government of Quebec.Google Scholar
GoQC. (2010). Québec's combat against poverty 2010–2015: Government action plan for solidarity and social inclusion. Québec: Government of Quebec.Google Scholar
GoQC. (2017). Plan D'action Gouvernemental Pour L'inclusion économique et La Participation Sociale 2017–2023: Un Revenu de Base Pour Une Société plus Juste. Québec: Government of Quebec.Google Scholar
GoSK. (2016). Taking action on poverty: The Saskatchewan poverty reduction strategy. Regina: Government of Saskatchewan.Google Scholar
Greason, V. (2012). Poverty as a human rights violation* (*Except in governmental anti-poverty strategies). In Table ronde des OVEP de l'Outaouais.Google Scholar
Hudson, C.-A., & Close, D. (2011). From neo-liberal populism to inclusive liberalism: The politics of newfoundland and Labrador's 2006 poverty reduction strategy. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 76–91.Google Scholar
Hudson, C.-A., & Graefe, P. (2011). The Toronto origins of Ontario's 2008 poverty reduction strategy: Mobilizing multiple channels of influence for progressive social policy change. Canadian Review of Social Policy, 65/66, 1–15.Google Scholar
Hunter, G., & Miazdyck, D. (2006). Current issues surrounding poverty and welfare programming in Canada. In Blake, R. & Keshen, J. (Eds.), Social fabric or patchwork quilt: The development of social policy in Canada (pp. 383–418). Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press.Google Scholar
Imbeau, L. M., Landry, R., Milner, H., Petry, F., Crete, J., Forest, P.-G., & Lemieux, V. (2000). Comparative provincial policy analysis: A research agenda. Canadian Journal of Political Science. Revue Canadienne de Science Politique, 4, 779–804.Google Scholar
Levinsohn, J. (2003). The World Bank's poverty reduction strategy paper approach: Good marketing or good policy? (Vol. 21). New York: United Nations.Google Scholar
Lord, S. (2015). Welfare reform in Canada: Nova Scotia. In Béland, D. & Daigneault, P.-M. (Eds.), Welfare reform in Canada: Provincial social assistance in comparative perspective (pp. 223–238). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
MacInnes, T., Bushe, S., Kelly, P., & McHardy, F. (2014). International and historical anti-poverty strategies: Evidence and policy review. London: New Policy Institute & Poverty Alliance.Google Scholar
Maquet, I., & Stanton, D. (2012). Income indicators for the EU's social inclusion strategy. In Besharov, Douglas J. & Couch, Kenneth A. (Eds.), Counting the poor (pp. 59–75). New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michaud, S., Cotton, C., & Bishop, K. (2004). Exploration of methodological issues in the development of the market basket measure of low income for human resources development Canada (75F0002MIE2004001). Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
Murphy, B., Zhang, X., & Dion, C. (2010). Revising statistics Canada's low income measure (LIM). Ottawa: Statistics Canada, Income Statistics Division. 75F0002M — No. 004.Google Scholar
Noël, A. (2002). Une Loi Contre La Pauvreté : La Nouvelle Approche Québécoise de Lutte Contre La Pauvreté et L'exclusion Sociale. Lien Social et Politiques, 48, 103–114.Google Scholar
Noël, A. (2006). The new global politics of poverty. Global Social Policy: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Public Policy and Social Development, 6(3), 304–333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Notten, G., & de Neubourg, C. (2011). Monitoring absolute and relative poverty: ‘Not enough’ is not the same as ‘much less’. Review of Income and Wealth, 57(2), 247–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Notten, G., & Laforest, R. (2016). Poverty reduction strategies in Canada: A new way to tackle an old problem? Maastricht: Maastricht Economic and Social Research Institute on Innovation and Technology (UNU-MERIT).Google Scholar
Osberg, L., & Xu, K. (2000). International comparisons of poverty intensity: Index decomposition and bootstrap inference. The Journal of Human Resources, 35(1), 51–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Osberg, L., & Xu, K. (2008). How should we measure poverty in a changing world? Methodological issues and Chinese case study. Review of Development Economics, 12(2), 419–441.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, P. (1998). Irresistible forces, immovable objects: Post-industrial welfare states confront permanent austerity. Journal of European Public Policy, 5(4), 539–560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Plante, C., & Sharp, K. (2014). Poverty costs Saskatchewan: A new approach to prosperity for all. Saskatoon: Poverty Costs.Google Scholar
Sanderson, I. (2009). Intelligent policy making for a complex world: Pragmatism, evidence and learning. Political Studies, 57(4), 699–719.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sen, A. (1976). Poverty: An ordinal approach to measurement. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 44(2), 219–231.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sen, A. (1983). Poor, relatively speaking. Oxford Economic Papers, 35(2), 153–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sen, A. (1985). Commodities and capabilities. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Sharma, R. (2012). Poverty in Canada. OUP Catalogue.Google Scholar
Smith-Carrier, T. (2017). Reproducing social conditions of poverty: A critical feminist analysis of social assistance participation in Ontario, Canada. Journal of Women, Politics & Policy, 38(4), 498–521.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith-Carrier, T., & Lawlor, A. (2017). Realising our (neoliberal) potential? A critical discourse analysis of the poverty reduction strategy in Ontario, Canada. Critical Social Policy, 37(1), 105–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stapleton, J., & Bednar, V. (2011). Trading place: Single adults replace lone parents as the new face of social assistance in Canada. Toronto: Mowat Centre for Policy Innovation.Google Scholar
Statistics Canada. (2015). Revisions to 2006 to 2011 income data. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
Statistics Canada. (2016). Low income lines: What they are and how they are created? Ottawa: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
Thériault, L., & Lebreton, H. (2015). Social assistance in New Brunswick: Origins, developments, and current situation. In Béland, D. & Daigneault, P.-M. (Eds.), Welfare reform in Canada: Provincial social assistance in comparative perspective (pp. 209–222). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Torjman, S. (2008). Poverty policy. Ottawa, ON: The Caledon Institute of Social Policy.Google Scholar
Torjman, S. (2010). Poverty reduction in Québec: The first five years. Ottawa: Caledon Institute of Social Policy.Google Scholar
van den Berg, A., Plante, C., Raïq, H., Proulx, C., & Faustmann, S. (2017). Combating poverty: Quebec's pursuit of a distinctive welfare state. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Weaver, K. R. (1986). The politics of blame avoidance. Journal of Public Policy, 6(4), 371–398.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zhang, X. (2010). Low income measurement in Canada: What do different lines and indexes tell us? Ottawa, ON: Statistics Canada, Income Statistics Division.Google Scholar