Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Masturbatory Insanity: the History of an Idea

  • E. H. Hare (a1)
Extract

A hundred years ago it was generally believed by the medical profession, and particularly by alienists, that masturbation was an important and frequent cause of mental disorder. Today no one believes this; and the masturbatory hypothesis (as we may call it) has in all probability been finally abandoned. If we enquire into the history of this change we find, somewhat surprisingly, that medical references to the harmfulness of masturbation are vanishingly rare before the 18th century. For practical purposes, the whole history of the masturbatory hypothesis is contained within the last 250 years. This history is not one in which the present-day psychiatrist is apt to feel much pride. Yet it is worth studying, not only for its own sake (and the history of psychiatric ideas is a much neglected subject), but also for the light it throws on the peculiar difficulty of refuting causal hypotheses in psychiatry. The aim of the present essay is, first, to give a short history of the idea that masturbation is an important cause of mental disorder and, second, to examine some of the reasons for the rise and fall of this idea and why it persisted for so long (1).

Copyright
References
Hide All
Allnatt, R. H., “Case of Atrophy of the Testicle from Excessive Masturbation”, Lancet; 1843, ii, 654.
Anderson, E. W., “A Study of the Sexual Life in Psychoses associated with Childbirth”, J. Ment. Sci., 1933, 79, 137.
Asher, R., “Making Sense”, Lancet, 1959, ii, 359.
Barrus, C., “Insanity in Young Women”, J. Nerv. Ment. Dis., 1896, 21, 365.
Bell, L., and Ray, I., Annual Report of the McLean Asylum, 1844. (Quoted by Bucknill and Tuke, 1874.)
Berne, E., “The Problem of Masturbation”, Dis. Nerv. Syst., 1944, 5, 301.
Bianchi, L., A Textbook of Psychiatry, trans. Macdonald, J. H., 1906. London. p. 696.
Blandford, G. F., Insanity and its Treatment, 1871. Edinburgh. p. 59.
Bleuler, E., Dementia Praecox, 1911, trans. Zinkin, J., 1950. New York. 343.
Bloch, I., The Sexual Life of our Time, translated from the 6th German edition by Paul, M. E. 1908. London.
Boerhaave, H., Institutes of Medicine, 1708, para. 776, translation of Vol. V, p. 456, 1746. London.
Brown, W., Psychology and Psychotherapy, 1934. 3rd edition. London. p. 118.
Bucknill, J. C., and Tuke, D. H., A Manual of Psychological Medicine. 1874. 3rd edition. London.
Burrows, G. M., Commentaries on the Causes, etc., of Insanity, 1828. London.
Christian, J., Article on “Onanisme” in the Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales, 1881. Paris.
Clark, A. C., and Clark, H. E., “Neurectomy, a Preventive of Masturbation”, Lancet, 1899, ii, 838.
Clouston, T. S., Clinical Lectures on Mental Disease, 1883. London.
Idem , ibid., 1904. 6th edition.
Idem , “Presidential Address to the Medico-Psychological Association”, J. Ment. Sci., 1888, 34, 325.
Copland, J., A Dictionary of Practical Medicine, 1844. London.
Davis, K. B., “A Study of Certain Auto-erotic Practices”, Ment. hyg., 1925, 9, 28.
Dukes, , Davis, K. B., The Preservation of Health, 1884 (quoted by Ellis, 1901).
Ellinger, , Davis, K. B., Zeit. f. Psychiat., 1845, 2, 22 (quoted by Morel, 1860).
Ellis, , Havelock, , Studies in the Psychology of Sex, 1901, Vol. I, Part 1. Page references to the edition of 1936. New York.
Ellis, W. C., Treatise on Insanity, 1839. London.
Esquirol, E., Article on “Folie” in the Dictionnaire des Sciences Médicales, 1816. Paris.
Idem , article on “Manie” in ibid., 1822, Paris.
Idem , Des Maladies Mentales, 1836. Paris.
Eyer, A., “Clitoridectomy for the Cure of Masturbation in Girls”, Int. med. Mag., 1894, 3, 259.
Field, M. J., “Witchcraft as a primitive interpretation of Mental Disorder”, J. Ment. Sci., 1955, 101, 826.
Flemming, G. F., “Uber das Causal-Verhältniss der Selbstbefleckung zur Geistesverwirrung”, Zeit. f. d. Beurtheilung u. Heilung der krankhaften Seelenzustände, 1838, 1, 205.
Fournier, , Flemming, G. F., and Régis, , Flemming, G. F., Article on “Masturbation” in the Dictionnaire des Sciences Médicales, 1819. Paris.
Frank, J. P., System einer vollständigen medicinischen Polizey, 1780, Vol. II, p. 599. Mannheim.
Gall, F. J., Fonctions du Cerveau, 1825, Vol. III, p. 337 (quoted by Ellis, 1901).
Gowers, W. R., Epilepsy and other Chronic Convulsive Diseases, 1881, p. 31. London.
Griesinger, W., Mental Pathology and Therapeutics, 1861. 2nd edition. Translated by Robertson, C. L., and Rutherford, J., 1867. London.
Grieves, J., Translation of Celsus' of Medicine, 1756. London.
Guislain, J., Leçons Orales sur les Phrénopathies, 1852, Vol. 2, p. 61. Ghent.
Hagenbach, A. W., “Masturbation as a Cause of Insanity”, J. nerv. ment. Dis., 1879, 6, 603.
Haire, N. (edit.), Encyclopaedia of Sexual Knowledge, 1952. 2nd edition. p. 80. London.
Hall, , Stanley, , Adolescence, 1904, Vol. I. New York.
Haslam, J., Observations on Madness and Melancholy. 1809. 2nd edition. London.
Henderson, D. K., and Gillespie, R. D., A Textbook of Psychiatry, 1936. 4th edition. Oxford, p. 200.
Huhner, M., “Masturbation in both Sexes”, Med. Times, 1944, 72, 188, 220.
Hunter, J., A Treatise on the Venereal Disease, 1786. London, p. 200.
Huschka, M., “The Incidence and Character of Masturbatory Threats in a Group of Problem Children”, Psychoanalyt. Quart., 1938, 7, 338.
Hutchinson, J., “On Circumcision as Preventive of Masturbation”, Arch. Surg., 1891, 2, 267.
Jeffreys, M. D. W., “Onanism, an Anthropological Survey”, Int. J. Sexology, 1951, 5, 61.
Jones, E., Papers on Psychoanalysis, 1918. 2nd edition. pp. 388, 559.
Kinsey, A. C., Pomeroy, W. B., and Martin, C. E., Sexual Behaviour in the Human Male, 1948. London.
Idem and Gebhard, P. H., Sexual Behaviour in the Human Female, 1953. London.
Kraepelin, E., Psychiatrie, 1896. 5th edition. Leipzig, p. 51.
Lallemand, C. F., Des Pertes Séminales Involontaires, 1838–1842. 3 volumes. Paris.
Lancet , letters on “Clitoridectomy”, 1866, ii, 495, 561.
Locock, C., Lancet, 1857, i, 528.
McClanahan, A. C., “An Investigation into the Effects of Masturbation”, New York med. J., 1897, 66, 499.
Malamud, W., and Palmer, G., “The Role played by Masturbation in the Causation of Mental Disturbances”, J. nerv. ment. Dis., 1932, 76, 220, 366.
Maudsley, H., The Physiology and Pathology of Mind, 1867. London.
Idem , “Illustrations of a Variety of Insanity”, J. Ment. Sci., 1868, 14, 149.
Idem , The Pathology of Mind, 1879. London.
Idem , ibid., 1895. 2nd edition. London.
Meagher, J. F. W., “Quackery de Luxe”, New York med. J., and med. Record, 1923, 117, 224.
Idem , A Study of Masturbation and its Reputed Sequelae, 1924. London.
Idem , ibid., 1936. 3rd edition. London.
Medical Times and Gazette , Obituary Notice of Isaac Baker Brown, 1873.
Menzies, K., Autoerotic Phenomena in Adolescence, 1919. London.
Moraglia, , Menzies, K., Zeit. f. Criminal-Anthropologie, 1897, p. 487 (quoted by Ellis, 1901).
Morel, B. A., Traité des Maladies Mentales, 1860. Paris, p. 178.
Nightingale, F., Notes on Nursing, 1861. Edition of 1952. London, p. 120.
Onania, or The Heinous Sin of Self-Pollution, and all its Frightful Consequences, in both Sexes, etc., ?1726. 4th edition. London.
Ibid., 1730. 15th edition. London.
Paget, J., Clinical Lectures and Essays, 1879. 2nd edition. London, p. 275.
“Philo-Castitatus”, Onania Examined, and Detected, etc., 1723. London.
Pinel, P., Traité Médico-philosophique sur l'Aliénation Mentale, 1809. 2nd edition. Paris.
Popper, K. R., The Poverty of Historicism, 1957. London, p. 13.
Pouillet, T., Essai Médico-Philosophique sur les Formes, les Causes, les Signes, les Conséquences et le Traitement de l'Onanisme chez la Femme, 1876. Paris.
Prichard, J. C., A Treatise on Insanity, 1835. London, p. 205.
Ray, I., Contributions to Mental Pathology, 1873. Boston, p. 36.
Robertson, A., “Notes on a Visit to American Asylums”, J. Ment. Sci., 1869, 17, 516.
Robinson, N., A New System of the Spleen, Vapours and Hypochondriack Melancholy, etc., 1729. London, p. 191.
Rohleder, H., Die Masturbation, 1899. Berlin (quoted by Ellis, 1901.)
Rosanoff, A. J., Manual of Psychiatry and Mental Hygiene, 1938. 7th edition. London, p. 153.
Rush, B., Medical Inquiries and Observations upon the Diseases of the Mind, 1812. Philadelphia, pp. 33, 347.
Sankey, W. H. O., Lectures on Mental Diseases, 1866. London, p. 248.
Idem , ibid., 2nd edition. London, p. 223.
Savage, G. H., and Goodall, E., Insanity and Allied Neuroses, 1907. 4th edition. London, p. 68.
Schroeder van der Kolk, J. L. C., Pathology and Therapeutics of Mental Diseases, translated by Rudall, J. T., 1870. London.
Schwartz, A., Dissertation sur les Dangers de l'Onanisme et les Maladies qui en Résultent, 1815. Strasbourg.
Skae, D., “A Rational and Practical Classification of Insanity”, J. Ment. Sci., 1868, 14, 149.
Idem , “The Morrisonian Lectures on Insanity for 1873”, ibid., 1874, 19, 491.
Spitz, R. A., “Authority and Masturbation”, Psychoanalyst. Quart., 1952, 21, 490.
Spitzka, E. C., “Cases of Masturbation (Masturbatic Insanity)”, J. Ment. Sci., 1887, 33, 57, 238; 1888, 34, 58, 216.
Spratling, E. J., “Masturbation in the Adult”, Med. Record, 1895, 48, 442.
Stekel, W., Auto-erotism, A Psychiatric Study of Masturbation and Neurosis, translated by Teslaar, J. S. van, 1951. London.
Stern, A., “Masturbation, its Role in the Neuroses”, Amer. J. Psychiat., 1930, 9(ii), 1081.
Tissot, S.-A. A. D., Onanism, or a Treatise upon the Disorders produced by Masturbation; or the Dangerous Effects of Secret and Excessive Venery, translated by Hume, A., 1766. London.
Voltaire, F. A., Oeuvres Completes. Vol. 42. Dictionnaire Philosophique, article “Onan, Onanisme”, 1784. Paris.
Wootton, B., Social Science and Social Pathology, 1959. London.
Yellowlees, D., J. Ment. Sci., 1876, 22, 336.
Idem , article on “Masturbation” in Hack Tuke's Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, 1892. London.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The British Journal of Psychiatry
  • ISSN: 0368-315X
  • EISSN: 2514-9946
  • URL: /core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed

Masturbatory Insanity: the History of an Idea

  • E. H. Hare (a1)
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.

×

Reply to: Submit a response


Your details


Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *