Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Behavioral economics perspectives on public sector pension plans

  • JOHN BESHEARS (a1), JAMES J. CHOI (a2), DAVID LAIBSON (a3) and BRIGITTE C. MADRIAN (a4)

Abstract

We describe the pension plan features of the states and the largest cities and counties in the U.S. Unlike in the private sector, defined benefit (DB) pensions are still the norm in the public sector. However, a few jurisdictions have shifted toward defined contribution (DC) plans as their primary savings plan, and fiscal pressures are likely to generate more movement in this direction. Holding fixed a public employee's work and salary history, we show that DB retirement income replacement ratios vary greatly across jurisdictions. This creates large variation in workers’ need to save for retirement in other accounts. There is also substantial heterogeneity across jurisdictions in the savings generated in primary DC plans because of differences in the level of mandatory employer and employee contributions. One notable difference between public and private sector DC plans is that public sector primary DC plans are characterized by required employee or employer contributions (or both), whereas private sector plans largely feature voluntary employee contributions that are supplemented by an employer match. We conclude by applying lessons from savings behavior in private sector savings plans to the design of public sector plans.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Agnew, J. R., Anderson, L. R., Gerlach, J. R. and Szykman, L. R. (2008) Who chooses annuities: an experimental investigation of gender, framing and defaults. American Economic Review, 98(2): 418422.
Applied Research and Consulting (2009) Financial Capability in the United States, [online]. Available at http://www.finrafoundation.org/web/groups/foundation/@foundation/documents/foundation/p120536.pdf (accessed 9 August 2010).
Benartzi, S. (2001) Excessive extrapolation and the allocation of 401(k) accounts to company stock? Journal of Finance, 56(5): 17471764.
Benartzi, S. and Thaler, R. H. (2001) Naive diversification strategies in retirement saving plans. American Economic Review, 91(1): 7998.
Benartzi, S. and Thaler, R. H. (2007) Heuristics and biases in retirement savings behavior. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 21(3): 81–104.
Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2008) The importance of default options for retirement saving outcomes: evidence from the united states. In Kay, S. J. and Sinha, T. (eds), Lessons from Pension Reform in the Americas. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 5987.
Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2010 a) Simplification and saving. NBER Working Paper No. 12659.
Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2010 b) The Limitations of Defaults. Harvard University Working paper.
Brown, J. R. (2007) Rational and behavioral perspectives on the role of annuities in retirement planning. NBER Working Paper No. 13537.
Brown, J. R., Kling, J. R., Mullainathan, S. and Wrobel, M. V. (2008) Why don't people insure late-life consumption? A framing explanation of the under-annuitization puzzle. American Economic Review, 98(2): 304309.
Brown, J. R., Liang, N. and Weisbenner, S. (2007) Individual account investment options and portfolio choice: behavioral lessons from 401(k) plans. Journal of Public Economics, 91(10): 19922013.
Brown, J. R. and Weisbenner, S. (2009) Who chooses defined contribution plans? In Brown, J. R., Liebman, J. B. and Wise, D. A. (eds), Social Security Policy in a Changing Environment. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 131161.
Calvet, L. E., Campbell, J. Y. and Sodini, P. (2009) Measuring the financial sophistication of households. American Economic Review, 99(2): 393398.
Card, D. and Ransom, M. (2011) Pension plan characteristics and framing effects in employee savings behavior. Review of Economics and Statistics, 93(1): 228243.
Carroll, G. D., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., Madrian, B. C. and Metrick, A. (2009) Optimal defaults and active decisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124(4): 16391674.
Chalmers, J. and Reuter, J. (2009) How do retirees value life annuities? Evidence from public employees. NBER Working Paper No. 15608.
Chan, S. and Stevens, A. H. (2008) What you don't know can't help you: worker knowledge and retirement decision-making. Review of Economics and Statistics, 90(2): 253266.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2004 a) Plan design and 401(k) savings outcomes. National Tax Journal, 57(2): 275298.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2009 a) Reducing the complexity costs of 401(k) participation through quick enrollment. In Wise, D. A. (ed.), Developments in the Economics of Aging. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 5785.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2009 b) Mental accounting in portfolio choice: evidence from a flypaper effect. American Economic Review, 99(5): 20852095.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (2010) Why does the law of one price fail? An experiment on index mutual funds. Review of Financial Studies, 23(4): 14051432.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D. and Madrian, B. C. (forthcoming) $100 Bills on the sidewalk: suboptimal investment in 401(k) plans. Review of Economics and Statistics. doi:10.1162/REST_a_00100.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., Madrian, B. C. and Metrick, A. (2004 b) Employees’ investment decisions about company stock. In Mitchell, O. S. and Utkus, S. P. (eds), Pension Design and Structure. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 121136.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., Madrian, B. C. and Metrick, A. (2006) Saving for retirement on the path of least resistance. In McCaffrey, E. J. and Slemrod, J. (eds), Behavioral Public Finance: Toward a New Agenda. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, pp. 304351.
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., Madrian, B. C. and Metrick, A. (2009) Reinforcement learning and savings behavior. Journal of Finance, 64(6): 25152534.
Engen, E. M., Gale, W. G. and Uccello, C. R. (1999) The adequacy of retirement saving. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2: 65–188.
Goda, G. S. and Manchester, C. F. (2010) Incorporating employee heterogeneity into default rules for retirement plan selection. NBER Working Paper No. 16099.
Gustman, A. L., Steinmeier, T. L. and Tabatabai, N. (2007) Imperfect knowledge of plan type. NBER Working Paper No. 13379.
Holden, K. C. and Nicholson, S. (1998) Selection of a joint-and-survivor pension. Institute for Research on Poverty Discussion Paper No. 1175–98. University of Wisconsin, Madison.
Hu, W. Y. and Scott, J. S. (2007) Behavioral obstacles in the annuity market. Financial Analysts Journal, 63(6): 7182.
Huberman, G. and Jiang, W. (2006) Offering vs. choice by 401(k) plan participants: equity exposure and number of funds. Journal of Finance, 61(2): 763801.
Karlsson, A., Massa, M. and Simonov, A. (2007) Pension portfolio choice and menu exposure. In Mitchell, O. S., Soldo, B. J. and Madrian, B. C. (eds), Redefining Retirement: How Will Boomers Fare? Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 248271.
Lusardi, A. and Mitchell, O. S. (2006) Financial literacy and planning: implications for retirement wellbeing. Pension Research Council Working Paper No. 2006–1.
Lusardi, A. and Mitchell, O. S. (2007) Financial literacy and retirement preparedness: evidence and implications for financial education. Business Economics, 42(1): 3544.
Lusardi, A., Mitchell, O. S. and Curto, V. (2010) Financial literacy among the young. Journal of Consumer Affairs, 44(2), 358380.
Lusardi, A. and Tufano, P. (2009) Debt literacy, financial experiences, and overindebtedness. NBER Working Paper No. 14808.
Madrian, B. C. and Shea, D. F. (2001) The power of suggestion: inertia in 401(k) participation and savings behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116(4): 11491187.
Maine Unified Retirement Plan Task Force (2010) Task Force Study and Report: Maine State Employee and Teacher Unified Retirement Plan. MainePERS.
Mitchell, O. S. (1999) New trends in pension benefit and retirement provisions. NBER Working Paper No. 7381.
Mitchell, O. S., Mottola, G. R., Utkus, S. P. and Yamaguchi, T. (2007) The dynamics of lifecycle investing in 401(k) plans. Pension Research Council Working Paper No. 2007–28.
Munnell, A. H. and Soto, M. (2005) What replacement rates do households actually experience in retirement? Boston College Center for Retirement Research Working Paper No. 2005–10.
Munnell, A. H. and Sundén, A. (2004) Coming up Short: The Challenge of 401(k) Plans. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press.
Munnell, A. H., Webb, A. and Golub-Sass, F. (2007) Is there really a retirement saving crisis? An NRRI analysis. Boston College Center for Retirement Research Issue Brief No. 7–11.
Nessmith, W. E. and Utkus, S. P. (2008) Target-date funds: plan and participation adoption in 2007. Vanguard Center for Retirement Research, 33: 116.
Pensions & Investments (2010 a) The P&I 1000: Largest Retirement Funds. Data set available online at http://www.pionline.com/section/datastore#pi1000 (accessed 7 July 2010).
Pensions & Investments (2010 b) The P&I 1000. Pensions & Investments, 38(3): 13.
Previtero, A. (2010) Stock market returns and annuitization. Working Paper.
Saku, A. (2005) Does the balance of power within a family matter? The case of the retirement equity act. Journal of Public Economics, 89(9–10): 16991717.
Scholz, J. K., Seshadri, A. and Khitatrakun, S. (2006) Are Americans saving ‘optimally’ for retirement? Journal of Political Economy, 114(4): 607643.
Snell, R. (2010 a) Pension reform: not easy, but worth it. State Legislatures, [online] July/August, 32–34. Available online at http://www.ncsl.org/?tabid=20716 (accessed 6 August 2010).
Snell, R. (2010 b) State defined contribution and hybrid pension plans. National Conference of State Legislatures [online]. Available online at http://www.ncsl.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=yGsmFhwoq7E%3d&tabid=18511 (accessed 6 August 2010).
Thaler, R. H. and Benartzi, S. (2004) Save more tomorrow: using behavioral economics to increase employee savings. Journal of Political Economy, 112(S1): S164S187.
U.S. Census Bureau (2008) Number and Membership of State and Local Public Employee Retirement Systems by State: Fiscal Year 2008. Available online at http://www.census.gov/govs/retire/2008ret05a.html (accessed 4 August 2010).
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics (2007) National Compensation Survey: Employee Benefits in Private Industry in the United States, 2005. Available online at http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ebs/sp/ebbl0022.pdf (accessed 18 January 2011).
U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefit Security Administration (2008) Private Pension Plan Bulletin Historical Tables. Available online at: http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/pdf/privatepensionplanbulletinhistoricaltables.pdf (accessed 13 December 2007).
U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefit Security Administration (2010) Private Pension Plan Bulletin: Abstract of 2007 Form 5500 Annual Reports. Available online at: http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/pdf/2007pensionplanbulletin.pdf (accessed 4 August 2010).
Yaari, M. E. (1965) Uncertain lifetime, life insurance, and the theory of the consumer. Review of Economic Studies, 32(2): 137150.
Yang, T. S. (2005) Understanding the defined benefit versus defined contribution choice. Pension Research Council Working Paper No. 2005–4.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed