Skip to main content
×
Home

Policy convergence as a multifaceted concept: the case of renewable energy policies in the European Union

  • Sebastian Strunz (a1), Erik Gawel (a1) (a2), Paul Lehmann (a3) and Patrik Söderholm (a4)
Abstract
Abstract

The literature on policy convergence has identified numerous facets and causal drivers of convergence. Distinguishing four dimensions of convergence (object, benchmark, drivers and directed process) helps clarify why and in what form policy convergence may occur (or not). Thus, depending on, for example, the object of analysis (policy outcome or instruments used), the same empirical case may give rise to opposing assessments. Furthermore, both economic and political drivers are necessary to account for successful policy convergence: economic convergence partly explains why countries may face similar problems, and political mechanisms explain why they might choose similar policies to solve a given problem. This article illustrates the multifaceted character of convergence for the dynamic field of renewable energy policies in the European Union. The empirical results indicate temporary convergence in the case of policy support instrument choices and conditional convergence in terms of renewable shares. However, the results suggest divergence of public R&D subsidies targeting renewables.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Ania A. and Wagener A. (2014) Laboratory Federalism: The Open Method Of Coordination (OMC) as an Evolutionary Learning Process. Journal of Public Economic Theory 16(5): 767795.
Bajona C. and Kehoe T. J. (2010) Trade, Growth and Convergence in a Dynamic Heckscher-Ohlin Model. Review of Economic Dynamics 13(3): 487513.
Baumol W. J. (1986) Productivity Growth, Convergence and Welfare. American Economic Review 76(5): 10721085.
Bennett C. J. (1991) What is Policy Convergence and What Causes it? British Journal of Political Science 21(2): 215233.
Borrás S. and Jacobsson K. (2004) The Open Method of Coordination and New Governance Patterns in the EU. Journal of European Public Policy 11: 185208.
Borsi T. M. and Metiu N. (2015) The Evolution of Economic Convergence in the European Union. Empirical Economics 48(2): 657681.
Brock W. A. and Taylor M. S. (2010) The Green Solow Model. Journal of Economic Growth 15(2): 127153.
Busch P.-O. and Jörgens H. (2005) The International Sources of Policy Convergence: Explaining the Spread of Environmental Innovations. Journal of European Public Policy 12(5): 860884.
Callies C. and Hey C. (2013) Multilevel Energy Policy in the EU: Paving the Way for Renewables? Journal for European Environmental and Planning Law 10(2): 87131.
Camarero M., Castillo J., Picazo-Tadeo A. J. and Tamarit C. (2013) Eco-Efficiency and Convergence in OECD Countries. Environmental and Resource Economics 55: 87106.
Carley S., Nicholson-Crotty S. and Miller C. J. (2016) Adoption, Reinvention and Amendment of Renewable Portfolio Standards in the American States. Journal of Public Policy. doi: http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1017/S0143814X15000379
Ćetković S. and Buzogány A. (2016) Varieties of Capitalism and Clean Energy Transitions in the European Union: When Renewable Energy Hits Different Economic Logics. Climate Policy 16(5): 642657.
Drezner D. W. (2001) Globalization and Policy Convergence. International Studies Review 3(1): 5378.
Edenhofer O., Hirth L., Knopf B., Pahle M., Schmid E. and Ueckerdt F. (2013) On the Economics of Renewable Energy Sources. Energy Economics 40: 1223.
Ek K. and Söderholm P. (2010) Technology Learning in the Presence of Public R&D: The Case of European Wind Power. Ecological Economics 69: 23562362.
European Union (EU) (2012) Consolidated Version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Official Journal of the European Union C 326: 47390.
Fernández S. A. (1994) Convergence in Environmental Policy? The Resilience of National Institutional Designs in Spain and Germany. Journal of Public Policy 14(1): 3956.
Fingleton B., Garretsen H. and Martin R. (2015) Shocking Aspects of Monetary Union: The Vulnerability of Regions in Euroland. Journal of Economic Geography 15(5): 843853.
Gawel E., Strunz S. and Lehmann P. (2014) To What Extent Should the German Energy Transition Policy be “Europeanized”? Zeitschrift für Energiewirtschaft 38: 163182.
Gawel E., Strunz S. and Lehmann P. (2017) Support Policies for Renewables – Instrument Choice and Instrument Change From a Public Choice Perspective. In Arent D., Arndt C., Miller M., Tarp F. and Zinaman O. (eds.), The Political Economy of Clean Energy Transitions. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 8099.
Grafström J., Söderholm P., Lehmann P., Strunz S. and Gawel E. (2017) Divergence of Renewable Public R&D Support: The Case of the European Union. Leipzig, Germany: Mimeo, Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research – UFZ.
Griliches Z. (1995) R&D and Productivity: Econometric Results and Measurement Issues. In Stoneman P. (ed.), Handbook of Economics on Innovation and Technological Change. Oxford: Blackwell, Oxford, 5289.
Grossman G. M. and Krueger A. B. (1995) Economic Growth and the Environment. Quarterly Journal of Economics 110: 353377.
Hall P. and Soskice D. (eds.) (2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundation of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hayward J. and Wurzel R. (eds.) (2012) European Disunion. Between Sovereignty and Solidarity. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Heichel S., Pape J. and Sommerer T. (2005) Is There Convergence in Convergence Research? An Overview of Empirical Studies on Policy Convergence. Journal of European Public Policy 12(5): 817840.
Holzinger K. and Knill C. (2005) Causes and Conditions of Cross-National Policy Convergence. Journal of European Public Policy 12(5): 775796.
Holzinger K., Knill C. and Arts B. (eds.) (2008a) Environmental Policy Convergence in Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Holzinger K., Jörgens H. and Knill C. (2008b) State of the Art – Conceptualising Environmental Policy Convergence. In Holzinger K., Knill C. and Arts B. (eds.), Environmental Policy Convergence in Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 729.
Howlett M. (2000) Beyond Legalism? Policy Ideas, Implementation Styles and Emulation-Based Convergence in Canadian and U.S. Environmental Policy. Journal of Public Policy 20(3): 305329.
International Energy Agency (2015a) Medium Term Renewable Energy Market Report 2015. IEA, Paris, http://www.iea.org/Textbase/npsum/MTrenew2015sum.pdf (accessed 7 November 2016).
International Energy Agency (2015b) IEA Energy Technology RD&D Statistics. Paris: OECD.
Islam N. (2003) What Have we Learned From the Convergence Debate. Journal of Economic Surveys 17(3): 309362.
Jacobs D. (2012) Renewable Energy Policy Convergence in the EU: The Evolution of Feed-in Tariffs in Germany, Spain and France. London: Ashgate.
Johnstone N., Haščič I. and Popp D. (2010) Renewable Energy Policy and Technological Innovation: Evidence Based on Patent Counts. Environmental and Resource Economics 45(1): 133155.
Keohane N., Revesz R. and Stavins R. (1998) The Choice of Regulatory Instruments in Environmental Policy. Harvard Environmental Law Review 22: 313367.
Kern F. (2011) Ideas, Institutions, and Interests: Explaining Policy Divergence in Fostering “System Innovations” Towards Sustainability. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 29: 11161134.
Kerr C. (1983) The Future of Industrial Societies: Convergence or Continuing Diversity?. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Klinge Jacobsen H., Pade L. L., Schröder S. T. and Kitzing L. (2014) Cooperation Mechanisms to Achieve EU Renewable Targets. Renewable Energy 63: 345352.
Kitzing L., Mitchell C. and Mothorst P. E. (2012) Renewable Energy Policies in Europe: Converging or Diverging? Energy Policy 51: 192201.
Knill C., Sommerer T. and Holzinger K. (2008) Degree and Direction of Environmental Policy Convergence: Analysis of Aggregate Data. In Holzinger K., Knill C. and Arts B. (eds.), Environmental Policy Convergence in Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 98143.
Kopp O., Eßer-Frey A. and Engelhorn T. (2012) Können sich erneuerbare Energien langfristig auf wettbewerblich organisierten Strommärkten finanzieren? Zeitschrift für Energiewirtschaft 36(4): 113.
Laird F. N. and Stefes C. (2009) The Diverging Paths of German and United States Policies for Renewable Energy: Sources of Difference. Energy Policy 37(7): 26192629.
Leruth B. and Lord C. (2015) Differentiated Integration in the European Union: A Concept, a System or a Theory? Journal of European Public Policy 22(6): 754763.
Maggetti M. and Gilardi F. (2016) Problems (and solutions) in the Measurement of Policy Diffusion Mechanisms. Journal of Public Policy 36(1): 87107.
Miller M., Bird L., Cochran J., Milligan M., Bazilian M, Denny E., Dillons, J., Bialek, M., O'Malley, M. and Neuhoff, K. (2013) RES-E-Next: Next Generation of RES-E Policy Instruments. Study Commissioned by IEA-RETD, 4 July, http://iea-retd.org/archives/publications/res-e-next (accessed 7 November 2016).
Mundell R. A. (1961) A Theory of Optimum Currency Areas. American Economic Review 51(4): 657665.
North D. C. (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Oates W. E. (1972) Fiscal Federalism. New York: Harcourt Brace Javanovich.
Oates W. E. (1999) An Essay on Fiscal Federalism. Journal of Economic Literature 37: 11201149.
Ohlin B. (1933) Interregional and International Trade. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Overbye E. (1994) Convergence in Policy Outcomes: Social Security Systems in Perspective. Journal of Public Policy 14(2): 147174.
Pettersson F., Maddison D., Acar S. and Söderholm P. (2014) Convergence of Carbon Dioxide Emissions: A Review of the Literature. International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics 7: 141178.
Plümper T. and Schneider C. J. (2009) The Analysis of Policy Convergence, or: How to Chase a Black Cat in a Dark Room. Journal of European Public Policy 16(7): 9901011.
Pierre J. (2015) Varieties of Capitalism and Varieties of Globalization: Comparing Patterns of Market Deregulation. Journal of European Public Policy 22(7): 908926.
Pitlik H. (2007) A Race to Liberalization? Diffusion of Economic Policy Reform Among OECD-Economies. Public Choice 132: 159178.
Rodriguez F. and Rodrik D. (2001) Trade Policy and Economic Growth: A Skeptic’s Guide to the Cross-National Evidence. In Bernanke B. and Rogoff K. (eds.), NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2000. Volume 15, Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 261338.
Samuelson P. A. (1948) International Trade and the Equalisation of Factor Prices. Economic Journal 58(230): 163184.
Söderholm P. (2008a) Harmonization of Renewable Electricity Feed-In Laws: A Comment. Energy Policy 36: 946953.
Söderholm P. (2008b) The Political Economy of International Green Certificate Markets. Energy Policy 36: 20512062.
Solow R. (1956) A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth. Quarterly Journal of Economics 70(1): 6594.
Streeck W. and Elsässer L. (2016) Monetary Disunion: The Domestic Politics of Euroland. Journal of European Public Policy 23(1): 124.
Strunz S., Gawel E. and Lehmann P. (2014) On the Alleged Need to Strictly “Europeanize” the German Energiewende. Intereconomics 49(5): 244250.
Strunz S., Gawel E. and Lehmann P. (2015) Towards a General “Europeanization” of EU Member States’ Energy Policies? Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy 2(4): 143159.
Tagliapietra S. (2014) Building Tomorrow’s Europe. The Role of an “EU Energy Union” (November 13). Review of Environment, Energy and Economics (Re3), http://dx.doi.org/10.7711/feemre3.2014.11.002
Tews K. (2005) The Diffusion of Environmental Policy Innovations: Cornerstones of an Analytical Framework. European Environment 15: 6379.
Tews K. (2015) Europeanization of Energy and Climate Policy: The Struggle Between Competing Ideas of Coordinating Energy Transitions. Journal of Environment & Development 24(3): 267291.
Teyssen J. (2013) Stop Unilateralism. The German Energiewende Needs a European Context. Energlobe, 13 May, http://energlobe.eu/economy/stop-unilaterism
Ther P. (2014) Die neue Ordnung auf dem alten Kontinent. Eine Geschichte des neoliberalen Europa. Berlin: Suhrkamp.
Unteutsch M. and Lindenberger D. (2014) Promotion of Electricity From Renewable Energy in Europe Post 2020 – The Economic Benefits of Cooperation. Zeitschrift für Energiewirtschaft 38(1): 4764.
Vasseur M. (2014) Convergence and Divergence in Renewable Energy Policy Among US States From 1998 to 2011. Social Forces 92(4): 16371657.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Public Policy
  • ISSN: 0143-814X
  • EISSN: 1469-7815
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-public-policy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Type Description Title
UNKNOWN
Supplementary Materials

Strunz supplementary material
Strunz supplementary material 4

 Unknown (13 KB)
13 KB
UNKNOWN
Supplementary Materials

Strunz supplementary material
Strunz supplementary material 1

 Unknown (194 bytes)
194 bytes
EXCEL
Supplementary Materials

Strunz supplementary material
Strunz supplementary material 3

 Excel (40 KB)
40 KB
EXCEL
Supplementary Materials

Strunz supplementary material
Strunz supplementary material 2

 Excel (39 KB)
39 KB

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 9
Total number of PDF views: 69 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 479 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 3rd May 2017 - 13th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.