Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Policy overreaction

  • Moshe Maor (a1)
Abstract

The literature on policy success and failure does not capture policies that may be too successful, as well as “too much” and/or “too soon” patterns of policy. To bridge this gap, this conceptual article relies on one of the most robust findings in the psychology of judgement, namely that many people are overconfident, prone to place too much faith in their intuitions. Based on this premise, the analytical framework advanced here revolves around two key dimensions of policy overreaction: (i) the effects of positive and negative events, and (ii) the effects of overestimation and accurate estimation of information. Based on these dimensions, the article identifies and illustrates four distinct modes of policy overreaction that reflect differences in the nature of implemented policy. It argues that the policy tools menu utilised in each mode of policy overreaction is dominated by unique mechanisms for changing or coordinating behaviour, which, once established, produce excessive – objective and/or perceived – social costs.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Moshe Maor Wolfson Family Professor of Public Administration Department of Political Science The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Mount Scopus Jerusalem 91905 Israel Tel.: +972 2588 3454 Fax: +972 2588 1333 Email: msmaor@mscc.huji.ac.il
References
Hide All
Akerlof, G. A.Shiller, R. J. (2009) Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy, and Why It Matters for Global Capitalism. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.
Alicke, M. D. (1985) Global self-evaluation as determined by the desirability and controllability of trait adjectives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 49: 16211630.
Andreas, P. (2003) Redrawing the line: borders and security in the twenty-first century. International Security 28(2): 78111.
Angner, E. (2006) Economists as experts: overconfidence in theory and practice. Journal of Economic Methodology 13(1): 124.
Azizian, R. (1999) Russia's crisis: what went wrong? New Zealand International Review 24(1): 2.
Barak, E. (2009) Statement from Israel's defense minister. The New York Times 3 January.
Barber, B. M.Odean, T. (2001) Boys will be boys: overconfidence, and common stock investment. Quarterly Journal of Economics 116(1): 261292.
Baumgartner, F. R.Jones, B. D. (1993) Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bénabou, R. (2009) Groupthink: collective delusions in organizations and markets. NBER Working Paper No. 14764. Accessed on 2 September 2012 at www.nber.org/papers/w14764
Boin, A., ’t Hart, P., Stern, E.Sundelius, B. (2005) The Politics of Crisis Management: Public Leadership under Pressure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Boin, A., ’t Hart, P.McConnell, A. (2008) Conclusions: the politics of crisis exploitation. In Arjen B., McConnell A. and ’t Hart P. (eds.), Governing after Crisis: The Politics of Investigation, Accountability and Learning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 285316.
Bovens, M.’t Hart, P. (1996) Understanding Policy Fiascos. New Brunswick: Transaction.
Bovens, M., ’t Hart, P.Peters, B. G. (2001) Analyzing governance success and failure in six European states. In Bovens M., ’t Hart P. and Peters B. G. (eds.), Success and Failure in Public Governance: A Comparative Analysis. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 1226.
Caldwell, W. B., Murphy, D.Menning, A. (2009) Learning to leverage new media: the Israeli Defense Forces in recent conflicts. Military Review 89(3): 210.
Cameron, A.Sebastien, B. (2010) Overconfidence and the Attainment of Status in Group. Working Paper Series. Institute for Research on Labor and Employment, UC Berkeley.
Carpenter, D. P. (2001) The Forging of Bureaucratic Autonomy: Reputations, Networks, and Policy Innovation in Executive Agencies, 1862–1928. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.
Cesarini, D., Sandewall, Ö.Johannesson, M. (2006) Confidence interval estimation tasks and the economics of overconfidence. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 61: 453470.
Colgrove, J. (2006) The ethics and politics of compulsory HPV vaccination. The New England Journal of Medicine 355: 23892391.
Comfort, L. K. (2002) Managing intergovernmental responses to terrorism and other extreme events. Publius 32(4): 2949.
Connell, E.Hunt, A. (2010) The HPV vaccination campaign: a project of moral regulation in an era of biopolitics. Canadian Journal of Sociology 35(1): 6382.
Cudahy, R. D. (2010) From Socialism to Capitalism: a winding road. Chicago Journal of International Law 11: 3952.
Daniel, K., Hirshleifer, D.Subrahmanyam, A. (1998) A theory of overconfidence, self-attribution, and security market under- and overreaction. Journal of Finance 53(6): 18391886.
Davidson, E. J. (2005) Evaluation Methodology Basics: The Nuts and Bolts of Sound Evaluation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
De Bondt, W. F. M.Thaler, R. (1995) Financial decision making in markets and firms: a behavioral perspective. In Jarrow R. A., Maksimovic V. and Ziembaet W. T. (eds.), Handbooks in Operations Research and Management Sciences, Vol. 9. North-Holland. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 385410.
Dunleavy, P. (1995) Policy disasters: explaining the UK's record. Public Policy and Administration 10(2): 5270.
Dunleavy, P.Rhodes, R. A. W. (1990) Core executive studies in Britain. Public Administration 2: 328.
Farquhar, S. C. (2009) Back to Basics: A Study of the Second Lebanon War and Operation Cast Lead. Fort Leavenworth, Kansas: Combat Studies Institute Press.
Feldman, M. S.March, J. G. (1981) Information in Organizations as Signal and Symbol. Administrative Science Quarterly 26(2): 171186.
Ferreira, C., Boholm, Å.Löfstedt, R. (2001) From vision to catastrophe: a risk event in search of images. In Flynn J., Slovic P. and Kunreuther H. (eds.), Risk, Media and Stigma: Understanding Public Challenges to Modern Science and Technology. London: Earthscan, 283300.
Fitzpatrick, M. (2001) The Tyranny of Health: Doctors and the Regulation of Lifestyle. London: Routledge.
Frenkel, S. (2009) Israel backs down over white phosphorus. The Sunday Times 23 April.
Friedman, B. H. (2011) Managing fear: the politics of homeland security. Political Science Quarterly 126(1): 77106.
Griffin, D.Brenner, L. (2004) Perspectives on probability judgment calibration. In Koehler D. J. and Harvey N. (eds.), Blackwell Handbook of Judgment & Decision Making, 2nd edition. Maldem, MA: Blackwell Publishing: 177199.
Hancock, P. A.Warm, J. S. (1989) A dynamic model of stress and sustained attention. Human Factors 31: 519537.
Handmer, J.Dovers, S. (2007) Handbook of Disaster and Emergency Policies and Institutions. London: Earthscan.
Harel, A.Sinai, R. (2009) IDF admits to overestimating Gaza rocket severity, but warns worst may be yet to come. Haaretz, 2 January.
Healy, A. J., Offenberg, J. (2007) Overconfidence, Social Groups, and Gender: Evidence from the Lab and Field. Accessed on 2 September 2012 at http://myweb.lmu.edu/jpate/overconfidence.pdf
Herrmann, R. K., Tetlock, P.Visser, P. S. (1999) Mass public decisions to go to war: a cognitive-interactionist framework. American Political Science Review 93(3): 553573.
Hilton, S., Hunt, K., Langan, M., Bedford, H.Petticrew, M. (2010) Newsprint media representations of the introduction of the HPV Vaccination programme for cervical cancer prevention in the UK (2005–2008). Social Science & Medicine 70: 942950.
Hogwood, B. W.Peters, B. G. (1985) The Pathology of Public Policy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Hood, C. (2011) The Blame Game: Spin, Bureaucracy, and Self-Preservation in Government. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Huddy, L., Feldman, S., Taber, C.Lahav, G. (2005) Threat, anxiety, and support of antiterrorism policies. American Journal of Political Science 49(3): 593608.
Ingram, H. M.Mann, D. E. (eds.) (1980) Why Policies Succeed or Fail. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Janis, I. (1972) Victims of Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascos. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Jones, B. D. (1999) Bounded rationality. Annual Review of Political Science 2: 297321.
Jones, B. D. (2012) Human nature of public policy: behavioral foundations for policy analysis. Keynote speech. The Federmann School of Public Policy and Government, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, May.
Jones, B. D.Baumgartner, F. R. (2005) The Politics of Attention: How Government Prioritizes Problems. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Kahneman, D. (2011) Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Kahneman, D.Tversky, A. (1984) Choices, values, and frames. American Psychologist 39: 341350.
Kasperson, J. X., Kasperson, F. E., Pidgeon, N.Slovic, P. (2010) The social amplification of risk: assessing fifteen years of research and theory. In Slovic P. (ed.), The Feeling of Risk: New Perspectives on Risk Perception. London: Earthscan, 317344.
Kassop, N. (2003) The war power and its limits. Presidential Studies Quarterly 33(3): 509529.
Kerr, D. H. (1976) The logic of “policy” and successful policies. Policy Sciences 7(3): 351363.
King, G., Murray, C. J. L., Salomon, J. A.Tandon, A. (2004) Enhancing the validity and cross-cultural comparability of measurement in survey research. American Political Science Review 98: 191207.
Kingdon, J. W. (1995) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. New York: Harper Collins.
Kleindorfer, P. R. (2010) What if you know you will have to explain your choices to others afterwards? Legitimation in decision making. In Michel-Kerjan E. and Slovic P. (eds.), The Irrational Economist: Making Decisions in a Dangerous World. NY: Perseus Books, 7278.
Krantz, D. H. (2010) Constructed preference and the quest for rationality. In Michel-Kerjan E. and Slovic P. (eds.), The Irrational Economist: Making Decisions in a Dangerous World. NY: Perseus Books, 6571.
Kumar, B. M.Whynes, D. K. (2011) Explaining variation in the uptake of HPV vaccination in England. BMC Public Health 11: 172178.
Lerner, J. S., Gonzales, R. M., Small, D. A.Fischhoff, B. (2003) Effects of fear and anger on perceived risks of terrorism: a national field experiment. Psychological Science 14(2): 144150.
Lerner, J. S.Keltner, D. (2000) Beyond valence: toward a model of emotion-specific influences on judgment and choice. Cognition and Emotion 14(4): 473493.
Levi, M. (2004) An analytic narrative approach to puzzles and problems. In Shapiro I., Smith R. M. and Massoud T. E. (eds.) Problems and Methods in the Study of Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 201226.
Lichtenstein, S., Fischhoff, B.Lawrence, P. D. (1982) Calibration of probabilities: the state of the art to 1980. In Kahneman D., Slovic P. and Tversky A. (eds.), Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 306334.
Maor, M. (2007) A scientific standard and an agency's legal independence: which of these reputation-protection mechanisms is less susceptible to political moves. Public Administration 85: 961978.
Maor, M. (2010) Organizational reputation and jurisdictional claims: the case of the U.S. food and drug administration. Governance 23(1): 133159.
Maor, M. (2011) Organizational reputation and the observability of public warnings in 10 pharmaceutical markets. Governance 24(3): 557582.
Maor, M. (2012) Risk and policy underreaction. Working Paper, Jerusalem: Department of Political Science, Hebrew University.
Maor, M., Sulitzeanu-Kenan, R. (2012) The effect of salient reputational threats on the pace of FDA enforcement. Governance. DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0491.2012.01601.x
Maor, M., Gilad, S.Bin-Nun Bloom, P. (forthcoming) Organizational reputation, regulatory talk and strategic silence, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory.
Marangos, J. (2003) Was shock therapy really a shock? Journal of Economic Issues 37(4): 943966.
Medvedev, R. (2000) Post-Soviet Russia through the Yeltsin Era. N.Y.: Columbia University Press.
McConnell, A. (2010) Understanding Policy Success: Rethinking Public Policy. Houndmills, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Moore, D. A.Healy, P. J. (2008) The trouble with overconfidence. Psychological Review 115(20): 502517.
National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2011) HPV Vaccine: Updated March 2011. Accessed on 3 April 2011 at www.ncsl.org/default.aspx?tabid=14381
Nelson, L. D.Kuzes, I. Y. (1995) Radical Reform in Yeltsin's Russia: Political, Economic, and Social Dimensions. N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
Palmer, L. I. (2009) What is urban health policy and what's law got to do with it? Georgetown Journal on Poverty Law & Policy, XV(3): 635–663.
Patt, A.Zeckhauser, R. (2000) Action bias and environmental decisions. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 21(1): 4572.
Platt, E. (2009) Crying out for justice. New Statesman 138, 4956, 28–29. Accessed on 2 September 2012 at www.newstatesman.com/middle-east/2009/07/israel-war-palestinian-rights
Plous, S. (1993) The Psychology of Judgment and Decision Making. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Poguntke, T.Webb, P. (2005) The Presidentialization of Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Prendergast, C. (1993) A theory of “yes men”. American Economic Review 83(4): 757770.
Rotemberg, J.Saloner, G. (2000) Visionaries, managers, and strategic direction. Rand Journal of Economics 31(4): 693716.
Sabatier, P. A.Weible, C. M. (2007) The advocacy coalition framework: innovations and clarifications. In Sabatier P. A. (ed.), Theories of the Policy Process, Second edition. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 189222.
Schachter, J. (2010) Unusually quiet: is Israel deterring terrorism? Strategic Assessment 13(2): 1927.
Siegrist, M., Gutscher, H.Keller, C. (2007) Trust and confidence in crisis communication: three case studies. In Siegrist M., Earle T. C. and Gutscher H. (eds.), Trust in Cooperative Risk Management: Uncertainty and Scepticism in the Public Mind. London: Earthscan, 267286.
Simon, H. A. (1982) Models of Bounded Rationality, 3 vols. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Slovic, P. (1993) Perceived risk, trust and democracy. Risk Analysis 13(6): 675682.
Slovic, P. (2000) The Perception of Risk. London: Earthscan.
Slovic, P. (ed.) (2010) The Feeling of Risk: New Perspectives on Risk Perception. London: Earthscan.
Slovic, P., Fischhoff, B.Lichtenstein, S. (1980) Facts and fears: understanding perceived risk. In Schwing R. and Albers W. (eds.), Societal Risk Assessment: How Safe is Safe Enough? New York: Plenum, 181216.
Spiegelhalter, D. (2011) Quantifying uncertainty. In Skinns L., Michael S. and Cox T. (eds.), Risk. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1733.
Stern, J. (2002/2003) Dreaded risks and the control of biological weapons. International Security 27(3): 89123.
Stone, D. (2002) Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making. NY: W.W. Norton & Company.
Stretch, R., Chambers, G., Wittaker, J., Critchley, T., Jackson, F., Montgomery, M. B., Roberts, S. A.Brabin, L. (2008) Implementing a school-based HPV vaccination programme. Nursing Times 104(48): 3033.
Sunstein, C. R. (2002) Probability neglect: emotions, worst cases and law. Yale Law Journal 112: 61107.
Sunstein, C. R., Zeckhauser, R. J. (2008) Overreaction to fearsome risks. Harvard Law School Program on Risk Regulation Research Paper No. 08–17. Accessed on 2 September 2012 at SSRN, http://ssrn.com/abstract=1319881
Sunstein, C. R.Zeckhauser, R. J. (2010) Dreadful possibilities, neglected probabilities. In Michel-Kerjan E. and Slovic P. (eds.), The Irrational Economist: Making Decisions in a Dangerous World. NY: Perseus Books, 116123.
Taylor, S. E. (1991) Asymmetrical effects of positive and negative events: the mobilization-minimization hypothesis. Psychological Bulletin 110(1): 6785.
Taylor, S. (2003) Rights, liberties, and security: recalibrating the balance after September 11. Brookings Review 21(1): 2531.
Tompson, W. (2002) Shock therapy: was Gaider really necessary? Problems of Post-Communism 49(4): 1221.
Tversky, A.Kahneman, D. (1974) Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science 185: 11241130.
Vamos, C.McDermott, R. (2008) The HPV vaccine: framing the arguments for and against mandatory vaccination of all middle school girls. Journal of School Health 78(6): 302309.
Walker, S. G.Malici, A. (2011) U.S. presidents and foreign policy mistakes. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Waller, J., McCaffery, K.Wardle, J. (2004) Beliefs about the risk factors for cervical cancer in a British population sample. Preventive Medicine 38: 745753.
Weible, C. M.Sabatier, P. A. (2009) Themes and Variations: Taking Stock of the Advocacy Coalition Framework. Policy Studies Journal 37(1): 121140.
Weick, K. E. (1995) Sensemaking in Organizations, Thousand Oaks. CA: Sage Publications.
Weick, K. E. (2001) Making Sense of the Organization. Malden, MA: Blackwell Business.
Wlezien, C. (1995) The public as thermostat: dynamics of preferences for spending. American Journal of Political Science 39(4): 9811000.
Zakaria, F. (2010) Don't panic: how our frenzied response to terrorism only feeds it. Newsweek. 9 January.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Public Policy
  • ISSN: 0143-814X
  • EISSN: 1469-7815
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-public-policy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed