Hostname: page-component-5d59c44645-mrcq8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-02-24T17:24:10.032Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Adding Insult to Injury: The Justification Frame in Official Narratives of Officer-Involved Killings

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 August 2022

Traci Burch*
American Bar Foundation, Chicago, IL 60611, USA Department of Political Science, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Get access


This article identifies the justification frame as a common narrative used by public officials to justify the use of lethal force by police. Officials deploy the justification frame to obfuscate the use of force or claim that victims posed a threat to officers in order to justify civilian deaths. I examine initial statements given in the aftermath of officer-involved deaths in 2016, focusing on incidents where an on-duty officer used force against victims who did not pose a threat when they were killed. I find that elements of the justification frame appear frequently in the explanations issued after these incidents. Statements about Black decedents are more likely to deploy the justification frame.

Research Article
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Race, Ethnicity, and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)


2News Oklahoma (2016) TPD Investigates Death of Man Tased at Arrest. 03 Jun 2016.Google Scholar
Ahumada, R (2016) Ceres Police: Paorlee Pulled Out Hand. Modesto Bee, 7 January 2016.Google Scholar
Arnold, RD (1990) The logic of congressional action. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Associated Press (2016) Tulsa Police Shoot, Kill Black Man in Street. Wall Street Journal, 17 Sep 2016.Google Scholar
Atuahene, B (2014) We Want What’s Ours: Learning from South Africa’s Land Restitution Program. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Baird, JB (2016) Police: Sheriff’s Deputy Fired Fatal Shots in Winooski. Burlington Free Press, 17 Sep 2016.Google Scholar
Barszewski, L (2019) Man Eating Takeout in His Backyard Was Shot Dead by Deputies. Now His Family Gets $125,000. Orlando Sentinel, 21 Nov 2019.Google Scholar
Beltran, J (2016) Man Wanted on Two Felony Warrants Shot Dead by San Antonio Police on North Side., 5 Feb 2016.Google Scholar
Bernstein, M (2016) Bend Police Officer Fatally Shot Motorist While Trying to Arrest Him After Erratic Driving, Police Say. The Oregonian, 24 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
Bonilla-Silva, E (2006) Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in the United States. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.Google Scholar
Burch, T (2021) Not all black lives matter: officer-involved deaths and the role of victim characteristics in shaping political interest and voter turnout. Perspectives on Politics, 1–17.Google Scholar
Carrega, C (2017) Exclusive: Family of Bronx Man who Died after Double Tasering by NYPD Files $10M Lawsuit. New York Daily News, 31 Jan 2017.Google Scholar
CBS Boston (2016) DA Indentifies Lynn Robbery Suspect Shot and Killed by Police. CBS Boston, 29 Nov 2016.Google Scholar
CBS News (2016) Milwaukee Man Fatally Shot by Police Officer Identified. 15 August 2016.Google Scholar
Chong, D and Druckman, JN (2007) Framing theory. Annual Review of Political Science 10, 103126.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chung, J (2016) Handcuffed Man Dies in Police Custody. Gothamist, 18 Mar 2016.Google Scholar
Claster, DS (1992) Bad Guys and Good Guys: Moral Polarization and Crime. Westport: Greenwood.Google Scholar
Clay, N (2016) Oklahoma County Sheriff Says Jailers Not to Blame for Trespassing Suspect’s Death. The Oklahoman, 29 Jul 2016.Google Scholar
Cleary, T (2016) David Joseph: 5 Fast Facts You Need To Know. Scholar
Coker, M (2016) Adalid Flores Shot Dead by Anaheim Police. OC Weekly, 21 Nov 2016.Google Scholar
Dowty, D (2016) Syracuse Shooting: Man Shot To Death Went By Alias; At Least 4 Guns Used in Fight. 20 Jun 2016.Google Scholar
Dukes, KN and Gaither, SE (2017) Black racial stereotypes and victim blaming: Implications for media coverage and criminal proceedings in cases of police violence against racial and ethnic minorities. Journal of Social Issues 73, 789807.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elinson, Z (2016) Fresno Police Release Body-Camera Video in Dylan Noble Shooting. Wall Street Journal, 14 Jul 2016.Google Scholar
Felstiner, WLF, Abel, RL and Sarat, A (1980) The emergence and transformation of disputes: Naming, blaming, claiming. Law and Society Review 15, 631654.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fitz-Gibbon, J (2020) Counterfeit $20 Bill Now Part of George Floyd Murder Case. The New York Post. Online.Google Scholar
Gavin, R (2020) Opening Arguments In Joel Abelove Trial Set For Tuesday. San Francisco Chronicle, 14 Sep 2020.Google Scholar
Georgia Bureau of Investigation (2016a) GBI Investigates Officer Involved Shooting in Atlanta, GA. Online: Georgia Bureau of Investigation.Google Scholar
Georgia Bureau of Investigation (2016b) GBI Investigates US Marshalls Service Task Force Shooting in East Point, GA. Online: Georgia Bureau of Investigation.Google Scholar
Gordon, B (2016) Update: BCA Investigating Officer-Ivolved Shooting in Falcon Heights. Online.Google Scholar
Graham v. Connor 490 US 386 (1989).Google Scholar
Guinyard, T and Arvin, C (2016) Man Killed in Police Shooting at Anaheim Park. 9 Feb 2016.Google Scholar
Hacker, JS and Pierson, P (2005) Abandoning the middle: The Bush tax cuts and the limits of democratic control. Perspectives on Politics 3, 3353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, R (2016) Preliminary Report Concerning February 29, 2016, Officer-Involved Shooting. Online.Google Scholar
Harris, A (2016) Police said man killed by cops had a gun. His family said he had his hands up. Miami Herald, 30 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
Holland, C (2016) ‘Combative’ Man Running in Street Dies in Police Custody. CBS5, 20 May 2016.Google Scholar
Holyoke, C (2016) Troy Police: Officer Justified in Weekend Shooting During Traffic Stop. 18 Apr 2016.Google Scholar
Huff, J, Alvarez, MJ and Miller, MK (2018) Mock juror perceptions of police shootings: the effects of victim race and shooting justifiability. Applied Psychology in Criminal Justice 14, 87101.Google Scholar
Hutchison, B (2016) Man Shot, Killed by Officer at Madison Park. 23 Jun 2016.Google Scholar
Judson, A (2020) Deadly Restraints by Local Police Continue to Happen as Policies Go Unchanged, Costing Taxpayers Millions. 18 Nov 2020.Google Scholar
KCRA News (2016) Driver Dies After Struggle with Elk Grove Police. 1 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
KETK News (2016) Trooper Cleared in Fatal Shooting of Longview Man. 18 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
Larimer, S (2016) Read the Charlotte Police Department’s Investigative Summary on the Keith Lamont Scott Shooting. Washington Post, 24 Sep 2016.Google Scholar
Lipscomb, J (2019) Family of Perrine Police-Shooting Victim Says Miami-Dade Cops Planted Gun at teh Scene. Miami New Times, 4 Jan 2019.Google Scholar
Los Angeles Times (2018) LAPD Officer Justified in 2016 Fatal Shooting of 18-Year-Old Man in South L.A., Jury Decides. Los Angeles Times, 2 Oct 2018.Google Scholar
Marshall News Messenger (2016) People Gather to Pray in Carthage After Man Killed by Trooper. Marshall News Messenger, 19 Feb 2016.Google Scholar
Mather, K (2016) Death ‘Happened So Fast’; Witness Says 18-Year-Old Ran from LAPD Before Officer Shot and Killed HIm in South L.A. Los Angeles Times, 18 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
Mckneely, L Jr. (2016) Officer Involved Shooting On North Foster Drive.Google Scholar
McLaughlin, EC (2016) Police: Man Killed by Officer Pointed Vaping Device, Not Gun. CNN, 30 Sep 2016.Google Scholar
Meaux, M (2016) Delacruz Family Seeking Answers in Son’s Death. 12 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
Mettler, S (2011) The Submerged State: How Invisible Government Policies Undermine American Democracy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michener, J (2019) Policy feedback in a racialized polity. Policy Studies Journal 47, 423450.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miles, D (2016) Emotionally Disturbed Man Shocked with Stun Gun by Police Dies in the Bronx. abc7ny, 3 Nov 2016.Google Scholar
Miller, ME (2016) ‘They Stood Over Him and Watched Him Die’: Outrage in Alabama after White Officer Kills Black Man. Washington Post, 01 Mar 2016.Google Scholar
New York State Office of the Attorney General (n.d.) Report on the Investigation into the Death of Edson Thevenin. ed. N. Y. S. O. o. t. A. General. Online.Google Scholar
Nolan, K and Bosman, J (2017) Milwaukee Officer is Acquitted in Killing of Sylville Smith. New York Times, 21 Jun 2017.Google Scholar
O’Brien, AJ and Thom, K (2014) Police use of TASER devices in mental health emergencies: A review. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 37, 420426.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
O’Brien, TC, Meares, TL and Tyler, TR (2020) Reconciling police and communities with apologies, acknowledgements, or both: A controlled experiment. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 687, 202215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pasquier, M, Carron, P-N, Vallotton, L and Yersin, B (2011) Electronic Control Device Exposure: A Review of Morbidity and Mortality. Annals of Emergency Medicine 58, 178188.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Peffley, M and Hurwitz, J (2010) Justice in America: The Separate Realities of Blacks and Whites. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perkins, JE and Bourgeois, MJ (2006) Perceptions of police use of deadly force. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 36, 161177.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pica, E, Sheahan, CL, Pozzulo, J and Bennell, C (2020) Guns, gloves, and tasers: perceptions of police officers and their use of weapon as a function of race and gender. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology 35, 348359.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, P (1993) When effect becomes cause: Policy feedback and political change. World Politics 45, 595628.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Powell, B (2016) Investigation Continues in Deadly Rockingham County Traffic Stop. 30 May 2016.Google Scholar
Ralph, L (2013) The qualia of pain: How police torture shapes historical consciousness. Anthropological Theory 13, 104118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosenthal, A (2020) Submerged for some? Government visibility, race, and american political trust. Perspectives on Politics 19, 10981114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Satterfield, J (2017) Lawsuit: Blount Deputy Accused of Killing Suspect, Agency Accused of Attempted Cover-Up. 24 Jul 2017.Google Scholar
Satterfield, J (2019) Judge: Blount Deputy Used Excessive Force in Fatal ‘Slamming’ of Unarmed Man. 27 Mar 2019.Google Scholar
Scanlan, D (2016) Jacksonville Man Dies Following Early Christmas Eve Police Confrontation on Golfair Boulevard. Florida Times-Union, 24 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
Schneider, A and Ingram, H (1993) Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American Political Science Review 87, 334347.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schultz, K (2016) Woman Killed by SF Police Sergeant IDd as Jessica Williams, 29. 20 May 2016.Google Scholar
Shannon, J (2018) Lawyer: Police Seized Pot to Smear Botham Jean After He Was Shot In His Own Apartment. USA Today.Google Scholar
Sharpe, J (2018) Lawsuit--Fulton DA Sues Feds for Records in Police Shooting - Jamarion Robinson was Shot 59 Times in 2019 at an East Point Apartment. Atlanta Journal-Constitution, 28 Dec 2018.Google Scholar
Smith, M (2017) Minnesota Officer Acquitted in Killing of Philando Castile. New York Times (Online).Google Scholar
Soss, J and Schram, SF (2007) A public transformed? Welfare reform as policy feedback. American Political Science Review 101, 111127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Staff (2016) County Jail Inmate Dies. Santa Barbara Independent, 05 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
Streeter, S (2019) The Racial Politics of Police Violence in the United States. Ph.D., Stanford University, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Sullivan, D (2016) Hillsborough Deputy Fatally Shoots Unarmed Man While Serving Warrant At Clair-Mel Home. 30 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
Surprise Police Department (2016) Police Investigate Officer Involved Shooting. Online: Surprise Police Department.Google Scholar
Suter, L (2016) Boy, 16, killed in officer-involved shooting, had ‘desire to end his own life,’ LAPD chief says. ABC7, 6 October 2016.Google Scholar
Tennenbaum, AN (1994) The influence of the Garner decision on police use of deadly force. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 85, 241.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tennessee v. Garner 471 US 1 (1985).Google Scholar
The Ledger (2016) Sheriff’s Office: 2 Deputies Involved in Fatal Shooting. The Ledger, 10 Sep 2016.Google Scholar
The Sun (2016) San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department Investigating Trona Man’s In-Custody Death. The Sun, 25 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
Truscott, A (2008) A knee in the neck of excited delirium. Canadian Medical Association Journal 178, 669670.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Tse, C (2016) Unarmed Man Shot and Killed by Sheriff’s Deputy was Homeless, Say Witnesses. 3 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
United States Department of Justice (1995) Positional Asphyxia--Sudden Death. ed. N. L. E. T. Center. Department of Justice.Google Scholar
United States Department of Justice (2017) Investigation of the Chicago Police Department.Google Scholar
Vera, A (2019) Federal Officials Say They Won’t Pursue Charges Against Former Oklahoma Officer Who Fatally Shot Unarmed Black Man. 1 Mar 2019.Google Scholar
Vielmetti, B (2020) Milwaukee to Weigh $4 Million Payment to Family of Sylville Smith, Fatally Shot by Police in 2016. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 23 Oct 2020.Google Scholar
Vives, R (2016) Man Collapses During Arrest. Los Angeles Times, 04 Jul 2016.Google Scholar
Wade, M (2021) Minneapolis Police Press Release Tells Different Story of George Floyd Death. 20 Apr 2021.Google Scholar
WAFF News (2016) Suspect and Woman Dead After Being Shot at Killen Standoff. 6 Oct 2016.Google Scholar
Walters, S and Connor, T (2016) Family Blasts Police Shooting of Francisco Serna, Unarmed Senior. 13 Dec 2016.Google Scholar
Weaver, RK (1986) The politics of blame avoidance. Journal of Public Policy 6, 371-398.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, K (2016) Questions Remain in Hays Officer-Involved Shooting. 19 Aug 2016.Google Scholar
White, MD, Ready, J, Riggs, C, Dawes, DM, Hinz, A and Ho, JD (2013) An incident-level profile of TASER device deployments in arrest-related deaths. Police Quarterly 16, 85112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, B, Feshir, R, Collins, J and Sepic, M (2021) Chauvin Trial: Breathing Expert Pinpoints Moment When ‘The Life Goes Out of His Body’. 8 Apr 2021.Google Scholar
WKYT News (2016) Laurel Co. Sheriff’s Office Investigating Fatal Shooting Involving a Constable. 5 Mar 2016.Google Scholar
WVLT News (2016) Attorney: Man Injured During Blount County Arrest Died, Law Firm Investigating Arrest’s Circumstances. 28 Jul 2016.Google Scholar
WYFF4 News (2016) Coroner: Man’s Death Caused by Drug and Alcohol Use, Not Taser. 2 May 2016.Google Scholar
Zhang, Y, Shah, D, Foley, J, Abhishek, A, Lukito, J, Suk, J, Kim, SJ, Sun, Z, Pevehouse, J and Garlough, C (2019) Whose lives matter? Mass shootings and social media discourses of sympathy and policy, 2012–2014. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication 24, 182202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar