Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Does Use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy While Continuing to Smoke Undermine Cessation?: A Systematic Review

  • Emma Beard (a1), Paul Aveyard (a2), Susan Michie (a3), Ann McNeill (a4) and Robert West (a1)...

Aims: To review population surveys to assess (a) prevalence of the use of NRT for smoking reduction (SR) and temporary abstinence (TA) and (b) how far this is associated with attempts to stop smoking, smoking cessation and reduction in cigarette consumption.

Methods: An electronic search was undertaken of EMBASE, MEDLINE, Web of Science and PsycINFO. Articles were selected if they (1) assessed whether smokers had used or were currently using NRT for SR and/or TA; (2) involved smokers who had not taken part in a harm reduction programme; and (3) assessed prevalence and/or association of SR and/or TA with reductions in cigarette consumption and/or attempts to stop smoking and/or with smoking cessation. Twelve studies met the inclusion criteria and results were extracted independently by two researchers.

Results: Data were available from five countries (US, UK, Canada, Switzerland and Australia). Between 1% and 23% of smokers reported having ever used NRT for smoking reduction and between 2% and 14% during periods of temporary abstinence. Use of NRT for SR and/or TA was associated with little or no reduction in cigarette consumption. There was some evidence that it was positively associated with attempts to stop smoking and smoking cessation.

Conclusion: In smoking populations use of NRT to aid SR and in situations where smoking is not permitted appears to be having little effect on achieving a reduction in cigarette consumption but does not undermine cessation and may promote it.

Corresponding author
Address for correspondence: Emma Beard, PhD, Cancer Research UK Health Behaviour Research Centre, University College London, WC1E 6BP. E-mail: Tel: 020 31083179.
Hide All
W. Al-Delaimy , E. Gilpin & J. Pierce 2005. When California smokers use Nicotine Replacement Therapy, most are trying to quit smoking. Tob Control. 14, 359360.

T. Asfar , J. O. Ebbert , R. C. Klesges & G. E. Relyea 2011. Do smoking reduction interventions promote cessation in smokers not ready to quit? Addict Behav, 36 (7). 764768.

M. A. Bansal , K. M. Cummings , A. Hyland & G. A. Giovino 2004. Stop-smoking medications: Who uses them, who misuses them, and who is misinformed about them? Nicotine Tob Res. 6 (S3), 303310.

J. E. Bauer , S. M. Carlin-Menter , P. B. Celestino , A. Hyland & K. M. Cummings 2006. Giving away free nicotine medications and a cigarette substitute (Better Quit) to promote calls to a quitline. Public Health Manag Pract. 12 (1), 6067.

E. Beard , J. Fidler & R. West 2011b. Is use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy while continuing to smoke associated with increased nicotine intake? Psychopharmacol. 218 (3), 609610.

E. Beard , A. McNeill , P. Aveyard , J. Fidler , S. Michie & R. West 2011a. Use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy for smoking reduction and during enforced temporary abstinence: A national survey of English smokers. Addiction. 106 (1), 197204.

C. J. Berg , L. C. An , M. Kirch , H. Guo , J. L. Thomas , C. A. Patten , J. S. Ahluwalia & R. West 2010. Failure to report attempts to quit smoking. Addict Behaviors. 35 (10), 900904.

K. M. Cummings & A. Hyland 2005. Impact of Nicotine Replacement Therapy on smoking behaviour. Annu Rev Public Health. 26 (1), 583589.

K. M. Cummings , A. Hyland , G. A. Giovino , J. Hastrup & J. Bauer 2004. Are smokers adequately informed about the health risks of smoking and medicinal nicotine? Nicotine Tob Res. 6 (S3), 333340.

S. J. Curry , L. C. Grothaus , T. McAfee & C. Pabiniak 1998. Use and cost effectiveness of smoking-cessation services under four insurance plans in a health maintenance organisation. New Engl J Prev Med. 339, 673679.

K.M. Emmons , M. G. Goldstein , M. Roberts , B. Cargill , C. B. Sherman , R. Millman , R. Brown & D. B. Abrams 2000. The use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy during hospitalization. Ann Behav Med. 22 (4), 325329.

J-F. Etter , J. le Houezec & B. Landfeldt 2003. Impact of messages on concomitant use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy and cigarettes: A randomised trial on the internet. Addiction. 98, 941950.

K. O. Fagerstrom 2005. Can reduced smoking be a way for smokers not interested in quitting to actually quit? Respiration. 72 (2), 216220.

K. O. Fagerstrom & J. R. Hughes 2002. Nicotine concentrations with concurrent use of cigarettes and nicotine replacement: A review. Nicotine Tob Res. 4 (S2), 7379.

P. Hajek , R. West , J. Foulds , F. Nilsson , S. Burrows & A. Meadow 1999. Randomized Comparative trial of nicotine polacrilex, a transdermal patch, nasal spray, and an inhaler. Arch Intern Med. 159, 20332038.

D. Hammond , L. Reid , P. Driezen , M. Cummings , R. Borland , G. T. Fong , A. McNeill & J. R. Hughes 2008. Smokers’ use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy for reasons other than stopping smoking: Findings from the ITC Country Survey. Addiction. 103, 16961703.

J. Higgins & S. Green 2008. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Oxford, UK: Wiley.

R. Horne & J. Weinman 1999. Patients’ beliefs about prescribed medicines and their role in adherence to treatment in chronic physical illness. J Psychosom Res. 47 (6), 555567.

J. R. Hughes , E. H. Adams , M. A. Franzon , M. K. Maguire & J. Guary 2005. A prospective study of off-label use of, abuse of, and dependence on nicotine inhaler. Tob Control. 14, 4954.

J. R. Hughes & M. J. Carpenter , 2006. Does smoking reduction increase future cessation and decrease disease risk? A qualitative review. Nicotine Tob Res. 8 (6), 739749.

J. R. Hughes , P. G. Lindgren , J. E. Connett & M. A. Nides 2004. Smoking reduction in the lung health study. Nicotine Tob Res. 6 (2), 275280.

J. R. Hughes , J. L. Pillitteri , P. W. Callas , R. Callahan & M. Kenny 2004. Misuse of and dependence on over-the-counter nicotine gum in a volunteer sample. Nicotine Tob Res. 6 (1), 7985.

D. Kotz , J. Fidler & R. West 2009. Factors associated with the use of aids to cessation in English smokers. Addiction. 104 (8), 14031410.

D. E. Levy , A. N. Thorndike , L. Biener & N. Rigotti 2007. Use of Nicotine Replacement Therapy to reduce or delay smoking but not to quit: Prevalence and association with subsequent cessation efforts. Tob Control. 16, 384389.

N. Miller , T. R. Frieden , S. Y. Liu , T. D. Matte , F. Mostashari , D. R. Deitcher , K. M. Cummings , C. Chang , U. Bauer & M. T. Bassett 2005. Effectiveness of a large-scale free nicotine patch distribution program. The Lancet. 365, 18491854.

D. Moher , A. Liberati , J. Tetzlaff & D. G. Altman 2009. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. BMJ. 339, 2535.

D. Moore , P. Aveyard , M. Connock , D. Wang , A. Fry-Smith & P. Barton , 2009. Effectiveness and safety of Nicotine Replacement Therapy assisted reduction to stop smoking: Systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 338, 1024.

L. Shahab , M. Cummings , D. Hammond , R. Borland , R. West & A. McNeill 2009. The impact of changing nicotine replacement therapy licensing laws in the United Kingdom: finding from the International Tobacco Control Four Country Survey. Addiction. 104, 14201427.

S. Shiffman , S. G. Feguson , J. Rohay & J. G. Gitchell 2008. Perceived safety and efficacy of nicotine replacement therapies among US smokers and ex-smokers: Relationship with use and compliance. Addiction. 103, 13721379.

S. Shiffman , J. R. Hughes , J. R. Di Marino & C. T. Sweeney 2003. Patterns of over the counter nicotine gum use: Persistent use and concurrent smoking. Addiction. 98 (12), 17471753.

A. N. Thorndike , L. Biener & N. A. Rigotti (2002). Effect on smoking cessation of switching nicotine replacement therapy to over-the-counter status. Am J Public Health, 92 (3), 437442.

P. Tonnesen 2002. Smoking reduction for smokers not able or motivated to quit? Respiration. 69 (6), 475478.

J. P. Zellweger 2001. Anti-smoking therapies: Is harm reduction a viable alternative to smoking cessation? Drugs. 61, 10411044.

S. H Zhu , T. M. Melcer , J. Sun , B. Rusbrook & J. P. Pierce 2000. Smoking cessation without and with assistance: A population based analysis. Am J Prev Med. 18, 305311.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Smoking Cessation
  • ISSN: -
  • EISSN: 1834-2612
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-smoking-cessation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 20 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 306 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.