Skip to main content Accessibility help

Differential growth responses in seedlings of ten species of Dipterocarpaceae to experimental shading and defoliation

  • C. E. Timothy Paine (a1), Martin Stenflo (a1), Christopher D. Philipson (a1), Philippe Saner (a1), Robert Bagchi (a2), Robert C. Ong (a3) and Andy Hector (a1)...

The responses of plants to shade and foliar herbivory jointly affect growth rates and community assembly. We grew 600 seedlings of ten species of the economically important Dipterocarpaceae in experimental gradients of shading (0.3–47.0% of full sunlight) and defoliation (0, 25%, 50% or 75% of leaf area removed). We assessed stem diameters initially, after 2 and 4 mo, and calculated relative growth rates (RGR) with a linear model. Shading interacted with defoliation, reducing RGR by 21.6% in shaded conditions and 8.9% in well-lit conditions. We tested three hypotheses for interspecific trade-offs in growth responses to shading and defoliation. They could be positively related, because both reduce a plant's access to carbon, or inversely related because of trade-offs between herbivore resistance and tolerance. We observed, however, that species varied in their response to shading, but not defoliation, precluding an interspecific trade-off and suggesting that plants tolerate shade and herbivory with differing strategies. Shading most strongly reduced the growth of species with less-dense wood and larger seeds. The strong and variable growth responses to shade, contrasted with the weak and uniform responses to defoliation, suggest that variation in light availability more strongly affects the growth of tropical tree seedlings, and thus community assembly, than does variation in herbivory.

Corresponding author
1Corresponding author. Email:
Hide All
ASHTON, P. S. 1982. Flora Malesiana—Dipterocarpaceae. Martinus Nijhoff/Dr. W. Junk, Dordrecht. 552 pp.
BARAZA, E., GÓMEZ, J. M., HÓDAR, J. A. & ZAMORA, R. 2004. Herbivory has a greater impact in shade than in sun: response of Quercus pyrenaica seedlings to multifactorial environmental variation. Canadian Journal of Botany 82:357364.
BEBBER, D., BROWN, N. & SPEIGHT, M. 2002. Drought and root herbivory in understorey Parashorea Kurz (Dipterocarpaceae) seedlings in Borneo. Journal of Tropical Ecology 18:795804.
BECKER, P. 1983. Effects of insect herbivory and artificial defoliation on survival of Shorea seedlings. Pp. 241252 in Sutton, S. L., Whitmore, T. C. & Chadwick, A. C. (eds.). Tropical rainforest: ecology and management. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.
BLUNDELL, A. G. & PEART, D. R. 2001. Growth strategies of a shade-tolerant tropical tree: the interactive effects of canopy gaps and simulated herbivory. Journal of Ecology 89:608615.
CHAMBERLAIN, T. C. 1880. The method of multiple working hypotheses. Science 15:9296.
CHAVE, J., COOMES, D. A., JANSEN, S., LEWIS, S. L., SWENSON, N. G. & ZANNE, A. E. 2009. Towards a worldwide wood economics spectrum. Ecology Letters 12:351366.
COLEY, P. D. & BARONE, J. A. 1996. Herbivory and plant defenses in tropical forests. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 27:305335.
COLEY, P., BRYANT, J. & CHAPIN, F. 1985. Resource availability and plant antiherbivore defense. Science 230:895899.
DUDLEY, S. A. & SCHMITT, J. 1996. Testing the adaptive plasticity hypothesis: density-dependent selection on manipulated stem length in Impatiens capensis. American Naturalist 147:445465.
EICHHORN, M. P., COMPTON, S. G. & HARTLEY, S. E. 2006. Seedling species determines rates of leaf herbivory in a Malaysian rain forest. Journal of Tropical Ecology 22:513.
EICHHORN, M. P., NILUS, R., COMPTON, S. G., HARTLEY, S. E. & BURSLEM, D. F. R. P. 2010. Herbivory of tropical rain forest tree seedlings correlates with future mortality. Ecology 91:10921101.
FINE, P. V. A., MESONES, I. & COLEY, P. D. 2004. Herbivores promote habitat specialization by trees in Amazonian forests. Science 305:663665.
GRIME, J. 1977. Evidence for the existence of three primary strategies in plants and its relevance to ecological and evolutionary theory. American Naturalist 111:11691194.
HECTOR, A., PHILIPSON, C. D., SANER, P., CHAMAGNE, J., DZULKIFLI, D., O'BRIEN, M., SNADDON, J. L., ULOK, P., WEILENMANN, M., REYNOLDS, G. & GODFRAY, H. C. J. 2011. The Sabah Biodiversity Experiment: a long-term test of the role of tree diversity in restoring tropical forest structure and functioning. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B – Biological Sciences 366:33033315.
HOWE, H. F. 1990. Survival and growth of juvenile Virola surinamensis in Panama: effects of herbivory and canopy closure. Journal of Tropical Ecology 6:259280.
KITAJIMA, K. 1994. Relative importance of photosynthetic traits and allocation patterns as correlates of seedling shade tolerance of 13 tropical trees. Oecologia 98:419428.
KOBE, R. 1997. Carbohydrate allocation to storage as a basis of interspecific variation in sapling survivorship and growth. Oikos 80:226233.
LANDIS, R. M. & PEART, D. R. 2005. Early performance predicts canopy attainment across life histories in subalpine forest trees. Ecology 86:6372.
LEIMU, R. & KORICHEVA, J. 2006. A meta-analysis of tradeoffs between plant tolerance and resistance to herbivores: combining the evidence from ecological and agricultural studies. Oikos 112:19.
LENTZ, K. A. & CIPOLLINI, D. F. 1998. Effect of light and simulated herbivory on growth of endangered northeastern bulrush, Scirpus ancistrochaetus Schuyler. Plant Ecology 139:125131.
LOUDA, S. M. & RODMAN, J. E. 1996. Insect herbivory as a major factor in the shade distribution of a native crucifer (Cardamine cordifolia A. Gray, Bittercress). Journal of Ecology 84:229.
MASCHINSKI, J. & WHITHAM, T. G. 1989. The continuum of plant responses to herbivory: the influence of plant association, nutrient availability, and timing. American Naturalist 134:119.
MEIJER, W. & WOOD, G. H. S. 1964. Dipterocarps of Sabah. Forest Department, Sandakan. 344 pp.
MONTGOMERY, R. A. & CHAZDON, R. L. 2002. Light gradient partitioning by tropical tree seedlings in the absence of canopy gaps. Oecologia 131:165174.
MYERS, J. A. & KITAJIMA, K. 2007. Carbohydrate storage enhances seedling shade and stress tolerance in a neotropical forest. Journal of Ecology 95:383395.
NEWMAN, M. F., BURGESS, P. F. & WHITMORE, T. C. 1996. Borneo Island light hardwoods. Royal Botanical Garden Edinburgh, Edinburgh. 275 pp.
NEWMAN, M. F., BURGESS, P. F. & WHITMORE, T. C. 1998. Borneo island medium and heavy hardwoods. Royal Botanical Garden Edinburgh, Edinburgh. 228 pp.
NÚÑEZ-FARFÁN, J., FORNONI, J. & VALVERDE, P. L. 2007. The evolution of resistance and tolerance to herbivores. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 38:541566.
PAINE, C. E. T., MARTHEWS, T. R., VOGT, D. R., PURVES, D. W., REES, M., HECTOR, A. & TURNBULL, L. A. 2012. How to fit nonlinear plant growth models and calculate growth rates: an update for ecologists. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3:245256.
PEARSON, T. R. H., BURSLEM, D. F. R. P., GOERIZ, R. E. & DALLING, J. W. 2003. Interactions of gap size and herbivory on establishment, growth and survival of three species of neotropical pioneer trees. Journal of Ecology 91:785796.
PHILIPSON, C. D., SANER, P., MARTHEWS, T. R., NILUS, R., REYNOLDS, G., TURNBULL, L. A. & HECTOR, A. in press. Light-based regeneration niches: evidence from 21 dipterocarp species using size-specific RGRs. Biotropica.
POORTER, L., WRIGHT, S. J., PAZ, H., ACKERLY, D. D., CONDIT, R., IBARRA-MANRIQUEZ, G., HARMS, K. E., LICONA, J. C., MARTÍNEZ-RAMOS, M., MAZER, S. J., MULLER-LANDAU, H. C., PEÑA-CLAROS, M., WEBB, C. O. & WRIGHT, I. J. 2008. Are functional traits good predictors of demographic rates? Evidence from five neotropical forests. Ecology 89:19081920.
ROGERS, W. E. & SIEMANN, E. 2002. Effects of simulated herbivory and resource availability on native and invasive exotic tree seedlings. Basic and Applied Ecology 3:297307.
SALGADO-LUARTE, C. & GIANOLI, E. 2010. Herbivory on temperate rainforest seedlings in sun and shade: resistance, tolerance and habitat distribution. PloS ONE 5:e11460.
SANER, P. G. 2009. Ecosystem carbon dynamics in logged forest of Malaysian Borneo. Ph.D. dissertation, Universität Zürich. 217 pp.
SANER, P., PHILIPSON, C. D., ONG, R. C., MAJALAP, N., EGLI, S. & HECTOR, A. 2010. Positive effects of ectomycorrhizal colonization on growth of seedlings of a tropical tree across a range of forest floor light conditions. Plant and Soil 338:411421.
SANER, P., LOH, Y. Y., ONG, R. C. & HECTOR, A. 2012. Carbon stocks and fluxes in tropical lowland dipterocarp rainforests in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo. PloS ONE 7:e29642.
SHIPLEY, B., LECHOWICZ, M. J., WRIGHT, I. J. & REICH, P. B. 2006. Fundamental trade-offs generating the worldwide leaf economics spectrum. Ecology 87:535541.
STRAUSS, S. Y. & AGRAWAL, A. A. 1999. The ecology and evolution of plant tolerance to herbivory. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 14:179185.
TURNBULL, L., PHILIPSON, C., PURVES, D., ATKINSON, R., CUNNIFF, J., GOODENOUGH, A., HAUTIER, Y., HOUGHTON, J., MARTHEWS, T. R., OSBORNE, C. P., PAUL-VICTOR, C., ROSE, K. E., SANER, P., TAYLOR, S. H., WOODWARD, F. I., HECTOR, A. & REES, M. (in press). Plant growth rates and seed size: a re-evaluation. Ecology.
VALLADARES, F. & NIINEMETS, Ü. 2008. Shade tolerance, a key plant feature of complex nature and consequences. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 39:237257.
WARTON, D. I., DUURSMA, R. A., FALSTER, D. S. & TASKINEN, S. in press. smatr 3- an R package for estimation and inference about allometric lines. Methods in Ecology and Evolution.
ZANGERL, A. R., HAMILTON, J. G., MILLER, T. J., CROFTS, A. R., OXBOROUGH, K., BERENBAUM, M. R. & DE LUCIA, E. H. 2002. Impact of folivory on photosynthesis is greater than the sum of its holes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99:10881091.
ZUIDEMA, P. A., BRIENEN, R. J. W., DURING, H. J. & GÜNERALP, B. 2009. Do persistently fast-growing juveniles contribute disproportionately to population growth? A new analysis tool for matrix models and its application to rainforest trees. American Naturalist 174:709719.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Tropical Ecology
  • ISSN: 0266-4674
  • EISSN: 1469-7831
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-tropical-ecology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed