Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T05:55:35.869Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Botched Executions and the Struggle to End Capital Punishment: A Twentieth-Century Story

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Austin Sarat ,
Katherine Blumstein ,
Aubrey Jones ,
Heather Richard ,
Madeline Sprung-Keyser  and
Robert Weaver
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why have accounts of botched executions not played a larger role in the struggle to end capital punishment in the United States? In the twentieth century, when methods of execution became increasingly controlled and sterilized, botched executions would seem to have had real abolitionist potential. This article examines newspaper coverage of botched executions to determine and describe the way they were presented to the public and why they have contributed little to the abolitionist cause. Although botched executions reveal pain, violence, and inhumanity associated with state killing, newspaper coverage of these events neutralizes the impact of that revelation. Throughout the last century, newspapers presented botched executions as misfortunes rather than injustices. We identify three distinct modes by which newspaper coverage neutralized the impact of botched executions and presented them as misfortunes rather than as systemic injustices: (1) the dual narratives of sensationalism and recuperation in the early years of the twentieth century, (2) the decline of sensationalism and the rise of “professionalism” in the middle of the century, and (3) the emphasis on “balanced” reporting toward the end of the century.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 38 , Issue 3 , Summer 2013 , pp. 694 - 720
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Alexandria Gazette. 1906. Strung Up a Second Time. Alexandria Gazette, December 24, 1.Google Scholar
Atlanta Constitution. 1900. Murderer Snell Dies on Gallows. Atlanta Constitution, June 30, 3.Google Scholar
Atlanta Constitution. 1903. Buckled in Death Chair Negro Defied Lightning. December 30, 1.Google Scholar
Atlanta Journal and Constitution. 1986. Texas Executes Drug User Killer by Lethal Injection. Atlanta Journal and Constitution, August 21, A8.Google Scholar
Banner, Stuart. 2003. The Death Penalty: An American History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Begos, Kevin. 2006. Execution Puts Crist to Test. Tampa Tribune, December 15, 1.Google Scholar
Blecker, Robert. 2008. Killing Them Softly: Meditations on a Painful Punishment of Death. Fordham Urban Law Journal 35:976–977.Google Scholar
Boston Daily Globe. 1900. Paid “The Wages of Sin.” Boston Daily Globe, June 30, 7.Google Scholar
Boston Evening Transcript. 1906. Bungle at Houston, Mo., Hanging. Boston Evening Transcript, December 22.Google Scholar
Bounds, Mary. 1985. 10 on Texas' Death Row Want Sentences Carried Out. Dallas Morning News, March 14, 44a.Google Scholar
Chicago Daily Tribune. 1923. Taken from His Coffin, Killer Is Executed Again. Chicago Tribune, February 3, 2.Google Scholar
Chicago Daily Tribune. 1956. Dies Screaming in Gas Chamber, Chicago Daily Tribune, April 7, 1.Google Scholar
Chicago Tribune. 1922. Iowa Preacher, a Sheriff, Pulls Trap at Hanging. Chicago Tribune, September 16, 8.Google Scholar
Daily Tribune. 1906. Hamilton Hangs Twice. Daily Tribune, December 24, 7.Google Scholar
Daly, Christopher. 2012. Covering America: A Narrative History of a Nation's Journalism. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press.Google Scholar
Day, The. 1935. Five Charges Used to Kill “Tough Guy.” March 21, 1.Google Scholar
Driehaus, Bob. 2009. Ohio Plans to Try Again as Execution Goes Wrong. New York Times, September 17, A16.Google Scholar
Emery, Edwin, and Emery, Michael. 1984. The Press and America: An Interpretive History of the Mass Media, 5th ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice‐Hall.Google Scholar
Fair, Kathy. 1988. Woman Leaves Executed Killer a Message: “Tell My Husband Hello.” Houston Chronicle, December 14, A25.Google Scholar
Fair, Kathy. 1992. White Was Helpful at Execution. Houston Chronicle, April 24, 31.Google Scholar
Freedberg, Sydney. 1999. Bloody Execution Leads to Stay for 2nd Inmate. St. Petersburg Times, July 9, 1A.Google Scholar
Gadsden Times. 1989. Two Attempts at Execution Kill Dunkins. Gadsden Times, July 14, 1.Google Scholar
Garland, David. 2010. Peculiar Institution: America's Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Greer, Chris. 2006. Delivering Death: Capital Punishment, Botched Executions, and the American News Media. In Captured by the Media: Prison Discourse in Popular Culture, ed. Mason, Paul. Portland, OR: Willan Publishing.Google Scholar
Griffin, Michael. 1997. Medina's Fiery Execution Starts Uproar. Orlando Sentinel, March 26, A1.Google Scholar
Haines, Herb. 1992. Flawed Executions, the Anti‐Death Penalty Movement, and the Politics of Capital Punishment. Social Problems 39:126–142.Google Scholar
Johnson, Alan, and Hoholik, Suzanne. 2009. What's Next for Unexecuted Inmate? Plan Still Is Death. Columbus Dispatch, September 17, A1.Google Scholar
Johnson, Richard. 1986–1987. What Is Cultural Studies, Anyway? Social Text 16:38–80.Google Scholar
Lawrence Daily World. 1906. The Rope Broke. Lawrence Daily World, December 22.Google Scholar
Lewiston Saturday Journal. 1906. Newsy Bits. Lewiston Saturday Journal, December 22.Google Scholar
Linders, Anulla. 2002. The Execution Spectacle and State Legitimacy: The Changing Nature of the American Execution Audience, 1833–1937. Law and Society Review 36 (3): 630–684.Google Scholar
Liptak, Adam. 2006. Trouble Finding Inmate's Vein Slows Lethal Injection in Ohio. New York Times, May 3, A16.Google Scholar
Los Angeles Herald. 1906. Hang Boy Twice Before He Dies. Los Angeles Herald, December 22, 1.Google Scholar
Los Angeles Times. 1900. Execution of a Giant. Los Angeles Times, June 30, 17.Google Scholar
Meriden Daily Journal. 1948. Boy, 18, Goes to Death for Murder Crying “God Have Mercy, I'm Sorry,” Meriden Daily Journal, August 21, 1.Google Scholar
Miami Herald. 1984. 19‐Minute Execution: First Surge Not Fatal. Miami Herald, December 13, 1A.Google Scholar
Mindich, David T. Z. 1998. Just the Facts: How “Objectivity” Came to Define American Journalism. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Moran, Robert. 2007. The Presence of Malice. New York Times, August 2, http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/02/opinion/02moran.html.Google Scholar
Nevada Daily Mail. 1906. Joda Hamilton Will Hang Today. Nevada Daily Mail, December 21.Google Scholar
Newburgh‐Beacon News. 1960. Sex Slayer Executed. Newburgh‐Beacon News, May 13, 1.Google Scholar
New York Times. 1900. Antonio Ferraro Executed. New York Times, February 27, 14.Google Scholar
New York Times. 1923. “Dead” Convict Moves After Death Shock. New York Times, February 3, 2.Google Scholar
New York Times. 1960. Rape Killer Executed. New York Times, May 13, 18.Google Scholar
New York Times. 1985. Texas Executes Drifter Who Killed Three Women. New York Times, March 13, A15.Google Scholar
New York Times. 1987. Death Penalty. New York Times, June 25, A16.Google Scholar
New York Tribune. 1900. Ferraro Makes No Struggle. New York Tribune, February 27.Google Scholar
New York Tribune. 1915. War Hero Dies in Death Chair. New York Tribune, September 4, 12.Google Scholar
Orlando Sentinel. 1985. 2,300 Volts Help Quench Lust for Revenge. Orlando Sentinel, October 20, H3.Google Scholar
Philadelphia Inquirer. 1983. Lawyer: Killer “Burned Alive.” Philadelphia Inquirer, April 24, A1.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Press. 1939. Novice Drags Out Deaths of Killers to 42 Minutes. Pittsburgh Press, August 2, 4.Google Scholar
Radalet, Michael. 2010. Examples of Post‐Furman Botched Executions. October 1. http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/some‐examples‐post‐furman‐botched‐executions.html.Google Scholar
Reading Eagle. 1906. Hanging of Youth a Gruesome Bungle. Reading Eagle, December 22, 8.Google Scholar
Rome News‐Tribune. 1989. Crossed Wires Bungle Killer's Electrocution. Rome‐News Tribune, July 14, 1.Google Scholar
San Francisco Call. 1903. Negro Suffers Death Penalty. San Francisco Call, December 30.Google Scholar
San Francisco Call. 1906. Murderer of Five Hangs Twice. San Francisco Call, December 22, 10.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin. 2001. When the State Kills: Capital Punishment and the American Condition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin, Blumstein, Katherine, Jones, Aubrey, Richard, Heather, Sprung‐Keyser, Madeline, and Weaver, Robert. 2012. Gruesome Spectacles: The Cultural Reception of Botched Executions in America, 1890−1920. British Journal of American Legal Studies 1:1–26.Google Scholar
Schudson, Michael. 1978. Discovering the News: A Social History of American Newspapers. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Shklar, Judith. 1992. The Faces of Injustice. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Spokane Daily Chronicle. 1932. Puts Up Fight Before Dying. Spokane Daily Chronicle, April 29, 1.Google Scholar
Stevens, John. 1991. Sensationalism and the New York Press. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
St. Joseph News‐Press. 1935. Pays Twice in Chair. St. Joseph News‐Press, March 21.Google Scholar
St. Louis Republic. 1900. Benjamin Snell Executed. St. Louis Republic, June 30.Google Scholar
Times, Tacoma. 1903. Frightful Execution. Tacoma Times, December 29, 1.Google Scholar
Margaret, Talev. 1997. Medina Dead When Mask Flamed Up. Tampa Tribune, April 1, 1.Google Scholar
Telegraph‐Herald. 1922. Weeks Asserts His Innocence Before Hanging. Telegraph‐Herald, September 15, 1.Google Scholar
Times‐Union [Warsaw, IN]. 1985. Use of Electric Chair Under Fire. Times‐Union, October 17, 24.Google Scholar
UPI News Service. 2009. Executioners Can't Find Vein for Injection. UPI News Service, September 15.Google Scholar
Victoria Advocate. 1939. Two Murderers Die in Massachusetts. Victoria Advocate, August 2, 2.Google Scholar
Washington Post. 1900. Snell Put to Death. Washington Post, June 30, 2.Google Scholar
Washington Post. 1903. Six Contacts Used to Kill. Washington Post, December 30, 3.Google Scholar
Washington Post. 1922. Minister‐Sheriff Acts as Hangman. Washington Post, September 16, 4.Google Scholar
Washington Post. 1960. 5 Murderers Are Executed. Washington Post, May 14, A3.Google Scholar
Washington Post. 1983. Attorney Charges Evans Was Tortured by Alabama in Botched Electrocution. Washington Post, April 24, A5.Google Scholar
Washington Times. 1900 . Benjamin Snell Hanged. Washington Times, June 30, 4.Google Scholar
Washington Times. 1903. Six Shocks Necessary to Electrocute Negro. Washington Times, December 29, 1.Google Scholar
Williams, Carol. 2009. Botched Execution in Ohio Raises Concerns About Lethal Injection. Los Angeles Times, September 18.Google Scholar
Word, Ron. 2006. Doctors, Death Penalty Foes Focus on Mistakes in Florida Execution. Press‐Register [Mobile, AL], December 17, A1.Google Scholar
Yellowstone News. 1906. Miscellaneous. Yellowstone News, December 22.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Broom v. Ohio, 130 S. Ct. 46 (2009).Google Scholar
State v. Mata, 275 Neb. 1, 44 (2008).Google Scholar