Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-m8qmq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T07:25:08.841Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Exclusion from Within: Noncitizens and the Rise of Discriminatory Licensing Laws

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2023

Allison Brownell Tirres*
Affiliation:
Associate Professor, DePaul University College of Law, Chicago, IL; Visiting Associate Professor, Santa Clara University School of Law, Santa Clara, CA, United States Email: atirres@depaul.edu

Abstract

In the United States in the early twentieth century, state and local laws discriminating on the basis of alienage proliferated. Progressive reformers, nativist groups, state legislatures, and city councils sought new methods for restricting noncitizen access to the workplace and the marketplace. As this article demonstrates, the primary vehicle they utilized was state and local licensing laws. Licensing proved to be a powerful tool of exclusion; by 1930, citizenship-based licensing restrictions were present in every state and most major cities. Noncitizens challenged some of these laws, pushing for greater protection of their constitutional rights. The resulting court contests over exclusionary licensing laws led to the creation of a new branch of legal doctrine, one that redefined the relationship between noncitizens and state power. This article highlights the significant and underappreciated role played by state and local laws in shaping the immigrant experience in the Progressive Era. It furthers our understanding of the licensing power and illuminates a pivotal moment in the development of immigrant rights. Today, noncitizens are still excluded from a range of economic activities due to licensing restrictions. This article explores the roots and the spread of this little understood – and still consequential – technique of exclusion.

Type
Articles
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Bar Foundation

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Adams, Luther. 2019. “Tipling toward Freedom: Alcohol and Emancipation.” Register of the Kentucky Historical Society 117: 323–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alexander, Norman. 1931. Rights of Aliens under the Federal Constitution. Montpelier, VT: Capital City Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baltimore News . 1914. “Bench and Bar Pay Tribute to Bryan.” April 4.Google Scholar
Bernstein, David E. 1994. “Licensing Laws: A Historical Example of the Use of Government Regulatory Power against African Americans.” San Diego Law Review 31: 89104.Google Scholar
Blair, Peter Q., and Chung, Bobby W.. 2019. “How Much of Barrier to Entry Is Occupational Licensing?British Journal of Industrial Relations 57, no. 4: 919–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Board of Temperance, Prohibition and Public Morals of the Methodist Episcopal Church. 1917. The Cyclopedia of Temperance, Prohibition and Public Morals. New York: Methodist Book Concern.Google Scholar
Buff, Rachel Ida. 2008. “Introduction: Toward a Redefinition of Immigrant Rights.” In Immigrant Rights in the Shadows of Citizenship, edited by Rachel Ida Buff, 122. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Calvo, Janet M. 2017. “Professional Licensing and Teacher Certification for Non-Citizens: Federalism, Equal Protection and a State’s Socio-Economic Interests.” Columbia Journal of Race and Law 8: 33121.Google Scholar
Calvo-Friedman, Janessa. 2014. “Note: The Uncertain Terrain of State Occupational Licensing Laws for Noncitizens: A Preemption Analysis.” Georgetown Law Journal 102: 15971645.Google Scholar
Cassie, Ron. 2016. “How Baltimore Became the New York of the South: European Immigration between 1867–1914 and the Development of Ethnic Neighborhoods around the Port of Baltimore.” Master’s thesis, Georgetown University.Google Scholar
Cassie, Ron. N.d. “City of Immigrants.” Baltimore Magazine. Accessed September 14, 2023. https://www.baltimoremagazine.com/section/historypolitics/city-of-immigrants-the-people-who-built-baltimore/.Google Scholar
Chin, Gabriel J., and Ormonde, John. 2018. “The War against Chinese Restaurants.” Duke Law Journal 67: 681741.Google Scholar
Colbern, Allan, and Karthick Ramakrishnan, S.. 2021. Citizenship Reimagined: A New Framework for States Rights in the United States. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
D’Andrea, Michael R. 2013. “Marcel Alphonse Viti, First President.” Swedish Colonial News 5, no. 2: 1013.Google Scholar
Fellman, David. 1938. “The Alien’s Right to Work.” Minnesota Law Review 22, no. 2: 137–76.Google Scholar
Fette, Julie. 2012. Exclusions: Practicing Prejudice in French Law and Medicine, 1920–1945. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Fields, Harold. 1933. “Where Shall the Alien Work?Social Forces 12: 213–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freund, Ernst. 1904. The Police Power, Public Policy and Constitutional Rights. Chicago: Callaghan & Company.Google Scholar
Friedman, Lawrence M. 1965. “Freedom of Contract and Occupational Licensing 1890–1910: A Legal and Social Study.” California Law Review 53: 487534.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Friedman, Milton, and Kuznets, Simon. 1945. Income from Independent Professional Practice. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
Friends’ Intelligencer and Journal . 1889. “The ‘Brooks Law’ in Pennsylvania.” January 5.Google Scholar
General Alumni Catalogue of the University of Pennsylvania. 1917. New York: R.L. Polk & Company.Google Scholar
Gross, Stanley J. 1984. Of Foxes and Hen Houses: Licensing and the Health Professions. Westport, CT: Quorum Books.Google Scholar
Gulasekaram, Pratheepan. 2012. “Guns and Membership in the American Polity.” William and Mary Bill of Rights Journal 21: 620–22.Google Scholar
Gulasekaram, Pratheepan, and Karthick Ramakrishnan, S.. 2015. The New Immigration Federalism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hatch, Nathan O. 1988. The Professions in American History. Notre Dame, IL: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Higham, John. 2002. Strangers in the Land: Patterns of American Nativism, 1860–1925. Rev. ed. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Hornaday, William T. 1913. Our Vanishing Wildlife: Its Extermination and Preservation. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.Google Scholar
House of Representatives. 1905. Report to the President of the Naturalization Commission to the President. 59th Cong., 1st Sess. November 8.Google Scholar
Immigrants in America Review. 1915. “Internal Restriction.” 1, no. 1: 5.Google Scholar
Kanstroom, Daniel. 2007. Deportation Nation: Outsiders in American History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaylor, Earl. 1963. “The Prohibition Movement in Pennsylvania, 1865–1920.” PhD diss., Pennsylvania State University.Google Scholar
Kearney, Joseph D., and Merrill, Thomas W. 2004. “The Origins of the American Public Trust Doctrine: What Really Happened in Illinois Central.” University of Chicago Law Review 71, no. 3: 799931.Google Scholar
Kens, Paul. 1991. “The Source of a Myth: Police Powers of the States and Laissez Faire Constitutionalism, 1900–1937.” American Journal of Legal History 35, no. 1: 7098.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Law, Marc T., and Kim, Sukkoo. 2005. “Specialization and Regulation: The Rise of Professionals and the Emergence of Occupational Licensing Regulation.” Journal of Economic History 65, no. 3: 723–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Law, Marc T., and Marks, Mindy S. 2009. “Effects of Occupational Licensing Laws on Minorities: Evidence from the Progressive Era.” Journal of Law and Economics 52, no. 2: 351–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lawyer, George A., and Earnshaw, Frank L.. 1920. “Game Laws for 1920: A Summary of the Provisions of Federal, State, and Provincial Statutes.” Farmers Bulletin 1138: 352.Google Scholar
Lay, Shawn. 1995. Hooded Knights on the Niagara: The Ku Klux Klan in Buffalo, New York. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Lay, Shawn, ed. 2004. The Invisible Empire in the West: Toward a New Historical Appraisal of the Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Lee, Erika. 2019. America for Americans: A History of Xenophobia in the United States. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Levin, Harvey. 1964. “Economic and Regulatory Aspects of Liquor Licensing.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 112: 785833.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
López, Ian Haney. 1996. White by Law: The Legal Construction of Race. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
McClain, Charles J. 1994. In Search of Equality: The Chinese Struggle against Discrimination in Nineteenth-Century America. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
McGirr, Lisa. 2016. The War on Alcohol: Prohibition and the Rise of the American State. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
Meader, J. H. 1891. The Cyclopaedia of Temperance and Prohibition. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.Google Scholar
Mills, Quincy T. 2013. Cutting along the Color Line: Black Barbers and Barber Shops in America. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
New Castle News. 1909. “Five Paid Fines; Three Are Jailed.” October 27.Google Scholar
Ngai, Mae. 2004. Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Noon, Mark A. 2005. Yuengling: A History of America’s Oldest Brewery. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company.Google Scholar
Novak, William J. 1996. The People’s Welfare: Law & Regulation in Nineteenth-Century America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Novak, William J. 2022. New Democracy: The Creation of the Modern American State. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Oldys, Henry, Brewster, C. E., and Earnshaw, Frank. 1910. “Game Laws of 1910.Farmers Bulletin 418: 347.Google Scholar
Olivas, Michael A. 2017. “Within You without You: Undocumented Lawyers, DACA, and Occupational Licensing.” Valparaiso University Law Review 52: 65164.Google Scholar
Painter, Nell Irvin. 2008. Standing at Armageddon: A Grassroots History of the Progressive Era. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
Parker, Kunal. 2015. Making Foreigners: Immigration and Citizenship Law in America, 1600–2000. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pascoe, Peggy. 2009. What Comes Naturally: Miscegenation Law and the Making of Race in America. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Plasencia, Luis F. B., Freeman, Gary P, and Setzler, Mark. 2003. “The Decline of Barriers to Immigrant Economic and Political Rights in the American States: 1977–2001.” International Migration Review 37, no. 1: 523.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Preston, William Jr.. 1963. Aliens and Dissenters: Federal Suppression of Radicals, 1903–1933. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Price, Polly. 1999. “Alien Land Restrictions in the American Common Law: Exploring the Relative Autonomy Paradigm.” American Journal of Legal History 43: 152208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Redbird, Beth. 2017. “The New Closed Shop? The Economic and Structural Effects of Occupational Licensure.” American Sociological Review 832, no. 3: 600–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salyer, Lucy. 2000. Laws Harsh as Tigers: Chinese Immigrants and the Shaping of Modern Immigration Law. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Seipp, Gerald. 2012. “Second Circuit Affirms Invalidation of New York Statute Limiting Pharmacist Licenses to U.S. Citizens and LPRs.” Interpreter Releases 89, no. 28: 1389–91.Google Scholar
Shanahan, Brendan A. 2021. “A ‘Practically American’ Canadian Woman Confronts a United States Citizen-Only Hiring Law: Katharine Short and the California Alien Teachers Controversy of 1915.” Law and History Review 39: 621–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Rogers M. 1997. Civic Ideals: Conflicting Visions of Citizenship in U.S. History. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Schibsby, Marian. 1927. Handbook for Immigrants to the United States. New York: Foreign Language Information Service.Google Scholar
Schibsby, Marian. 1940. “Aliens and the Right to Work with Special Reference to the Professions and Licensed Occupations.” Interpreter Releases 17, no. 47: 359–88.Google Scholar
Szymanski, Ann-Marie E. 2003. Pathways to Prohibition: Radicals, Moderates, and Social Movement Outcomes. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Taylor, Dorceta E. 2016. The Rise of the American Conservation Movement: Power, Privilege and Environmental Protection. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Tiedeman, Christopher G. 1900. A Treatise on State and Federal Control of Persons and Property in the United States: Considered from Both a Civil and Criminal Standpoint. Vol. 1. St. Louis: F. H. Thomas Law Book Company.Google Scholar
Tirres, Allison Brownell. 2012. “Property Outliers: Non-Citizens, Property Rights and State Power.” Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 27: 77133.Google Scholar
Tirres, Allison Brownell. 2013. “Ownership without Citizenship: The Creation of Noncitizen Property Rights.” Michigan Journal of Race and Law 19: 159.Google Scholar
Tirres, Allison Brownell. Forthcoming. “The Unfinished Revolution for Immigrant Civil Rights.” University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law 25, no. 4.Google Scholar
Tirres, Allison Brownell. N.d. “From Alienage to Legality: Immigration Status and State Power” (in author’s possession).Google Scholar
Tomlins, Christopher. 2008. “The Supreme Sovereignty of the States: A Genealogy of Police in American Constitutional Law, from the Founding Era to Lochner.” In Police and the Liberal State, edited by Marcus, D. Dubber and Valverde, Mariana, 3353. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Toy, Eckard V. Jr. 1962. “The Ku Klux Klan in Tillamook, Oregon.” Pacific Northwest Quarterly 53, no. 2: 6064.Google Scholar
Unrau, William E. 1996. White Man’s Wicked Water: The Alcohol Trade and Prohibition in Indian Country, 1802–1892. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.Google Scholar
Urofsky, Melvin I. 1985. “State Courts and Protective Legislation during the Progressive Era: A Reevaluation.” Journal of American History 72, no. 1: 6391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
The Voice. 1890. “The Race Problem.” October 28.Google Scholar
Warren, Louis S. 1997. The Hunter’s Game: Poachers and Conservationists in Twentieth-Century America. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Weil, Patrick. 2013. The Sovereign Citizen: Denaturalization and the Origins of the American Republic. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welke, Barbara Young. 2010. Law and the Borders of Belonging in the Long Nineteenth Century United States. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, G. Edward. 1993. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes: Law and the Inner Self. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wines, Frederick Howard. 1897. The Liquor Problem in Its Legislative Aspects. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin.Google Scholar
Witz, Anne. 1990. “Patriarchy and Professions: The Gendered Politics of Occupational Closure.” Sociology 24, no. 4: 675–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar