Skip to main content Accessibility help


  • Ana María Herrera (a1), Latika Gupta Lagalo (a1) and Tatsuma Wada (a1)

This paper tests the three leading specifications of asymmetric and possibly nonlinear feedback from the real price of oil to U.S. industrial production and its sectoral components. We show that the evidence for such feedback is sensitive to the estimation period. Support for a nonlinear model is strongest for samples starting before 1973. Instead, using post-1973 data only, the evidence against symmetry becomes considerably weaker. For example, at the aggregate level, there is no evidence against the hypothesis of symmetric responses to oil price innovations of typical magnitude, consistent with results of Kilian and Vigfusson [Quantitative Economics, 2(3), 419–453 (2011)] for U.S. real GDP. There is strong evidence of asymmetries at the disaggregate level, however, especially for industries that are energy-intensive in production (such as chemicals) or that produce goods that are energy-intensive in use (such as transportation equipment). Our analysis suggests that these asymmetries may be obscured in the aggregate data and highlights the importance of developing multisector models of the transmission of oil price shocks.

Corresponding author
Address correspondence to: Ana María Herrera, Department of Economics, Wayne State University, 2095 Faculty Administration Building, 656 W. Kirby, Detroit, MI 48202, USA; e-mail:
Hide All
Balke, Nathan S., Brown, Stephen P.A., and Yücel, Mine K. (2002) Oil price shocks and the U.S. economy: Where does the asymmetry originate? Energy Journal 23 (3), 2752.
Bernanke, Ben S., Gertler, Mark, and Watson, Mark (1997) Systematic monetary policy and the effects of oil price shocks. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1, 91142.
Bresnahan, Timothy F. and Ramey, Valerie A. (1993) Segment shifts and capacity utilization in the U.S. automobile industry. American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 83 (2), 213218.
Davis, Steven J. (1987a) Allocative disturbances and specific capital in real business cycle theories. American Economic Review 77 (2), 326332.
Davis, Steven J. (1987b) Fluctuations in the pace of labor reallocation. Carnegie–Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 27 (1), 335402.
Davis, Steven J. and Haltiwanger, John (2001) Sectoral job creation and destruction responses to oil price changes. Journal of Monetary Economics 48, 465512.
Dvir, Eyal and Rogoff, Kenneth S. (2010) Three Epochs of Oil. Mimeo, Department of Economics, Harvard University.
Edelstein, Paul and Kilian, Lutz (2007) The response of business fixed investment to changes in energy prices: A test of some hypotheses about the transmission of energy price shocks. B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics 7 (1), (Article 35). Available at
Foerster, Andrew T., Sarte, Pierre-Daniel G., and Watson, Mark W. (2008) Sectoral vs. Aggregate Shocks: A Structural Factor Analysis of Industrial Production. Mimeo, Princeton University. Available at
Gallant, A. Ronald, Rossi, Peter E., and Tauchen, George (1993) Nonlinear dynamic structures. Econometrica 61, 871907.
Hamilton, James D. (1988) A neoclassical model of unemployment and the business cycle. Journal of Political Economy 96 (3), 593617.
Hamilton, James D. (1996) This is what happened to the oil price–macroeconomy relationship. Journal of Monetary Economics 38 (2), 215220.
Hamilton, James D. (2003) What is an oil shock? Journal of Econometrics 113 (2), 363398.
Hamilton, James D. (2010) Nonlinearities and the Macroeconomic Effects of Oil Prices. Mimeo, University of California, San Diego. Available at
Hamilton, James D. and Herrera, Ana María (2004) Oil shocks and aggregate economic behavior: The role of monetary policy. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36 (2), 265286.
Hooker, Mark A. (1996) What happened to the oil price–macroeconomy relationship? Journal of Monetary Economics, 38 (2), 195213.
Huntington, Hillard G. (1998) Crude oil price and U.S. economic performance: Where does the asymmetry reside? Energy Journal 19 (4), 107132.
Inoue, Atsushi and Kilian, Lutz (2004) In-sample or out-of-sample tests of predictability: Which one should we use? Econometric Reviews 23 (4), 371402.
Kilian, Lutz and Vega, Clara (2011) Do energy prices respond to U.S. macroeconomic news? Review of Economics and Statistics 93 (2), 660671.
Kilian, L. and Vigfusson, R.J. (2011) Are the responses of the U.S. economy asymmetric in energy price increases and decreases? Quantitative Economics 2 (3), 419453.
Kilian, Lutz and Vigfusson, Robert J. (this is issue, in press) Nonlinearities in the oil–output relationship. Macroeconomic Dynamics.
Koop, Gary, Pesaran, M. Hashem, and Potter, Simon (1996) Impulse response analysis in nonlinear multivariate models. Journal of Econometrics 74 (1), 119147.
Lee, Kiseok and Ni, Shawn (2002) On the dynamic effects of oil price shocks: A study using industry level data. Journal of Monetary Economics, 49 (4), 823852.
Lee, Kiseok, Ni, Shawn, and Ratti, Ronald A. (1995) Oil shocks and the macroeconomy: The role of price variability. Energy Journal 16 (4), 3956.
Loungani, Prakash (1986) Oil price shocks and the dispersion hypothesis. Review of Economics and Statistics 68 (3), 536539.
Mork, Knut A. (1989) Oil and the macroeconomy when prices go up and down: An extension of Hamilton's results. Journal of Political Economy 97 (3), 740744.
Shea, John (2002) Complementarities and comovements. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 34 (2), 412433.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Macroeconomic Dynamics
  • ISSN: 1365-1005
  • EISSN: 1469-8056
  • URL: /core/journals/macroeconomic-dynamics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed