Skip to main content Accessibility help

Ethno-racial identity (politics) by law: “Fraud” and “choice”

  • Andras L. Pap (a1) (a2) (a3) (a4)


Following an introduction to the changes in how ethno-racial identity is conceptualized in the social sciences and humanities by the destabilization of categorical frameworks, the author looks at how law reacts to these discussions and paradigm shifts, and argues that legal and administrative approaches face severe linguistic and conceptual limitations by operating within a “choice” and “fraud” binary. The article then questions if the free choice of identity exists as a principle of international minority protection law, a legal field that arguably represents a global political and ethical consensus. The author makes two claims. First, according to the basic tenet of legal logic, a proper right to free choice of identity allowing people to opt out of racial, ethnic, or national (minority) communities would necessitate the freedom to opt in to the majority or to any chosen group. The second claim, however, is that international law would not actually construct an approach to opting in. Thus, the right to free choice of identity is not an autonomous, sui generis right under international law.


Corresponding author

* Email:


Hide All
Aceves, William J. 2015. “Two Stories about Skin Color and International Human Rights Advocacy.” Washington University Global Studies Law Review 14 (4): 563584.
Ambrus, Monika. 2012. “Genocide and Discrimination: Lessons to Be Learnt from Discrimination Law.” Leiden Journal of International Law 25: 935954.
Barth, Frederik. 1969. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: The Social Organization of Culture Difference. Bergen: Scandinavian University Press.
Bieber, Florian. 2015. “The Construction of National Identity and its Challenges in Post-Yugoslav Censuses.” Social Science Quarterly 96 (3): 873903.
Bowker, Geoffrey C., and Star, Susan L. 1999. Sorting Things Out: Classification and its Consequences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Brubaker, Rogers. 2004. Ethnicity Without Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Brubaker, Rogers. 2016a. “The Dolezal Affair: Race, Gender, and the Micropolitics of Identity.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 39 (3): 414448.
Brubaker, Rogers. 2016b. Trans: Gender, Race, and the Micropolitics of Identity. Princeton University Press.
Brubaker, Rogers, and Cooper, Frederick. 2000. “Beyond ‘Identity'.” Theory and Society 29 (1): 147.
Brubaker, Rogers, Loveman, Mara, and Stamatov, Peter. 2004. “Ethnicity as Cognition.” Theory and Society 33 (1): 3164.
Carstocea, Andreea. 2011. “Ethno-Business – the Manipulation of Minority Rights in Romania and Hungary.” In Perpetual Motion? Transformation and Transition in Central and Eastern Europe & Russia, edited by Bhambry, Tul'si, Griffin, Clare, Hjelm, Titus, Nicholson, Christopher, and Voronina, Olga G., 1628. London: UCL, School of Slavonic and East European Studies.
Chanbonpin, Kim D. 2015. “Between Black and White: The Coloring of Asian Americans: Passing in Colorism.” Washington University Global Studies Law Review 14 (4): 637663.
Clarke, Jessica. 2015. “Against Immutability.” Yale Law Journal 125 (1): 2102.
Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe. 1990. Concluding Document on the Human Dimension, Copenhagen, paras 3233.
Council of Europe. 1995a. Explanatory Report to the Council of Europe's Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities 3. Article 3, para 36.
Council of Europe. 1995b. Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities, paras 34–36, Article 3.1, Strasbourg, H(1995)010.
Deets, Stephen. 2002. “Reconsidering East European Minority Policy: Liberal Theory and European Norms.” East European Politics and Society 16(1): 3053.
Deets, Stephen, and Stroschein, Sherrill. 2005. “Dilemmas of Autonomy and Liberal Pluralism: Examples Involving Hungarians in Central Europe.” Nations and Nationalism 11 (2): 285305.
Domínguez, Virginia R. 1986. White by Definition: Social Classification in Creole Louisiana. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
European Court of Human Rights. 2010. Ciubotaru v. Moldova, App. No. 27138/04.
Ford, Christopher A. 1994. “Administering Identity: The Determination of ‘Race’ in Race-Conscious Law.” California Law Review 82 (5): 12311285.
Garance, Franke-Ruta. 2012. “Is Elizabeth Warren Native American or What?” The Atlantic, May 20.
Harris, Cheryl I. 1993. “Whiteness as Property.” Harvard Law Review 106 (8): 17071791.
Harris, David R., and Joseph Sim, Jeremiah. 2002. “Who Is Multiracial? Assessing the Complexity of Lived Race.” American Sociological Review 67 (4): 614627.
Heyes, Cressida. 2003. “Feminist Solidarity after Queer Theory: The Case of Transgender.” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 28 (4): 10931120.
Heyes, Cressida. 2006. “Changing Race, Changing Sex: The Ethics of Self-Transformation.” Journal of Social Philosophy 37 (2): 266282.
Heyes, Cressida. 2016. “Identity Politics.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Zalta., Edward N.
Hobbs, Allyson Vanessa. 2014. A Chosen Exile: A History of Racial Passing in American Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hoffmann, Tamás. 2014. “The Perils of Judicial Construction of Identity – A Critical Analysis of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia's Jurisprudence on Protected Persons.” In Allegiance and Identity in a Globalised world, edited by Fiona Jenkins, Mark Nolan, and Rubenstein, Kim, 497521. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hungarian data protection law on Informational Self-Determination and Freedom of Information, 2011, Act No. CXII.
Hungarian minority rights act – on the Rights of National and Ethnic Minorities, 1993, Act LXXVII.
Hunter, Margaret. 2011. “Buying Racial Capital: Skin-Bleaching and Cosmetic Surgery in a Globalized World.” The Journal of Pan African Studies 4 (4): 142164.
Ignatiev, Noel. 1995. How the Irish Became White. New York: Routledge.
Ignatiev, Noel, and Garvey, John, eds. 1996. Race Traitor. New York: Routledge.
Jeffreys, Sheila, and Gottschalk, Lorene. 2013. Gender Hurts: A Feminist Analysis of the Politics of Transgenderism. New York: Routledge.
Jenkins, Fiona. 2014. “Pledging Allegiance: the Strangers Inside Democracy and Citizenship.” In Allegiance and Identity in a Globalised World, edited by Fiona Jenkins, Mark Nolan, and Rubenstein, Kim, 169191. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kelly, Mary E., and Nagel, Joane. 2002. “Ethnic Re-Identification: Lithuanian Americans and Native Americans.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 28 (2): 275289.
Kennedy, Randall. 2003. Interracial Intimacies: Sex, Marriage, Identity, and Adoption. New York: Pantheon.
Kimmerling, Baruch. 2002. “Nationalism, Identity, and Citizenship. An Epilogue to the Yehoshua-Shammas Debate.” In Challenging Ethnic Citizenship. German and Israeli Perspectives on Immigration, edited by Levy, Daniel, and Weiss, Yfaat, 181195. New York: Berghahn.
Kruks, Sonia. 2001. Retrieving Experience: Subjectivity and Recognition in Feminist Politics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Kymlicka, Will. 1995. Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Laitin, David D. 1998. Identity in Formation: The Russian-Speaking Populations in the near Abroad. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Language Rights of Persons Belonging to National Minorities under the Framework Convention, Thematic Commentary.
Lingaas, Carola. 2016. “Imagined Identities: Defining the Racial Group in the Crime of Genocide.” Genocide Studies and Prevention 10 (1): 79106.
López, Ian F. 1996. White by Law, the Legal Construction of Race. New York: New York University Press.
Loveman, Mara. 2014. National Colors, Racial Classification and the State in Latin America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Minority Rights Ombudsman database. 2010. (“Rövid összegzés a nemzeti és etnikai jogok országgyűlési biztosának a ‘Romák foglalkoztatása a közigazgatásban és az igazságszolgáltatásban’ című program vizsgálatáról” [Short summary of the report on the investigation of the parliamentary commissioner for national and ethnic minority rights on “Roma employment in the public service and justice system”]).
Molnár, Emilia, and Schaft, Kai A. 2003. “Preserving ‘Cultural Autonomy’ or Confronting Social Crisis? The Activities and Aims of Roma Local Minority Self-Governments 2000–2001.” Review of Sociology of the Hungarian Sociological Association 9 (1): 2742.
Onwuachi-Willig, Angela. 2007. “The Admission of Legacy Blacks.” Vanderbilt Law Review 60: 11411231.
Organization on Security and Cooperation in Europe. 2012. The Ljubljana Guidelines on Integration of Diverse Societies.
Overall, Christine, and Rowan, John. 2004. “Transsexualism and ‘Transracialism'.” Social Philosophy Today 20: 183193.
Pap, András László. 2015. “Is There a Legal Right to Free Choice of Ethno-Racial Identity? Legal and Political Difficulties in Defining Minority Communities and Membership Boundaries.” Columbia Human Rights Law Review 46 (2): 153232.
Pember, Mary Annette. 2007. “Ethnic Fraud?Diverse: Issues in Higher Education 23 (25): 2023.
Ram, Melanie H. 2014. “Europeanized Hypocrisy: Roma Inclusion and Exclusion in Central and Eastern Europe.” Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe 13 (3): 1544.
Rich, Camille Gear. 2014. “Elective Race: Identifying Race Discrimination in the Era of Racial Self Definition.” Georgetown Law Journal 102 (5): 15021572.
Rotunda, Ronald. 1993. Modern Constitutional Law, Cases and Notes. St. Paul: West.
S. and Marper v. the United Kingdom GC nos.30562/04 and 30566/04, § 66, December 4, 2008.
Sharfstein, Daniel J. 2007. “Crossing the Color Line: Racial Migration and the One-Drop Rule, 1600–1860.” Minnesota Law Review 91: 592656.
Simon, Patrick. 2007. “Ethnic” Statistics and Data Protection in the Council of Europe Countries. European Commission Against Racism and Intolerance.
Spiro, Peter J. 2014. “The End of Olympic Nationality.” In Allegiance and Identity in a Globalised World, edited by Fiona Jenkins, Mark Nolan, and Rubenstein, Kim, 478496. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sternberg, Nitzan. 2012. “Do I Need to Pin a Target to My Back? The Definition of ‘Particular Social Group’ in U.S. Asylum Law.” Fordham Urban Law Journal 39 (1): 246297.
Tajfel, Henri. 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taylor, Charles. 1989. Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
UN Human Rights Committee. 1981. Lovelace v. Canada, Communication No. R/6/24/ para 14, U.N. Doc. Supp. No. 40 (A/36/40) at 166.
UN Human Rights Committee. 2007. UN Principles and Recommendations for Population and
Housing Censuses, Rev. 2, 2007 (ST/ESA/STAT/ SER.M/67/Rev.2).
UN Human Rights Committee. 2007. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, 2007.
Valentine, John R. 2004. “Toward a Definition of National Minority.” Denver Journal of International Law and Policy 32 (3): 445473.
Walker, Bela August. 2008. “Fractured Bonds: Policing Whiteness and Womanhood through Race-Based Marriage Annulments.” Depaul Law Review 58: 150.
Weiss, Yfaat. 2002. “The Golem and its Creator, or How the Jewish Nation-State Became Multi-Ethnic.” In Challenging Ethnic Citizenship. German and Israeli Perspectives on Immigration, edited by Levy, Daniel, and Weiss, Yfaat, 82104. New York: Berghahn.
Wright, Luther Jr. 1995. “Who's Black, Who's White, and Who Cares: Reconceptualizing the United States's Definition of Race and Racial Classifications.” Vanderbilt Law Review 48: 513569.
Yang, Tseming. 2006. “Choice and Fraud in Racial Identification: The Dilemma of Policing Race in Affirmative Action, the Census, and a Color-Blind Society.” Michigan Journal of Race and Law 11: 267417.
Young, Rebecca. 2010. “How Do We Know Them When We See Them? The Subjective Evolution in the Identification of Victim Groups for the Purpose of Genocide.” International Criminal Law Review 10 (1): 122.
Zagor, Matthew. 2014. “Recognition and Narrative Identities: Is Refugee Law Redeemable?.” In Allegiance and Identity in a Globalised World, edited by Fiona Jenkins, Mark Nolan, and Rubenstein, Kim, 311353. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed