Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Democracy versus Security as Standards of Political Legitimacy: The Case of National Policy on Irregular Migrant Arrivals

  • Patti Tamara Lenard and Terry Macdonald

Abstract

Democratic citizens confront a range of problems framed as “security” issues, in policy areas such as counterterrorism and migration control, which place substantial political pressure on democratic norms. We develop a normative theoretical framework for assessing whether and how policies that curtail democratic governance standards in the name of security can be justified as politically legitimate. To do so, we articulate a novel normative account of legitimacy, which integrates insights from both democratic and realist traditions of thought to illuminate the complementary contributions of democratic and security standards to political legitimacy. We further elaborate a framework for applying this theoretical account to political practice in the form of a policy-focused “security test” for legitimacy in democratic states. Finally, we explore how this test may be deployed to help resolve policy dilemmas in democratic practice, by examining its application to a case study of national policy on irregular boat arrivals in Australia and Canada. Through this analysis, we contribute to the development of both richer theoretical understandings of the complex modern value of political legitimacy, and clearer action-guiding principles for balancing competing demands of legitimacy within securitized democratic policy regimes.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Democracy versus Security as Standards of Political Legitimacy: The Case of National Policy on Irregular Migrant Arrivals
      Available formats
      ×

      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Democracy versus Security as Standards of Political Legitimacy: The Case of National Policy on Irregular Migrant Arrivals
      Available formats
      ×

      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Democracy versus Security as Standards of Political Legitimacy: The Case of National Policy on Irregular Migrant Arrivals
      Available formats
      ×

Copyright

This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Footnotes

Hide All

They thank the following research assistants for their work on this article: Ikram Handulle, Joshua Knoop, and Emily Look. They also thank the incredibly generous and thoughtful reviewers, who engaged in the best possible way with the arguments they have offered here. The article is much stronger for their work.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Agamben, Giorgio. 2005. State of Exception: Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Aradau, Claudia. 2004. “Security and the Democratic Scene: Desecuritization and EmancipationJournal of International Relations and Development 7: 388413.
Baldwin, David A. 1997. “The Concept of Security.” Review of International Studies 23: 526.
Beitz, Charles R. 1989. Political Equality: An Essay in Democratic Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Benhabib, Seyla. 1994. “Deliberative Rationality and Models of Democratic Legitimacy.” Constellations 1(1): 2652.
Bohman, James. 2000. Public Deliberation: Pluralism, Complexity, and Democracy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Buchanan, Allen. 2013. The Heart of Human Rights. Oxford: University Press.
Buchanan, Allen and Keohane, Robert O.. 2006. “The Legitimacy of Global Governance Institutions. Ethics & International Affairs 20(4): 405–37.
Burke, Anthony. 2008. Fear of Security: Australia’s Invasion Anxiety. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Buzan, Barry, Waever, Ole, and de Wilde, Jaap. 1998. Security: A New Framework for Analysis. London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Canadian Council of Refugees. 2012. “Canada Rolls Back Refugee Protection Bill C-31 Receives Royal Assent.” https://ccrweb.ca/en/bulletin/12/06/29.
Christiano, Thomas. 2008. The Constitution of Equality: Democratic Authority and Its Limits. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cohen, Joshua. 1997. “Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy.” In Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics , ed. Bohman, James, 6792. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia. 2001a. “House of Representatives Parliamentary Debates, Official Hansard.” 18 September: Columns 30869-30871.
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia. 2001b. “House of Representatives Parliamentary Debates, Official Hansard.” 19 September: Column 30954.
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia 2001c. Migration Amendment (Excision from Migration Zone) Bill 2001. Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r1413
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia. 2012a. “Migration Amendment (Unauthorised Maritime Arrivals and Other Measures) Act 2012”. Commonwealth, Memorandum: Column 1. Retrieved August 3, 2015 (http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r4920).
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia. 2012b. “Migration Legislation Amendment (Regional Processing and Other Measures) Bill 2012.” Commonwealth. Retrieved August 3, 2015 (http://www.aph.gov.au/ParliamenD2tary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r4683).
Commonwealth Parliament of Australia. 2015. “Australian Border Force Bill 2015.” Retrieved August 3, 2015 (http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r5408).
Department of Defence. 2015. “Border Protection News: Operation Resolute.” Retrieved August 3, 2015 (http://www.defence.gov.au/operations/borderprotection/).
Department of Home Affairs. 2019. Organisational Chart: Joint Agency Task Force—Operation Sovereign Borders. Retrieved August 29, 2019. https://osb.homeaffairs.gov.au/Files/OSB-organisational-chart.pdf/.
Dewey, John. 1938. The Later Works of John Dewey. Vol. 12, 1925–1953, Logic: The Theory of Inquiry, ed. Boydston, JoAnne. 1991. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University.
Dewey, John. 1946. The Public and Its Problems: An Essay in Political Inquiry. Chicago: Gateway Books.
Dryzek, John S. 2001. “Legitimacy and Economy in Deliberative Democracy.” Political Theory 29(5): 651–69.
Erman, Eva. 2016. “Global Political Legitimacy beyond Justice and Democracy?International Theory 8(1): 2962.
Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers. 2012. “Report of the Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers.” Australian Government. Retrieved August 3, 2015 http://apo.org.au/files/Resource/expert_panel_on_asylum_seekers_full_report_0.pdf.
Farrell, Paul. 2015. “Nauru Asylum Seekers Could Face Jail for Protesting Conditions Under New Law.” The Guardian. Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/may/13/nauru-asylum-seekers-could-face-jail-for-protesting-conditions-under-new-law.
Floyd, Rita. 2011. “Can Securitization Theory be Used in Normative Analysis? Towards a Just Securitization Theory.” Security Dialogue 42(4-5): 427–39.
Floyd, Jonathan. 2016. “Normative Behaviourism and Global Political Principles.” Journal of International Political Theory 12(2): 152–68.
Fox, Peter D. 2010. “International Asylum and Boat People: The Tampa Affair and Australia’s Pacific Solution”. Midwest Journal of International Law 25: 356–73.
Freedman, Lawrence. 1992. “The Concept of Security.” In Encyclopedia of Government and Politics, vol. 2, ed. Hawkesworth, Mary and Kogan, Maurice, 730741. New York: Routledge.
Fung, Archon. 2013. “Infotopia: Unleashing the Democratic Power of Transparency.” Politics & Society 41(2): 183212.
Geuss, Raymond. 2009. “What Is Political Judgement?” In Political Judgment: Essays for John Dunn, ed. Bourke, Richard and Geuss, Raymond. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Givens, Terry, Freeman, Gary P., and Leal, David L.. 2008. Immigration Policy and Security: US, European, and Commonwealth Perspectives. New York: Routledge.
Goodhart, Michael. 1995. Democracy as Human Rights: Freedom and Equality in an Age of Globalization. New York: Routledge.
Government of Canada. 2012. Bill C-31: Protecting Canada’s Immigration System Act.
Held, David. 2006. Models of Democracy. Cambridge: Polity.
Hirst, Paul. 2013. Associative Democracy: New Forms of Economic and Social Governance. John Wiley & Sons.
Howard, Jessica. 2003. “To Deter and Deny: Australia and the Interdiction of Asylum Seekers.” Refuge 21(4): 35–51.
Hurst, Daniel. 2015. “Tony Abbott Refuses to Rule Out Paying People Smugglers to Turn Back Boats.” The Guardian. Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2015/jun/12/tony-abbott-refuses-to-rule-out-paying-people-smugglers-to-turn-back-boats.
Ignatieff, Michael. 2004. The Lesser Evil: Political Ethics in an Age of Terror. Toronto: Penguin Canada.
Jabour, Bridie and Hurst, Daniel. 2014. “Nauru to Increase Visa Cost for Journalists From $200 to $8,000.” The Guardian. Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jan/09/nauru-visa-to-cost-8000.
Knight, Jack and Johnson, James. 1994. “Aggregation and Deliberation: On the Possibility of Democratic Legitimacy.” Political Theory (22)2: 277–96.
Landemore, Hélène. 2012. Democratic Reason: Politics, Collective Intelligence, and the Rule of the Many. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Lazar, Nomi. 2009. States of Emergency in Liberal Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lazarus, Liora. 2015. “The Right to Security.” In The Philosophical Foundation of Human Rights, ed. Cruft, Rowan, Liao, S. Matthew, and Renzo, Massimo, 423441. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lenard, Patti Tamara. 2012. Trust, Democracy and Multicultural Challenges. University Park: Penn State Press.
Liew, Jamie. 2011. “Managing the Fear of the Tsunami: Canada’s Proposed Policy to Detain Boat People and Lessons Learned From the United States’ Detention Policies.” Rutgers Race and Law Review 13: 168.
Library of Parliament (Canada). 2012. “Legislative Summary, Bill C-31, An Act to Amend the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.” http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2012/bdp-lop/ls/41-1-c31-1-eng.pdf.
Loader, Ian and Walker, Neil. 2007. Civilizing Security. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Macdonald, Terry. 2016. “Institutional Facts and Principles of Global Political Legitimacy.” Journal of International Political Theory 12(2): 134–51.
Macdonald, Terry. 2017. “Democratizing Global ‘Bodies Politic’: Collective Agency, Political Legitimacy, and the Democratic Boundary Problem.” Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric 10(2): 2242.
Macdonald, Terry. 2018. “Sovereignty, Democracy, and Global Political Legitimacy.” In The Oxford Handbook of International Political Theory, ed. Brown, Chris and Eckersley, Robyn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Macdonald, Terry. 2019. Global Political Legitimacy: A Normative Theory of Pluralist World Order. Unpublished book manuscript.
Macdonald, Kate and Macdonald, Terry. 2017. “Liquid Authority and Political Legitimacy in Transnational Governance.” International Theory 9(2): 329–51.
Macdonald, Terry and Macdonald, Kate. Forthcoming. “Towards a ‘Pluralist’ World Order: Creative Agency and Legitimacy in Global Institutions.” European Journal of International Relations. DOI: 10.1177/1354066119873134.
Mathew, Penelope. 2002. “Australian Refugee Protection in the Wake of the Tampa.” American Society of International Law, 96(3): 661676.
McDonald, Matt. 2008. “Securitization and the Consruction of Security.” European Journal of International Relations . 14(4): 563587.
Meisels, Tamar. 2008. The Trouble with Terror: Liberty, Security and the Response to Terrorism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Miller, David. 1992. “Deliberative Democracy and Social Choice.” Political Studies 40(1_suppl): 5467.
Miller, David. 1995. On Nationality. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Newey, Glen. 2012. “Liberty, Security Notwithstanding.” In Social Cohesion, Securitization and Counter-terrorism , ed. Husband, Charles and Alam, Yunis. Helsinki: Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies, 121.
Parliament of Canada. 2012a. “House of Commons Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration Minutes of Proceedings , 41st Parliament, 1st session: meeting 31.” Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?DocId=5525470&Language=E&Mode=1.
Parliament of Canada. 2012b. “House of Commons, Edited Hansard.” Retrieved August 3, 2015 http://www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?Pub=Hansard&Doc=90&Parl=41&Ses=1&Language=E&Mode=1#6841714.
Parliament of Canada. 2012c. “House of Commons, Edited Hansard.” Retrieved August 3, 2015 http://www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?Pub=Hansard&Doc=90&Parl=41&Ses=1&Language=E&Mode=1&DocId=5474617&File=0.
Phillips, Janet. 2014. “A Comparison of Coalition and Labor Government Asylum Policies in Australia since 2001.” Parliament of Australia, Department of Parliamentary Services, Research Paper Series. Retrieved August 3, 2015 http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/library/prspub/3024333/upload_binary/3024333.pdf;fileType=application%2Fpdf.
Philp, Mark. 2007. Political Conduct. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Przeworski, Adam and Stokes, Susan C.. 1999. Democracy, Accountability, and Representation. Vol. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rawls, John. 2005. Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
Rossi, Enzo and Sleat, Matt. 2014. “Realism in Normative Political Theory.” Philosophy Compass 9(10): 689701.
Rudolph, Christopher. 2006. National Security and Immigration: Policy Development in the United States and Western Europe since 1945. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Sagar, Rahul. 2007. “On Combatting the Abuse of State Secrecy.” Journal of Political Philosphy 15(4): 404–27.
Sagar, Rahul. 2013. Secrets and Lies: The Dilemma of State Secrecy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Salter, Mark, ed. 2008. Politics at the Airport. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Saward, Michael. 1998. The Terms of Democracy. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Shue, Henry. 1996. Basic Rights: Subsistence, Affluence and U.S. Foreign Policy. 2nd ed. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Silverman, Stephanie. 2014. “In the Wake of Irregular Arrivals: Changes to the Canadian Immigration Detention System.” Refuge 30(2): 2734.
Taylor, Isaac. 2018. The Ethics of Counterterrorism. New York: Routledge.
Tranter, Kellie. 2014. “No Comment on Operations: How Morrison’s media strategy took shape.” The Guardian. Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/10/no-comment-on-operations-how-morrisons-media-strategy-took-shape.
United Nations. 2015. “International Migration 2015.” Department of Economic and Social Affairs (Population Division). Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/migration/publications/wallchart/docs/MigrationWallChart2015.pdf.
Valentini, Laura. 2012. “Assessing the Global Order: Justice, Legitimacy, or Political Justice?Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 15(5): 593612.
Waldron, Jeremy. 2003. “Security and Liberty: The Image of Balance.” Journal of Political Philosophy 11(2): 191210.
Waldron, Jeremy. 2012. “Safety and Security.” In Civil Liberties, National Security and the Prospects for Consensus, ed. Reed, Esther D. and Dumper, Michael. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University press, 1334.
Warren, Mark E. 2001. Democracy and Association. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Watson, Scott. 2007. “Manufacturing Threats: Asylum Seekers as Threats or Refugees.” Journal of International Law and International Relations 3(1): 95117.
Whitaker, Reginald. 1987. Double Standard: The Secret History of Canadian Immigration Policy. Toronto: Lester & Orpen Dennys, Ltd.
Williams, Bernard A. O. 2005. In the Beginning was the Deed: Realism and Moralism in Political Argument Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Williams, Michael C. 2011. “Securitization and the Liberalism of Fear.” Security Dialogue 42: 453–63.
Williams, Michael C. 2015. “Securitization as Political Theory: The Politics of the Extraordinary.” International Relations 29(1): 114–20.
Wolfendale, Jessica. 2017. “Moral Security.” Journal of Political Philosophy (25)2: 238–55.
Wolfers, Arnold. 1952. “‘National Security’” as an Ambiguous Symbol.” Political Science Quarterly (67)4: 481502.
Wright, Tony. 2014. “Manus Island Events ‘Tragic and Distressing’ But Who is Accountable?” The Guardian . Retrieved August 3, 2015. http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-opinion/manus-island-events-tragic-and-distressing-but-who-is-accountable-20140526-38zlc.html#ixzz3i5p6QRLU.
Youssef, Marten. 2010. “More Tamil Vessels May be Headed for Canada.” Globe and Mail, August 5.
Zedner, Lucia. 2005. “Securing Liberty in the Face of Terror: Reflections from Criminal Justice.” Journal of Law and Society 32: 507–33.
Zureik, Elia and Salter, Mark (eds.). 2008. Global Surveillance and Policing: Borders, Security, Identity. UK: Willan Publishing.

Democracy versus Security as Standards of Political Legitimacy: The Case of National Policy on Irregular Migrant Arrivals

  • Patti Tamara Lenard and Terry Macdonald

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed