Skip to main content
×
Home

Racial Priming Revived

  • Tali Mendelberg (a1)
Abstract

This comment addresses the growing controversy over the effects of implicit racial messages in politics. Many scholars find evidence that these implicit messages work and that they have racializing effects. However, the biggest study to date finds that racial messages—implicit or explicit—have no effects. In this paper I conduct a thorough review of several relevant literatures in order to adjudicate between these competing claims. I find that the large study's null findings conflict with 17 public opinion experiments involving over 5,000 subjects, 2 aggregate studies, and a large social psychology literature. Using different methods, samples, and settings, these studies show that racial cues do in fact racialize opinion. I explain the large study's null results by noting that its participants perceived only small differences across messages, that racial predispositions were measured just before exposure to the ad, thereby neutralizing the effect of the ad's racial cue, and that WebTV studies such as this one have failed to provide many subjects with their assigned ad. Thus, the weight of the evidence heavily favors the racial effect of racial cues and messages. I offer several directions for future research on racial communication and politics.Tali Mendelberg is Associate Professor of Politics at Princeton University (talim@princeton.edu). She is the author of The Race Card: Campaign Strategy, Implicit Messages, and the Norm of Equality (Princeton University Press, 2001). She wishes to thank Oleg Bespalov and Dan Cassino for research assistance, Adam Berinsky, Claudine Gay, Martin Gilens, Vince Hutchings, Jon Krosnick, Shawn Rosenberg, and Nick Valentino for helpful feedback, and the Bobst Center for Peace and Justice at Princeton University and the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences for research support.

Copyright
References
Hide All

References

Achen, Christopher H. 1983. Toward theories of data: The state of political methodology. In Political Science: The State of the Discipline, ed. Ada W. Finifter. Washington, DC: American Political Science Association.
Banaji, Mahzarin R., and Anthony G. Greenwald. 1994. Implicit stereotyping and prejudice. In The Psychology of Prejudice: The Ontario Symposium, ed. Mark P. Zanna, James M. Olson, and vol. 7. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Bargh, John A. 1996. Principles of automaticity. In Social Psychology: Handbook of Basic Principles, ed. E. Tory Higgins and Arie W. Kruglanski. New York: Guilford.
Bargh, John A., and Mark Chen. 1997. Nonconscious behavioral confirmation processes: The self-fulfilling consequences of automatic stereotype activation. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 33 (5): 54160.
Bargh, John A., Mark Chen, and Lara Burrows. 1996. Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of trait construct and stereotype priming on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71 (2): 23044.
Bartels, Larry M. 1993. Messages received: The political impact of media exposure. American Political Science Review 87 (2): 26784.
Bartels, Larry M. 2003. Democracy with attitudes. In Electoral Democracy, ed. Michael MacKuen and George Rabinowitz. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Berinsky, Adam J. 1999. The two faces of public opinion. American Journal of Political Science 43 (4): 120930.
Berinsky, Adam J. 2002. Political context and the survey response: The dynamics of racial policy opinion. Journal of Politics 64 (2): 56784.
Berinsky, Adam J. 2004. Silent Voices. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Berinsky, Adam J., and Tali Mendelberg. 2005. The indirect effects of discredited stereotypes in judgments of Jewish leaders. American Journal of Political Science 49 (4): 84564.
Blair, Irene V., Charles M. Judd, and Kristine M. Chapleau. 2004. The influence of Afrocentric facial features in criminal sentencing. Psychological Science 15 (1): 67479.
Bobo, Lawrence D., and Ryan A. Smith. 1998. From Jim Crow racism to laissez-faire racism: The transformation of racial attitudes. In Beyond Pluralism: The Conception of Groups and Group Identities in America, ed. Wendy F. Katkin, Ned C. Landsman, and Andrea Tyree. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Bradburn, Norman. 1982. Question-wording effects in surveys. In Question Framing and Response Consistency, ed. R. Hogarth. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Brooks, Deborah J., and John G. Geer. 2007. Beyond negativity: The effects of incivility on the electorate. American Journal of Political Science 51 (1): 116.
Chandra, Kanchan. 2004. Why Ethnic Parties Succeed: Patronage and Ethnic Headcounts in India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Citrin, Jack, Donald Green, and David O. Sears. 1990. White reactions to black candidates: When does race matter? Public Opinion Quarterly 54 (1): 7496.
Clawson, Rosalee A., and Rakuya Trice. 2000. Poverty as we know it: Media portrayals of the poor. Public Opinion Quarterly 64 (1): 5364.
Clinton, Joshua D., and John S. Lapinski. 2004. “Targeted” advertising and voter turnout: An experimental study of the 2000 presidential election. Journal of Politics 66 (1): 6996.
Cohen, Cathy. 1999. The Boundaries of Blackness. Chicago: University of Chicago.
Correll, Joshua, Bernadette Park, Charles M. Judd, and Bernd Wittenbrink. 2002. The police officer's dilemma: Using ethnicity to disambiguate potentially threatening individuals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83 (6): 131429.
Dawson, Michael, and Ernest Wilson III. 1991. Paradigms and paradoxes: Political science and the study of African American politics. In Political Science: Looking to the Future, ed. William Crotty and vol. 1. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
Devine, Patricia G. 1989. Stereotypes and prejudice: Their automatic and controlled components. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56 (1): 68090.
Devine, Patricia G., and Andrew J. Elliot. 1995. Are racial stereotypes really fading? The Princeton trilogy revisited. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 21 (11): 113950.
Devine, Patricia G., Margo J. Monteith, Julia R. Zuwerink, and Andrew J. Elliot. 1991. Prejudice with and without compunction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 60 (6): 81730.
Dickson, Eric, and Kenneth Scheve. 2006. Social identity, political speech and electoral competition. Journal of Theoretical Politics 18 (1): 539.
Domke, David. 2001. Racial cues and political ideology: an examination of associative priming. Communication Research 28 (6): 772801.
Dovidio, John F., and Samuel Gaertner. 1986. Prejudice, discrimination, and racism. In Prejudice, Discrimination, and Racism, ed. John F. Dovidio and Samuel Gaertner. New York: Academic Press.
Dovidio, John F., Kerry Kawakami, Craig Johnson, Brenda Johnson, and Adaiah Howard. 1997. On the nature of prejudice: Automatic and controlled processes. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 33 (5): 51040.
Dovidio, John F., Nancy Evans, and Richard B. Tyler. 1986. Racial stereotypes: The contents of their cognitive representations. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 22 (1): 2237.
Eberhardt, Jennifer L., Phillip Atiba Goff, Valerie J. Purdie, and Paul G. Davies. 2004. Seeing black: Race, crime, and visual processing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 87 (6): 87693.
Eberhardt, Jennifer L., Paul G. Davies, Valerie J. Purdie-Vaughns, and Sheri Lynn Johnson. 2006. Looking deathworthy: Perceived stereotypicality of black defendants predicts capital-sentencing outcomes. Psychological Science 17 (5): 38386.
Edsall, Thomas B., and Mary D. Edsall. 1991. “When the Official Subject Is Presidential Politics, Taxes, Welfare, Crime, Rights, or Values … the Real Subject Is Race.” Atlantic Monthly (May): 5386.
Entman, Robert M., and Andrew Rojecki. 2000. The Black Image in the White Mind: Media and Race in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Fazio, Russell H., Joni R. Jackson, Bridget C. Dunton, and Carol J. Williams. 1995. Variability in automatic activation as an unobtrusive measure of racial attitudes: A bona fide pipeline? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 (6): 101327.
Federico, Christopher M. 2004. When do welfare attitudes become racialized? The paradoxical effects of education. American Journal of Political Science 48 (2): 37491.
Fiske, Alan P., Shinobu Kitayama, Hazel R. Markus, and Richard E. Nisbett. 1999. The cultural matrix of social psychology. In The Handbook of Social Psychology, ed. Daniel T. Gilbert, Susan T. Fiske, Gardner Lindzey, and vol. 2. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
Fraga, Luis R., and David L. Leal. 2004. Playing the “Latino card”: Race, ethnicity, and national party politics in 2000 and 2004. Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race 1: 297317
Gale, Kristina, Betsey Gimbel Hawkins, Richard Hawkins, David B. Magleby, J. Quin Monson, and Kelly D. Patterson. 2005. Elections: effects of the stand by your ad provision on attitudes about candidates and campaigns. Presidential Studies Quarterly 35 (4): 77183.
Gibson, James L., and Amanda Gouws. 2002 Overcoming Intolerance in South Africa: Experiments in Democratic Persuasion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gilens, Martin. 1999. Why Americans Hate Welfare. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gilliam, Frank D. 1999. The “welfare queen” experiment: How viewers react to images of African-American mothers on welfare. Nieman Reports 53 (2): 11219.
Gilliam, Frank D., and Shanto Iyengar. 2000. Prime suspects: The influence of local television news on the viewing public. American Journal of Political Science 44 (3): 56073.
Gilliam, Frank D., Nicholas A. Valentino, and Matthew N. Beckmann. 2002. Where you live and what you watch: The impact of racial proximity and local television news on attitudes about race and crime. Political Research Quarterly 55 (4): 75580.
Glaser, James M. 2002. White voters, black schools: Structuring racial choices with a checklist ballot. American Journal of Political Science 46 (1): 3546.
Glaser, James M., and Martin Gilens 1997. Interregional migration and political resocialization: A study of racial attitudes under pressure. Public Opinion Quarterly 61 (1): 7286.
Graham, Sandra, and Brian S. Lowery. 2004. Priming unconscious racial stereotypes about adolescent offenders. Law and Human Behavior 28 (5): 483504.
Greenwald, Anthony G., and Linda Krieger. 2006. Implicit bias: Scientific foundations. California Law Review Symposium on Behavioral Realism and Implicit Social Cognition. Berkeley: California Law Review, Inc.
Huber, Gregory A., and John Lapinski. 2006. The “race card” revisited: Assessing racial priming in policy contests. American Journal of Political Science 48 (2): 375401.
Huddy, Leonie. 1994. The political significance of voters' gender stereotypes. Research in Micropolitics 4: 16993.
Hurwitz, Jon, and Mark Peffley. 1997a. Racial stereotypes and whites' political views of blacks in the context of welfare and crime. American Journal of Political Science 41 (1): 3060.
Hurwitz, Jon, and Mark Peffley. 2005. Playing the race card in the post-Willie Horton era. Public Opinion Quarterly 69 (1): 99112.
Hutchings, Vincent L., and Nicholas A. Valentino. 2003. “Wedge Politics: The Structure and Function of Racial Group Cues in Contemporary American Politics.” Presented at the Eagleton School, Rutgers University.
Hutchings, Vincent L., and Nicholas A. Valentino. 2004. The centrality of race in American politics. Annual Review of Political Science 7: 383408.
Hutchings, Vincent L., Hanes Walton, Jr., and Andrea Benjamin. 2005. “Heritage or Hate? Race, Gender, Partisanship and the Georgia State Flag Controversy.” Presented at the 101st Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association. Washington, DC, September 1–4.
Hutchings, Vincent L., Nicholas A. Valentino, Tasha S. Philpot, and Ismail K. White. 2004. The compassion strategy: Race and the gender gap in campaign 2000. Public Opinion Quarterly 68 (4): 51241.
Jamieson, Kathleen H. 1992. Dirty Politics: Deception, Distraction, and Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press.
Johnson, James D., Mike S. Adams, William Hall, and Leslie Ashburn. 1997. Race, media, and violence: Differential racial effects of exposure to violent news stories. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 19 (1): 8190.
Kellstedt, Paul M. 2003. The Mass Media and the Dynamics of American Racial Attitudes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kinder, Donald, and Lynn Sanders. 1996. Divided by Color. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Krueger, Joachim. 1996. Personal beliefs and cultural stereotypes about racial characteristics. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71 (3): 53648.
Kuklinski, James H., Paul M. Sniderman, Kathleen Knight, Thomas Piazza, Phillip E. Tetlock, Gordon R. Lawrence, and Barbara Mellers. 1997. Racial prejudice and attitudes toward affirmative action. American Journal of Political Science 41 (2): 40219.
Kuklinski, James H., Michael D. Cobb, and Martin Gilens. 1997. Racial attitudes and the “New South.” Journal of Politics 59 (2): 32349.
Macrae, C. Neil, Alan B. Milne, and Galen V. Bodenhausen. 1994. Out of mind but back in sight: Stereotypes on the rebound. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 67 (5): 808917.
Mendelberg, Tali. 1997. Executing Hortons: Racial Crime in the 1988 Presidential Campaign. Public Opinion Quarterly 61(1): 13457.
Mendelberg, Tali. 2001. The Race Card: Campaign Strategy, Implicit Messages, and the Norm of Equality. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Nelson, Thomas E., and Donald R. Kinder. 1996. Issue frames and group-centrism in American public opinion. Journal of Politics 58 (4): 105578.
Olson, Michael A., and Russell H. Fazio. 2004. Trait inferences as a function of automatically activated racial attitudes and motivation to control prejudice. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 26 (1): 111.
Payne, B. Keith. 2001. Prejudice and perception: The role of automatic and controlled processes in misperceiving a weapon. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81 (2): 18192.
Payne, B. Keith, Alan J. Lambert, and Larry L. Jacoby. 2002. Best laid plans: Effects of goals on accessibility bias and cognitive control in race-based misperceptions of weapons. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 38 (4): 38496.
Peffley, Mark, and Jon Hurwitz. 1993. International events and foreign policy beliefs: Public response to changing Soviet-US relations. American Journal of Political Science 36: 43161.
Peffley, Mark, Todd Shields, and Bruce Williams. 1996. The intersection of race and crime in television news stories: An experimental study. Political Communication 13 (3): 30928.
Plant, E. Ashby, and B. Michelle Peruche. 2005. The consequences of race for police officers' responses to criminal suspects. Psychological Science 16 (3): 18083.
Poehlman, T. Andrew, Eric Luis Uhlmann, Anthony G. Greenwald, and Mahzarin R. Banaji. 2005. “Understanding and Using the Implicit Association Test: Meta-Analysis of Predictive Validity.” Unpublished manuscript.
Reeves, Keith. 1997. Voting Hopes or Fears?: White Voters, Black Candidates & Racial Politics in America. New York: Oxford University Press.
Schuman, Howard, Charlotte Steeh, Lawrence D. Bobo, and Maria Krysan. 1998. Racial Attitudes in America: Trends and Interpretations, Revised Edition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Schuman, Jean, and Stanley Presser. 1981. Questions and Answers in Attitude Surveys. New York: Academic Press.
Sears, David O., James Sidanius, and Lawrence D. Bobo, eds. 2000. Racialized Politics: Values, Ideology, and Prejudice in American Public Opinion. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Sniderman, Paul M., and Thomas Piazza. 1993. The Scar of Race. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Terkildsen, Nayda. 1993. When white voters evaluate black candidates: The processing implications of candidate skin color, prejudice and self-monitoring. American Journal of Political Science 37: 103253.
Thernstrom, Abigail. 1987. Whose Vote Counts? Affirmative Action and Minority Voting Rights. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Tourangeau, Roger, and Kenneth A. Rasinski. 1988. Cognitive processes underlying context effects in attitude measurement. Psychological Bulletin 103 (3): 299314.
Valentino, Nicholas A. 1999. Crime news and the priming of racial attitudes during evaluations of the president. Public Opinion Quarterly 63 (3): 293320.
Valentino, Nicholas A., and David O. Sears. 2005. Old times there are not forgotten: Race and partisan realignment in the contemporary south. American Journal of Political Science 49 (3): 67288.
Valentino, Nicholas A., Michael Traugott, and Vincent Hutchings. 2002. Group cues and ideological constraint: A replication of political advertising effects studies in the lab and in the field. Political Communication 19 (1): 2948.
Valentino, Nicholas A., Vincent L. Hutchings, and Ismail K. White. 2002. Cues that matter: How political ads prime racial attitudes during campaigns. American Political Science Review 96 (1): 7590.
White, Ismail. 2007. When race matters and when it doesn't: Racial group differences in response to racial cues. American Political Science Review 101 (2): 116.
Winter, Nicholas J.G. 2006. Beyond welfare: Framing and the racialization of white opinion on social security. American Journal of Political Science 50 (2): 40020.
Wittenbrink, Berndt, Charles M. Judd, and Bernadette Park. 1997. Evidence for racial prejudice at the implicit level and its relationship with questionnaire measures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72 (2): 26274.
Zaller, John. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Perspectives on Politics
  • ISSN: 1537-5927
  • EISSN: 1541-0986
  • URL: /core/journals/perspectives-on-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 143 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 541 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.