Skip to main content Accessibility help

Reconstituting the Submerged State: The Challenges of Social Policy Reform in the Obama Era

  • Suzanne Mettler (a1)

President Barack Obama came into office with a social welfare policy agenda that aimed to reconstitute what can be understood as the “submerged state”: a conglomeration of existing federal policies that incentivize and subsidize activities engaged in by private actors and individuals. By attempting to restructure the political economy involved in taxation, higher education policy, and health care, Obama ventured into a policy terrain that presents immense obstacles to reform itself and to the public's perception of its success. Over time the submerged state has fostered the profitability of particular industries and induced them to increase their political capacity, which they have exercised in efforts to maintain the status quo. Yet the submerged state simultaneously eludes most ordinary citizens: they have little awareness of its policies or their upwardly redistributive effects, and few are cognizant of what is at stake in reform efforts. This article shows how, in each of the three policy areas, the contours and dynamics of the submerged state have shaped the possibilities for reform and the form it has taken, the politics surrounding it, and its prospects for success. While the Obama Administration won hard-fought legislative accomplishments in each area, political success will continue to depend on how well policy design, policy delivery and political communication reveal policy reforms to citizens, so that they better understand how reforms function and what has been achieved.

Hide All
Alarkon, Walter. 2009. “Beneficiaries of Sallie Mae, Nelnet Fight Obama's Student-Aid Proposal.” The Hill, March 9.
Ansolabehere, Stephen, de Figueiredo, John M., and Snyder, James M. Jr. 2003. “Why Is There So Little Money in U.S. Politics?Journal of Economic Perspectives 17(1): 105130.
Attkisson, Sharyl. 2009. “White House & Big Pharma: What's the Deal?” CBS News. August 10.
Blumenthal, David, and Morone, James A.. 2009. The Heart of Power: Health and Politics in the Oval Office. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Boles, Corey. 2010. “Alternate Senate Student Loan Plan Would Retain Role for Banks.” Dow Jones News Wire,, accessed March 1, 2010.
Burman, Leonard, Toder, Eric, and Geissler, Christopher. 2008. “How Big Are Total Individual Income Tax Expenditures, and Who Benefits from Them?” Discussion Paper No. 31. The Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center., accessed March 1, 2010.
Campbell, Andrea Louise, and Skocpol, Theda. 2003. “AARP at Risk of Medicare Blowback.” Albany Times Union. November 30. Originally written for Newsday., accessed March 1, 2010.
CBS/AP. 2009. “Top Dems Question Tax Deduction Proposal.” CBS News/Politics., accessed January 29, 2010.
CBS News/New York Times Poll. 2010. “The Tea Party Movement.” February 5–10., accessed March 1, 2010.
Congdon, William, Kling, Jeffrey R., and Mullainathan, Sendhil. 2009. “Behavioral Economics and Tax Policy.” National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 15328.
Delisle, Jason. 2010. “Senator Conrad's Choice on Student Loan Bill.” Higher Ed Watch. New America Foundation. January 19., accessed March 1, 2010.
Dreas, Maryann. 2009. “Private Lenders Focus on Jobs in Student Loan Fight.” The Hill., accessed March 1, 2010.
Field, Kelly. 2009b. “On Higher-Education Spending, the White House and Congress Agree, to a Point.” Chronicle of Higher Education, August 17.
Garfinkel, Irwin, Rainwater, Lee, and Smeeding, Timothy M.. 2006. “A Re-examination of Welfare States and Inequality in Rich Nations: How In-Kind Transfers and Indirect Taxes Change the Story.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 25(4): 897919.
Geiger, Kim, and Hamburger, Tom. 2009. “Healthcare Reform Wins over Doctors Lobby.” Los Angeles Times, September 15
Gladieux, Lawrence E., and Wolanin, Thomas R.. 1976. Congress and the Colleges: The National Politics of Higher Education. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Glendinning, David. 2009. “AMA backs House health system reform bill that includes Medicare pay overhaul.” July 27.
Gottschalk, Marie. 2000. The Shadow Welfare State: Labor, Business, and the Politics of Health Care in the United States. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Greenhouse, Steven. 2009. “Dennis Rivera Leads Labor Charge for Health Reform” New York Times, August 26.
Hacker, Jacob S. 2002. The Divided Welfare State: The Battle Over Public and Private Social Benefits in the United States. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hacker, Jacob S. 2008. “The New Push for American Health Security.” In Health at Risk: America's Ailing Health System—and How to Heal It, ed. Hacker, Jacob S.. New York: Columbia/SSRC.
Hacker, Jacob S., Mettler, Suzanne, and Soss, Joe, eds. 2007. “The New Politics of Inequality: A Policy-Centered Perspective.” In Remaking America: Democracy and Public Policy in an Age of Inequality.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Hall, Holly. 2009. “Charitable-Giving Plan Divides Nonprofit Groups and Worries Donors.” Chronicle of Philanthropy. March 2., accessed January 29, 1010.
Hall, Richard L., and Wayman, Frank W.. 1990. “Buying Time: Moneyed Interests and the Mobilization of Bias in Congressional Committees.” American Political Science Review 84(3): 797820.
Hamburger, Tom. 2009. “Obama gives powerful drug lobby a seat at the health care table.” Los Angeles Times, August 4.
Hoak, Amy. 2009. “This Week's Real Estate Stories.” Marketwatch: Real Estate Weekly, February 27.
Howard, Christopher. 1997. The Hidden Welfare State: Tax Expenditures and Social Policy in the United States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kaiser Family Foundation. 2010. “Focus on Health Care: Side-by-Side Comparison of Major Health Care Reform Proposals.”, accessed March 1, 2010.
Klein, Rick. 2009. “Labor on Line in Health Care Debate,” ABC News, September 7.
Knight, Danielle. 2009. “Lobbying Showdown Over the Future of Student Loans.” Huffington Post Investigative Fund. July 29., accessed March 1, 2010.
Levy, Frank, and Temlin, Peter. 2007. “Inequality and Institutions in 20th Century America.” Industrial Performance Center, MIT, Working Paper Series. MIT-IPC-07-002.
Lewin, Tamar. 2009. “House Passes Bill to Expand College Aid.” New York Times, Sept. 18.
Lichtblau, Eric. 2010. “Lobbying Imperils Overhaul of Student Loans.” New York Times, February 5.
MacGillis, Alec. 2008. “Obama Rallies Labor in Fight for Health-Care Reform.” Washington Post, September 16.
McCarty, Nolan, Poole, Keith T., and Rosenthal, Howard. 2006. Polarized America: The Dance of Ideology and Unequal Riches. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
McLean, Bethany. 2005. “Sallie Mae: A Hot Stock, A Tough Lender.” CNN Money. December 14.
McMillan, Charles. 2009. “Letter to Honorable Barack Obama, from National Association of Realtors.” February 26., accessed January 28, 2010.
Mettler, Suzanne. 2009a. “Promoting Inequality: The Politics of Higher Education Policy in and Era of Conservative Governance.” In The Unsustainable American State, eds. Jacobs, Lawrence and King, Desmond. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mettler, Suzanne. 2009b. “Visible Lessons: How Experiences of Higher Education Policies Influence Participation in Politics.” Unpublished paper. Available from author at
Mettler, Suzanne, and Guardino, Matt. 2009. “Revealing the ‘Hidden Welfare State’: How Policy Information Influences Public Attitudes about Tax Expenditures.” Unpublished, available upon request from
Mettler, Suzanne, and Rose, Deondra. 2009. “Unsustainability of Equal Opportunity: The Development of the Higher Education Act, 1965–2008.” Prepared for delivery at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association. Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Sept. 3–6.
Morgan, Kimberley J., and Campbell, Andrea Louise. 2009. “Exploring the Rube Goldberg State.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Toronto, Ontario, Canada; September 3–6.
Mortgage Bankers Association. 2009. “MBA Raises Concern Over Limit on Mortgage Interest Deduction in Federal Budget.” February 27., accessed January 28, 2010.
National Association of Realtors. 2009a. “In This Issue: March 2009 Update.” Eye on the Hill., accessed January 28, 2010.
National Association of Realtors. 2009b. “In This Issue: 2009 NAR Public Policy Accomplishments.” Eye on the Hill., accessed January 28, 2010.
National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education. 2002. Losing Ground: A National Status Report on the Affordability of American Higher Education. San Jose, CA: National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education.
Nelson, Libby. 2009. “Sallie Mae Fights for Student-Loan Role in a Campaign that's All About Jobs.” November 22. Chronicle of Higher Education., accessed March 1, 2010.
Obama, Barack. 2007. “Announcement for President.” February 10., accessed March 1, 2010.
Obama, Barack. 2008. “Remarks of Senator Barack Obama: Super Tuesday.” February 5, 2008.
Obama, Barack. 2009a. “Transcript: President Obama's News Conference.” New York Times. March 23., accessed January 29, 2010.
Obama, Barack. 2009b. “Remarks by the President on Higher Education” April 24, 2009., accessed February 26, 2010.
Obama, Barack. 2009c. “Remarks by the President in Town Hall on Health Care” August 14, 2009,, accessed February 26, 2010.
Obama, Barack. 2009d. “Remarks by the President in an Online Town Hall on Health Care” July 1, 2009,, accessed February 26, 2010.
OECD. 2007. “Education at a Glance: OECD Briefing Note for the United States.” 2010a. “Lobbying: National Association of Realtors, Client Profile, Summary 2009.” Center for Responsive Politics., accessed January 28, 2010. 2010b. “Real Estate: Long-term Contribution Trends.” Center for Responsive Politics., accessed January 28, 2010. 2010c. Center for Responsive Politics. Available at:, accessed January 29, 2010.
Page, Benjamin I., and Jacobs, Lawrence R.. 2009. “No Class War: Economic Inequality and the American Public.” In The Unsustainable American State, ed. Jacobs, Lawrence and King, Desmond. New York: Oxford University Press.
Pear, Robert. 2009. “In Divide Over Health Care Overhaul, 2 Major Unions Withdraw from a Coalition.” New York Times, March 6,
Perry, Suzanne. 2009. “Meaning of Senate Language on Charitable Deductions in Eye of Beholder.” Chronicle of Philanthropy. April 3., accessed January 29, 2010.
Quadagno, Jill, and McKelvey, J. Brandon. 2008. “The Transformation of American Health Insurance.” In Health at Risk: America's Ailing Health System—and How to Heal It, ed. Hacker, Jacob S.. New York: Columbia/SSRC. Website. 2010. “Track the Money.”, accessed January 23, 2010.
Robert Woods Johnson Foundation. 2009. “Talking about Quality, Party I: Health Care Today.”, accessed March 1, 2010.
Rohack, J. James. 2009. “AMA Reaction to President Obama's Address on Health System Reform” September 9.
Rucker, Philip. 2009. “Obama Defends Push to Cut Tax Deductions for Charitable Gifts.” Washington Post, March 26, A02.
Runningen, Roger, and Donmoyer, Ryan J.. 2009. “Obama Asks Volcker to Lead Panel on Tax-Code Overhaul.”, accessed January 26, 2010.
Schatz, Joseph J. 2009. “Obama's Budget Proposal Alters the Typical Tax and Spend Equation.” CQ Weekly. March 2. Pp. 480–81.
Sinclair, Barbara. 2006. Party Wars: Polarization and the Politics of National Policy Making. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
Skocpol, Theda. 1997. Boomerang: Health Care Reform and the Turn Against Government. New York: W.W. Norton and Co.
Skocpol, Theda. 2003. Diminished Democracy: From Membership to Management in American Civic Life. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
Skowronek, Stephen. 1982. Building a New American State: The Expansion of National Administrative Capacities, 1877–1920. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Social, and Government Issues and Participation Study. 2008. Survey conducted by Survey Research Institute, Cornell University. Principal Investigator, Suzanne Mettler. Contact for more information.
Starr, Paul, and Esping-Andersen, Gosta. 1979. “Passive Intervention.” Working Papers for a New Society, July/August., accessed March 1, 2010.
Stone, Peter H. 2010. “Health Insurers Funded Chamber Attack Ads.” National Journal, January 12.
Strom, Stephanie. 2009. “Limiting Deductions on Charity Draws Ire.” New York Times. February 27., accessed January 29, 2010.
Swartz, Katherine. 2008. “Uninsured in America: New Realities, New Risks.” In Health at Risk: America's Ailing Health System—and How to Heal It, ed. Hacker, Jacob S.. New York: Columbia/SSRC.
Thayler, Richard H., and Sunstein, Cass. 2008. Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Tumulty, Karen, and Scherer, Michael. 2009. “How Drug-Industry Lobbyists Won on Health Care,” Time, October 22,,8599,1931595,00.html.
U.S. Congress 2009b. House of Representatives. Clerk. “Final Vote Results for Roll Call 719.”, accessed September 21, 2009.
U.S. Congress. Joint Committee on Taxation. 2006. “Estimates of Federal Tax Expenditures for Fiscal Years 2006–2010.”, accessed March 1, 2010.
U.S. Congressional Budget Office. 2009. “An Analysis of the President's Budgetary Proposals for FY 2010.”, accessed June 15, 2010.
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Inspector General. 2006. “Review of Financial Partners' Monitoring and Oversight of Guaranty Agencies, Lenders, and Servicers.” Final Audit Report. September.
U.S. Senate Finance Committee. 2009. “Description of Policy Options: Financing Comprehensive Health Care Reform: Proposed Health System Savings and Revenue Options.” May 20., accessed March 1, 2010.
U.S. Senate Finance and House Ways and Means Committee. 2009. “The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009—February 12, 2009. Full Summary of Provisions.”, accessed January 23, 2010.
Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. 2009a. “Tax Stimulus Report Card, Conference Bill, as of February 13, 2009.”, accessed January 26, 2010.
Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. 2009b. “Tax Proposals in the 2010 Budget.”, accessed January 26, 2010.
Voteview website. 2010. “Party Polarization: 1879–2009. Updated 4 January 2010.
Wall St. Journal. 2009. “Senate Finance Bill: Drug Industry Likes It, Unions Don't.” Health Blog, October 14.
Washington Post. 2006. “Top 100 Executives by Total Compensation.”
Young, Jeffrey. 2009a. “AMA endorses Senate healthcare reform bill” The Hill. December 21.
Young, Jeffrey. 2009b. “AARP endorses House healthcare reform bill” The Hill. November 5.
Young, Jeffrey. 2009c. “Reid vows help for Medicare drug costs” The Hill's Blog Briefing Room, December 14.
Zeleny, Jeff. 2010. “Blogging the Massachusetts Senate Race,” New York Times, January 19,
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Perspectives on Politics
  • ISSN: 1537-5927
  • EISSN: 1541-0986
  • URL: /core/journals/perspectives-on-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed