Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

The Threat of Genes: A Comment on Evan Charney's “Genes and Ideologies”

  • Rebecca J. Hannagan (a1) and Peter K. Hatemi (a2)

In his essay, “Genes and Ideologies,” Evan Charney wrangles with the question of the role of genes in the formation of political attitudes via a critique of Alford, Funk, and Hibbing's 2005 American Political Science Review article. Although critical evaluations are necessary, his essay falls short of what is required of a scientific critique on both empirical and theoretical grounds. We offer a comment on his essay and further contend that it is naïve to proceed on the assumption that a barrier exists between the biological and social sciences, such that the biological sciences have nothing to offer the social sciences. If we look beyond our discipline's current theoretical models we may find a more thorough, and not just competing, explanation of political behavior.

Hide All
Alford John, Funk Carolyn, and Hibbing John R.. 2005. Are political orientations genetically transmitted? American Political Science Review 99 (2): 153168.
Bouchard Thomas J., Segal Nancy L., Tellegen Auke, McGue Matt, Keyes Margaret, and Krueger Robert. 2003. Evidence for the construct validity and heritability of the Wilson-Patterson conservatism scale: a reared-apart twins study of social attitudes. Personality and Individual Differences 34: 959–69.
Caspi Avshalom, McClay Joseph, Moffitt Terrie, Mill Jonathan, Martin Judie, Craig Ian, Taylor Allen, and Poulton Richie. 2002. Role of genotype in the cycle of violence in maltreated children. Science 297: 851–53.
Caspi Avshalom, Sugden Karen, Moffitt Terrie, Taylor Alan, Craig Ian, McClay Honalee Harrington Joseph, Mill Jonathan, Martin Judie, Braithwaite Antony, and Poulton Richie. 2003. Influence of life stress on depression. Science 301: 386–89.
Darwin Charles. 1998 [1872]. The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animals, ed. Eckman Paul. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Eagly A.H., and Chaiken S.. 1993. The Psychology of Attitudes. San Diego, CA: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Eaves L.J., and Eysenck H.J.. 1974. Genetics and the development of social attitudes. Nature 249: 288–89.
Eaves L.J., Eysenck H.J., and Martin N.G.. 1989. Genes, Culture and Personality: An Empirical Approach. New York: Academic Press.
Eaves Lindon, Heath Andrew, Martin Nicholas, Maes Hermine, Neale Michael, Kendler Kenneth, Kirk Katherine, and Corey Linda. 1999. Comparing the biological and cultural inheritance of personality and social attitudes in the Virginia 30,000 study of twins and their relatives. Twin Research 2: 6280.
Fowler James. 2006. “The Genetic Basis of Political Cooperation.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Philadelphia, PA. August 30–September 2.
Fowler James. 2007. “The Genetic Basis of Voter Turnout.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, IL. April 12–15.
Fowler James, Baker Laura, and Dawes Christopher. 2006. “The Genetic Basis of Politicl Cooperation.” Presented at the Hendricks Conference on Biology and Politics, Lincoln, NE, October 13–14.
Fowler James, and Dawes Chris. 2007. “The Genetic Basis of Political Participation.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago, IL, August 30–September 2.
Freese Jeremy, and Powell Brian. 2003. Tilting at twindmills: Rethinking sociological responses to behavioral genetics. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 44 (2): 130–35.
Hatemi Peter K. 2007. “The Genetics of Political Attitudes.” PhD diss., University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
Hatemi Peter, Alford John, Hibbing John, Keller Matthew, Martin Nicholas, Medland Sarah, and Eaves Lindon. 2007. “Not by Twins Alone: Using the Extended Twin Family Design to Investigate the Genetic Basis of Political Beliefs.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago, IL, August 30–September 2.
Hatemi Peter K., Medland Sarah E., Morley Katherine I., Heath Andrew C., and Martin Nicholas G.. 2007. The genetics of voting: An Australian twin study. Behavior Genetics 37 (3): 435–48.
Heath A.C., Jardine R., and Martin N.G.. 1989. Interactive effects of genotype and social environment on alcohol consumption in female twins. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 60: 3848.
Hettema J.M., Neale M.C., and Kendler K.S.. 1995. Physical similarity and the equal-environments assumption in twin studies of psychiatric disorders. Behavior Genetics 25: 327–35.
Horwitz Allan, Videon Tami, Schmitz Mark, and Davis Diane. 2003. Rethinking twins and environments: Possible social structures for assumed genetic influences in twin research. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 44 (2): 111–29.
Kendler K.S. 1983. Overview: Current perspective on twin studies of schizophrenia. American Journal of Psychiatry 140: 1413–25.
Kendler K.S., Heath A.C., Martin N.G., and Eaves L.J.. 1987. Symptoms of anxiety and symptoms of depression. Same genes, different environments? Archives of General Psychiatry 44: 451–57.
Kendler K.S., Neale M.C., Kessler R.C., Heath A.C., and Eaves L.J.. 1993. A test of the equal-environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illness. Behavior Genetics 23: 2127.
Loehlin J.C., and Nichols R.C.. 1976. Heredity, Environment, and Personality: A Study of 850 Sets of Twins. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
Lytton H. 1977. Do parents create, or respond to, differences in twins? Developmental Psychology 13: 456–59.
Martin N.G., Eaves L.J., Heath A.C., Jardine R., Feingold L.M., and Eysenck H.J.. 1986. Transmission of social attitudes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 83: 4364–68.
Matheny A.P., Wilson R.S., and Dolan A.B.. 1976. Relations between twins' similarity of appearance and behavioral similarity: Testing an assumption. Behavior Genetics 6: 343–51.
Neale M.C. 1997. Mx: Statistical Modeling (Box 980126) 3d ed.Richmond, VA: MCV.
Neale M.C. 2000. QTL mapping with sib-pairs: The flexibility of Mx. In Advances in Twin and Sib-Pair Analysis, ed. Spector T.D., Snieder H., and MacGregor A.J.. London: Oxford University Press.
Neale M.C., and Cardon L.R.. 1992. Methodology for Genetic Studies of Twins and Families. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Nelson Stephen D. 1974. Nature/nurture revisited I: A review of the biological bases of conflict. Journal of Conflict Resolution 18 (2): 285335.
Olson James M., Vernon Philip A., Harris Julie Aitken, and Jang Kerry L.. 2001. The heritability of attitudes: A study of twins. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 80 (6): 845–60.
Plomin R., Willerman L., and Loehlin J.C.. 1976. Resemblance in appearance and the equal environments assumption in twin studies of personality traits. Behavior Genetics 6: 4352.
Rijsdijk Frühling V., and Sham Pak C.. 2002. Analytic approaches to twin data using structural equation models. Briefings in Bioinformatics 3 (2): 119–33.
Scarr S., and Carter-Saltzman L.. 1979. Twin method: Defense of a critical assumption. Behavior Genetics 9: 527–42.
Truett K.R., Eaves L.J., Meyer J.M., Heath A.C., and Martin N.G.. 1992. Religion and education as mediators of attitudes: A multivariate analysis. Behavior Genetics 22: 43–6.
Xian Hong, Scherrer Jeffrey F., Eisen Seth A., True William R., Heath Andrew C., Goldberg Jack, Lyon Michael J., and Tsuang Ming T.. 2000. Self-reported zygosity and the equal-environments assumption for psychiatric disorders in the Vietnam era twin registry. Behavior Genetics 30: 303–10.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Perspectives on Politics
  • ISSN: 1537-5927
  • EISSN: 1541-0986
  • URL: /core/journals/perspectives-on-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 5
Total number of PDF views: 9 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 141 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.