Skip to main content Accessibility help

Could Captain Scott have been saved? Revisiting Scott's last expedition

  • Karen May (a1)

Captain Scott has been criticised for indecisiveness and for not making use of the dog teams for his own relief in his Terra Nova Expedition (1910–1913). This essay will demonstrate how a mistake made in Roland Huntford's double biography of Scott and Amundsen in 1979, repeated in polar writing by various authors until the present day, has maligned Scott's reputation. In fact, Scott left appropriate written orders in October 1911 for the polar party's relief by the dog teams, orders that were not subsequently implemented by the men at base. A re-examination of the actions and roles of two expedition members in particular, Lieutenant E.R.G.R. Evans and Surgeon Edward Atkinson, suggests strongly that misjudgements back at Cape Evans led to the failure of the mission to rescue Scott and his polar party. In this account all distances are in geographical miles.

Hide All
Atkinson, E.L. 1912a. Letter to the Atkinson family, February 1912. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 1912/2;D.
Atkinson, E.L. 1912b. Letter to C.S. Wright, 22 February 1912. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 1178/1;D.
Atkinson, E.L. 1913. The last year at Cape Evans. In: Scott, R.F.Scott's last expedition. London: Smith, Elder and Co: 298349.
Atkinson, E.L. 1919a. Letter to A. Cherry-Garrard, 17 April 1919. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 873/2/12.
Atkinson, E.L. 1919b. Letter to A. Cherry-Garrard, 5 December 1919. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 873/2/19.
Bell, M.H. 1968. What shall we do tomorrow? London: Cassell & Co.
Bull, C., and Wright, P.F.. (editors). 1993. Silas. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.
Carpenter, K. 1988. The history of scurvy and vitamin C. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cherry-Garrard, A. Journal. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 559/2;BJ.
Cherry-Garrard, A. 1913. Letter to E.L. Atkinson, 3 April 1913. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 559/42;D.
Cherry-Garrard, A. 1919. Letter to E.L. Atkinson, April 1919. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 873/2/14.
Cherry-Garrard, A. 1994. The worst journey in the world. London: Picador.
Crane, N. 2006. Scott of the Antarctic. London: Harper Perennial.
Debenham, F. 1981. Best-loved books: Scott's last expedition. London: Reader's Digest.
Debenham, F. 1992. The quiet land: the diaries of Frank Debenham. Bluntisham: Bluntisham Press.
Debenham, F. 1998. In the Antarctic: stories of Scott's last expedition. Banham, Norfolk: Erskine Press.
Ellis, A. (editor). 1969. Under Scott's command: Lashly's Antarctic diaries. London: Victor Gollancz.
Evans, E.R.G.R. 1927. The mystery of ‘the Polar Star’. London: Partridge.
Evans, E.R.G.R. 1949. South with Scott. London: Collins.
Evans, E.R.G.R. 1952. Adventurous life. London: Hutchinson.
Fiennes, R. 2004. Captain Scott. London: Hodder and Stoughton.
Gawler, J. 1995. Lloyd's medals, 1836–1989. Charlottesville, VA: Howell Press.
Gran, T. 1984. The Norwegian with Scott. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
Hooper, M. 2011. The longest winter: Scott's other heroes. London: John Murray.
Huntford, R. 1999. Scott and Amundsen. London: Abacus.
Jones, A.G.E. 1992. Polar portraits. Whitby: Caedmon of Whitby.
Jones, M. 2003. The last great quest. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lagerbom, C. 1999. The fifth man: Henry R. Bowers. Whitby: Caedmon of Whitby.
Limb, S., and Cordingley, P.. 2009. Captain Oates, soldier and explorer. Barnsley: Pen and Sword Books Ltd.
Navy List 1907. Navy list for July 1907. London: His Majesty's Stationery Office.
Ponting, H. 1922. The great white south. New York: Robert M. McBride and Co.
Pound, R. 1963. Evans of the ‘Broke’. London: Oxford University Press.
Preston, D. 1997. A first-rate tragedy. London: Constable and Co.
Raeside, A. 2009. Return to Antarctica. Ontario: John Wiley and Sons.
Ryan, R. 2009. Death on the ice. London: Headline Press.
Scott, R.F. 1911a. Letter to G. Simpson, 3 October 1911. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 1483/3/1;D.
Scott, R.F. 1911b. Letter to J. Kinsey, 28 October 1911. Wellington, New Zealand: Alexander Turnbull Library.
Scott, R.F. 1911c. Letter to G. Simpson, 24 November 1911. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 1483/3/2;D.
Scott, R.F. 2008. Journals: Captain Scott's last expedition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sewell Hawkins, D. 2009. The man who found Captain Scott: Surgeon-Captain E.L. Atkinson, RN. Old Forester 1895–1900 (Cambridge; Scott Polar Research Institute: Pam 92 [Atkinson, E.L.])
Simpson, G.C. 1923. British Antarctic Expedition 1910–1913, Meteorology Vol. III: Tables. London: Harrison and Sons Ltd.
Smith, G. 2011. Royal Navy and Merchant Navy – Awards of the Albert Medal from the London Gazette in edition order. URL: (accessed 12 November 2011)
Smith, J.M. 2010. The role of F.J. Hooper in Scott's expedition to the South Pole (revised edition). (Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute (*7): 91 (08) [1910–1913 SCOTT] [SMI])
Smith, M. 2002. I am just going outside: Captain Oates – Antarctic tragedy. Staplehurst: Spellmount Limited.
Solomon, S. 2001. The coldest march: Scott's fatal Antarctic expedition. London: Yale University Press.
South Polar Times. 1914. South Polar Times vol. III. London: Smith, Elder & Co.
Spufford, F. 2003. I may be some time: ice and the English imagination. London: Faber.
Stein, G.M. 2011. Could it have been different? Boatswain Feather with Scott in the Antarctic. URL: (accessed 20 May 2011)
Taylor, T. G. 1916. With Scott: the silver lining. London: Smith, Elder and Co.
Wheeler, S. 2002. Cherry: A life of Apsley Cherry-Garrard. London: Vintage.
Wilson, E.A. 1905. The medical aspect of the Discovery's voyage to the Antarctic. British Medical Journal 8 July 1905: 77–80.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Polar Record
  • ISSN: 0032-2474
  • EISSN: 1475-3057
  • URL: /core/journals/polar-record
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed