Skip to main content
×
Home

Geo-Nested Analysis: Mixed-Methods Research with Spatially Dependent Data

  • Imke Harbers (a1) and Matthew C. Ingram (a2)
Abstract

Mixed-methods designs, especially those where cases selected for small-N analysis (SNA) are nested within a large-N analysis (LNA), have become increasingly popular. Yet, since the LNA in this approach assumes that units are independently distributed, such designs are unable to account for spatial dependence, and dependence becomes a threat to inference, rather than an issue for empirical or theoretical investigation. This is unfortunate, since research in political science has recently drawn attention to diffusion and interconnectedness more broadly. In this paper we develop a framework for mixed-methods research with spatially dependent data—a framework we label “geo-nested analysis”—where insights gleaned at each step of the research process set the agenda for the next phase and where case selection for SNA is based on diagnostics of a spatial-econometric analysis. We illustrate our framework using data from a seminal study of homicides in the United States.

Copyright
Corresponding author
* Email: i.harbers@uva.nl
Footnotes
Hide All

Authors’ note: Previous versions of this paper were presented at faculty seminars at the University of Amsterdam, at an ECPR Joint Sessions workshop on spatial and network dependence convened by Jos Elkink and Kristian Gleditsch, and at the 2015 meeting of the American Political Science Association. We would like to thank audiences and discussants in these settings, especially Kyle Beardsley, Andrew Bennett, Brian Burgoon, Gustavo Flores-Macias, Lee Seymour, and Steve Wuhs for their suggestions. We gratefully acknowledge helpful feedback from the journal’s anonymous reviewers and editor, as well as from Glenn Deane and Tse-Chuan Yang, who commented on early drafts. We thank the National Consortium on Violence Research (NCOVR) for making available the county-level homicide data and Luc Anselin for making data so accessible (http://spatial.uchicago.edu/sample-data). Replication materials (data and code) are available at Harvard Dataverse, doi:10.7910/DVN/HRLHA4 (Harbers and Ingram 2016). Both authors contributed equally, and all remaining errors are their own.

Contributing Editor: Jonathan Katz

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Ahram Ariel. 2011. The theory and method of comparative area studies. Qualitative Research 11(1):6990.
Anselin Luc. 1988. Spatial econometrics: Methods and models . Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Anselin Luc. 1995. Local indicators of spatial association—LISA. Geographical Analysis 27(2):93115.
Anselin Luc. 2005. Exploring spatial data with GeoDa: A workbook. Urbana, IL: Spatial Analysis Laboratory, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.
Anselin Luc, and Bera Anil K.. 1998. Spatial dependence in linear regression models with an introduction to spatial econometrics. In Handbook of applied economic statistics , ed. Ullah Aman and Giles David. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp. 237289.
Anselin Luc, and Rey Sergio J.. 2014. Modern spatial econometrics in practice . Chicago: GeoDa Press.
Baller Robert D., Anselin Luc, Messner Steven F., Deane Glenn, and Hawkins Darnell F.. 2001. Structural covariates of US county homicide rates: Incorporating spatial effects. Criminology 39(3):561588.
Beck Nathaniel, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede, and Beardsley Kyle. 2006. Space is more than geography: Using spatial econometrics in the study of political economy. International Studies Quarterly 50(1):2744.
Bell Andrew, and Jones Kelvyn. 2015. Explaining fixed effects: Random effects modeling of time-series cross-sectional and panel data. Political Science Research and Methods 3:133153.
Bennett Andrew, and Checkel Jeffrey T.. 2015. Process tracing: From metaphor to analytic tool . New York: Cambridge University Press.
Berry William D., Fording Richard C., and Hanson Russell L.. 2003. Reassessing the “race to the bottom” in state welfare policy. Journal of Politics 65(2):327349.
Bivand Roger, and Piras Gianfranco. 2015. Comparing implementations of estimation methods for spatial econometrics. Journal of Statistical Software 63(18):136. http://www.jstatsoft.org/v63/i18/.
Brady Henry E., and McNulty John E.. 2011. Turning out to vote: The costs of finding and getting to the polling place. American Political Science Review 105(01):115134.
Brinks Daniel, and Coppedge Michael. 2006. Diffusion is no illusion neighbor emulation in the third wave of democracy. Comparative Political Studies 39(4):463489.
Brunsdon Chris A., Fotheringham Stewart, and Charlton Martin. 1996. Geographically weighted regression: A method for exploring spatial nonstationarity. Geographical Analysis 28(4):281298.
Charlton Martin, and Fotheringham A. Stewart. 2009. Geographically weighted regression. White Paper, National Centre for Geocomputation, National University of Ireland Maynooth URL: http://www.geos.ed.ac.uk/∼gisteac/fspat/gwr/gwr_arcgis/GWR_WhitePaper.pdf.
Cho Wendy K. Tam, Gimpel James G., and Dyck Joshua J.. 2006. Residential concentration, political socialization, and voter turnout. Journal of Politics 68(1):156167.
Clark Tom S., and Linzer Drew A.. 2015. Should I use fixed or random effects? Political Science Research and Methods 3:399408.
Cliff Andrew, and Ord Keith. 1972. Testing for spatial autocorrelation among regression residuals. Geographical Analysis 4(3):267284.
Collier David, Brady Henry E., and Seawright Jason. 2004. Sources of leverage in causal inference: Toward an alternative view of methodology. In Rethinking social inquiry: Diverse tools, shared standards , ed. Brady Henry E. and Collier David. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 229266.
Darmofal David. 2006. The political geography of macro-level turnout in American political development. Political Geography 25(2):123150.
Darmofal David. 2015. Spatial analysis for the social sciences . New York: Cambridge University Press.
Deaton Angus. 2010. Instruments, randomization, and learning about development. Journal of Economic Literature 48(2):424455.
Dieleman Joseph L., and Templin Tara. 2014. Random-effects, fixed-effects and the within-between specification for clustered data in observational health studies: A simulation study. PLoS ONE 9(10): e110257.
Dube Arindrajit, Dube Oeindrila, and García-Ponce Omar. 2013. Cross-border spillover: US gun laws and violence in Mexico. American Political Science Review 107(03):397417.
Erikson Robert S., and Minnite Lorraine C.. 2009. Modeling problems in the voter identification-voter turnout debate. Election Law Journal 8(2):85101.
Falleti Tulia G., and Lynch Julia F.. 2009. Context and causal mechanisms in political analysis. Comparative Political Studies 42(9):11431166.
Fearon James D., and Laitin David D.. 2003. Ethnicity, insurgency, and civil war. American Political Science Review 91(1):7590.
Fjelde Hanne, and von Uexkull Nina. 2012. Climate triggers: Rainfall anomalies, vulnerability and communal conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa. Political Geography 31(7):444453.
Florax Raymond J. G. M., Folmer Hendrik, and Rey Sergio J.. 2003. Specification searches in spatial econometrics: The relevance of Hendry’s methodology. Regional Science and Urban Economics 33(5):557579.
Fotheringham A. Stewart, Brunsdon Chris, and Charlton Martin. 2002. Geographically weighted regression: The analysis of spatially varying relationships . Chichester: Wiley.
Gerring John. 2007. Case study research: Principles and practices . New York: Cambridge University Press.
Graham Erin R., Shipan Charles R., and Volden Craig. 2013. The diffusion of policy diffusion research in political science. British Journal of Political Science 43(03):673701.
Harbers Imke, and Ingram Matthew C.. 2016. Replication data for: Geo-nested analysis: Mixed-methods research with spatially dependent data. doi:10.7910/DVN/HRLHA4. Harvard Dataverse.
Harbers Imke, and Ingram Matthew. n.d. Politics in space: Methodological considerations for taking space seriously in subnational comparative research. In Inside countries: Subnational research in comparative politics, ed. Richard Snyder, Agustina Giraudy and Eduardo Moncada (unpublished manuscript).
Hilbink Lisa. 2012. The origins of positive judicial independence. World Politics 64(04):587621.
Huckfeldt Robert, and Sprague John. 1992. Political parties and electoral mobilization: Political structure, social structure, and the party canvass. American Political Science Review 86(01):7086.
Humphreys Macartan, and Jacobs Alan M.. Mixing methods: A Bayesian approach. American Political Science Review 109(4):653673.
Ingram Matthew C. 2016a. Crafting courts in new democracies: The politics of subnational judicial reform in Brazil and Mexico . New York: Cambridge University Press.
Ingram Matthew C. 2016b. Mandates, geography, and networks: Explaining subnational diffusion of criminal procedure reform in Mexico. Latin American Politics and Society 58(1):121145.
Ingram Matthew C. 2016c. Networked justice: Judges, the diffusion of ideas, and legal reform movements in Mexico. Journal of Latin American Studies 48(4):739768.
Kasara Kimuli, and Suryanarayan Pavithra. 2015. When do the rich vote less than the poor and why? Explaining turnout inequality across the world. American Journal of Political Science 59(3):613627.
Kelejian Harry H., and Prucha Ingmar R.. 2010. Specification and estimation of spatial autoregressive models with autoregressive and heteroskedastic disturbances. Journal of Econometrics 157(1):5367. doi:10.1016/j.jeconom.2009.10.025.
King Gary. 1996. Why context should not count. Political Geography 15(2):159164.
King Gary. 1997. A solution to the ecological inference problem . Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Koesel Karrie J., and Bunce Valerie J.. 2013. Diffusion-proofing: Russian and Chinese responses to waves of popular mobilizations against authoritarian rulers. Perspectives on Politics 11(03):753768.
Land Kenneth C., McCall Patricia L., and Cohen Lawrence E.. 1990. Structural covariates of homicide rates: Are there any invariances across time and social space? American Journal of Sociology 95(4):922963.
Lieberman Evan S. 2005. Nested analysis as a mixed-method strategy for comparative research. American Political Science Review 99(3):435452.
Messner Steven F., Anselin Luc, Baller Robert D., Hawkins Darnell F., Deane Glenn, and Tolnay Stewart E.. 1999. The spatial patterning of county homicide rates: An application of exploratory spatial data analysis. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 15(4):423450.
Moran Patrick A. P. 1950. Notes on continuous stochastic phenomena. Biometrika 37:1723.
Nielsen Richard A. 2016. Case selection via matching. Sociological Methods and Research 45(3):569597.
Nisbett Richard E. 1993. Violence and US regional culture. American Psychologist 48:441449.
Østby Gudrun, Nordås Ragnhild, and Ketil Rød Jan. 2009. Regional inequalities and civil conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa. International Studies Quarterly 53(2):301324.
Páez Antonio, Uchida Takashi, and Miyamoto Kazuaki. 2002. A general framework for estimation and inference of geographically weighted regression models: 2. Spatial association and model specification tests. Environment and Planning A 34:883904.
Pierskalla Jan H., and Hollenbach Florian M.. 2013. Technology and collective action: The effect of cell phone coverage on political violence in Africa. American Political Science Review 107(02):207224.
Powell G. Bingham. 1986. American voter turnout in comparative perspective. American Political Science Review 80(01):1743.
Przeworski Adam, and Teune Henry. 1970. The logic of comparative social inquiry . New York: Wiley.
R Core Team. 2016. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org/.
Rohlfing Ingo. 2008. What you see and what you get: Pitfalls and principles of nested analysis in comparative research. Comparative Political Studies 41(11):14921514.
Rohlfing Ingo, and Starke Peter. 2013. Building on solid ground: Robust case selection in multi-method research. Swiss Political Science Review 19(4):492512.
Seawright Jason. 2016. Multi-method social science: Combining qualitative and quantitative tools . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Seawright Jason, and Gerring John. 2008. Case selection techniques in case study research: A menu of qualitative and quantitative options. Political Research Quarterly 61(2):294308.
Shipan Charles R., and Volden Craig. 2008. The mechanisms of policy diffusion. American Journal of Political Science 52(4):840857.
Shoff Carla, Yi-Ju Chen Vivian, and Yang Tse-Chuan. 2014. When homogeneity meets heterogeneity: The geographically weighted regression with spatial lag approach to prenatal care utilization. Geospatial Health 8(2):557568.
Simmons Beth A., Dobbin Frank, and Garrett Geoffrey. 2008. The global diffusion of markets and democracy . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Soifer Hillel. n.d. Units of analysis in subnational research. In Inside countries: Subnational research in comparative politics, ed. Richard Snyder, Agustina Giraudy and Eduardo Moncada (unpublished manuscript).
Tiefelsdorf Michael. 2002. The saddlepoint approximation of Moran’s I and local Moran’s Ii reference distributions and their numerical evaluation. Geographical Analysis 34:187206.
Tolnay Stewart E., Deane Glenn, and Beck Ellwood M.. 1996. Vicarious violence: Spatial effects on southern lynchings, 1890–1919. American Journal of Sociology 102(3):788815.
Trelles Alejandro, and Carreras Miguel. 2012. Bullets and votes: Violence and electoral participation in Mexico. Journal of Politics in Latin America 4(2):89123.
Weyland Kurt. 2012. The Arab spring: Why the surprising similarities with the revolutionary wave of 1848? Perspectives on Politics 10(4):917934.
Yom Sean. 2015. From methodology to practice inductive iteration in comparative research. Comparative Political Studies 48(5):616644.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Political Analysis
  • ISSN: 1047-1987
  • EISSN: 1476-4989
  • URL: /core/journals/political-analysis
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
MathJax

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 28
Total number of PDF views: 239 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 740 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 15th May 2017 - 17th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.