Skip to main content

Dependency Status and Demand for Social Insurance: Evidence from Experiments and Surveys*

  • John S. Ahlquist, John R. Hamman and Bradley M. Jones

Current thinking on the origins and size of the welfare state often ignores household relations in which people may depend on others for income or have dependents themselves. The influence of “dependency status” on individuals’ political preferences is unknown. We report results from a laboratory experiment designed to estimate the effect of dependency on preferences for policies that insure against labor market risk. Results indicate that (1) willingness to vote in favor of a social insurance policy is highly responsive to unemployment risk, (2) symmetric, mutual dependence is unrelated to support for insurance, but (3) asymmetric dependence (being dependent on someone else) increases support for social insurance. We connect our lab results to observational survey data and find similar relationships.

Hide All
Abdellaoui Mohammed, I’Haridon Olivier, and Paraschiv Corina. 2013. ‘Individual vs. Couple Behavior: An Experimental Investigation of Risk Preferences’. Theory and Decision 75(2):175191.
Agranov Marina, and Palfrey Thomas R.. 2014. ‘Equilibrium Tax Rates and Income Redistribution: A Laboratory Study’. Working Paper No. 19918, National Bureau of Economic Research.
Almås Ingvild, Cappelen Alexander W., Sorensen Erik, and Tungodden Bertil. 2010. ‘Fairness and the Development of Inequality Acceptance’. Science 328(5982):11761178.
Anderson Dan R., and Nevin John R.. 1975. ‘Determinants of Young Marrieds’ Life Insurance Purchasing Behavior: An Empirical Investigation’. The Journal of Risk and Insurance 42(3):375387.
Ashraf Nava. 2009. ‘Spousal Control and Intra-Household Decision Making: An Experimental Study in the Philippines’. The American Economic Review 99(4):12451277.
Bagozzi Richard P. 2012. ‘Alternative Approaches for Thinking About and Modeling Consumer Decisions in Relationships’. Journal of Consumer Psychology 22(3):315319.
Barber Benjamin, Beramendi Pablo, and Wibbels Erik. 2013. ‘The Behavioral Foundations of Social Politics: Evidence from Surveys and a Laboratory Experiment’. Comparative Political Studies 46(10):11551189.
Bateman Ian, and Munro Alistair. 2005. ‘An Experiment on Risky Choice Amongst Households’. The Economic Journal 115(502):C176C189.
Bateman Ian, and Munro Alistair. 2013. ‘Testing Economic Models of the Household: An Experiment’. Technical report, CSERGE Working Paper EDM, No. 04-01.
Bellante Don, and Green Carole A.. 2004. ‘Relative Risk Aversion Among the Elderly’. Review of Financial Economics 13:269281.
Belot Michele, Duch Raymond, and Miller Luis. 2015. ‘A Comprehensive Comparison of Students and Non-Students in Classic Experimental Games’. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 113:2633.
Bertocchi Graziella, Brunetti Marianna, and Torricelli Costanza. 2010. ‘Marriage and Other Risky Assets: A Portfolio Approach’. CEPR Discussion Papers No. DP7162.
Bogach Olga, Lefgren Lars, and Sims David. 2014. ‘Did You Build That? Effort, Luck, and Voting for Redistribution’. Unpublished working paper, Brigham Young University.
Bolton Gary E., and Ockenfels Axel. 2000. ‘Erc: A Theory of Equity, Reciprocity, and Competition’. The American Economic Review 90(1):166193.
Bone John, Hey John, and Suckling John. 1999. ‘Are Groups More or Less Consistent than Individuals?’. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 8:6381.
Braaten R. Haugli, and Martinsson Peter. 2015. ‘Experimental Measures of Household Decision Power’. Technical Report 02/2015 CREE.
Burden Barry C. 2008. ‘The Social Roots of the Partisan Gender Gap’. Public Opinion Quarterly 72(1):5575.
Cabrales Antonio, Nagel Rosemarie, and RodrguezMora Jos V.. 2012. ‘It is Hobbes, Not Rousseau: An Experiment on Voting and Redistribution’. Experimental Economics 15(2):278308.
Carlsson Fredrik, Martinsson Peter, Qin Ping, and Sutter Matthias. 2013. ‘The Influence of Spouses on Household Decision Making Under Risk: An Experiment in Rural China’. Experimental Economics 16(3):383401.
Charness Gary, and Rabin Matthew. 2002. ‘Understanding Social Preferences with Simple Tests’. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 117(3):817869.
Chen Yan, and Li Sherry X.. 2009. ‘Group Identity and Social Preferences’. The American Economic Review 99(1):431457.
Clarke Daniel, and Kalani Gautam. 2011. Microinsurance decisions: evidence from Ethiopia. Mimeo, University of Oxford: Oxford, UK.
de Palma Andre, Picard Nathalie, and Ziegelmeyer Anthony. 2011. ‘Individual and Couple Decision Behavior Under Risk: Evidence on the Dynamics of Power Balance’. Theory and Decision 70(1):4564.
Drewianka Scott. 2008. ‘Household Production and Risk-Aversion’. Working paper, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.
Edlund Lena, and Pande Rohini. 2002. ‘Why Have Women Become Left-Wing? The Political Gender Gap and the Decline in Marriage’. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 117(3):917961.
Esarey Justin, Salmon Timothy C., and Barrilleaux Charles. 2011a. ‘Social Insurance and Income Redistribution in a Laboratory Experiment’. Political Research Quarterly 65(3):685698.
Esarey Justin, Salmon Timothy C., and Barrilleaux Charles. 2011b. ‘What Motivates Political Preferences? Self-Interest, Ideology, and Fairness in a Laboratory Democracy’. Economic Inquiry 50(3):604624.
Falk Armin, and Fischbacher Urs. 2006. ‘A Theory of Reciprocity’. Games and Economic Behavior 54(2):293315.
Fehr Ernst, and Schmidt Klaus M.. 1999. ‘A Theory of Fairness, Competition, and Cooperation’. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 114(3):817868.
Ferber Robert, and Lee Lucy C.. 1980. ‘Acquisition and Accumulation of Life Insurance in Early Married Life’. The Journal of Risk and Insurance 47(4):713734.
Finseraas Henning, Jakobsson Niklas, and Kotsadam Andreas. 2012. ‘The Gender Gap in Political Preferences: An Empirical Test of a Political Economy Explanation’. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State & Society 19(2):219242.
Fischbacher Urs. 2007. ‘Z-Tree: Zurich Toolbox for Ready-Made Economic Experiments’. Experimental Economics 10(2):171178.
Fortin Bernard, and Lacroix Guy. 1997. ‘A Test of the Unitary and Collective Models of Houselhold Labour Supply’. The Economic Journal 107(443):933955.
Gill David, and Prowse Victoria. 2011. ‘A Novel Computerized Real Effort Task Based on Sliders’. IZA Discussion Papers No. 5801, Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA).
Gill David, and Prowse Victoria. 2012. ‘A Structural Analysis of Disappointment Aversion in a Real Effort Competition’. American Economic Review 102(1):469503.
Goldsmith Art. 1983. ‘Household Life Cycle Protection: Human Capital Versus Life Insurance’. The Journal of Risk and Insurance 50(3):473486.
Gorlin Margarita, and Dhar Ravi. 2012. ‘Bridging the Gap Between Joint and Individual Decisions: Deconstructing Preferences in Relationships’. Journal of Consumer Psychology 22(3):320323.
Gray Jeffrey S. 1998. ‘Divorce-Law Changes, Household Bargaining, and Married Women’s Labor Supply’. The American Economic Review 88(3):628642.
Greiner Ben. 2015. ‘Subject Pool Recruitment Procedures: Organizing Experiments with ORSEE’. Journal of the Economic Science Association 1:114125.
Hall Peter, and Soskice. David (eds). 2001. Varieties of Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hamilton Rebecca W., and Biehal Gabriel J.. 2005. ‘Achieving Your Goals or Protecting Their Future? The Effects of Self? View on Goals and Choices’. Journal of Consumer Research 32(2):277283.
Higgins Tory. 1998. ‘Promotion and Prevention: Regulatory Focus as a Motivational Principle’. In Mark P. Zanna (ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 146. Princeton, NJ: Academic Press.
Hopper JoAnne S. 1995. ‘Family Financial Decision Making: Implications for Marketing Strategy’. Journal of Services Marketing 9(1):2432.
Hotz V. Joseph, Peet Evan, and Thomas Duncan. 2013. ‘Household Decision-Making: The Efficiency of Resource Allocations in Indonesian Households’. Technical report, Duke University.
Howard Christopher. 2008. The Welfare State Nobody Knows: Debunking Myths About U.S. Social Policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Iversen Torben, and Soskice David. 2001. ‘An Asset Theory of Social Policy Preferences’. American Political Science Review 95(4):875893.
Iversen Torben, and Rosenbluth Frances. 2006. ‘The Political Economy of Gender: Explaining Cross-National Variation in Household Bargaining, Divorce, and the Gender Voting Gap’. American Journal of Political Science 50(1):119.
Iversen Torben, and Rosenbluth Frances. 2010. Women, Work, and Politics. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Klor Esteban F., and Shayo Moses. 2010. ‘Social Identity and Preferences Over Redistribution’. Journal of Public Economics 94(34):269278.
Lee Angela, Aaker Jennifer, and Gardner Wendi. 2000. ‘The Pleasures and Pains of Distinct Self-Construals: The Role of Interdependence in Regulatory Focus’. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78(6):11221134.
Lowery David, de Jong Marsha, van Eijk Carola J., and Taal Sandra. 2013. ‘Partisan Differences in Spending Preferences After the New Democrat and New Labour Transformations of Party Images’. Journal of Political Science and Public Affairs 1:1–8.
Lundberg Shelly, and Pollak Robert A.. 1996. ‘Bargaining and Distribution in Marriage’. The Journal of Economic Perspectives 10(4):139158.
Lundberg Shelly J., Pollak Robert A., and Wales Terence J.. 1997. ‘Do Husbands and Wives Pool Their Resources? Evidence from the United Kingdom Child Benefit’. The Journal of Human Resources 32(3):463480.
Mandel Naomi. 2003. ‘Shifting Selves and Decision Making: The Effects of Self-Construal Priming on Consumer Risk-Taking’. Journal of Consumer Research 30(1):3040.
Margalit Yotam. 2013. ‘Explaining Social Policy Preferences: Evidence from the Great Recession’. American Political Science Review 107(1):80103.
McCarty Nolan, and Pontusson Jonas. 2011. ‘The Political Economy of Inequality and Redistribution’. In Brian Nolan, Wiemer Salverda and Timothy M. Smeeding (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Economic Inequality. New York: Oxford University Press.
Meltzer Allan, and Richard Scott. 1981. ‘Rational Theory of the Size of Government’. Journal of Political Economy 101(49–83):914927.
Moene Karl O., and Wallerstein Michael. 2001. ‘Inequality, Social Insurance, and Redistribution’. American Political Science Review 95(4):859874.
Moene Karl O., and Wallerstein Michael. 2003. ‘Earnings Inequality and Welfare Spending’. World Politics 55:485516.
Munro Alistair, Bateman Ian, and McNally Tara. 2013. ‘The Family Under the Microscope: An Experiment Testing Economic Models of Household Choice’. Technical report, MPRA Working Paper No. 8974, MPRA.
Nickelsburg Jerry, and Timmons Jeffrey F.. 2012. ‘On the (Ir)relevance of Skill Specificity for Social Insurance’. Quarterly Journal of Political Science 7:3567.
Rabin Matthew. 1993. ‘Incorporating Fairness into Game Theory and Economics’. The American Economic Review 83(5):12811302.
Rehm Philip. 2009. ‘Risks and Redistribution: An Individual-Level Analysis’. Comparative Political Studies 42(7):855881.
Rehm Philip. 2011. ‘Social Policy by Popular Demand’. World Politics 63(2):271299.
Rutstrom Elizabeth E., and Williams Melonie B.. 2000. ‘Entitlements and Fairness: An Experimental Study of Distributive Preferences’. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 43(1):7589.
Scheve Kenneth, and Stasavage David. 2006. ‘Religion and Preferences for Social Insurance’. Quarterly Journal of Political Science 1:255286.
Scheve Kenneth, and Stasavage David. 2008. ‘Religion and Social Insurance: Evidence from the United States, 1970–2002’. In Ian Shapiro, Peter Swenson and Daniela Donno (eds), Divide and Deal: The Politics of Distribution in Democracies. 149185. New York: New York University Press.
Simpson Jeffry A., Griskevicius Vladas, and Rothman Alexander J.. 2012. ‘Consumer Decisions in Relationships’. Journal of Consumer Psychology 22(3):304314.
Sundn Annika E., and Surette Brian J.. 1998. ‘Gender Differences in the Allocation of Assets in Retirement Savings Plans’. American Economic Review, Papers & Proceedings 88:207211.
Zhou Rongrong, and Pham Michel T.. 2004. ‘Promotion and Prevention Across Mental Accounts: When Financial Products Dictate Consumers Investment Goals’. Journal of Consumer Research 31(1):125135.
Zietz Emily Norman. 2003. ‘An Examination of the Demand for Life Insurance’. Risk Management and Insurance Review 6(2):159191.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Political Science Research and Methods
  • ISSN: 2049-8470
  • EISSN: 2049-8489
  • URL: /core/journals/political-science-research-and-methods
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Ahlquist supplementary material
Online Appendix

 PDF (227 KB)
227 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 79
Total number of PDF views: 202 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 725 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.