Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The efficacy of primary care chaplaincy compared with antidepressants: a retrospective study comparing chaplaincy with antidepressants

  • Gordon Macdonald (a1)
Abstract
Aim

To determine the effectiveness of primary care chaplaincy (PCC) when used as the sole intervention, with outcomes being compared directly with those of antidepressants. This was to be carried out in a homogenous study population reflective of certain demographics in the United Kingdom.

Background

Increasing numbers of patients are living with long-term conditions and ‘modern maladies’ and are experiencing loss of well-being and depression. There is an increasing move to utilise non-pharmacological interventions such as ‘talking therapies’ within this context. Chaplaincy is one such ‘talking therapy’ but within primary care its evidence base is sparse with only one quantitative study to date. There is therefore a need to evaluate PCC excluding those co-prescribed antidepressants, as this is not evidenced in the literature as yet. PCC also needs to be directly compared with the use of antidepressants to justify its use as a valid alternative treatment for loss of well-being and depression.

Methods

This was a retrospective observational study based on routinely collected data. There were 107 patients in the PCC group and 106 in the antidepressant group. Socio-demographic data were collected. Their pre- and post-intervention (either chaplaincy or antidepressant) well-being was assessed, by the Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS) which is a validated Likert scale.

Findings

The majority of both groups were female with both groups showing marked ethnic homogeneity. PCC was associated with a significant and clinically meaningful improvement in well-being at a mean follow-up of 80 days. This treatment effect was maintained after those co-prescribed antidepressants were removed. PCC was associated with an improvement in well-being similar to that of antidepressants with no significant difference between the two groups.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Correspondence to: Dr Gordon Macdonald, Regent Gardens Medical Practice, 18 Union St, Kirkintilloch, Glasgow G66 1DH, UK. Email: Gordon.macdonald@nhs.net
References
Hide All
Amick, H.R., Gartlehner, G., Gaynes, B.N., Forneris, C., Asher, G.N., Morgan, L.C., Coker-Schwimmer, E., Boland, E., Lux, L.J., Gaylord, S., Bann, C., Pierl, C.B. and Lohr, K.N. 2015: Comparative benefits and harms of second generation antidepressants and cognitive behavioral therapies in initial treatment of major depressive disorder: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 351, h6019.
Barnett, K., Mercer, S.W., Norbury, M., Watt, G., Wyke, S. and Guthrie, B. 2012: Epidemiology of multimorbidity and implications for health care, research, and medical education: a cross-sectional study. Lancet 380, 3743.
Bartram, D.J., Sinclair, J.M. and Baldwin, D.S. 2013: Further validation of the Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS) in the UK veterinary profession: Rasch analysis. Quality of Life Research 22, 379391.
Bet, P.M., Hugtenburg, J.G., Penninx, B.W. and Hoogendijk, W.J. 2013: Side effects of antidepressants during long-term use in a naturalistic setting. European Neuropsychopharmacology 23, 14431451.
Braunholtz, S., Davidson, S., Myant, K. and O’Conner, R. 2007: Well? What do you think? (2006). The third national survey of Scottish attitudes to mental health, mental wellbeing and mental health problems, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh.
Brown, S.J.K. 2008: Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale (WEMWBS). Edited by Parkinson, J., User guide version 1. NHS Health Scotland.
Bryson, P., Dawlatly, S., Hughes, A., Bryson, E. and Petra, H. 2012: Honouring personhood in patients: the added value of chaplaincy in general practice. England: Whole Person Health Trust.
Bunniss, S.M.H. 2013: Community chaplaincy listening: practical theology in action. Scottish Journal of Healthcare Chaplaincy 16 (Special), 4251.
Christensen, K., Doblhammer, G., Rau, R. and Vaupel, J.W. 2009: Ageing populations: the challenges ahead. Lancet 374, 11961208.
Cimpean, D. and Drake, R.E. 2011: Treating co-morbid chronic medical conditions and anxiety/depression. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 20, 141150.
Delgado-Guay, M.O. 2014: Spirituality and religiosity in supportive and palliative care. Current Opinion in Supportive and Palliative Care 8, 308313.
DOH 2011: Talking therapies: A four year plan of action. A supporting document to No health without Mental Health: A cross-government mental health outcomes strategy for people of all ages. p. 224. Retrieved 8 August 2016 from https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/talking-therapies-a-4-year-plan-of-action
Donatella, B. 2012. The performance of the Warwick Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale as a screening tool for depression in the UK and in Italy. Italy: University of Bologna.
Dowrick, C. and Frances, A. 2013: Medicalising unhappiness: new classification of depression risks more patients being put on drug treatment from which they will not benefit. BMJ 347, f7140.
Ehman, J.W., Ott, B.B., Short, T.H., Ciampa, R.C. and Hansen-Flaschen, J. 1999: Do patients want physicians to inquire about their spiritual or religious beliefs if they become gravely ill? Archives of Internal Medicine 159, 18031806.
Gray, P. 2015: Politicians vie to support access to talking therapies on NHS. BMJ 350, h896.
Hanlon, P., Carlisle, S., Hannah, M., Reilly, D. and Lyon, A. 2011: Making the case for a ‘fifth wave’ in public health. Public Health 125, 3036.
Hofmann, B. 2016: Obesity as a socially defined disease: philosophical considerations and implications for policy and care. Health Care Analysis 24, 86100.
Kevern, P. and Hill, L. 2015: ‘Chaplains for well-being’ in primary care: analysis of the results of a retrospective study. Primary Health Care Research & Development 16, 8799.
Kevern, P. and Ladbury, I. 2015: Resource implications of a measured change in patient wellbeing: a retrospective cohort analysis study. The Journal of New Writing in Health and Social Care 2.
King, M.B. and Koenig, H.G. 2009: Conceptualising spirituality for medical research and health service provision. BMC Health Services Research 9, 116.
Maheswaran, H., Weich, S., Powell, J. and Stewart-Brown, S. 2012: Evaluating the responsiveness of the Warwick Edinburgh Mental Well-Being Scale (WEMWBS): group and individual level analysis. Health and Quality of Life Outcomes 10, 156.
Mair, F.S. and May, C.R. 2014: Thinking about the burden of treatment. BMJ 349, g6680.
Manning, L.K. 2014: Enduring as lived experience: exploring the essence of spiritual resilience for women in late life. Journal of Religion and Health 53, 352362.
Maslow, A.H. 1943: A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review 50, 370396.
Maslow, A.H. 1970 [1964]. Religions, experience and peak values. New York: Penguin.
Mathers, N. 2014: James Mackenzie Lecture 2013: the Tao of family medicine. British Journal of General Practice 64, e675e677.
Mcsherry, W., Boughey, A. and Kevern, P. 2016: ‘Chaplains for wellbeing’ in primary care: a qualitative investigation of their perceived impact for patients’ health and wellbeing. Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy 22, 151170.
Moscrop, A. 2011: Medicalisation, morality, and addiction: why we should be wary of problem gamblers in primary care. British Journal of General Practice 61, e836e838.
Mowat, H.B. and S. Kelly, E. 2012: Community chaplaincy listening: working with general practioner to support patient wellbeing. Scottish Journal of Healthcare Chaplaincy 15 (1), 2735.
Moynihan, R. 2011: Medicalization. A new deal on disease definition. BMJ 342, d2548.
Oliver, D. 2012: 21st century health services for an ageing population: 10 challenges for general practice. British Journal of General Practice 62, 396397.
Pargament, K. 1999: The psychology of religion and spirituality? Yes and no. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 9, 316.
Price, J., Cole, V., Doll, H. and Goodwin, G.M. 2012: The Oxford Questionnaire on the Emotional Side-effects of Antidepressants (OQuESA): development, validity, reliability and sensitivity to change. Journal of Affective Disorders 140, 6674.
Puchalski, C., Ferrell, B., Virani, R., Otis-Green, S., Baird, P., Bull, J., Chochinov, H., Handzo, G., Nelson-Becker, H., Prince-Paul, M., Pugliese, K. and Sulmasy, D. 2009: Improving the quality of spiritual care as a dimension of palliative care: the report of the consensus conference. Journal of Palliative Medicine 12, 885904.
Radloff, L.S. 1977: The CES-D scale. Applied Psychological Measurement I (3), 385401.
Scottish Executive Health Department HDL 2002: 76 spiritual care in NHSScotland, SEHD HDL. Guidelines on Chaplaincy and Spiritual Care in the NHS in Scotland. Retrieved 18 August 2016 from www.sehd.scot.nhs.uk/mels/hdl2002_76.pdf
Scottish Government Department of Health and Wellbeing 2008: Spiritual care and chaplaincy in NHSScotland CEL 49, SGDH. Guidelines on Chaplaincy and Spiritual Care in the NHS in Scotland, Annex A Paragraph 5-17. Retrieved 18 August 2016 from www.sehd.scot.nhs.uk/mels/CEL2008_49.pdf
Tanyi, R.A. 2002: Towards clarification of the meaning of spirituality. Journal of Advanced Nursing 39, 500509.
Tennant, R., Hiller, L., Fishwick, R., Platt, S., Joseph, S., Weich, S., Parkinson, J., Secker, J. and Stewart-Brown, S. 2007: The Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS): development and UK validation. Health and Quality of Life Outcomes 5, 63.
Vallurupalli, M., Lauderdale, K., Balboni, M.J., Phelps, A.C., Block, S.D., Ng, A.K., Kachnic, L.A., Vanderweele, T.J. and Balboni, T.A. 2012: The role of spirituality and religious coping in the quality of life of patients with advanced cancer receiving palliative radiation therapy. Journal of Supportive Oncology 10, 8187.
Van Der Heyden, J.H., Gisle, L., Hesse, E., Demarest, S., Drieskens, S. and Tafforeau, J. 2009: Gender differences in the use of anxiolytics and antidepressants: a population based study. Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety 18, 11011110.
Vazquez, F.L., Blanco, V. and Lopez, M. 2007: An adaptation of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale for use in non-psychiatric Spanish populations. Psychiatry Research 149, 247252.
Vermandere, M., De Lepeleire, J., Smeets, L., Hannes, K., Van Mechelen, W., Warmenhoven, F., Van Rijswijk, E. and Aertgeerts, B. 2011: Spirituality in general practice: a qualitative evidence synthesis. British Journal of General Practice 61, e749e760.
Williams, J.A., Meltzer, D., Arora, V., Chung, G. and Curlin, F.A. 2011: Attention to inpatients’ religious and spiritual concerns: predictors and association with patient satisfaction. Journal of General Internal Medicine 26, 12651271.
Wise, J. 2014: Only half of patients referred for talking therapies enter treatment. BMJ 348, g295.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Primary Health Care Research & Development
  • ISSN: 1463-4236
  • EISSN: 1477-1128
  • URL: /core/journals/primary-health-care-research-and-development
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed