Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Kinds versus continua: a review of psychometric approaches to uncover the structure of psychiatric constructs

  • D. Borsboom (a1), M. Rhemtulla (a1), A. O. J. Cramer (a1), H. L. J. van der Maas (a1), M. Scheffer (a2) and C. V. Dolan (a3)...
Abstract

The question of whether psychopathology constructs are discrete kinds or continuous dimensions represents an important issue in clinical psychology and psychiatry. The present paper reviews psychometric modelling approaches that can be used to investigate this question through the application of statistical models. The relation between constructs and indicator variables in models with categorical and continuous latent variables is discussed, as are techniques specifically designed to address the distinction between latent categories as opposed to continua (taxometrics). In addition, we examine latent variable models that allow latent structures to have both continuous and categorical characteristics, such as factor mixture models and grade-of-membership models. Finally, we discuss recent alternative approaches based on network analysis and dynamical systems theory, which entail that the structure of constructs may be continuous for some individuals but categorical for others. Our evaluation of the psychometric literature shows that the kinds–continua distinction is considerably more subtle than is often presupposed in research; in particular, the hypotheses of kinds and continua are not mutually exclusive or exhaustive. We discuss opportunities to go beyond current research on the issue by using dynamical systems models, intra-individual time series and experimental manipulations.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: D. Borsboom, Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam, Weesperplein 4, Amsterdam 1018 XA, The Netherlands. (Email: d.borsboom@uva.nl)
References
Hide All
Adolf J, Schuurman NK, Borkenau P, Borsboom D, Dolan CV (2014). Measurement invariance within and between individuals: a distinct problem in testing the equivalence of intra- and inter-individual model structures. Frontiers in Quantitative Psychology and Measurement 5, 883.
Agresti A (2013). Categorical Data Analysis. Wiley: New York.
Ahmed AO, Buckley PF, Mabe PA (2012). Latent structure of psychotic experiences in the general population. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavia 125, 5465.
American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edn. American Psychiatric Publishing: Arlington, VA.
Arminger G, Stein P, Wittenberg J (1999). Mixtures of conditional mean- and covariance-structure models. Psychometrika 64, 475494.
Asparouhov T, Muthén B (2008). Multilevel mixture models. In Advances in Latent Variable Mixture Models (ed. Hancock G.R. and Samuelsen K.M.), pp. 2751. Information Age Publishing, Inc.: Charlotte, NC.
Bartholomew DJ (1987). Latent Variable Models and Factor Analysis. Griffin: London.
Boker SM, Molenaar PCM, Nesselroade JR (2009). Issues in intraindividual variability: individual differences in equilibria and dynamics over multiple time scales. Psychology and Aging 24, 858862.
Bollen KA (1989). Structural Equations with Latent Variables. Wiley: New York.
Borsboom D (2005). Measuring the Mind: Conceptual Issues in Contemporary Psychometrics. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Borsboom D, Cramer AOJ (2013). Networks: an integrative approach to the structure of psychopathology. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 9, 91121.
Borsboom D, Mellenbergh GJ, Van Heerden J (2003). The theoretical status of latent variables. Psychological Review 110, 203219.
Bringmann LF, Lemmens LHJM, Huibers MJH, Borsboom D, Tuerlinckx F (2015). Revealing the dynamic network structure of the Beck Depression Inventory-II. Psychological Medicine 45, 747757.
Bringmann LF, Vissers N, Wichers M, Geschwind N, Kuppens P, Peeters F, Borsboom D, Tuerlinckx F (2013). A network approach to psychopathology: new insights into clinical longitudinal data. PLOS ONE 8, e60188.
Clark SL, Muthén B, Kaprio J, D'Onofrio BM, Viken R, Rose RJ (2013). Models and strategies for factor mixture analysis: an example concerning the structure underlying psychological disorders. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal 20, 681703.
Cooper G, Humphry SM (2012). The ontological distinction between units and entities. Synthese 187, 393401.
Cramer AOJ (2013). The glue of (ab)normal mental life: networks of interacting thoughts, feelings and behaviors. Ph.D. Thesis (http://dare.uva.nl/record/452479). Accessed September 2015.
Cramer AOJ, Borsboom D, Aggen SH, Kendler KS (2012 a). The pathoplasticity of dysphoric episodes: differential impact of stressful life events on the patterns of depressive symptom inter-correlations. Psychological Medicine 42, 957965.
Cramer AOJ, van der Sluis S, Noordhof A, Wichers M, Geschwind N, Aggen SH, Kendler KS, Borsboom D (2012 b). Dimensions of normal personality as networks in search of equilibrium: you can't like parties if you don't like people. European Journal of Personality 26, 414431.
Cramer AOJ, Waldorp LJ, van der Maas HLJ, Borsboom D (2010). Comorbidity: a network perspective. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33, 137193.
Cronbach LJ, Meehl PE (1955). Construct validity in psychological tests. Psychological Bulletin 52, 281302.
Croon MA (1990). Latent class analysis with ordered latent classes. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 43, 171192.
De Boeck P, Wilson M, Acton GS (2005). A conceptual and psychometric framework for distinguishing categories and dimensions. Psychological Review 112, 129158.
Dolan CV, Van der Maas HLJ (1998). Fitting multivariate normal finite mixtures subject to structural equation modeling. Psychometrika 63, 227253.
Dutilh G, Wagenmakers EJ, Visser I, Van der Maas HLJ (2010). A phase transition model for the speed–accuracy trade-off in response time experiments. Cognitive Science 34, 211250.
Epskamp S, Cramer AOJ, Waldorp LJ, Schmittmann VD, Borsboom D (2012). qgraph: Network visualizations of relationships in psychometric data. Journal of Statistical Software 48, 118.
Erosheva EA (2005). Comparing latent structures of the grade of membership, Rasch, and latent class models. Psychometrika 70, 619628.
Forbes D, Haslam N, Williams BJ, Creamer M (2005). Testing the latent structure of posttraumatic stress disorder: a taxometric study of combat veterans. Journal of Traumatic Stress 18, 647656.
Halpin PF, Dolan CV, Grasman RPPP, De Boeck P (2011). On the relation between the linear factor model and the latent profile model. Psychometrika 76, 564583.
Hamaker EL, Nesselroade JR, Molenaar CM (2007). The integrated trait–state model. Journal of Research in Personality 41, 295315.
Haslam N, Holland E, Kuppens P (2012). Categories versus dimensions in personality and psychopathology: a quantitative review of taxometric research. Psychological Medicine 42, 903.
Hölder O (1901). Die Axiome der Quantität und die Lehre vom Mass (The axioms of quantity and the doctrine of weight). Ber. Verh. Kgl. Sächsis. Ges. Wiss. Leipzig, Math.-Phys. Classe 53, 164.
Hyland ME (2011). The Origins of Health and Disease. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
Jablensky A (2006). Subtyping schizophrenia: implications for genetic research. Molecular Psychiatry 11, 815836.
Jablensky A (2010). The diagnostic concept of schizophrenia: its history, evolution, and future prospects. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience 12, 271287.
Kendler KS, Zachar P, Craver C (2011). What kinds of things are psychiatric disorders? Psychological Medicine 41, 11431150.
Kindermann R, Snell JL (1980). Markov Random Fields and their Applications. American Mathematical Society: Providence, RI.
Kraepelin E, Dierendorf AR (1915). Clinical Psychiatry. A Textbook for Students and Physicians. The MacMillan Company: New York.
Krantz DH, Luce RD, Suppes P, Tversky A (1971). Foundations of Measurement, vol. I. Academic Press: New York.
Kuppens P, Allen NB, Sheeber LB (2010). Emotional inertia and psychological maladjustment. Psychological Science 21, 984991.
Lazarsfeld PF, Henry NW (1968). Latent Structure Analysis. Houghton-Mifflin: Boston, MA.
Lord FM, Novick MR (1968). Statistical Theories of Mental Test Scores. Addison-Welsley: Reading, MA.
Lubke GH, Miller PJ (2015). Does nature have joints worth carving? A discussion of taxometrics, model-based clustering and latent variable mixture modeling. Psychological Medicine 45, 705715.
Lubke GH, Muthén B (2005). Investigating population heterogeneity with factor mixture models. Psychological Methods 10, 2139.
Lubke GH, Neale M (2006). Distinguishing between latent classes and continuous factors: resolution by maximum likelihood. Multivariate Behavioral Research 41, 499532.
Lubke GH, Neale M (2008). Distinguishing between latent classes and continuous factors with categorical outcomes: class invariance of parameters of factor mixture models. Multivariate Behavioral Research 43, 592620.
MacCallum RC, Zhang S, Preacher KJ, Rucker DD (2002). On the practice of dichotomization of quantitative variables. Psychological Methods 7, 1940.
Manton KG, Korten A, Woodbury MA, Anker M, Jablensky A (1994). Symptom profiles of psychiatric disorders based on graded disease classes: an illustration using data from the WHO International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia. Psychological Medicine 24, 133144.
Maraun MD, Slaney K (2005). An analysis of Meehl's MAXCOV-HITMAX procedure for continuous indicators. Multivariate Behavioral Research 40, 489518.
Maraun MD, Slaney K, Goddyn L (2003). An analysis of Meehl's MAXCOV-HITMAX procedure for dichotomous indicators. Multivariate Behavioral Research 38, 81112.
Markus KA, Borsboom D (2012). The cat came back: evaluating arguments against psychological measurement. Theory and Psychology 22, 452466.
Markus KA, Borsboom D (2013). Frontiers of Test Validity Theory: Measurement, Causation, and Meaning. Routledge: New York.
Masyn K, Henderson C, Greenbaum P (2010). Exploring the latent structures of psychological constructs in social development using the dimensional–categorical spectrum. Social Development 19, 470493.
McCutcheon AL (1987). Latent Class Analysis. Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences Series no. 64. Sage: Thousand Oaks, CA.
McGrath RE, Walters GD (2012). Taxometric analysis as a general strategy for distinguishing categorical from dimensional latent structure. Psychological Methods 17, 284293.
McLachlan G, Peel D (2000). Finite Mixture Models. Wiley: New York.
Meehl PE (1992). Factors and taxa, traits and types, difference of degree and differences in kind. Journal of Personality 60, 117174.
Meehl PE (1995). Bootstraps taxometrics: solving the classification problem in psychopathology. American Psychologist 50, 266275.
Mellenbergh GJ (1989). Item bias and item response theory. International Journal of Educational Research 13, 127143.
Mellenbergh GJ (1994). Generalized linear item response theory. Psychological Bulletin 115, 300307.
Meredith W (1993). Measurement invariance, factor analysis, and factorial invariance. Psychometrika 58, 525543.
Michell J (1997). Quantitative science and the definition of measurement in psychology. British Journal of Psychology 88, 355383.
Michell J (1999). Measurement in Psychology: A Critical History of a Methodological Concept. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
Molenaar D, Dolan CV, Verhelst ND (2010). Testing and modeling non-normality within the one factor model. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 63, 293317.
Molenaar PCM (2004). A manifesto on psychology as idiographic science: bringing the person back into scientific psychology, this time forever. Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives 2, 201218.
Molenaar PCM, Campbell CG (2009). The new person-specific paradigm in psychology. Current Directions in Psychology 18, 112117.
Molenaar PCM, Lerner RM, Newell KM (2013). Handbook of Developmental Systems. Guilford: New York.
Molenaar PCM, Von Eye A (1994). On the arbitrary nature of latent variables. In Latent Variables Analysis (ed. Von Eye A. and Clogg C.C.), pp. 226242. Sage Publications: Thousand Oaks, CA.
Montpetit MA, Bergeman CS, Deboeck PR, Tiberio SS, Boker SM (2010). Resilience-as-process: negative affect, stress, and coupled dynamical systems. Psychology and Aging 25, 631640.
Muthén B (2006). Should substance use disorders be considered as categorical or dimensional? Addiction 101 (Suppl. 1), 616.
Muthén B (2008). Latent variable hybrids: overview of old and new models. In Advances in Latent Variable Mixture Models (ed. Hancock G. R. and Samuelsen K. M.), pp. 124. Information Age: Charlotte, NC.
Nurnberg HG, Woodbury MA, Bogenschutz MP (1999). A mathematical typology analysis of DSM-III-R personality disorder. Comprehensive Psychiatry 40, 6171.
Pe ML, Kircanski K, Thompson RJ, Bringmann LF, Tuerlinckx F, Mestdagh M, Mata J, Jaeggi SM, Buschkuehl M, Jonides J, Kuppens P, Gotlib IH (2015). Emotion-network density in major depressive disorder. Clinical Psychological Science 3, 292300.
Pearl J (2009). Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
Reise SP, Waller NG (2009). Item response theory and clinical measurement. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 5, 2748.
Robitzsch A (2014). sirt: Supplementary Item Response Theory Models. R package version 0.47–36 (http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/sirt/). Accessed September 2015.
Ruscio J, Haslam N, Ruscio AM (2006). Introduction to the Taxometric Method: A Practical Guide. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah, NJ.
Ruscio J, Ruscio AM, Meron M (2007). Applying the bootstrap to taxometric analysis: generating empirical sampling distributions to help interpret results. Multivariate Behavioral Research 42, 349386.
Scheffer M, Bascompte J, Brock WA, Brovkin V, Carpenter SR, Dakos V, Held H, van Nes EH, Rietkerk M, Sugihara G (2009). Early-warning signals for critical transitions. Nature 461, 5359.
Scheffer M, Carpenter SR, Lenton TM, Bascompte J, Brock W, Dakos V, van de Koppel J, van de Leemput IA, Levin SA, van Nes EH, Pascual M, Vandermeer J (2012). Anticipating critical transitions. Science 338, 344348.
Schmitt JE, Aggen SH, Mehta PD, Kubarych TS, Neale MC (2006). Semi-nonparametric methods for detecting latent non-normality: a fusion of latent trait and ordered latent class modeling. Multivariate Behavioral Research 41, 427443.
Stevens SS (1946). On the theory of scales of measurement. Science 103, 667680.
Suppes P, Zinnes JL (1963). Basic measurement theory. In Handbook of Mathematical Psychology (ed. Luce R.D., Bush R. and Galanter E.), pp. 376. Wiley: New York.
Tao T (2011). An Introduction to Measure Theory. American Mathematical Society: Providence, RI.
Thom R (1975). Structural Stability and Morphogenesis. Benjamin Press: Reading, MA.
Trendler G (2009). Measurement theory, psychology, and the revolution that cannot happen. Theory and Psychology 19, 579599.
Van Borkulo CD, Borsboom D, Epskamp S, Blanken TF, Boschloo L, Schoevers RA, Waldorp LJ (2014). A new method for constructing networks from binary data. Scientific Reports 4, 5918.
Van de Leemput IA, Wichers M, Cramer AOJ, Borsboom D, Tuerlinckx F, Kuppens P, Van Nes EH, Viechtbauer W, Giltay EJ, Aggen SH, Derom C, Jacobs N, Kendler KS, Van der Maas HLJ, Neale MC, Peeters F, Thiery E, Zachar P, Scheffer M (2014). Critical slowing down as early warning for the onset and termination of depression. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 111, 8792.
Van der Maas HLJ, Molenaar PCM (1992). Stagewise cognitive development: an application of catastrophe theory. Psychological Review 99, 395417.
Van der Sluis S, Posthuma D, Nivard MG, Verhage M, Dolan CV (2013). Power in GWAS: lifting the curse of the clinical cut-off. Molecular Psychiatry 18, 23.
Verkuilen J, Kievit RA, Zand Scholten A (2011). Representing concepts by fuzzy sets. In Concepts and Fuzzy Logic (ed. Belohavek R. and Klir G.J.), pp. 149176. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
Vermunt JK (2001). The use of restricted latent class models for defining and testing nonparametric and parametric item response theory models. Applied Psychological Measurement 25, 283294.
Von Davier M, Naemi B, Roberts RD (2012). Factorial versus typological models: a comparison of methods for personality data. Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives 10, 185208.
Waller NG, Meehl PE (1998). Multivariate Taxometric Procedures: Distinguishing Types from Continua. Sage: Thousand Oaks, CA.
Wichers M (2014). The dynamic nature of depression: a new micro-level perspective of mental disorder that meets current challenges. Psychological Medicine 44, 13491360.
Woodbury MA, Manton KG (1989). Grade of membership analysis of depression-related psychiatric disorders. Sociological Methods and Research 18, 126163.
World Health Organization (1992). International Statistical Classification of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of Death. Sixth Revision of the International List of Diseases and Causes of Death. World Health Organization: Geneva.
Yung YF (1997). Finite mixtures in confirmatory factor-analysis models. Psychometrika 62, 297330.
Zeeman EC (1977). Catastrophe Theory: Selected Papers. Addison-Wesley: Reading, MA.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 13
Total number of PDF views: 224 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 617 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.