Skip to main content
×
Home

Psychological treatments for early psychosis can be beneficial or harmful, depending on the therapeutic alliance: an instrumental variable analysis

  • L. P. Goldsmith (a1), S. W. Lewis (a2), G. Dunn (a2) and R. P. Bentall (a3)
Abstract
Background

The quality of the therapeutic alliance (TA) has been invoked to explain the equal effectiveness of different psychotherapies, but prior research is correlational, and does not address the possibility that individuals who form good alliances may have good outcomes without therapy.

Method

We evaluated the causal effect of TA using instrumental variable (structural equation) modelling on data from a three-arm, randomized controlled trial of 308 people in an acute first or second episode of a non-affective psychosis. The trial compared cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) over 6 weeks plus routine care (RC) v. supportive counselling (SC) plus RC v. RC alone. We examined the effect of TA, as measured by the client-rated CALPAS, on the primary trial 18-month outcome of symptom severity (PANSS), which was assessed blind to treatment allocation.

Results

Both adjunctive CBT and SC improved 18-month outcomes, compared to RC. We showed that, for both psychological treatments, improving TA improves symptomatic outcome. With a good TA, attending more sessions causes a significantly better outcome on PANSS total score [effect size −2.91, 95% confidence interval (CI) −0.90 to −4.91]. With a poor TA, attending more sessions is detrimental (effect size +7.74, 95% CI +1.03 to +14.45).

Conclusions

This is the first ever demonstration that TA has a causal effect on symptomatic outcome of a psychological treatment, and that poor TA is actively detrimental. These effects may extend to other therapeutic modalities and disorders.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Psychological treatments for early psychosis can be beneficial or harmful, depending on the therapeutic alliance: an instrumental variable analysis
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Dropbox account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Psychological treatments for early psychosis can be beneficial or harmful, depending on the therapeutic alliance: an instrumental variable analysis
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Google Drive account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Psychological treatments for early psychosis can be beneficial or harmful, depending on the therapeutic alliance: an instrumental variable analysis
      Available formats
      ×
Copyright
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Corresponding author
* Address for correspondence: R. P. Bentall, Department of Psychological Sciences, Liverpool University, Liverpool L69 3GL, UK. (Email: richard.bentall@liverpool.ac.uk)
References
Hide All
Cape J, Whittington C, Buszewicz M, Wallace P, Underwood L (2010). Brief psychological therapies for anxiety and depression in primary care: meta-analysis and meta-regression. BMC Medicine 8, 3851.
Cuijpers P, van Straten A, Andersson G, van Oppen P (2008). Psychotherapy for depression in adults: a meta-analysis of comparative outcome studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76, 909922.
Davis LW, Lysaker PH (2007). Therapeutic alliance and improvements in work performance over time in patients with schizophrenia. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders 195, 353357.
Day JC, Bentall RP, Roberts C, Randall F, Rogers A, Cattell D, Healy D, Rae P, Power C (2005). Attitudes toward antipsychotic medication: the impact of clinical variables and relationships with health professionals. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 717724.
Dunn G, Bentall R (2007). Modelling treatment-effect heterogeneity in randomized controlled trials of complex interventions (psychological treatments). Statistics in Medicine 26, 47194745.
Dunn G, Fowler D, Rollinson R, Freeman D, Kuipers E, Smith B, Steel C, Onuwmere J, Jolley S, Garety P, Bebbington P (2012). Effective elements of cognitive behaviour therapy for psychosis: results of a novel type of subgroup analysis based on principal stratification. Psychological Medicine 42, 10571068.
Dunn H, Morrison AP, Bentall RP (2006). The relationship between patient suitability, therapeutic alliance, homework compliance and outcome in cognitive therapy for psychosis. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 13, 145152.
Enders CK, Bandalos DL (2001). The relative performance of full information maximum likelihood estimation for missing data in structural equation models. Structural Equation Modelling 8, 430457.
Frank AF, Gunderson JG (1990). The role of therapeutic alliance in the treatment of schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 47, 228236.
Green J, Dunn G (2008). Using intervention trials in developmental psychiatry to illuminate basic science. British Journal of Psychiatry 192, 323325.
Gunderson JG, Frank AF, Katz HM, Vannicelli ML, Frosch JP, Knapp PH (1984). Effects of psychotherapy in schizophrenia: II. Comparative outcome of two forms of treatment. Schizophrenia Bulletin 10, 564598.
Haddock G, Devane S, Bradshaw T, McGovern J, Tarrier N, Kinderman P, Baguley I, Lancashire S, Harris N (2001). An investigation into the psychometric properties of the cognitive therapy scale for psychosis (CTS-Psy). Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 29, 93106.
Halpern JY, Pearl J (2005). Causes and explanations: a structural model approach. Part 1: causes. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 56, 843887.
Horvath AO, Symonds BD (2001). Relation between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy: a meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 38, 139149.
Howgego IM, Yellowlees P, Owen C, Meldrum L, Dark F (2003). The therapeutic alliance: the key to effective patient outcome? A descriptive review of the evidence in community mental health case management. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 37, 169183.
Jauhar S, McKenna PJ, Radua E, Fung R, Salvador R, Laws KR (2014). Cognitive-behavioural therapy for the symptoms of schizophrenia: systematic review and meta-analysis with examination of potential bias. British Journal of Psychiatry 204, 2029.
Johansson H, Eklund M (2006). Helping alliance and early dropout from psychiatric out-patient care: the influence of patient factors. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 41, 140147.
Jones C, Hacker D, Cormac I, Meaden A, Irving CB (2012). Cognitive behavioural therapy versus other psychosocial treatments for schizophrenia (Review). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2012. Art. no.: CD008712. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008712.pub2.
Kay SR, Fiszbein A, Opler LA (1987). The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) for schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin 13, 507518.
Krupnick JL, Sotsky SM, Simmens S, Moyer J, Elkin I, Watkins J, Pilkonis PA (1996). The role of the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy outcome: findings in the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 64, 532539.
Lewis SW, Tarrier N, Haddock G, Bentall R, Kinderman P, Kingdon D, Siddle R, Drake R, Everitt K, Leadley K, Benn A, Grazebrook K, Haley C, Akhtar S, Davies L, Palmer S, Faragher B, Dunn G (2002). Randomised controlled trial of cognitive behaviour therapy in early schizophrenia: acute-phase outcomes. British Journal of Psychiatry 181 (Suppl. 43), 9197.
Marmar CR, Gaston L, Gallagher D, Thompson LW (1989). Towards the validation of the California Therapeutic Alliance Rating System. Psychological Assessment 1, 4652.
Martin DJ, Garske JP, Davis MK (2000). Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: a meta-analytic review. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 68, 438450.
McCabe R, Bullenkamp J, Hansson L, Lauber C, Martinez-Leal R, Rössler W, Salize HJ, Svensson B, Torres-Gonzalez F, van den Brink R, Wiersama D, Priebe S (2012). The therapeutic relationship and adherence to antipsychotic medication in schizophrenia. PLoS ONE 7, 4, e36080.
McCabe R, Priebe S (2008). Communication and psychosis: it's good to talk, but how? British Journal of Psychiatry 192, 404405.
McLeod BD (2011). The relation of the alliance with outcomes in youth psychotherapy: a meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 31, 603616.
Pearl J (1998). Graphs, causality and structural equation models. Sociological Methods and Research 27, 226.
Rogers CR (1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology 21, 95103.
Sensky T, Turkington D, Kingdon D, Scott JL, Scot J, Siddle R, O'Carroll M, Barnes TRE (2000). A randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavioral therapy for persistent symptoms in schizophrenia resistant to medication. Archives of General Psychiatry 57, 165172.
StataCorp (2013). Stata Statistical Software: Release 13. StataCorp LP: College Station, TX.
Svensson B, Hansson L (2007). Therapeutic alliance in cognitive therapy for schizophrenic and other long-term mentally ill patients: development and relationship to outcome in an in-patient treatment programme. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 99, 281287.
Tarrier N, Kinney C, McCarthy E, Humphreys L, Wittkowski A, Morris J (2000). Two-year follow-up of cogitve-behavioral therapy and supportive counselling in the treatment of persistent symptoms in chronic schizophrenia. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 68, 917922.
Tarrier N, Lewis SW, Haddock G, Bentall R, Drake R, Kinderman P, Kingdon D, Siddle R, Everitt J, Leadley K, Benn A, Grazebrook K, Haley C, Akhtar S, Davies L, Palmer S, Dunn G (2004). Cognitive-behavioural therapy in first-episode and early schizophrenia: 18-month follow-up of a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 184, 231239.
Tarrier N, Wykes T (2004). Is there evidence that cognitive behaviour therapy is an effective treatment for schizophrenia? A cautious or cautionary tale? Behaviour Research and Therapy 42, 13771401.
Turner DT, van der Gaag M (2014). Psychological Interventions for Psychosis: a meta-analysis of comparative outcome studies. American Journal of Psychiatry 171, 523538.
Wampold BE (2001). The Great Psychotherapy Debate: Models, Methods and Findings. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah, NJ.
Wykes T, Steel C, Everitt B, Tarrier N (2008). Cognitive behavior therapy for schizophrenia: effect sizes, clinical models, and methodological rigor. Schizophrenia Bulletin 34, 523537.
Yuan K-H, Yang-Wallentin F, Bentler PM (2012). ML versus MI for missing data with violation of distribution conditions. Sociological Methods and Research 41, 598629.
Zimmermann G, Favrod J, Trieu VH, Pomini V (2005). The effect of cognitive behavioural treatment on the positive symptoms of schizophrenia spectrum disorders: a meta-analysis. Schizophrenia Research 77, 19.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 68
Total number of PDF views: 852 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1278 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.