Skip to main content

Trajectories of PTSD risk and resilience in World Trade Center responders: an 8-year prospective cohort study

  • R. H. Pietrzak (a1) (a2) (a3), A. Feder (a3), R. Singh (a3), C. B. Schechter (a4), E. J. Bromet (a5), C. L. Katz (a3), D. B. Reissman (a6), F. Ozbay (a3), V. Sharma (a3), M. Crane (a7), D. Harrison (a8), R. Herbert (a7), S. M. Levin (a7), B. J. Luft (a9), J. M. Moline (a10), J. M. Stellman (a11), I. G. Udasin (a12), P. J. Landrigan (a7) and S. M. Southwick (a1) (a2) (a3)...

Longitudinal symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are often characterized by heterogeneous trajectories, which may have unique pre-, peri- and post-trauma risk and protective factors. To date, however, no study has evaluated the nature and determinants of predominant trajectories of PTSD symptoms in World Trade Center (WTC) responders.


A total of 10835 WTC responders, including 4035 professional police responders and 6800 non-traditional responders (e.g. construction workers) who participated in the WTC Health Program (WTC-HP), were evaluated an average of 3, 6 and 8 years after the WTC attacks.


Among police responders, longitudinal PTSD symptoms were best characterized by four classes, with the majority (77.8%) in a resistant/resilient trajectory and the remainder exhibiting chronic (5.3%), recovering (8.4%) or delayed-onset (8.5%) symptom trajectories. Among non-traditional responders, a six-class solution was optimal, with fewer responders in a resistant/resilient trajectory (58.0%) and the remainder exhibiting recovering (12.3%), severe chronic (9.5%), subsyndromal increasing (7.3%), delayed-onset (6.7%) and moderate chronic (6.2%) trajectories. Prior psychiatric history, Hispanic ethnicity, severity of WTC exposure and WTC-related medical conditions were most strongly associated with symptomatic trajectories of PTSD symptoms in both groups of responders, whereas greater education and family and work support while working at the WTC site were protective against several of these trajectories.


Trajectories of PTSD symptoms in WTC responders are heterogeneous and associated uniquely with pre-, peri- and post-trauma risk and protective factors. Police responders were more likely than non-traditional responders to exhibit a resistant/resilient trajectory. These results underscore the importance of prevention, screening and treatment efforts that target high-risk disaster responders, particularly those with prior psychiatric history, high levels of trauma exposure and work-related medical morbidities.

Corresponding author
* Address for correspondence: R. H. Pietrzak, Ph.D., M.P.H., National Center for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, VA Connecticut Healthcare System, Yale University School of Medicine, 950 Campbell Avenue 151E, West Haven, CT 06516, USA. (Email:
Hide All
Alexander DA (1993). Stress among police body handlers. A long-term follow-up. British Journal of Psychiatry 163, 806808.
Alexander DA, Wells A (1991). Reactions of police officers to body-handling after a major disaster. A before-and-after comparison. British Journal of Psychiatry 159, 547555.
Berninger A, Webber MP, Cohen HW, Gustave J, Lee R, Niles JK, Chiu S, Zeig-Owens R, Soo J, Kelly K, Prezant DJ (2010 a). Trends of elevated PTSD risk in firefighters exposed to the World Trade Center disaster: 2001–2005. Public Health Reports 125, 556566.
Berninger A, Webber MP, Niles JK, Gustave J, Lee R, Cohen HW, Kelly K, Corrigan M, Prezant DJ (2010 b). Longitudinal study of probable post-traumatic stress disorder in firefighters exposed to the World Trade Center disaster. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 53, 11771185.
Blanchard EB, Jones-Alexander J, Buckley TC, Forneris CA (1996). Psychometric properties of the PTSD Checklist (PCL). Behaviour Research and Therapy 34, 669673.
Bonanno GA, Mancini AD, Horton JL, Powell TM, Leardmann CA, Boyko EJ, Wells TS, Hooper TI, Gackstetter GD, Smith TC (2012). Trajectories of trauma symptoms and resilience in deployed U.S. military service members: prospective cohort study. British Journal of Psychiary 200, 317323.
Bowler RM, Han H, Gocheva V, Nakagawa S, Alper H, DiGrande L, Cone JE (2010). Gender differences in probable posttraumatic stress disorder among police responders to the 2001 World Trade Center terrorist attack. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 53, 11861196.
Bowler RM, Harris M, Li J, Gocheva V, Stellman SD, Wilson K, Alper H, Schwarzer R, Cone JE (2012). Longitudinal mental health impact among police responders to the 9/11 terrorist attack. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 55, 297312.
Brackbill RM, Hadler JL, DiGrande L, Ekenga CC, Farfel MR, Friedman S, Perlman SE, Stellman SD, Walker DJ, Wu D, Yu S, Thorpe LE (2009). Asthma and posttraumatic stress symptoms 5 to 6 years following exposure to the World Trade Center terrorist attack. Journal of the American Medical Association 302, 502516.
Brewin CR, Andrews B, Valentine JD (2000). Meta-analysis of risk factors for posttraumatic stress disorder in trauma-exposed adults. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 68, 748766.
Bryant RA, O'Donnell ML, Creamer M, McFarlane AC, Clark CR, Silove D (2010). The psychiatric sequelae of traumatic injury. American Journal of Psychiatry 167, 312320.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2004). Mental health status of World Trade Center rescue and recovery workers and volunteers – New York City, July 2002-August 2004. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 53, 812815.
Charuvastra A, Cloitre M (2008). Social bonds and posttraumatic stress disorder. Annual Review of Psychology 59, 301328.
Chiu S, Niles JK, Webber MP, Zeig-Owens R, Gustave J, Lee R, Rizzotto L, Kelly KJ, Cohen HW, Prezant DJ (2011). Evaluating risk factors and possible mediation effects in posttraumatic depression and posttraumatic stress disorder comorbidity. Public Health Reports 126, 201209.
Cukor J, Wyka K, Jayasinghe N, Weathers F, Giosan C, Leck P, Roberts J, Spielman L, Crane M, Difede J (2011 a). Prevalence and predictors of posttraumatic stress symptoms in utility workers deployed to the World Trade Center following the attacks of September 11, 2001. Depression and Anxiety 28, 210217.
Cukor J, Wyka K, Mello B, Olden M, Jayasinghe N, Roberts J, Giosan C, Crane M, Difede J (2011 b). The longitudinal course of PTSD among disaster workers deployed to the World Trade Center following the attacks of September 11th. Journal of Traumatic Stress 24, 506514.
Curran PJ, Hussong AM (2003). The use of latent trajectory models in psychopathology research. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 112, 526544.
deRoon-Cassini TA, Mancini AD, Rusch MD, Bonanno GA (2010). Psychopathology and resilience following traumatic injury: a latent growth mixture model analysis. Rehabilitation Psychology 55, 111.
Farfel M, DiGrande L, Brackbill R, Prann A, Cone J, Friedman S, Walker DJ, Pezeshki G, Thomas P, Galea S, Williamson D, Frieden TR, Thorpe L (2008). An overview of 9/11 experiences and respiratory and mental health conditions among World Trade Center Health Registry enrollees. Journal of Urban Health 85, 880909.
Friedman MJ, Schnurr PP, McDonagh-Coyle A (1994). Post-traumatic stress disorder in the military veteran. Psychiatric Clinics of North America 17, 265277.
Goldmann E, Calabrese JR, Prescott MR, Tamburrino M, Liberzon I, Slembarski R, Shirley E, Fine T, Goto T, Wilson K, Ganocy S, Chan P, Serrano MB, Sizemore J, Galea S (2012). Potentially modifiable pre-, peri-, and postdeployment characteristics associated with deployment-related posttraumatic stress disorder among Ohio Army National Guard soldiers. Annals of Epidemiology 22, 7178.
Herbert R, Moline J, Skloot G, Metzger K, Baron S, Luft B, Markowitz S, Udasin I, Harrison D, Stein D, Todd A, Enright P, Stellman JM, Landrigan PJ, Levin SM (2006). The World Trade Center disaster and the health of workers: five-year assessment of a unique medical screening program. Environmental Health Perspectives 114, 18531858.
Hobfoll SE, Mancini AD, Hall BJ, Canetti D, Bonanno GA (2011). The limits of resilience: distress following chronic political violence among Palestinians. Social Science and Medicine 72, 14001408.
Johnson SB, Langlieb AM, Teret SP, Gross R, Schwab M, Massa J, Ashwell L, Geyh AS (2005). Rethinking first response: effects of the clean-up and recovery effort on workers at the World Trade Center disaster site. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 47, 386391.
Kaniasty K, Norris FH (2008). Longitudinal linkages between perceived social support and posttraumatic stress symptoms: sequential roles of social causation and social selection. Journal of Traumatic Stress 21, 274281.
Kessler RC, McLaughlin KA, Koenen KC, Petukhova M, Hill ED (2012). The importance of secondary trauma exposure for post-disaster mental disorder. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 21, 3545.
Kristensen P, Weisæth L, Heir T (2012). Bereavement and mental health after sudden and violent losses: a review. Psychiatry 75, 7697.
Landau J, Mittal M, Wieling E (2008). Linking human systems: strengthening individuals, families, and communities in the wake of mass trauma. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy 34, 193209.
Landrigan PJ, Lioy PJ, Thurston G, Berkowitz G, Chen LC, Chillrud SN, Gavett SH, Georgopoulos PG, Geyh AS, Levin S, Perera F, Rappaport SM, Small C (2004). Health and environmental consequences of the World Trade Center disaster. Environmental Health Perspectives 112, 731739.
Li J, Brackbill RM, Stellman SD, Farfel MR, Miller-Archie SA, Friedman S, Walker DJ, Thorpe LE, Cone J (2011). Gastroesophageal reflux symptoms and comorbid asthma and posttraumatic stress disorder following the 9/11 terrorist attacks on World Trade Center in New York City. American Journal of Gastroenterology 106, 19331941.
Lo Y, Mendell N, Rubin D (2001). Testing the number of components in a normal mixture. Biometrika 88, 767778.
Luft BJ, Schechter C, Kotov R, Broihier J, Reissman D, Guerrera K, Udasin I, Moline J, Harrison D, Friedman-Jimenez G, Pietrzak RH, Southwick SM, Bromet EJ (2012). Exposure, probable PTSD and lower respiratory illness among World Trade Center rescue, recovery and clean-up workers. Psychological Medicine 42, 10691079.
McLachlan G, Peel D (2000). Finite Mixture Models. Wiley: New York, NY.
Muthén B (2004). Latent variable analysis: growth mixture modeling and related techniques for longitudinal data. In Handbook of Quantitative Methodology for the Social Sciences (ed. Kaplan D.), pp. 345368. Sage Publications: Newbury Park, CA.
Muthén B, Muthén L (2002). Mplus: The comprehensive Modeling Program for Applied Researchers. Muthén & Muthén: Los Angeles, CA.
Nagin DS, Tremblay RE (2001). Analyzing developmental trajectories of distinct but related behaviors: a group-based method. Psychological Methods 6, 1834.
Neria Y, Gross R, Susser E (2006). 9/11 Mental Health in the Wake of Terrorist Attacks. Cambridge University Press: New York.
Norris F, Tracy M, Galea S (2009). Looking for resilience: understanding the longitudinal trajectories of responses to stress. Social Science and Medicine 68, 21902198.
Nylund KL, Asparouhov T, Muthén B (2007). Deciding on the number of classes in latent class analysis and growth mixture modeling. A Monte Carlo simulation study. Structural Equation Modeling 14, 535569.
Ozer EJ, Best SR, Lipsey TL, Weiss DS (2003). Predictors of posttraumatic stress disorder and symptoms in adults: a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 129, 5273.
Perrin MA, DiGrande L, Wheeler K, Thorpe L, Farfel M, Brackbill R (2007). Differences in PTSD prevalence and associated risk factors among World Trade Center disaster rescue and recovery workers. American Journal of Psychiatry 164, 13851394.
Pietrzak RH, Goldstein RB, Southwick SM, Grant BF (2011). Medical comorbidity of full and partial posttraumatic stress disorder in US adults: results from Wave 2 of the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. Psychosomatic Medicine 73, 697707.
Pietrzak RH, Schechter CB, Bromet EJ, Katz CL, Reissman DB, Ozbay F, Sharma V, Crane M, Harrison D, Herbert R, Levin SM, Luft BJ, Moline JM, Stellman JM, Udasin IG, Landrigan PJ, Southwick SM (2012). The burden of full and subsyndromal posttraumatic stress disorder among police involved in the World Trade Center rescue and recovery effort. Journal of Psychiatric Research 46, 835842.
Renshaw KD (2011). An integrated model of risk and protective factors for post-deployment PTSD symptoms in OEF/OIF era combat veterans. Journal of Affective Disorders 128, 321326.
Robins LN, Smith EM (1983). The Diagnostic Interview Schedule/Disaster Supplement. Washington University School of Medicine: St Louis, MO.
Soo J, Webber MP, Gustave J, Lee R, Hall CB, Cohen HW, Kelly KJ, Prezant DJ (2011). Trends in probable PTSD in firefighters exposed to the World Trade Center disaster, 2001–2010. Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness 5 (Suppl. 2), S197S203.
Steenkamp MM, Dickstein BD, Salters-Pedneault K, Hofmann SG, Litz BT (2012). Trajectories of PTSD symptoms following sexual assault: is resilience the modal outcome? Journal of Traumatic Stress 25, 469474.
Stellman JM, Smith RP, Katz CL, Sharma V, Charney DS, Herbert R, Moline J, Luft BJ, Markowitz S, Udasin I, Harrison D, Baron S, Landrigan PJ, Levin SM, Southwick S (2008). Enduring mental health morbidity and social function impairment in World Trade Center rescue, recovery, and cleanup workers: the psychological dimension of an environmental health disaster. Environmental Health Perspectives 116, 12481253.
van Buuren S, Brand JPL, Groothuis-Oudshoorn CGM, Rubin DB (2006). Fully conditional specification in multivariate imputation. Journal of Statistical Computation and Simulation 76, 10491064.
Walsh F (2007). Traumatic loss and major disasters: strengthening family and community resilience. Family Process 46, 207227.
Wang PS, Lane M, Olfson M, Pincus HA, Wells KB, Kessler RC (2005). Twelve-month use of mental health services in the United States: results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 629640.
Weathers F, Litz B, Herman D, Huska J, Keane T (1993). The PTSD Checklist (PCL): reliability, validity, and diagnostic utility. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies, San Antonio, TX.
Wilson JP, Drozdek B, Turkovic S (2006). Posttraumatic shame and guilt. Trauma, Violence and Abuse 7, 122141.
Wisnivesky JP, Teitelbaum S, Todd A, Boffetta P, Crane M, Dellenbaugh C, Harrison D, Herbert R, Jeon Y, Kaplan J, Levin S, Luft B, Markowitz S, Moline J, Pietrzak RH, Shapiro M, Southwick SM, Stevenson L, Udasin I, Wallenstein S, Landrigan P (2011). Long persistence of multiple illnesses in September 11 responders. Lancet 378, 888897.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 48
Total number of PDF views: 261 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1296 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.