Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-hfldf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-25T07:33:25.663Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

De Gaulle, the Nation-State and Foreign Policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

P. G. Cerny
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Valery has written that “A great man is one who leaves others after him in a state of embarrassment.” Certainly, the eighteen-month-old era of aprés de Gaulle has been characterized by an unexpected sense of confidence, not the oft-predicted chaos. But embarrassment persists. The enigma of de Gaulle himself remains. We have many and varied chronicles of his long political career. We have his speeches, his early books, his war memoirs and the first volume of his new Mémoires d'Espoir. But we have only begun the long process of sifting and reconciling the varied and contradictory facts at hand. The final analysis, as with so many other political leaders who left an ambiguous mark upon their contemporaries, will be left to the judgment of history—So subjective, yet so precious to de Gaulle himself.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 33 , Issue 2 , April 1971 , pp. 254 - 278
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1971

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Quoted at the beginning of Chapter 1 (in part), in de Gaulle, Charles, Le Fil de l'Epée (Paris, 1932), p. 13Google Scholar.

2 Discours et Messages 1940–1969 (5 vols.: Paris, 1970)Google Scholar; The Complete War Memoirs of Charles de Gaulle, (New York, 1967)Google Scholar; Mémoires d'Espoir, I, “Le Renouveau 1958–1962” (Paris, 1970)Google Scholar; La Discorde chez l'Ennemi (Paris, 1924)Google Scholar; Le Fil de l'Epée; Vers l'Armée de Métier (Paris, 1934)Google Scholar; La France et son Armée (Paris, 1938)Google Scholar; Trois Études (Paris, 1945)Google Scholar.

3 Chambraud, André, “De Gaulle: Une Histoire sans Mémoire,” L'Express, 10 12–18, 1970, pp. 18–19Google Scholar.

4 The Complete War Memoirs, p. 335.

5 Lacouture, however, insists that the obsession with grandeur remains throughout, though mixed in with other terms: Lacouture, J., ed., Citations du Président de Gaulle (Paris, 1968)Google Scholar. Strong criticisms of grandeur are in: Mengin, R., No Laurels for de Gaulle (New York, 1966)Google Scholar; N. Leites, Médiocrité et Grandeur: Essai sur Charles de Gaulle, mimeo (no date); and Hassner, P., “Détente à la Française,” Modern World, VI (1968), 37Google Scholar. Strong defenses of the General are in: Hess, J. L., The Case for de Gaulle: An American Viewpoint (New York, 1968)Google Scholar; and Pickles, William, “Making Sense of de Gaulle,” International Affairs, XLII, no. 3 (07, 1966), 410CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Cf. Kulski, W. W., De Gaulle and the World (Syracuse, 1966)Google Scholar.

7 Chapman, Brian, “Prince and Player,” The Guardian, 05 8, 1969, p. 9Google Scholar.

8 Fidus, , “En Relisant Michel Debré,” Revue des Deux Mondes, 02 1, 1966, p. 354Google Scholar. Debré is notorious for his about-faces; others, like Soustelle, became opponents of the General; still others, like Pompidou, may be having the last laugh: cf. Alexandre, P., Le Duel de Gaulle-Pompidou (Paris, 1970)Google Scholar.

9 Press conference, September 5, 1960, in Major Addresses, Statements, and Press Conferences of General Charles de Gaulle, May 19, 1958-January 31, 1964 (French Embassy Press and Information Service: New York, 1964), p. 84Google Scholar.

10 Le Fil de l'Epée.

11 Cf. Nachin, L., introduction to de Gaulle, C., Trois Études, p. xGoogle Scholar. Gaulle, De also speaks of the “creative spark” which cannot come from a rigid doctrine, in Vers l'Armé de Métier, p. 174Google Scholar.

12 “Gaullism: II—Style,” International Herald Tribune, May 8, 1968, p. 4.

13 The Complete War Memoirs, pp. 82–83.

14 Vers l'Armie de MStier, p. 160.

15 The Complete War Memoirs, p. 499.

16 Grosser, A., La Politique Extérieure de la Ve République (Paris, 1965), P. 39Google Scholar

17 Le Fil de l'Epée, p. 9.

18 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 51.

19 Ibid., 49ff.

20 Hoffmann, Stanley, “De Gaulle's Memoirs: The Hero as History,” World Politics, XIII, no. 1 (10, 1960), 145Google Scholar.

21 Ibid., 151.

22 de Bayeux, Discours, 06 16, 1946, Discours et Messages, II, “Dans I'Attente,” 8Google Scholar.

23 The Complete War Memoirs, p. 3.

24 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 40.

25 Hoffman, , “De Gaulle's Memoirs,” p. 155Google Scholar.

26 Vers l'Armé de Métier, pp. 169–170.

27 “The Political Methods of General de Gaulle,” International Affairs, XXXVII, no. 1 (01, 1961), 22Google Scholar. For a more particular example, see Cerny, P. G., “The Fall of Two Presidents and Extra-parliamentary Opposition: France and the United States in 1968,” Government and Opposition, V, no. 3 (Summer, 1970), 292–298Google Scholar.

28 Quoted in Leites, , Médiocrité et Grandeur, p. 81Google Scholar.

29 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 34.

30 Cf. Crawley, A., De Gaulle (London, 1969), p. 21Google Scholar.

31 Cf. Tournoux, J.-R., Pétain and de Gaulle (London, 1966)Google Scholar.

32 Johnson, Douglas, “The Political Principles of General de Gaulle,” International Affairs, XLI, no. 4 (10, 1965), 651Google Scholar.

33 Address, May 31, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 75.

34 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 7–8.

35 Le Fil de l'Epée, p. 13.

36 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 7.

37 Address, May 31, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 75.

38 Press conference, September 5, 1960, ibid., p. 91.

39 La France et son Armée, p. 9.

40 The Complete War Memoirs, p. 773.

41 Press conference, July 29, 1963, Major Addresses, p. 237.

42 Address, broadcast November 4, 1960, ibid., p. 100.

43 Address, broadcast, April 13, 1963, ibid., p. 223.

44 Inaugural address, January 8, 1959, ibid., p. 35.

45 Grosser, , La Politique Extérieure de la Ve République, p. 29Google Scholar.

46 Address, broadcast December 31, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 110.

47 Vers l'Armée de Métier, pp. 76–77.

48 Press conference, September 9, 1965, de France, Ambassade, Service de Presse et d'Information, London, p. 11Google Scholar.

49 Hamon, L., “Legs, Actualité et Finalité de la Politique Françhise,” Revue Française de Science Politique, XV, no. 5 (10, 1965), 991Google Scholar.

50 he Fil de l'Epée, pp. 92, 126; Vers l'Armée de Métier, p. 69.

51 Idem.

52 Debné, M., “Science Politique et Action Politique,” Revue Française de Science Politique, XI, no. 2 (06, 1961), 801Google Scholar.

53 Interview with Michel Droit, broadcast June 7, 1968, de France, Ambassade, Service de Presse et d'Infonnation, London, p. 5Google Scholar.

54 La Discorde chez l'Ennemi, p. viii.

55 Ibid., p. X.

56 Press conference, February 21, 1965, de France, Ambassade, Service de Presse et d'Information, London, p. 5Google Scholar.

57 Le Fil de l'Epée, pp. 48–54.

58 Ibid., p. 66.

59 Press conference, October 28, 1966, de France, Ambassade, Service de Presse et d'Information, London, p. 2Google Scholar; Speech at Moscow University, June 22, 1966, in La Politique Etrangére de la France, Textes et Documents, 1966, “La Documentation Françhise,” (Paris, 1967), p. 104Google Scholar.

60 Press conference, January 31, 1964, Major Addresses, p. 245.

61 Cf. Aristotle, , Politics, III, 1280bGoogle Scholar.

92 This is true of allied Gaullist concepts such as self-determination, or of the necessary moral factors for political integration in Europe: cf. Press conference, September 5, 1960, Major Addresses, pp. 92–93.

63 Press conference, September 5, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 85.

64 Address, May 3 1, 1960, ibid., p. 78.

65 Interview with Réalités-Entreprises, October 18, 1966, La Politique Etrangére de la France, p. 166.

66 Combat, August, 24, 1944, quoted in Serfaty, S., France, De Gaulle and Europe (Baltimore, 1968), p. 85Google Scholar.

67 Le Fil de l'Epée, pp. 76ff; Vers l'Armée de Métier, p. 175.

68 Pickles, D., The Uneasy Entente (London, 1966)Google Scholar; also see Grosser, A., “General de Gaulle and the Foreign Policy of the Fifth Republic,” International Affairs, XXXIX, no. 2 (04, 1963), 200–201Google Scholar.

69 Press conference, September 5, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 93.

70 Press conference, September 9, 1965, de France, Ambassade, Service de Presse et d'Information, London, p. 9Google Scholar.

71 Press conference, November 10, 1959, Major Addresses, p. 57; cf. Grosser, , La Politique Extérieure de la Ve République, p. 173Google Scholar.

72 Talk to a group of representatives of foreign banks in Paris, May 22, 1967, La Politique Etrangère de la France, Textes et Documents, 1967, premier semestre, p. 99.

73 De Gaulle and the World, pp. 76–77.

74 Cygielman, V., “L'Explosion Nationaliste,” Le Soir (Brussels), 03 7, 1968, pp. 1, 6Google Scholar; cf. also de Gaulle's remarks on self-determination in Africa in his press conference, November 10, 1959, Major Addresses, p. 65.

75 Cf. Reith, Lester Pearson's lectures, The Guardian, 12 9, 1968, p. 3Google Scholar.

76 Cf. Girardet, R., “Autour de l'ldéologie Nationaliste: Perspectives de Recherches,” Revue Française de Science Politique, XV, no. 3 (06, 1965), 423CrossRefGoogle Scholar; P. Hassner, “Nationalisme et Relations Internationales,” ibid., 499; S. Hoffmann, “De Gaulle's Memoirs”; Malraux, A., “Une Présence Humaine et Généreuse,” Nouuelle Frontiére, V (01, 1964), 3Google Scholar.

77 See particularly Kedourie, E., Nationalism (London, 1966)Google Scholar.

78 Cited in Girardet, , op. cit., 426–427Google Scholar, from Grosse Brockhaus (16th ed., 1955).

79 Serfaty, , France, de Gaulle, and Europe, p. 114Google Scholar.

80 Hoffmann, , “De Gaulle's Memoirs,” p. 155Google Scholar.

81 Vers l'Armée de Métier, p. 116.

82 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 7.

83 Idem (my italics).

84 La France et son Armée, p. 270.

85 Pompidou, G., speech to the Institut des Hautes Études de Défense Nationale, 11 3, 1967Google Scholar, La Politique Etrangère de la France, Textes et Documents, 1967, deuxième semestre, p. 129.

86 De Gaulle, speech at Moscow University, June 22, 1966, loc. cit.

87 April 14, 1966, in La Politique Etrangère …, 1966, p. 70.

88 Pickles, Dorothy, The Uneasy Entente, p. 82Google Scholar.

89 Vers l'Armée de Métier, p. 175.

90 La Discorde chez l'Ennemi, p. x. The Complete War Memoirs, p. 3.

91 Cf. Nordlinger, E. A., “Democratic Stability and Instability: The French Case,” World Politics, XVIII, no. 1 (10, 1965), 127CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Le Fil de l'Épée, p. 27.

93 Mémoires d'Espoir, I, 145.

94 de Bayeux, Discours, Discours, II, 8Google Scholar.

95 The Complete War Memoirs, p. 3.

96 Cf. Cerny, P. G., The French Presidency, unpublished honors thesis, Kenyon College (1967)Google Scholar.

97 Sulzberger, C. L., “Gaullism: I—Aims,” International Herald Tribune, 05 6, 1968, p. 4Google Scholar.

98 Vers l'Armée de Métier, p. 33; Press conference, September 5, 1960, Major Addresses, p. 92; Speech, May 8, 1961, ibid., p. 139.

99 New Year's Message, broadcast December 29, 1961, ibid., p. 157.

100 Kulski, , op. cit., pp. 72–74Google Scholar; Grosser, , La Politique Extérieure de la Ve République, pp. 79, 167Google Scholar; “French Cultural Promotion Abroad,” Ambassade de France, London, document B/39/10/7; Dollot, L., La France dans le Monde Actuel (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar; Manue, G. R., “Réalités et Perspectives de la Francophonie,” Revue de Défense Nationale, XXIII, no. 2 (02, 1967), 223Google Scholar; R. P. Calvez, “Les Raisons Spirituelles de l'Aide des Pays Plus Developpés aux Pays Moins Developpés,” ibid., XXIV, no. 8 (October, 1968), 1438.

101 Billotte, P., “La France et la Puissance Mondiale,” Revue des Deux Mondes, 09 1, 1966, p. 3Google Scholar; Semidei, M., “De l'Empire à la Decolonisation à Travers les Manuels Scolaires Français,” Revue Française de Science Politique, XVI, no. 1 (02, 1966), 56CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hayter, Teresa, “French Aid to Africa—Its Scope and Achievements,” International Affairs, XLI, no. 2 (04, 1965), 236CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mialet, J., “La Coopération dans la Politique Étrangère de la France,” Revue Juridique et Politique, XXII, no. 3 (07–09, 1968), 811Google Scholar.

102 Press conference, November 10, 1959, Major Addresses, p. 67.

103 Press conference, January 31, 1964, ibid., p. 252.

104 I regret that lack of space prevents me from dealing with each level of policy in greater detail.