Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Carbon Trading: Unethical, Unjust and Ineffective?

  • Simon Caney (a1) and Cameron Hepburn (a2)
Abstract

Cap-and-trade systems for greenhouse gas emissions are an important part of the climate change policies of the EU, Japan, New Zealand, among others, as well as China (soon) and Australia (potentially). However, concerns have been raised on a variety of ethical grounds about the use of markets to reduce emissions. For example, some people worry that emissions trading allows the wealthy to evade their responsibilities. Others are concerned that it puts a price on the natural environment. Concerns have also been raised about the distributional justice of emissions trading. Finally, some commentators have questioned the actual effectiveness of emissions trading in reducing emissions. This paper considers these three categories of objections – ethics, justice and effectiveness – through the lens of moral philosophy and economics. It is concluded that only the objections based on distributional justice can be sustained. This points to reform of the carbon market system, rather than its elimination.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Corresponding author.E-mail address:c.j.hepburn@lse.ac.uk
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

Cameron Hepburn , ‘Carbon trading: a review of the Kyoto mechanisms', Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 32 (2007), 375393

Robert N Stavins , ‘What Can We Learn from the Grand Policy Experiment? Lessons from SO2 Allowance TradingJournal of Economic Perspectives 12:3 (1998), 6988

Judith Andre ‘Blocked Exchanges: A Taxonomy' in Pluralism, Justice, and Equality (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995) edited by David Miller and Michael Walzer , 171196

Debra Satz , Why Some Things Should Not Be for Sale: The Moral Limits of Markets (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010)

Robert Goodin Selling Environmental Indulgences’, Kyklos 47:4 (1994), 573596

CaneyMarkets, Morality and Climate Change: What, if anything, is Wrong with Emissions Trading?', New Political Economy 15:2 (2010), 204205

James Tobin defends restrictions on trade for this reason: ‘On Limiting the Domain of Inequality’, Journal of Law and Economics, 13:2 (1970), 266

Henry Shue Subsistence Emissions and Luxury Emissions’, Law and Policy 15:1 (1993), 58

HyamsA Just Response to Climate Change: Personal Carbon Allowances and the Normal-Functioning Approach’, Journal of Social Philosophy 40:2 (2009), 244

Simon Caney Justice Beyond Borders: A Global Political Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), chapter 5

Uri Gneezy and Aldo Rustichini's well-known paper ‘A Fine is a Price’, Journal of Legal Studies 29:1 (2000), 117

Leonard P. Gianessi , Henry M. Peskin and Edward N. Wolff The Distributional Effects of Uniform Air Pollution Policy in the United States’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 93 (1979), 281301

David H. Robison , ‘Who Pays for Industrial Pollution Abatement?Review of Economics and Statistics 67 (1985), 702706

Cameron Hepburn , Michael Grubb ,Karsten Neuhoff ,Felix Matthes , and Max Tse ., ‘Auctioning of EU ETS Phase II allowances: how and why?Climate Policy, 6:1 (2006), 135158

Robin Smale , Murray Hartley , Cameron Hepburn , John Ward , and Michael Grubb , ‘The impact of CO2 emissions trading on firm profits and market prices’, Climate Policy, 6:1 (2006), 3148

Ian W H Parry , 2004. Are emission permits regressive? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 47:2, 364387

Scott Barrett . 2003. Environment and Statecraft, Oxford: Oxford University Press

Robert N Stavins , ‘Addressing climate change with a comprehensive US cap-and-trade system’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24:2 (2008), 298321

Carlson, Curtis, Dallas Burtraw , Maureen Cropper , and Karen Palmer . 2000. ‘SO2 Control by Electric Utilities: What are the Gains from Trade?Journal of Political Economy, 108:6 (2000), 12721326

Denny Ellerman , and Barbara Buchner . ‘Over-Allocation or Abatement? A Preliminary Analysis of the EU ETS Based on the 2005–06 Emissions Data’, Environmental and Resource Economics, 41 (2008), 267287

Erik Delarue , Kris Voorspools , William D. D'haeseleer . ‘Fuel switching in the electricity sector under the EU ETS: review and prospective’. Journal of Energy Engineering, 134:2 (2008), 4046

Thomas Sterner , ‘Fuel taxes: An important instrument for climate policy’, Energy Policy 35 (2007), 31943202

Cameron Hepburn , ‘Regulation by prices, quantities or both: A review of instrument choice’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 22:2 (2006), 226247

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements
  • ISSN: 1358-2461
  • EISSN: 1755-3555
  • URL: /core/journals/royal-institute-of-philosophy-supplements
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×