Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

On Becoming, Cosmic Time and Rotating Universes1


In the literature on the compatibility between the time of our experience and the time of physics, the special theory of relativity has enjoyed central stage. By bringing into the discussion the general theory of relativity, I suggest a new analysis of the misunderstood notion of becoming, developed from hints in Gödel's published and unpublished arguments for the ideality of time. I claim that recent endorsements of such arguments, based on Gödel's own ‘rotating’ solution to Einstein's field equation, fail: once understood in the right way, becoming can be shown to be both mind-independent and compatible with spacetime physics. Being a needed tertium quid between views of time traditionally regarded as in conflict, such a new approach to becoming should also help to dissolve a crucial aspect of the century-old debate between the so-called A and B theories of time.

Hide All
Boltzmann L. 18961898. Vorlesungen über Gastheorie, transl. by Brush S. [1964], Lectures on Gas Theory. 1896-1898. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Broad C. D. 1938. Examination of McTaggart's philosophy, Cambridge: Cambridge University.
Callender C. 1997. ‘Review of M. Dorato's Time and Reality, Bologna, Clueb 1995’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 48, 117–20.
Clifton R. and Hogarth M. 1995. ‘The Definability of Becoming in Minkowski Spacetime’, Synthese, 103, 355–87.
Dieks D. 1988. ‘Discussion: Special Relativity and the Flow of Time’, Philosophy of Science, 55, 456460.
Dorato M. 1995. Time and Reality, Clueb, Bologna.
Dorato M. 1996. ‘On Becoming, Relativity and Non-separability’, Philosophy of Science, 64, 585604.
Dorato M. 2002. ‘Becoming and the Arrow of Causation’, Philosophy of Science, Supplement to vol. 67, 3, S523534.
Earman J. 1995. Bangs, Crunches, Whimpers and Shrieks. Singularities Acausalities in Relativistic Spacetimes. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Eddington A. S. 1920. Space, Time and Gravitation. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Faye J. 1989. The Reality of the Future, Odense, Odense University Press.
Gödel, K. 1949a. ‘A Remark About the Relationship Between Relativity Theory and Idealistic Philosophy’, in P. A. Schilpp (ed.), Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, La Salle IL: Open Court, pp. 557-62, reprinted with corrections and additions in Gödel (1990).
Gödel K. (1949b. ‘An Example of a New Type of Cosmological Solution of Einstein's Field Equations of Gravitation’, Review of Modern Physics, 21, 447–50.
Gödel K. (1990. Collected Works, Feferman S. et. al. (eds), Vol. 2, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gödel K. (1995. Collected Works, Feferman S. et. al. (eds), Vol. 3, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Godfrey-Smith W. 1979. ‘Special Relativity and the Present’, Philosophical Studies, 36, 233–44.
Grüinbaum A. 1963. Philosophical Problems of Space and Time, New York: A. Knopf.
Horwich P. 1987. Asymmetries in Time, Harvard Mass.: The Mit Press.
Jeans J. 1936. ‘Man and the Universe’, Sir Stewart Alley Lecture, in Scientific Progress, New York: The McMillan Company, pp. 1338.
Kim J. 1976. ‘Events as property exemplification’, in M. Brand and d. Walton (eds), Action Theory, Dordrecht: Reidel, pp. 159–77.
Le Poidevin R. (ed.) (1998. Questions of Time and Tense, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Malament D. 1995. ‘Introductory Note for 1949b’ in Gödel (1995), Collected Works, Feferman S. et. al. (eds), Vol. 3, Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp. 261–69.
Maxwell N. 1985. ‘Are Probabilism and Special Relativity Incompatible?’, Philosophy of Science, 52, pp. 2343.
McTaggart J. 1908. ‘The Unreality of Time’, Mind, 68, pp. 457–74.
Mellor D. H. 1997. Real Time II, London: Routledge.
Oaklander N., and Smith Q. (eds) (1994. The New Theory of Time, New Haven: Yale University Press.
Oaklander N. 1998. Freedom and the New Theory of Time, in Le Poidevin R. (ed.) (1998. Questions of Time and Tense, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Padgett A. 1992. God, Eternity and the Nature of Time, New York: St. Martin's Press.
Putnam H. 1967. ‘Time and Physical Geometry’, The Journal of Philosophy, 64, pp. 240–47.
Quine W. v. O. 1987. ‘Space-time’, in Quiddities, Harvard University Press: Harvard Mass.
Rakic N. 1997. ‘Past, present and future and special relativity’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 48, 257280.
Rietdijk C. 1966. ‘A rigorous proof of determinism derived from the special theory of relativity’, Philosophy of Science, 33, 341–44.
Rovelli C. 1997. ‘Half-way through the woods: Contemporary Research in Space and Time’, in Earman J. and Norton J. (eds), The Cosmos of Science, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, pp. 180224.
Russell B. 1915. ‘On the Experience of Time’, Monist, 25, 212–33.
Saunders S. 1996. ‘Time, Quantum Mechanics and Tense’, Synthese, 107, 1953.
Savitt S. 1994. ‘The Replacement of Time’, Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 72, 463474.
Savitt S. (2002. ‘There's No Time Like the Present (in Minkowski space-time)’, in Howard D. (ed.), PSA 98, part II, Supplement to volume 67, 3, S563-S573.
Sellars W. 1962. ‘Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man’, in Colodny R. (ed.), Frontiers of Science and Philosophy, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, pp. 3578.
Smith Q. 2002. ‘Review of Philip Turezsky's Time’, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 51, 27933.
Stein H. 1968. ‘On Einstein-Minkowski spacetime’, Journal of Philosophy, 65, 523.
Stein H. 1970. ‘On the Paradoxical Time-Structure of Gödel,Philosophy of Science, 37, 589601.
Stein H. 1991. ‘On Relativity Theory and Openness of the Future’, Philosophy of Science, 58, 147–67.
Tooley M. 1997. Time, Tense and Causation, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wang H. 1995. ‘Time in Philosophy and in Physics from Kant and Einstein to Gödel’, Synthese, 102, 215–34.
Weingard R. 1972. ‘Relativity and the Reality of Past and Future Events’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 23, 199221.
Weyl H. 1918. Raum-Zeit Materie, Berlin, J. Springer.
Williams, D. 1951. ‘The Myth of Passage’, reprinted in R. Gale (ed.) 1967, The Philosophy of Time, New York: Anchor Books, pp. 98-116.
P. Yourgrau 1991. The Disappearance of Time, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
P. Yourgrau 1999. Gödel meets Einstein, New York: Open Court.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements
  • ISSN: 1358-2461
  • EISSN: 1755-3555
  • URL: /core/journals/royal-institute-of-philosophy-supplements
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *