Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-x24gv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-30T17:20:40.633Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Resisting the Market University: Political Challenges to the Locus of Authority in Public University Tuition Policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 June 2018

Jennifer M. Nations
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The devolution of tuition authority, or abdication of tuition-setting control from elected representatives to unelected university governing boards, is an instance of marketization in higher education. Except for New York and Florida, all states have moved closer to a market-priced ideal by “deregulating” tuition. In this article, I describe my analysis of these two negative cases and argue that preexisting higher education policies have lasting effects on the institutional logics to which policy makers and other stakeholders have access, leading to divergent outcomes. What policy makers deem appropriate policy in their local context is shaped by a history of education policy making that likely preceded their position in office. However, the structure of institutions and the founding ideas of those institutions—as preserved in planning documents and remembered by select institutional actors—perpetuate a commitment to a certain institutional logic. Specifically, Florida and New York policy makers were constrained in their decision making about tuition devolution at multiple points in time by a family of institutions logic that reinforced the importance of their state university systems’ lack of formal tiers and their commitment to price similarity. The state policies governing these state systems became politically consequential because policy makers invoked the system cohesiveness mandated by such policies as a principal reason for rejecting devolution proposals. This powerful narrative appears to have precluded the ideational change toward a market university despite a move in this direction in other states.

Type
Research Article
Information
Social Science History , Volume 42 , Issue 3 , Fall 2018 , pp. 575 - 600
Copyright
© Social Science History Association, 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Associated Press (1989) “UF, FSU Seeking to charge more than other schools.” Orlando Sentinel, February 11.Google Scholar
Becker, Carl L. (1943) Cornell University: Founders and the Founding. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Berman, Elizabeth P. (2012) Creating the Market University: How Academic Science Became and Economic Engine. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Burka, Paul (2002) “Sinking flagship.” Texas Monthly, August, www.texasmonthly.com/articles/sinking-flagship/ (accessed October 23, 2015).Google Scholar
Campbell, John L. (1998) “Institutional analysis and the role of ideas in political economy.” Theory and Society 27 (3): 377–409.Google Scholar
Campbell, John L. (2002) “Ideas, politics, and public policy.” Annual Review of Sociology 28: 21–38.Google Scholar
Chandler, Hendrix (1983) Dreams and Political Realities: A 20th Century History of Florida’s University System. Tallahassee, FL: FSUS Board of Regents.Google Scholar
Chatterji, Aaron K., Kim, Joowon, and McDevitt, Ryan C. (2016) “School spirit: Legislator school ties and state funding for higher education,” https://faculty.fuqua.duke.edu/~rcm26/ckm_schoolties_sept_2016.pdf (accessed November 15, 2016).Google Scholar
Clark, John B., Leslie, W. Bruce, and O’Brien, Kenneth P. (2010) “Introduction: Taking stock of New York’s State University after six decades.” in John B. Clark, W. Bruce Leslie, and Kenneth P. O’Brien (eds.) SUNY at Sixty: The Promise of the State University of New York. Albany, NY: SUNY Press: xvi–xxxii.Google Scholar
Davis, Daniel, and Binder, Amy (2016) “Selling students: The rise of corporate partnership programs in university career centers.” in Elizabeth Popp Berman and Catherine Paradeise (eds.) Research in the Sociology of Organizations, special issue 46: 395–422.Google Scholar
Douglass, John Aubrey (2010) “The best laid plans: Introduction,” in John B. Clark, W. Bruce Leslie and Kenneth P. O’Brien (eds.) SUNY at Sixty: The Promise of the State University of New York. Albany, NY: SUNY Press: 184–224.Google Scholar
Eaton, Charlie, Habinek, Jacob, Goldstein, Adam, Dioun, Cyrus, Godoy, Daniela García Santibánez, and Osley-Thomas, Robert (2016) “The financialization of US higher education.” Socioeconomic Review 14 (3): 1–29.Google Scholar
Finney, Joni E. (1997) State Structures for the Governance of Higher Education: Florida Case Study Summary. San Jose: California Higher Education Policy Center.Google Scholar
Florida Legislature (1978a) Quality Universities to Serve Florida’s Future: Report of the Commission on the Future of Florida’s Public Universities. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida Legislature (1978b) Report of the Florida Legislative Joint Committee on Economic Policy. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida Legislature (2007a) Senate. Public hearing, March 21. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida Legislature (2007b) Senate. Floor debate, April 27. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida Postsecondary Education Planning Commission (1982) The Master Plan for Florida Postsecondary Education: Report and Recommendations of the Postsecondary Education Planning Commission. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida State (1975) Department of Education. Annual Progress Report State University System of Florida, Plan for Equalizing Educational Opportunity in Public Higher Education in Florida. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Florida State University System Board of Regents (1978) Planning Guidelines for the State University System of Florida. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Friedland, Roger, and Alford, Robert R. (1991) “Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices, and institutional contradictions,” in Walter W. Powell and Paul J. DiMaggio (eds.) The New Institutionalism and Organizational Analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press: 232–265.Google Scholar
Gelber, Sidney (2001) Politics and Public Higher Education in New York State—Stony Brook—A Case History. New York: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Gladieux, Lawrence E., King, Jacqueline E., and Corrigan, Melanie E. (2005) “The federal government and higher education,” in Philip G. Altbach, Robert O. Berdahl and Patricia Gumport (eds.) American Higher Education in the Twenty-First Century, 2nd ed. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press: 163–197.Google Scholar
Goldberg, Chad Alan (2007) Citizens and Paupers: Relief, Rights, and Race from the Freedmen’s Bureau to Workfare. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Gumport, Patricia J. (2000) “Academic restructuring: Organizational change and institutional imperatives.” Higher Education: The International Journal of Higher Education and Educational Planning 39: 67–91.Google Scholar
Immergut, Ellen M. (1998) “The theoretical core of the new institutionalism.” Politics and Society 26 (1): 5–34.Google Scholar
Independent Commission on the Future of the State University (1985) State University of New York: The Challenge and the Choice. Albany, NY: State University of New York.Google Scholar
Jayson, Sharon (2002) “UT brass pushing for tuition control—With GOP in charge, system again will ask if it can set its rates.” Austin American-Statesman, December 12.Google Scholar
Johnson, Larry, and Borman, Kathryn M. (2007) “Competing agendas for university governance: Placing the conflict between Jeb Bush and Bob Graham in context,” in Kathryn M. Borman and Sherman Dorn (eds.) Education Reform in Florida: Diversity and Equity in Public Policy. Albany, NY: SUNY Press: 185–210.Google Scholar
Kenyon, Jim (1993) “State’s public colleges could set tuition rates.” The Tampa Tribune, December 3.Google Scholar
Kerr, Clark (1991) The Great Transformation in Higher Education. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
Kirp, David L. (2003) Shakespeare, Einstein, and the Bottom Line: The Marketing of Higher Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Krippner, Greta (2011) Capitalizing on Crisis: The Political Origins of the Rise of Finance. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Johnston, Joseph B. (2014) “Resisting charters: A comparative policy development analysis of Washington and Kentucky, 2002–2012.” Sociology of Education 87 (4): 223–240.Google Scholar
Levine, Sanford H. (2010) “The Empire State creates a university,” in John B. Clark, W. Bruce Leslie and Kenneth P. O’Brien (eds.) SUNY at Sixty: The Promise of the State University of New York. Albany, NY: SUNY Press: 1–38.Google Scholar
Livingston, Ellen (1985) “College plan rides on South Florida’s legislative power.” The Miami Herald, January 21.Google Scholar
Loss, Christopher P. (2012a) Between Citizens and the State: The Politics of American Higher Education in the Twentieth Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Loss, Christopher P. (2012b) From pluralism to diversity: Reassessing the political uses of the university.” Social Science History 36 (4): 525–549.Google Scholar
Mahoney, James (2000) “Path dependence in historical sociology.” Theory and Society 29 (4): 507–548.Google Scholar
Marcus, Jon (1990) “Regents OK variable tuition at state colleges.” Sun Sentinel, January 26.Google Scholar
Mautz, Robert B. (1982) The Power Game: Governance of Higher Education in Florida. Institute for Studies in Higher Education, Fellows Program, Vol. 1. Tallahassee, FL.Google Scholar
Mayfield, Jim, Chance, William, and Lieb, Roxanne (2002) Higher Education Coordination in Washington State. Washington State Institute for Public Policy. Olympia, WA, wsipp.wa.gov.Google Scholar
McBain, Lesley (2010) Tuition-Setting Authority and Deregulation at State Colleges and Universities. American Association of State Colleges and Universities, www.aascu.org. (accessed October 25, 2015).Google Scholar
McCabe, Joshua T., and Berman, Elizabeth Popp (2016) “American exceptionalism revisited: Tax relief, poverty reduction, and the politics of child tax credits.” Sociological Science 3: 540–567.Google Scholar
McLendon, Michael K., Mokher, Christine G., and Doyle, William (2009) “‘Privileging’ public research universities: An empirical analysis of the distribution of state appropriations across research and non-research universities.” Journal of Education Finance 34 (4): 372–401.Google Scholar
Miami Herald (2008) “Strengthening Florida’s universities.” News editorial, November 20.Google Scholar
NACUBO (National Association of College and University Business Officers) (2017) “U.S. and Canadian institutions listed by fiscal year 2016 endowment market value,” www.nacubo.org/Research/NACUBO-Commonfund_Study_of_Endowments/Public_NCSE_Tables.html (accessed May 31, 2017).Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1948) Report of the Temporary Commission on the Need for a State University (and Supporting Documents). Albany, NY: Williams Press, Inc.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1985) Senate and Assembly. Committee on Higher Education, “Hearing to review the governance of public higher education in New York State” held February 12, Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1996a) Assembly. “Public hearing in the matter of rethinking SUNY” held February 9, Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1996b) Assembly. “Public hearing in the matter of rethinking SUNY” held March 1, Binghamton, NY.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1996c) Assembly. “Public hearing in the matter of rethinking SUNY” held February 16, Buffalo, NY.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (1996d) “New York State temporary task force on variable campus-based tuition, report to the governor and the legislature.” Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (2005a) Senate and Assembly. Standing Committee on Higher Education. “Public hearing in the matter of the future of the public university systems in New York State.” October 6, Stony Brook University.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (2005b) Senate and Assembly. Standing Committee on Higher Education. “Public hearing in the matter of the future of the public university systems in New York State.” October 7, CUNY Graduate Center, New York.Google Scholar
New York Legislature (2005c) Senate and Assembly. Standing Committee on Higher Education. “Public hearing in the matter of the future of the public university systems in New York State.” October 17, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York State (1960) Meeting the Increasing Demand for Higher Education in New York State: A Report to the Governor and Board of Regents. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York State (1972) Report of the State Task Force on the Financing of Higher Education in New York State. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
New York State (1985) Education Law, Title 1, Article 8, Laws of 1985.Google Scholar
O’Mara, Margaret (2012) “The uses of the foreign student.” Social Science History 36 (4): 583–615.Google Scholar
Ost, Laura (1987) “Separate tuitions discussed regents study letting schools set own rates.” The Orlando Sentinel, January 27.Google Scholar
Ottman, Tod (2010) “Forging SUNY in New York’s political cauldron.” in John B. Clark, W. Bruce Leslie, and Kenneth P. O’Brien (eds.) SUNY at Sixty: The Promise of the State University of New York. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
Palm Beach Post (2001) “Free the universities.” News editorial, October 19.Google Scholar
Palmer, James C., and Gillilan, Sandra L. (2001) State Tax Appropriations to Higher Education, Fiscal Year 2001. Center for the Study of Education Policy. www.education.illinoisstate.edu (accessed October 23, 2015).Google Scholar
Price, H. D. (1957) The Negro and Southern Politics: A Chapter of Florida History. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Reed, Charles (2015) Author interview. November 17.Google Scholar
Scheuerman, William E. (2013) Author interview, Albany, NY. August 19.Google Scholar
Schnur, James Anthony (1992) Cold warriors in the hot sunshine: USF and the Johns Committee.” University of South Florida Digital Archive, dspace.nelson.usf.edu/xmlui/handle/10806/120 (accessed May 31, 2017).Google Scholar
Shabazz, Amilcar (2004) Advancing Democracy: African Americans and the Struggle for Access and Equity in Higher Education in Texas. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Slaughter, Sheila, and Leslie, Larry L. (1999) Academic Capitalism: Politics, Policies, and the Entrepreneurial University. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Slaughter, Sheila, and Rhoades, Gary (2004) Academic Capitalism and the New Economy: Markets, State, and Higher Education. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
State Higher Education Executive Officers (2011) State Higher Education Finance, FY 2010. Denver, CO, www.sheeo.org (accessed April 17, 2012).Google Scholar
State Higher Education Executive Officers (2016) State Higher Education Finance, FY 2015. Denver, CO, www.sheeo.org (accessed October 23, 2015).Google Scholar
State University of New York (1960) Board of Trustees. The Master Plan, Revised 1960. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
State University of New York, SUNY (1964) Board of Trustees. Stature and Excellence: Focus for the Future, 1964 Revised Master Plan. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
State University of New York, SUNY (1972) Board of Trustees. The Master Plan, Revised 1972. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
State University of New York, SUNY (1995) Board of Trustees. Rethinking SUNY. Albany, NY.Google Scholar
State University of New York, SUNY (2016) State University Construction Fund, “Contract colleges at Cornell University: 2016 campus statement.” www.sucf.suny.edu/project/mcp/cornell.pdf (accessed May 31, 2017).Google Scholar
State University System of Florida (2017) SUS Tuition and Fees Data, Author Calculations, www.flbog.edu/board/office/budget/tuition.php (accessed May 31, 2017).Google Scholar
Steck, Henry (2006) “Contested futures: Public policy and the State University of New York.” in Robert F. Pecorella and Jeffrey M. Stonecash (eds.) Governing New York State, 5th ed. Albany, NY: SUNY Press: 289–331.Google Scholar
Stevens, Mitchell L., and Gebre-Medhin, Ben (2016) “Association, service, market: Higher education in American political development.” Annual Review of Sociology 42: 121–142.Google Scholar
Strach, Patricia (2009) “Making higher education affordable: Policy design in postwar America.” Journal of Policy History 21 (1): 61–88.Google Scholar
Tampa Bay Times (2012) “Weak state funding holds back higher ed.” News editorial, October 30.Google Scholar
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (1991) Texas Public Higher Education Governance for the 21st Century, Final Report. January 19. Austin, TX.Google Scholar
Texas Legislature (1995) Senate Education Committee, Public hearing on 74th legislature interim charges, October 23. Austin, TX.Google Scholar
Texas Legislature (1996) Senate Education Committee, Final Report to the 75th Legislature. Austin, TX.Google Scholar
Texas Legislature (2000) House Committee on Higher Education, interim report, Austin, TX.Google Scholar
Texas Legislature (2003) House, 78th Legislature, floor debate of HB 3015. April 29, www.house.state.tx.us/video-audio/chamber/78/ (accessed October 23, 2015).Google Scholar
The Orlando Sentinel (2008) “UF, FSU raise costs; newbies to see 15% rise,” June 14.Google Scholar
Thelen, Kathleen (1999) “Historical institutionalism in comparative politics.” Annual Review of Sociology 2: 369–404.Google Scholar
Thornton, Patricia William Ocasio, H., and Lounsbury, Michael (2012) The Institutional Logics Perspective: A New Approach to Culture, Structure, and Process. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
University of the State of New York (1944) Regents Plan for Postwar Education in the State of New York. Albany, NY: State Education Department.Google Scholar
Washington Higher Education Coordinating Board (1987) Building a System: The 1987 Washington State Master Plan for Higher Education. Olympia, WA.Google Scholar
Washington Higher Education Coordinating Board (1992) A Commitment to Opportunity: 1992 Update of the Master Plan for Higher Education. Olympia, WA.Google Scholar
Washington Higher Education Coordinating Board (2012) “Key facts about higher education in Washington. Olympia, WA,” wsac.wa.gov/sites/default/files/KeyFacts2012.pdf (accessed June 27, 2016).Google Scholar
Washington Legislature (2011a) House. Floor debate, May 9. Olympia, WA.Google Scholar
Washington Legislature (2011b) House Ways and Means Committee. Hearing, February 14. Olympia, WA.Google Scholar
Washington State Journal (1999) “Tuition hikes hinge on supply, demand,” January 17.Google Scholar
Zinth, Kyle, and Smith, Matthew (2012) “Tuition-setting authority for public colleges and universities.” Education Commission of the States, www.ecs.org (accessed October 23, 2015).Google Scholar
Zumeta, William (2001) “Public policy and accountability in higher education: Lessons from the past and present for the new millennium,” in Donald E. Heller (ed.) The States and Public Higher Education Policy: Affordability, Access, and Accountability. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press: 155–196.Google Scholar
Zumeta, William (2006) “Public higher education in Washington State: Aspirations are misaligned with fiscal structure and politics.” in Ronald Ehrenberg (ed.) What’s Happening to Public Higher Education? Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press: 275–301.Google Scholar