Skip to main content
×
×
Home

“President” Landon and the 1936 Literary Digest Poll: Were Automobile and Telephone Owners to Blame?

  • Dominic Lusinchi
Abstract

The disastrous prediction of an Alf Landon victory in the 1936 presidential election by the Literary Digest poll is a landmark event in the history of American survey research in general and polling in particular. It marks both the demise of the straw poll, of which the Digest was the most conspicuous and well-regarded example, and the rise to prominence of the self-proclaimed “scientific” poll. Why did the Digest poll fail so miserably? One view has come to prevail over the years: because the Digest selected its sample primarily from telephone books and car registration lists and since these contained, at the time, mostly well-to-do folks who would vote Republican, it is no wonder the magazine mistakenly predicted a Republican win. This “conventional explanation” has found its way into countless publications (scholarly and in the press) and college courses. It has been used to illustrate the disastrous effects of a poorly designed poll. But is it correct? Empirical evidence, in the form of a 1937 Gallup poll, shows that this “conventional explanation” is wrong, because voters with telephones and cars backed Franklin D. Roosevelt and because it was those who failed to participate in the poll (overwhelmingly supporters of Roosevelt) who were mainly responsible for the faulty prediction.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Alpern, Sara Dale, Baum (1985) “Female ballots: The impact of the Nineteenth Amendment.Journal of Interdisciplinary History 16 (1): 4367.
American Institute of Public Opinion (1938) The New Science of Public Opinion Measurement. Princeton, NJ: American Institute of Public Opinion.
Andersen, Kristi (1979) The Creation of a Democratic Majority, 1928–1936. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Babbie, Earl (1990) Survey Research Methods, 2nd ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Baum, Matthew A. Kernell, Samuel (2001) “Economic class and popular support for Franklin Roosevelt in war and peace.Public Opinion Quarterly 65 (2): 198229.
Berinsky, Adam J. (2006) “American public opinion in the 1930s and 1940s: The analysis of quota-controlled sample survey data.Public Opinion Quarterly 70 (4): 499529.
Bernstein, Stephen Ruth, Bernstein (1999) Elements of Statistics I: Descriptive Statistics and Probability. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Blondiaux, Loïc (1998) La fabrique de l’opinion. Paris: Seuil.
Bradburn, Norman M. Sudman, Seymour (1988) Polls and Surveys: Understanding What They Tell Us. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bryson, Maurice C. (1976) “The Literary Digest poll: Making of a statistical myth.American Statistician 30 (4): 18485.
Bryson, Maurice C. (1977) “Reply.American Statistician 31 (4): 181.
Burner, David Ross, Rosenfield (2003) “Polling,” in Kutler, Stanley I. (ed.) Dictionary of American History, 3rd ed., vol. 6. New York: Scribner: 409.
Burnham, Walter D. (1987) “The turnout problem,” in Reichley, A. J. (ed.) Elections American Style. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution: 97133.
Cahalan, Don (1989) “The Digest poll rides again!Public Opinion Quarterly 53 (1): 12933.
Cahalan, Don Meier, Norman C. (1939) “The validity of mail-ballot polls.Psychological Record 3 (1): 311.
Converse, Jean M. (1987) Survey Research in the United States: Roots and Emergence, 1890–1960. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Converse, Jean M. (2009) Survey Research in the United States: Roots and Emergence, 1890–1960. Repr. with new introduction. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
Crossley, Archibald M. (1937) “Straw polls in 1936.Public Opinion Quarterly 1 (1): 2435.
Deming, W. Edwards (1964 [1943]) Statistical Adjustment of Data. New York: Dover.
Deming, W. Edwards Stephan, Frederick F. (1940) “On a least squares adjustment of a sampled frequency table when the expected marginal totals are known.Annals of Mathematical Statistics 11 (4): 42744.
Desrosières, Alain (1998) The Politics of Large Numbers: A History of Statistical Reasoning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Erikson, Robert S. (1976) “The relationship between public opinion and state policy: A new look based on some forgotten data.American Journal of Political Science 20 (1): 2536.
Erikson, Robert S. Tedin, Kent L. (1981) “The 1928–1936 partisan realignment: The case for the conversion hypothesis.American Political Science Review 75 (4): 95162.
Fallacy Files (n.d.) “Fallacy watch: How to read a poll; Scientific versus self-selected,www.fallacyfiles.org/readpoll.html (accessed April 29, 2009).
Field, Mervin D. (1983) “Political opinion polling in the United States of America,” in Worcester, Robert M. (ed.) Political Opinion Polling: An International Review. London: Macmillan: 198222.
Fischer, Claude S. (1992) America Calling: A Social History of the Telephone to 1940. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Gallup, George H. (1938) “Government and the sampling referendum.Journal of the American Statistical Association (201): 13142.
Gallup, George H. (1972a) “Opinion polling in a democracy,” in Tanur, Judith M. (ed.) Statistics: A Guide to the Unknown. San Francisco: Holden-Day: 14649.
Gallup, George H. (1972b) The Sophisticated Poll Watcher’s Guide. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Opinion Press.
Gallup, George H. Rae, Saul F. (1940) The Pulse of Democracy: The Public-Opinion Poll and How It Works. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Gallup, George H. Robinson, Claude E. (1938) “American Institute of Public Opinion—Surveys, 1935–38.Public Opinion Quarterly 2 (3): 37398.
Gidengil, Elisabeth (1992) “Canada votes: A quarter century of Canadian national election studies.Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique 25 (2): 21948.
Grier, David Alan (2002) “Predicting the unpredictable election.Chance 15 (2): 3035.
Herbst, Susan (1993) Numbered Voices: How Opinion Polling Has Shaped American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Higgins, Sean (2010) “George Gallup’s visionary grip on American wins and whims.Investors.com, www.investors.com/NewsAndAnalysis/Article.aspx?id=526858 (accessed March 11, 2010).
Hofstadter, Richard Miller, William Aaron, Daniel (1959) The American Republic. Vol. 2, Since 1865. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Huff, Darrell (1954) How to Lie with Statistics. New York: Norton.
Igo, Sarah E. (2006) “‘A gold mine and a tool for democracy’: George Gallup, Elmo Roper, and the business of scientific polling, 1935–1955.Journal of the History of Behavioral Sciences 42 (2): 10934.
Kalton, Graham Flores-Cervantes, Ismael (2003) “Weighting methods.Journal of Official Statistics 19 (2): 8197.
Katz, Daniel Hadley, Cantril (1937) “Public opinion polls.Sociometry 1 (1–2): 15579.
Kircher, Steve (2007) “Pigs, pols, and polls.St. Petersburg Times, ,www.sptimes.com/ 2007/12/09/Opinion/Pigs__pols_and_polls.shtml (accessed December 9, 2007).
Kitchens, Larry J. (1987) Exploring Statistics: A Modern Introduction to Data Analysis and Inference. St. Paul, MN: West.
Kleppner, Paul (1982) “Were women to blame? Female suffrage and voter turnout.Journal of Interdisciplinary History 12 (4): 62143.
Kruskal, William Frederick, Mosteller (1979a) “Representative sampling, I: Non-scientific literature.International Statistical Review 47 (1): 1324.
Kruskal, William Frederick, Mosteller (1979b) “Representative sampling, II: Scientific literature, excluding statistics.International Statistical Review 47 (2): 11127.
Kruskal, William Frederick, Mosteller (1979C) “Representative sampling, III: The current statistical literature.International Statistical Review 47 (3): 16995.
Kruskal, William Frederick, Mosteller (1980) “Representative sampling, IV: The history of the concept in statistics, 1895–1939.International Statistical Review 48 (2): 24565.
Ladd, Everett Carll (1985) The American Polity: The People and Their Government. New York: Norton.
Ladd, Everett Carll Jr. Hadley, Charles D. (1975) Transformations of the American Party System. New York: Norton.
Lee, Sunghee (2006) “Propensity score adjustment as a weighting scheme for volunteer panel web surveys.Journal of Official Statistics 22 (2): 32949.
Leonard, William R. (1961) “Walter F. Willcox: Statist.American Statistician 15 (1): 1619.
Literary Digest (1928) November 3.
Literary Digest; (1936a) August 22.
Literary Digest; (1936b) August 29.
Literary Digest; (1936c) October 31.
Literary Digest; (1936d) November 14.
Moon, Nick (1999) Opinion Polls: History, Theory, and Practice. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
New York Times (1936) “Digest to seek reason for failure of poll.” November 4.
News-Week (1936) “Poll: Dr. Gallup closes a gap between people and government.” November 14.
Oberschall, Anthony (2008) “The historical roots of public opinion research,” in Donsbach, Wolfgang Traugott, Michael W. (eds.) The Sage Handbook of Public Opinion Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage: 8392.
Ogburn, William F. Goltra, Inez (1919) “How women vote.Political Science Quarterly 34 (3): 41333.
Ohmer, Susan (2006) Gallup in Hollywood. New York: Columbia University Press.
Ozouf, Jacques (1963) “L’enquête d’opinion en histoire. Un exemple: L’instituteur français, 1900–1914.Le mouvement social 44: 322.
Raj, Des (1972) The Design of Sample Surveys. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Robinson, Claude E. (1932) Straw Votes: A Study of Political Prediction. New York: Columbia University Press.
Robinson, Claude E. (1937) “Recent developments in the straw-poll field.Public Opinion Quarterly 1 (1): 4556.
Robinson, Claude E. (1939) “Measuring public opinion.Savings Bank Journal 20 (4): 24.
Robinson, Daniel J. (1999) The Measure of Democracy: Polling, Market Research, and Public Life, 1930–1945. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Roper, Elmo (1940) “Sampling public opinion.Journal of the American Statistical Association (210, pt. 1): 32534.
Roper Center for Public Opinion Research (2003a) Gallup Poll no. 83.
Roper Center for Public Opinion Research (2003b) USAIPO1937-0083.
Rossi, Peter H. Wright, James D. Anderson, Andy B., eds. (1983) Handbook of Survey Research. New York: Academic.
Rugg, Donald (1947) “How representative are ‘representative samples’?,” in Cantril, Hadley (ed.) Gauging Public Opinion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press: 14349.
Rusciano, Frank Louis (2007) “Book Reviews: Susan Ohmer; George Gallup in Hollywood.Public Opinion Quarterly 71 (2): 31418.
Saxon, Wolfgang (2000) “Seymour Sudman, 71, expert in survey design.New York Times, May 8.
Shively, W. Phillips (1972) “A reinterpretation of the New Deal realignment.Public Opinion Quarterly 35 (4): 62124.
Smith, Charles W. Jr. (1952) “Measurement of voter attitude.Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (283): 14855.
Squire, Peverill (1988) “Why the 1936 Literary Digest poll failed.Public Opinion Quarterly 52 (1): 12533.
Stephan, Frederick F. (1939) “Representative sampling in large-scale surveys.Journal of the American Statistical Association (206): 34352.
Stephan, Frederick F.(1942) “An iterative method of adjusting sample frequency tables when expected marginal totals are known.Annals of Mathematical Statistics 13 (2): 16678.
US Bureau of the Census (1931) Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1931. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
US Bureau of the Census (1943) Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1942. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
US Bureau of the Census (1970) Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1970. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
US Bureau of the Census (1997) Historical Statistics of the United States on CD-ROM: From Colonial Times to 1970, ed. Carter, Susan B.. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Weiner, Sanford L. (1976–77) “The competition for certainty: The polls and the press in Britain.Political Science Quarterly 91 (4): 67396.
Weisberg, Herbert F. Krosnick, Jon A. Bowen, Bruce D. (1998) An Introduction to Survey Research, Polling, and Data Analysis, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Wilks, Samuel S. (1940) “Representative sampling and poll reliability.Public Opinion Quarterly 4 (2): 26169.
Willcox, Walter F. (1931) “An attempt to measure public opinion about repealing the Eighteenth Amendment.Journal of the American Statistical Association, n.s. (175): 24361.
Wright, Gerald C. (1993) “Errors in measuring vote choice in the national election studies, 1952–88.American Journal of Political Science 37 (1): 291316.
Zeisel, Hans (1985) Say It with Figures, 6th ed. New York: Harper and Row.
Zunz, Oliver (1998) Why the American Century? Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Social Science History
  • ISSN: 0145-5532
  • EISSN: 1527-8034
  • URL: /core/journals/social-science-history
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 5 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 534 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th September 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.