Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Concepts of Disease and the Abuse of Psychiatry in the USSR

  • K. W. M. Fulford (a1), A. Y. U. Smirnov (a2) and E. Snow (a3)
Abstract

There is a strong prima facie case linking the abuse of psychiatry with difficulties about the concept of mental illness. However, a survey of recent Soviet literature showed that the concept of disease employed in the former USSR (where abuse was for a time widespread) was similar to its counterparts in the UK and USA in being strongly scientific in nature. A number of factors - legal, bureaucratic and professional - are important in abuse becoming widespread. These, however, fail to explain why psychiatry, rather than physical medicine, should be vulnerable to abuse. It is here that the concept of disease could be important. A scientific model of disease suggests that a significant vulnerability factor is the relatively underdeveloped status of psychiatry as a science. This leaves room for poor standards of scientific work in clinical research and practice, factors which are recognised as important in the Soviet case. In addition to the scientific element, there is an evaluative element of meaning in the concept of disease. Hence a second vulnerability factor could be the evaluatively problematic nature of judgements. of mental illness. It is concluded that a failure to recognise this factor greatly increases the vulnerability of psychiatry, not only to gross abuses, but also to inadvertent misuses of involuntary treatment in everyday practice. This conclusion, far from undermining the role of science in psychiatry, is a step towards clarifying its proper role.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Correspondence
References
Hide All
Akhmedzhanov, M. (1971) Methodological aspects of the problem of determining the basic concepts of medicine. Journal of the Academy of Medical Science, 26 (4), 4550.
Akhmedzhanov, M. (1973) Apropos of the article of academician V. Kh. Vasilenko: “The problem of the concept of disease”. Clinical Medicine, 51 (5), 139142.
Akhmedzhanov, M. & Lipshits, A. M. (1971) On the discussion of the “disease” concept. Archives of Pathology, 30 (3), 8790.
Aleksakhina, R. I. (1968) The concept of “essence” and the question of the essence of the disease. Journal of the Academy of Medical Science, 23 (1), 3034.
Birley, J. L. T. (1991) Psychiatrists and citizens. British Journal of Psychiatry, 159, 16.
Bloch, S. & Reddaway, P. (1977) Russia's Political Hospitals. London: Gollancz.
Bloch, S. & Chodoff, P. (1991) Psychiatric Ethics (2nd edn). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Boorse, C. (1975) On the distinction between disease and illness. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 5, 4968.
Clare, A. (1979) The disease concept in psychiatry. In Essentials of Postgraduate Psychiatry (eds Hill, P., Murray, R. ft Thorley, A.). New York: Academic Press, Grune & Stratton.
Davidovskii, I. V. (1962) Problems of Causality in Medicine. Moscow: The State Medical Publisher.
Davidovskii, & Sil-vestrov, V. E. (1966) On the definition of “disease” concept. Archives of Pathology, 28 (1), 38.
Davidovskii, & Snezhnevsky, A. V. (1972) Schizophrenia. Moscow: News of the Academy of Medical Science.
Fulford, K. W. M. (1989) Moral Theory and Medical Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fulford, K. W. M. (1990) Philosophy and medicine: the Oxford connection. British Journal of Psychiatry, 157, 111115.
Fulford, K. W. M. (1991) The concept of disease. In Psychiatric Ethics (2nd edn) (eds Bloch, S. ft Chodoff, P.), ch. 6. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fulford, K. W. M. (1993) Dissent and dissensus: the limits of consensus formation in psychiatry. In Consensus Formation in Health Care Ethics (eds Have, H. T. ft Sass, M.). Kluwer (in press).
Galankin, V. N. (1988) The interrelation of adaptation and disease in phylogeny and ontogeny. Archives of Pathology, 50 (10), 7378.
Gluzman, S. (1989) On the road towards science and law. Neolitsinskaio jazeta, 60, 21 May, p. 31.
Hare, R. M. (1963) Descriptivism. Proceedings of the British Academy, 49, 115134. Reprinted in Essays on the Moral Concepts (1972) (ed. Hare, R. M.). London: Macmillan Press.
Hesse, M. (1980) Revolutions and Reconstructions in the Philosophy of Science. Brighton: Harvester Press.
Il-in, B. M. (1988) The concept of human health. Journal of the Academy of Medical Science, 4, 1518.
Jaspers, K. (1913) Causal and “meaningful” connexions between life history and psychosis. In Themes and Variations in European Psychiatry (1974) (eds Kirsch, S. R. ft Shepherd, M.), ch. 5. Bristol: Wright ft Sons.
Kagermazov, U. A. (1973) Concepts of “norm”, “health” and “disease”. Journal of the Academy of Medical Science, 28 (9), 1622.
Kendell, R. E. (1975) The concept of disease and its implications for psychiatry. British Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 305315.
Kopelman, L. M. (1990) On the evaluative nature of competency and capacity judgements. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 13, 309329.
Koryagin, A. (1989) The involvement of soviet psychiatry in the persecution of dissenters. British Journal of Psychiatry, 154, 336340.
Lewis, A. J. (1955) Health as a social concept. British Journal of Sociology, 4, 109124.
Mayer-Gross, W., Slater, E. & Roth, M. (1969) Clinical Psychiatry. London: Baillière, Tindall ft Cassell.
Merskey, H. (1986) Variable meanings for the definition of disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 11, 215232.
Merskey, H. & Shafran, B. (1986) Political hazards in the diagnosis of sluggish schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry, 148, 247256.
New Scientist (1990) Soviet psychiatrists paid to issue false diagnoses. New Scientist, 17 February, p. 19.
Novikov, A. (1988) Investigations of the ‘closed’ themes. Komsomolsuaia Pravda, 164, 16 July, p. 14.
Pavlenko, S. M. (1980) Systems approach to the study of the problem of nosology and the concept of sanatogenesis. Soviet Medicine, 10, 9396.
Petlenko, V. P., Strukov, A. I. & Khmel-Nitskii, O. K. (1984) The deterministic concept of human diseases. Archives of Pathology, 46 (10), 310.
Petrov, S. S. & Petrov, S. V. (1989) The content of the concepts of “etiology” and “pathogenesis”. Archives of Pathology, 4, 8791.
Reich, W. (1991) Psychiatric diagnosis as an ethical problem. In Psychiatric Ethics (2nd edn) (eds Bloch, S. ft Chodoff, P.), pp. 101135. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Roth, M. & Kroll, J. (1986) The Reality of Mental Illness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sarkisov, D. S. (1973) Apropos of the article by academician V. Kh. Vasilenko: “The problem of the concept of disease”. Clinical Medicine, 51 (5), 143145.
Schmidt, Y., Morozov, G., Badalyan, L., et al (1973) A letter from the Presidium of the All-Union Society of Neurologists and Psychiatrists to The Guardian. Reprinted in Russia's Political Hospitals (1977) (eds Bloch, S. ft Reddaway, P.). London: Victor Gollancz.
Sedgwick, P. (1973) Illness - mental and otherwise. The Hastings Studies Center Studies I, 3, 1940.
Shafran, B., Merskey, H. & Zoubok, B. (1989) Comments on ‘slowly progressive schizophrenia’ by A. B. Smulevitch. British Journal of Psychiatry, 155, 174177.
Sil-Vestrov, V. E. (1968) Definition of the “disease” concept - the key to discovery of general, particular and specific regularities of pathology. Archives of Pathology, 30 (3), 9092.
Smulevitch, A. B. (1989) Slowly progressive schizophrenia - myth or clinical reality? British Journal of Psychiatry, 155, 166177.
Snezhnevsky, A. V. (1971) The symptomatology, clinical forms and nosology of schizophrenia. In Modern Perspectives in World Psychiatry (ed. Howells, J. G.). New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Snezhnevsky, A. V. & Vartanyan, M. (1970) The forms of schizophrenia and their biological correlates. In Biochemistry, Schizophrenia and Affective Illnesses (ed. Himwich, H. E.). Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
Szasz, T. S. (1960) The myth of mental illness. American Psychologist, 15, 113118.
Totsuka, E. (1990) The history of Japanese psychiatry and the rights of mental patients. Psychiatric Bulletin, 14, 193200.
Urmson, J. O. (1950) On grading. Mind, 59, 145169.
Vail, S. S. (1973) Some observations apropos of the article by academician V. Kh. Vasilenko: “The problem of the concept of disease”. Clinical Medicine, 51 (5), 142143.
Vasilenko, V. Kh. (1972) The concept of disease. Clinical Medicine, 50 (9), 140146.
Vasilenko, V. Kh. (1976) Discussion about concept of disease and concomitant problems. Clinical Medicine, 54 (12), 114124.
Vauhkonen, K. (1968) On the Pathogenesis of Morbid Jealousy, with Special Reference to the Personality Traits of, and Interaction between, Jealous Patients and their Spouses. Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
Vilensky, D. (1990) Psychiatry and politics. Argumenty i Facti, 14, 713.
Vlasiuk, V. V. (1980) Concept of etiology as interaction. Journal of the Academy of Medical Science, 8, 6874.
Vlasov, V. V. (1988) Concepts of the development of disease in the theory of internal medicine. Soviet Medicine, 1, 5053.
Warnock, G. J. (1967) Contemporary Moral Philosophy. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press.
Williams, B. (1985) Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy. London: Fontana.
Wing, J. K. (1978) Reasoning About Madness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
World Health Organization (1973) Report of the International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia. Geneva: WHO.
World Health Organization (1978) Mental Disorders: Glossary and Guide to their Classification in Accordance with the Ninth Revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-9). Geneva: WHO.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The British Journal of Psychiatry
  • ISSN: 0007-1250
  • EISSN: 1472-1465
  • URL: /core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed

Concepts of Disease and the Abuse of Psychiatry in the USSR

  • K. W. M. Fulford (a1), A. Y. U. Smirnov (a2) and E. Snow (a3)
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.

×

Reply to: Submit a response


Your details


Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *