Skip to main content
×
Home

‘Currency manipulation’ and world trade

  • ROBERT W. STAIGER (a1) and ALAN O. SYKES (a2)
Abstract
Abstract

Central bank intervention in foreign exchange markets may, under some conditions, stimulate exports and retard imports. In the past few years, this issue has moved to center stage because of the foreign exchange policies of China. Numerous public officials and commentators argue that China has engaged in impermissible ‘currency manipulation’, and various proposals for stiff action against China have been advanced. This paper considers the relationship between exchange rate policy and international trade, and addresses the questions of whether and how currency manipulation should be addressed by the international trading system. Our conclusions are at odds with much of what is currently being said by proponents of multilateral or unilateral actions against China. In particular, we question whether China's practices can be adjudicated to be ‘manipulation’ under international law, and doubt that their trade effects can be identified with the degree of confidence necessary to ascertain whether the practices ‘frustrate the intent’ of WTO/GATT commitments. The difficulty of identifying the trade effects of currency practices undermines the ability of the WTO dispute resolution system to address them, and calls into question the wisdom and legitimacy of unilateral countermeasures that have been proposed in various quarters.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Email: rstaiger@stanford.edu
References
Hide All
Bagwell K. and Staiger R. W. (1999), ‘An Economic Theory of GATT’, American Economic Review, March.
Bagwell K. and Staiger R. W. (2002), The Economics of the World Trading System, MIT Press.
Bacchetta P. and van Wincoop E. (2005), ‘A theory of the currency denomination of international trade’, Journal of International Economics, 67: 295319.
Bergsten C. F. (2007), ‘The Global Imbalances and the US Economy’, Testimony before the Subcom-mittees on Trade, Ways and Means Committee: Commerce, Trade and Consumer Protection, Energy and Commerce Committee; and Domestic and International Monetary Policy, Trade and Technology, Financial Services Committee of the House of Representatives, 9 May.
Betts C. and Devereux M. B. (2000), ‘Exchange Rate Dynamics in a Model of Pricing-to-Market’, Journal of International Economics, 50(1): 215244.
Blanchard E. J. (2009), ‘Trade taxes and international investment’, Canadian Journal of Economics, 50(3): 882899.
Broda C. and Weinstein D. E. (2007), ‘Understanding International Price Differences Using Barcode Data’, mimeo, November.
Canzoneri M. and Henderson D. (1991), Monetary Policy in Interdependent Economies, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Caves R., Frankel J., and Jones R. (2005), World Trade And Payments: An Introduction, Ninth Edition, Addison-Wesley.
Chipman J. S. (2006), ‘Protection and Exchange Rates in a Small Open Economy’, Review of Devel-opment Economics, 10(4).
Cline W. (2005), The United States as a Debtor Nation, Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics.
Corden M. (1985), Protection, Growth and Trade: Essays in International Economics, Oxford: Blackwell.
Corsetti G. and Pesenti P. (2007), ‘The Simple Geometry of Transmission and Stabilization in Closed and Open Economies’, European University Institute mimeo, September.
Dam K. W. (1982). The Rules of the Game, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Devereux M. B., Kang S. and Xu Juanyi (2007), ‘Global Monetary Policy under a Dollar Standard’, Journal of International Economics, 71(1): 113132.
Engel C. (2002), ‘Expenditure Switching and Exchange Rate Policy’, NBER Macroeconomics Annual, 17: 231272.
Feenstra R. C. (1985), ‘Anticipated Devaluations, Currency Flight, and Direct Trade Controls in a Monetary Economy’, American Economic Review, 75(3): 386401.
Goldberg L. and Tille C. (2006), ‘The International Role of the Dollar and Trade Balance Adjustment’, Group of 30 Occasional Paper No. 71, Washington, DC.
Goldberg L. and Tille C. (2009), ‘Micro, Macro, and Strategic Forces in International Trade Invoicing’, NBER Working Paper No. 15470, November.
Goldstein M. and Lardy N. R. (eds.) (2008), Debating China's Exchange Rate Policy, Washington, DC: Peterson Institute for International Economics.
Gopinath G., Itskhoki O., and Rigobon R. (forthcoming), ‘Currency Choice and Exchange Rate Pass-through’, Quarterly Journal of Economics.
Hudec R. E. (1990), The GATT Legal System and World Trade Diplomacy. Salem, NH: Butterworth Legal Publishers.
Hufbauer G. C., Wong Yee, and Sheth K. (2006), US – China Trade Disputes: Rising Tide, Rising Stakes, Policy Analyses in International Economics, 78. Washington: Institute for International Economics.
IMF (2006a), ‘Article IV of the Fund's Articles of Agreement: An Overview of the Legal Framework’, 28 June.
IMF (2006b), ‘Treatment of Exchange Rate Issues in Bilateral Surveillance – A Stocktaking’, 30 August.
IMF (2007a), ‘Surveillance Guidelines: Landmark Framework for IMF Surveillance’, IMF Survey Online, 21 June, at http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/survey/so/2007/POL0621B.htm.
IMF (2007b), ‘Bilateral Surveillance over Member's Policies’, Executive Board Decision, 15 June.
IMF (2007c), ‘Review of the 1997 Decision – Proposal for a New Decision’ Supplement, 13 June.
Jackson J. H., Davey W. J., and Sykes A. O. (2008), International Economic Relations, 5th edn, Minneapolis: Thompson West.
Helpman E. and Krugman P. R. (1989), Trade Policy and Market Structure, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Keynes J. M. (1931), Addendum I to: Great Britain, Committee on Finance and Industry, Report. London: His Majesty's Stationery Office, pp. 190209.
Krugman P. R. and Obstfeld M. (2007), International Economics, 7th edn, Boston: Addison Wesley.
Lerner A. (1936), ‘The Symmetry between Import and Export Taxes’, Economica, NS, 3 (August) 306313.
Ma G. and McCauley R. N. (2008), ‘Efficacy of China's Capital Controls: Evidence from Price and Flow Data’, Pacific Economic Review, 13(1): 104123.
Mattoo A. and Subramanian A. (2009), ‘Currency Undervaluation and Sovereign Wealth Funds: A New Role for the World Trade Organization’, The World Economy, 32: 11351164.
Mayer W. (1981), ‘Theoretical considerations on negotiated tariff adjustments’, Oxford Economic Papers, 33: 135153.
McKinnon R. (2006), ‘Why China Should Keep Its Exchange Rate Pegged to the Dollar: A Historical Perspective from Japan’, mimeo.
McKinnon R. (2009), ‘China's Exchange Rate Policy and Fiscal Expansion’, SIEPR Policy Brief, March.
McCown A. T., Pollard P., and Weeks J. (2007), ‘Equilibrium Exchange Rate Models and Misalignments’, US Department of Treasury, Office of International Affairs, Occasional Paper No. 7, March.
Mussa M. (1974), ‘A Monetary Approach to Balance-of-Payments Analysis’, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 6(3): 333351.
Mussa M. (1985), ‘The Real Exchange Rate as a Tool of Commercial Policy’, NBER Working Paper No. 1577, March.
Mussa M. (2007), ‘IMF Surveillance over China's Exchange Rate Policy’, Peterson Institute of International Economics Working Paper.
Obstfeld M. (2007), ‘The Renminbi's Dollar Peg at the Crossroads’, Monetary and Economic Studies (special edition), Bank of Japan, December.
Obstfeld M. and Rogoff K. (1995), ‘Exchange Rate Dynamics Redux’, Journal of Political Economy, 103: 624660.
Obstfeld M. and Rogoff K. (1996), Foundations of International Macroeconomics, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Obstfeld M. and Rogoff K. (2002), ‘Global Implications of Self-Oriented National Monetary Rules’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117: 503536.
O'Connell S. A. (1989), ‘Uniform Trade Taxes, Devaluation, and the Real Exchange Rate: A Theoretical Analysis’, Policy Planning and Research Working Paper Series, No. 185, The World Bank, April.
Pesenti P. (2008), ‘The Global Economy Model (GEM): Theoretical Framework’, IMF Staff Papers, 55(2): 243284.
Razin A. and Svensson L. E. O. (1983), ‘Trade Taxes and the Current Account’, Economics Letters, 13: 5557.
Rogoff K. (2006), ‘Global Imbalances and Exchange Rate Adjustment’, Journal of Policy Modeling, 28: 695699.
Sarno L. and Taylor M. P. (2001), ‘Official Intervention in the Foreign Exchange Market: Is it Effective and, If So, How Does It Work?’, Journal of Economic Literature, 39 (September): 839868.
Subramanian A. (2008), ‘Imbalances and undervalued exchange rates: Rehabilitating Keynes’, FT.com, 9 November.
Tchakarov I. (2004), ‘The Gains from International Monetary Cooperation Revisited’, IMF Working Paper WP/01/1, January.
Torres H. R. (2007), ‘Reforming the International Monetary Fund – Why Its Legitimacy is at Stake’, Journal of International Economic Law, 10: 443460.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

World Trade Review
  • ISSN: 1474-7456
  • EISSN: 1475-3138
  • URL: /core/journals/world-trade-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 21
Total number of PDF views: 179 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 949 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.