Skip to main content

US–Stainless Steel (Mexico)


The US–Mexico Stainless-Steel dispute presents two interesting questions. First, what role does and should stare decisis (precedent) play in the WTO dispute-resolution system? Second, are there circumstances under which exceptional methodologies, i.e. ‘zeroing’, can better achieve the stated objectives of the agreement than the standard methodologies explicitly stated in the agreement? We argue that the institutional structure and foundational norms of the WTO imply the need for Panels to be bound by the prior decisions of the Appellate Body. Our economic analysis describes the costs and benefits of legal systems with and without precedent. Regarding methodology, we argue that any analysis of the suitability of a methodology (i.e. ‘zeroing’) must be undertaken jointly with an analysis of the underlying objective of the agreement (i.e. remedying injury). We conclude that, under limited circumstances, the ‘zeroing’ methodology is more effective at remedying injury than the ordinary methodology outlined in the Anti-Dumping Agreement.

Corresponding author
Hide All
Anderlini Luca, Leonardo Felli, and Alessandro Riboni (2008), ‘Statute Law or Case Law?’, August, Georgetown University mimeo.
Blonigen Bruce A. and Jee-Hyeong Park (2004), ‘Dynamic Pricing in the Presence of Antidumping Policy: Theory and Evidence’, American Economic Review, 94: 134154.
Bown Chad P. and Sykes Alan O. (2008), ‘The Zeroing Issue: A Critical Analysis of Softwood V’, World Trade Review, 7(1): 121142.
Crowley Meredith A. (2008), ‘Split Decisions in Antidumping Cases’, February, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago mimeo.
Crowley Meredith A. (2009), ‘Cyclical Dumping and US Antidumping Protection: 1980–2001’, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Working Paper (WP-2007-21), March.
Deardorff Alan V. (2005), ‘Glossary of International Economics’, available at (last visited 4 January 2010).
Gennaioli Nicola and Shleifer Andrei (2007a), ‘The Evolution of Common Law’, Journal of Political Economy, 115: 4368.
Gennaioli Nicola and Shleifer Andrei (2007b), ‘Overruling and the Instability of Law’, Journal of Comparative Economics, 35: 309328.
Janow Merit E. and Staiger Robert W. (2003), ‘EC–Bed Linen’, in Horn Henrik and Mavroidis Petros C. (eds.), The WTO Case Law of 2001: The American Law Institute Reporters' Studies, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 115139.
Knoops Geert-Jan Alexander (2005), Theory and Practice of International and Internationalized Criminal Proceedings, Kluwer Law International, pp. 45.
Kornhauser Lewis A. (1989), ‘An Economic Perspective on stare decisis’, Chicago Kent Law Review, 65: 6392.
Maggi Giovanni and Staiger Robert W. (2008), ‘On the Role and Design of Dispute Settlement Procedures in International Trade Agreements’, NBER Working Paper #14067.
Prusa Thomas J. and Vermulst Edwin (January 2009), ‘A One-Two Punch on Zeroing: US–Zeroing (EC) and US–Zeroing (Japan)’, World Trade Review, 8: 187241.
Schott Peter K. (2008), ‘The Relative Sophistication of Chinese Exports’, Economic Policy, 53 (January): 5–49.
Staiger Robert W. and Wolak Frank A. (1992), ‘The Effects of Domestic Antidumping Law in the Presence of Foreign Monopoly’, Journal of International Economics, 32 (3–4): 265287.
Staiger Robert W. and Wolak Frank A. (1994), ‘Measuring Industry Specific Protection: Antidumping in the United States’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity: Microeconomics, Volume 1.
Tyner Davis B. (2006), ‘Internationalization of War Crimes Prosecutions: Correcting the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia's Folly in Tadic’, Florida Journal of International Law, 18: 843885.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

World Trade Review
  • ISSN: 1474-7456
  • EISSN: 1475-3138
  • URL: /core/journals/world-trade-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 32 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 358 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 14th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.