Hostname: page-component-76d6cb85b7-f97m6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-07-13T02:22:59.478Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 June 2025

Alexandra Leskova
Affiliation:
IPSiM, University of Montpellier, CNRS, INRAE, Institut Agro, Montpellier, France
Tou C. Xiong
Affiliation:
IPSiM, University of Montpellier, CNRS, INRAE, Institut Agro, Montpellier, France
Stéphane Mari
Affiliation:
IPSiM, University of Montpellier, CNRS, INRAE, Institut Agro, Montpellier, France
Catherine Curie*
Affiliation:
IPSiM, University of Montpellier, CNRS, INRAE, Institut Agro, Montpellier, France
*
Corresponding author: Catherine Curie; Email: catherine.curie@cnrs.fr

Abstract

Iron (Fe) is an essential element in plants, involved in numerous metabolic processes including photosynthesis. Its cellular concentration must be regulated accurately to avoid toxicity while meeting metabolic demands. This review explores the distribution, dynamics, and regulation of Fe pools in plant cells, focusing on recent advances in imaging and quantification techniques. We discuss the major Fe compartments—chloroplasts, vacuoles, apoplasts—and their interaction to maintain Fe homeostasis, as well as novel methodologies like single-cell ICP-MS that have transformed our understanding of Fe localization. By summarizing the current knowledge on intracellular Fe dynamics and the complex interplay between different Fe pools, we provide insights into the mechanisms that underpin Fe regulation in plants, which is crucial for future breeding programs aimed at improving plant resilience and nutritional quality.

Information

Type
Review
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press in association with John Innes Centre
Figure 0

Figure 1. Quantitative representation of Fe distribution across different cell layers in the primary root of Arabidopsis. (a) Schematic representation of the symplastic Fe concentration measured via ICP-MS in tissue-specific cell-sorted root protoplasts, based on data from Giehl et al. (2023). (b) Distribution of labile Fe2+ in the Arabidopsis root showing polar localization in the epidermis (based on data from Alcon et al., 2024). Left: Longitudinal confocal laser scanning microscopy images of the differentiation and mature zones of the primary root of Arabidopsis stained with an Fe2+-specific fluorescent probe and counter-stained with propidium iodide. The pictures show enrichment of Fe2+ in cell walls and opposite polarity in the two root stages. Right: Schematic representation of the distribution and relative quantification of labile Fe2+ pools in the same two root regions. Fe levels are represented using a color-coded scale. Magenta LUT: SiRhoNox-1, Fe2+; Blue LUT: Propidium iodide, PI. Ep = epidermis; c = cortex; en = endodermis. Scale bar = 20 μm.

Figure 1

Table 1 Comparison of advanced analytical methods for measuring iron content and dynamics in plant tissues and cells

Author comment: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R0/PR1

Comments

Dear Editor,

You kindly invited me to write a review for Quantitative Plant Biology. Together with my colleagues Alexandra Leskova, Tou Cheu Xiong and Stéphane Mari, we are submitting a review entitled: “Untangling Iron Threads: a Deep Dive into the Intracellular Pools”.

The review explores the distribution, dynamics, and regulation of Fe pools in plant cells, focusing on recent advances in imaging and quantification techniques. We discuss the major Fe compartments—chloroplasts, vacuoles, apoplasts—and their interaction to maintain Fe homeostasis, as well as novel methodologies like single-cell ICP-MS that have transformed our understanding of Fe localization.

With best regards,

Catherine Curie

Review: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R0/PR2

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

The review has a clear objective: to summarize recent advancements in detecting major iron pools within cells, mapping their distribution, and elucidating their functions in cellular compartments. The manuscript successfully achieves this by presenting cutting-edge methodologies such as single-cell ICP-MS, fluorescent probes, and LA-ICP-MS, which have advanced the detection of symplastic and labile iron, including its oxidation states.

The topic is highly relevant to plant physiology, particularly in understanding iron homeostasis and its role in improving crop resilience and nutritional value. The review is well-organized, with robust conclusions highlighting critical gaps and paving the way for future research. The literature review is comprehensive, referencing significant studies to establish a strong foundation.

Thanks to the implementation of advanced technologies, several significant findings have been highlighted such as: 1) Labile iron is predominantly localized in the apoplast. 2) NanoSIMS has shown iron accumulation in endosperm vacuoles, including vesicle fusion. 3) Substantial amounts of iron have been detected in nuclei and nucleoli.

The manuscript raises important questions for future exploration, such as the role of iron in the apoplast and nucleus, reliable methods for detecting trace levels of iron in organelles, and mechanisms of iron transport across the plasma membrane.

I have only a few comments:

1. The methodology section is thorough and aligns with the study’s objectives, with techniques like single-cell ICP-MS and fluorescence probes highlighted as significant advancements. However, adding a chapter comparing these methods could provide additional value. This section could outline each method’s strengths, limitations, and complementary aspects, enhancing clarity and underscoring how these techniques improve our understanding of intracellular iron dynamics.

2. The manuscript is well-written, but certain sections could be simplified to improve readability using language refinement tools.

3. The sentence regarding iron utilization in the chloroplast (lines 110–111) could perhaps be made a bit more precise. In addition to its role in the electron transport chain and Fe-S protein synthesis, the chloroplast also uses iron for the biosynthesis of other compounds, which might be worth mentioning.

4. Lines 111–112 mention ferritin in the chloroplast stroma but lack information on its developmental stage-specific accumulation. Providing this context would be relevant in understanding iron homeostasis.

5. Although the figure legends provide the methodologies used to detect and quantify iron distribution for both panels A and B, the figure itself only includes the method for panel A, with panel B lacking this information. Including this information on the figure might make it easier to follow.

Overall, this manuscript provides an excellent overview of technological advancements in studying intracellular iron dynamics and makes substantial contributions to the field.

Review: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R0/PR3

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

In this review article, Alexandra Leskova and colleagues present recent advances in our understanding of iron intracellular pools in plants, highlighting major technical advances that enabled those advances. The review also outlines the many remaining challenges and unknows of iron distribution in cells.

The manuscript is authored by a team that is expert of the topic and that contributed many landmark studies in the plant iron homeostasis field. The text is both expert and accessible to the more general reader.

I have only minor comments to further improve the manuscript.

1) In many cases, whole paragraphs or important statements are without citations. I would suggest to include references to support the text. For instance, lines 57-63, line 93, lines 109-115, …

2) Lines 72-74. I would specify which are those two studies (citations + naming more precisely the methods), as it may be unclear down in the text which they are.

3) Lines 162-164. This sentence is unclear to me, as it seems it refers to (an)other species than Arabidopsis, although such species is not specified and the two references at the end of the sentence are about Arabidopsis.

4) The example of chloroplast/vacuole coordinated Fe storage via YSLs and NRAMPs is somehow counterintuitive. Is it correct that it either results in Fe depletion (no YSLs, associated to NRAMPs shutdown) or Fe excess (YSL overexpression associated to reduced vacuolar Fe) in the cytoplasm? One might expect some sort of compensation.

5) Here are a few typos/suggestions :

- line 43 : Fe-proteins --> Fe proteins

- line 50 : The --> the

Recommendation: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R0/PR4

Comments

Dear Cathy et al.,

your manuscript has now been seen by two reviewers. I apologize for the delay, but the last two months of the year are always busy around the world. Both reviewers are very positive and think that the MS makes a substantial contribution to the field. The reviewers mentioned a few points that might help to polish the MS in a minor revision. Please have a look at their comments and see how you can implement their suggestions. Thank you very much for your valuable contribution to the Research Topic “Quantitative approaches to cellular aspects of plant ion homeostasis”.

Best wishes, Merry Xmas and All the Best for the New Year.

Ingo

Decision: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R0/PR5

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Author comment: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R1/PR6

Comments

Dear Ingo,

Thank you very much for handling our Review and for all your suggestions of improvement. I believe that we have addressed the majority of them. The biggest modification is the incorporation of a Table 1 that compares the analytical techniques described in the Review and highlights their specific strengths (see below in our responses). This is to answer the comment #1 of Reviewer 1. We believe that it is a valuable addition to the Review and will likely boost its citation rate.

Let me know whether we can improve the manuscript further in any way.

With best regards,

Cathy

Recommendation: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R1/PR7

Comments

Dear authors,

Thank you for the careful revision of the manuscript. And thanks again for your valuable contribution to the Research Topic “Quantitative approaches to cellular aspects of plant ion homeostasis”. It is highly appreciated.

Best regards, Ingo

Decision: Untangling iron threads: A deep dive into plant intracellular pools — R1/PR8

Comments

No accompanying comment.