INTRODUCTION
Human toxocarosis is a parasitic disease caused by larval stages of Toxocara canis and Toxocara cati, frequent parasites of domestic and wild carnivores. The life-cycle of these parasites is direct, adult worms live in the intestinal tract of definitive host and shed eggs via the faeces into the environment. Humans may become infected after the accidental ingestion of embryonated Toxocara eggs or, more rarely, by ingesting encapsulated larvae contained in the raw or undercooked tissues of paratenic hosts, such as cows, sheep or chicken. In the small intestine larvae hatch from the eggs and migrate through the body, but do not develop to adult worms. The clinical spectrum of Toxocara infestation in humans varies from asymptomatic, the most common form, to severe organ injury. Two clinical syndromes are classically described: visceral larva migrans (VLM; a systemic disease caused by migration of larvae through organs) or, if there is eye damage, ocular larva migrans [Reference Rubinsky-Elefant1]. Neurotoxocarosis has been also described in previous studies [Reference Eberhardt2, Reference Finsterer and Auer3].
The Roma belong to one of the oldest and largest minorities in Europe. In general, their socioeconomic conditions and health, especially those living in segregated settlements, are worse than that of the non-Roma population. Their health status is characterized by shorter life expectancy, higher infant mortality, numerous chronic illnesses, unbalanced nutrition and unhealthy lifestyle [Reference Liegois and Gheorghe4]. Segregated settlements, often with no access to electricity, tap water and sewage system [Reference Rudohradská5], are concentrated in small areas with large numbers of people and domestic animals in one place. Such conditions can significantly contribute to the spread of infectious and parasitic diseases, but the literature dealing health conditions and occurrence of diseases in the Roma ethnic minority is sparse [Reference Földes and Covaci6, Reference Hajduchová and Urban7]. Moreover, information about the occurrence of parasitic diseases in Roma people is scarce or completely missing. Therefore, the aim of this cross-sectional population-based study was to map the seroprevalence of human toxocarosis in the population living in separated and segregated Roma settlements and to compare it with the occurrence of specific antibodies in the non-Roma population living in the catchment area of Eastern Slovakia. Occurrence of clinical symptoms and infection risk factors were also analysed.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Collection of data
Data from the cross-sectional population-based HepaMeta study conducted in Slovakia in 2011 were used. This project aimed to map the prevalence of viral hepatitis B/C and metabolic syndrome in the population living in separated and segregated Roma settlements and to compare it with the occurrence of the same health indicators in the majority non-Roma population. The HepaMeta study was set up following the principles of community-based participatory research. Roma, as the target group, were involved in the process of questionnaire development (designing and piloting) and data collection through active involvement of Roma community workers in all phases of the study [Reference Madarasová8].
The target population comprised residents of settlements in the Košice region (Eastern Slovakia) and the control group was the non-Roma population in the same region and of the same age composition. With cooperation between the HepaMeta team, general practitioners and Roma community workers a total of 429 Roma respondents from the segregated settlements and 394 respondents from the non-Roma population living in the same sub-region of Eastern Slovakia were included in the study. Inclusion criteria for the respondents were as follows: no preventive medical check-up in the past 2 years, no acute illness, age between 18 and 55 years, and availability during the week of data collection.
Trained medical personnel collected blood samples and selected medical data, and assisted respondents in completing the questionnaire developed by a group of experts (public health experts, academics, Roma health mediators and community workers). The questionnaire gathered information on socio-demographic background, living conditions, health-related behaviour, health, and healthcare use. The questionnaire also contained questions about education which was divided into three categories (elementary, secondary vocational school, higher education) and employment status. The economic situation and poverty were assessed by the presence of any problems regarding regular living expenses (e.g. rent, electricity and water costs, healthcare, general shopping, loans). Style of living was assessed according to the presence of household sanitary facilities, and type of household heating.
The analyses of soil from segregated settlements would have been very useful for better interpretation and understanding of results, but unfortunately no soil samples were taken during the collection of samples and data within the HepaMeta study.
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine at Šafárik University, Košice (No. 104/2011). Participation in the study was on a fully voluntary basis and anonymous. Detailed information about the study and its procedures was given to all respondents, and informed consent was obtained prior to the medical examination.
Serological tests
Collection of venous blood was performed under standard conditions, after overnight fasting, from a peripheral vein in the antecubital fossa. After centrifugation of the blood, serum samples were collected and stored at –20 °C until tested. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used for the detection of anti-Toxocara antibodies. T. canis larval excretory-secretory (E/S) antigen was prepared according to method of de Savigny [Reference De Savigny9]. Microtitre plates were coated overnight at 4 °C with antigen containing 1 μg/ml protein diluted in carbonate buffer (pH 9·6). The plates were washed three times and serum samples (diluted 1:200) were placed on plates in a volume of 100 μl per well. After 1 h incubation at 37 °C the plates were repeatedly washed three times. Horseradish peroxidase-labelled anti-human IgG (anti-human IgG, Sigma-Aldrich, USA) diluted 1: 40 000 in a volume of 100 μl was used as conjugate. After incubation for 1 h, plates were washed three times and 100 μl substrate (o-phenylenediamine with 0·05% H2O2) was added. The reaction was stopped after 20 min of incubation in the dark at room temperature by 50 μl of 2 m H2SO4 and optical density (OD) was measured spectrophotometrically at 490 nm (Thermo Labsystems Opsys MR, USA).
Sera of patients with confirmed Toxocara infection (obtained with the cooperation of infection clinics) and negative sera were used as controls. Positivity or negativity of control sera was verified by Toxocara IgG EIA test kit (Test Line, Czech Republic). Cut-off value was calculated according to OD values of positive and negative control panel sera. Sera with OD values >0·6 were considered as positive. Sera with OD values between 0·6 and 0·9 were interpreted as having low antibody titres, sera with OD values between 0·9 and 1·2 as medium antibody titres, and sera with OD values >1·2 were considered highly positive.
Statistical analyses
Prevalence is described as relative frequency with 95% confidence interval (95% CI). Differences between categorical variables were analysed by χ 2 test, in case of only two categories (2 × 2 contingency table), odds ratios (OR) with 95% CI were also calculated. Differences between continuous variables were analysed by Mann–Whitney test. The risk factors were first tested univariately by logistic regression with adjustment for confounders. Statistically significant predictors in univariate regression were, in meaningful cases, included in the multivariate regression model. A two-sided P value of 0·05 was considered statistically significant.
RESULTS
Seroprevalences in Roma and non-Roma populations
The final sample comprised 429 Roma and 394 non-Roma participants. The seropositivity to Toxocara in the Roma inhabitants of segregated settlements reached 22·1% (95% CI 18·5–26·3), while only four samples (1·0%, 95% CI 0·3–2·7) out of the majority population were found to be positive (P < 0·0001). Unadjusted relative risk (RR) of seropositivity to Toxocara in the Roma population was more than 21 times higher than in the non-Roma population (RR 21·07, OR 27·7, 95% CI 10·1–76·9). After adjustment (standardization) for age and sex the odds ratio was still significantly against the Roma population (OR 25·0, 95% CI 9·2–71·4).
Table 1 summarizes the baseline parameters in the study population and confirms significant differences in the lifestyle of the Roma and non-Roma populations in Slovakia. Roma participants were more frequently unemployed and unable to afford every-day living expenses, and attained a lower level of education. The average age of both analysed groups was similar (P = 0·043), reaching 34·7 ± 9·14 years in the Roma minority and 33·5 ± 7·41 years in the non-Roma population.
Baseline parameters of the cohort study
* Lacking at least one of the following items: sewage system, water supply, flushing toilet, bathroom or shower, electricity supply.
† Inability to pay at least one of the following items: rent, loan payment, healthcare, electricity and water costs, other expenses.
Risk factors of Toxocara infection
The seropositivity to Toxocara varied with age, gender, education, employment and hygiene habits of analysed persons (Table 2). Risk factors for seropositivity to Toxocara were analysed by univariate logistic regression separately for Roma and non-Roma groups (Table 3). Gender, level of education and unemployment did not significantly influence the prevalence of antibodies. Moreover, poverty and living in non-brick houses were not found to be significant risk factors for Toxocara seropositivity in the Roma population.
Occurrence of anti-Toxocara antibodies in relation to gender, age, education and employment
CI, Confidence interval.
Predictors of positivity to Toxocara for the Roma and non-Roma populations
Odds ratio; CI, confidence interval; n.a., not available/not calculated.
* Lacking at least one of the following items: sewage system, water supply, flushing toilet, bathroom or shower, electricity supply.
† Inability to pay at least one of the following items: rent, loan, healthcare, electricity and water costs, other expenses.
Roma people had a higher risk of being Toxocara seropositive with increasing age (OR 1·029 for each year, 95% CI 1·003–1·056) and the major risk factor for positivity to Toxocara in Roma people was the lack of household hygiene facilities. The lack of at least one of the following: sewage system, water supply, flushing toilet, bathroom/shower or electricity supply was found to be a significant predictor of positivity to Toxocara (OR 2·512, 95% CI 1·477–4·271). None of analysed predictors was found to be significant in the non-Roma population due to the low number of positive individuals (Table 3). Significant predictors of Toxocara seropositivity in Roma people (age and household facilities) were included in the multivariate regression model. Both predictors remained statistically significant with OR 2·422 (95% CI 1·418–4·139) for household facilities and 1·029 (95% CI 1·002–1·056) for age, which means they are independent from one another.
As a significant relationship between occurrence of anti-Toxocara antibodies and household facilities was detected, we further analysed this aspect in detail. Infection risk factors related to lifestyle and hygiene were evaluated only in Roma respondents, because all participants from the non-Roma population reported availability of adequate sanitary facilities. Table 4 shows the results of logistic regression analyses of individual risk factors associated with living conditions adjusted for age. The highest odds ratio for seropositivity to Toxocara was found in Roma people living without tap water, followed by individuals without flushing toilet, bathroom and sewage system. The unavailability of electricity was not found to be a significant predictor of seropositivity (P = 0·114). When combined in a multivariate regression model, only the lack of tap water remained independently associated with seropositivity (Table 5).
Influence of lack of sanitary facilities in Roma households on seropositivity to Toxocara
aOR, Age-adjusted odds ratio; CI, confidence interval.
Multivariate regression model of Toxocara seropositivity predictors related to lack of sanitary facilities
OR, Odds ratio; CI, confidence interval.
Analyses also revealed the influence of heating system on the occurrence of antibodies to Toxocara in the Roma minority. Out of 95 seropositive individuals, significantly more (93·7%) participants used wood for heating compared to the seronegative group (84·4%, P = 0·01). Age-adjusted odds ratio showed that using wood for heating increased the chance for Toxocara seropositivity almost fourfold. On the other hand, the odds ratio of seropositivity in individuals who usually used radiators for heating was more than 80% lower compared to those who used other materials. We performed no multivariate regression due to the high degree of intercorrelation between two significant predictors (wood and radiators; R = 0·473, P < 0·0001) (Table 6).
Influence of use of different heating materials in Roma households on positivity to Toxocara
aOR, Age-adjusted odds ratio; CI, confidence interval.
Clinical symptoms
In Toxocara-seropositive individuals (both Roma and non-Roma participants grouped together) the occurrence of clinical symptoms was analysed. Out of symptoms that could be related to Toxocara infection, headache, muscle pain, influenza-like symptoms and diarrhoea occurred significantly more frequently in persons with anti-Toxocara antibodies than in negative individuals. These symptoms, except diarrhoea, remained significantly associated with the presence of antibodies to Toxocara even after adjustment for age and sex, but the frequency of symptoms did not correlate with the antibody titres. The occurrence of some neurological or psychological disorders that could indicate the presence of neurotoxocarosis did not differ significantly between the seropositive and seronegative groups (Table 7).
Occurrence of clinical signs and symptoms related to human toxocarosis in persons positive and negative to Toxocara. Age- and sex-adjusted univariate regression.
OR, Odds ratio; CI, confidence interval.
DISCUSSION
Toxocarosis is one of the most widespread parasitozoonoses that humans share with dogs, cats and a range of wild definitive hosts, particularly foxes. It is prevalent primarily in the tropics and subtropics and in less industrialized nations, but it is also an important cause of morbidity in developed countries, especially in children and socioeconomically disadvantaged populations [Reference Torgerson, Budke, Smith and Smith10–Reference Macpherson12]. The Roma people are considered to be a socioeconomically disadvantaged minority; their health status, particularly those living in settlements, is heavily compromised by poor living conditions, low educational level, unemployment, poverty, segregation and discrimination [Reference Vašečka and Džambazovič13, Reference Ginter14]. In this study, the prevalence of antibodies to Toxocara in respondents from the non-Roma population was only 1·0%, while in the Roma minority it was as high as 22·1%. This result highlights the differences between the two population groups. In Slovakia, Toxocara seropositivity detected in studies focused exclusively, or mostly so, on non-Roma populations ranges between 1·3% observed in randomly chosen healthy persons [Reference Škutová, Oros and Vasilková15] and 5·5% detected in women with habitual abortions [Reference Pavlinová16] and 8·4% in pregnant women from the Bratislava region [Reference Ondriska17]. These data are similar to results observed in other European countries. In Austria, 6·3% of individuals volunteering for military service tested positive for Toxocara [Reference Poeppl18], in Italy 6·6% positivity in 201 healthy persons was reported by Nicoletti et al. [Reference Nicolleti19] and 2·4% prevalence was recorded in Denmark [Reference Stensvold20]. However, in populations living in poor social and hygiene conditions seropositivity is usually higher. Seropositivity in rural settlers in Brazilian Amazonia reached 28·6% [Reference Rubinsky-Elefant21]; Ajayi et al. [Reference Ajayi22] found 30·4% seroprevalence in adults from Nigeria and 31·6% of positive individuals were detected in three provinces of Patagonia [Reference Fillaux23].
The prevalence of Toxocara spp. in humans is influenced by environmental, geographical, cultural and socioeconomic factors at the population level; and by age, gender, nutrition, behaviour, susceptibility to infection and genetics at the individual level [Reference Macpherson12, Reference Viney and Graham24]. In this study positivity was not influenced by gender of either tested population groups. Similarly, unemployment and inability to pay normal living expenses (poverty) were not found to be predictors of human toxocarosis.
Education level is considered to be related to behaviour, health conditions and access to knowledge that can have direct and indirect impacts on activities that can increase the risk of infection [Reference Hussain25]. It has been confirmed that education level influences the risk of some infectious diseases, e.g. cystic echinococcosis [Reference Bingham26] or human papillomavirus infection [Reference Franceschi27]. Although some correlation between the level of education and the seropositivity of Roma respondents was expected, the level of completed education did not influence the prevalence of antibodies. It can be assumed that higher and better education of the Roma people did not change their hygiene consciousness or habits. By contrast, in the USA Won et al. [Reference Won28] observed an association between education of the head of household and Toxocara positivity. They found that the higher level of completed education decreased the seroprevalence of antibodies in family members.
In this study, age appears to be a significant risk factor of Toxocara infestation in the Roma participants. Each year of age increases the chance of Toxocara seropositivity by 1·029 times (P = 0·029). Usually, young age is considered to be the prominent risk factor of infection [Reference Rubinsky-Elefant21, Reference Fan29], but children were not included in our study. The positive correlation of seroprevalence with age observed in adult Roma participants is probably related to high infectious pressure of an environment contaminated with Toxocara spp. eggs. Cumulative effect of repeated infections that elicits the increase of seroprevalence with age was observed also in studies provided in populations with poor sanitary levels [Reference Fillaux23, Reference Magnaval30].
Analysis of infection of risk factors in Roma participants revealed a very strong association between household sanitary facilities and occurrence of antibodies. People who had no access to a sewage system, tap water, flushing toilet and bathroom were positive significantly more often than persons with better equipped homes. The risk of infection was highest in people without tap water, followed by people without a flushing toilet, bathroom and sewage system in their homes. Similarly to our results, a study from La Réunion confirmed the absence of water supply to be a risk factor of Toxocara infection while type of housing did not influence the positivity of inhabitants [Reference Magnaval30].
Another interesting result was the influence of the type of heating on seropositivity. People that used wood for heating were positive significantly more often than those who used coal, petrol or oil, with almost a fourfold increased risk of being seropositive. We assume that collection and handling of wood, which is often contaminated by soil, together with inadequate hygiene habits and limited access to water significantly increases the possibility of acquiring infection. This assumption also supports the finding of significantly lower prevalence of antibodies in people using electric radiators for heating. The odds ratio of seropositivity in individuals that use radiators was more than 80% lower than in those who used other materials. Several authors have studied risk factors of toxocarosis in humans. Deutz et al. [Reference Deutz31] discovered a correlation between some occupations and Toxocara antibody prevalence. The risk of infection in farmers, veterinarians, slaughterhouse workers and hunters was higher than that in a control group. Dog ownership and occupational animal contact were also significantly associated with a higher risk of seropositivity to Toxocara [Reference Poeppl18, Reference Won28]. Higher prevalence of antibodies was recorded in people from rural areas (11·0%) than in those from urban settings (6·6%) [Reference Ondriska17].
Human Toxocara infections are usually clinically asymptomatic. The clinical picture of the most common generalized form, VLM syndrome, includes fever, abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhoea, respiratory signs, cough, anorexia, weight loss, fatigue and neurological manifestations [Reference Macpherson12, Reference Fillaux and Magnaval32]. In this study, headache, muscle pain and influenza-like symptoms occurred significantly more often in Toxocara-positive individuals. Incidence of some neurological or psychological disturbances did not differ significantly between the group of seropositive and seronegative participants.
The life of the Roma minority in segregated settlements consists of a high concentration of people and animals. Poverty, a serious problem of people living in segregated settlements, affects almost every aspect of life of the inhabitants. Inadequate hygiene habits are also frequently described as occurring in the Roma minority [Reference Hubková33]. Settlements often lack access to drinking water, sewage, waste pits, sanitary facilities and garbage disposal [Reference Rudohradská5]. The health status of humans as well as their healthcare is unsatisfactory. Available studies suggest the existence of barriers to access of healthcare and overuse of emergency care and underuse of preventative services in the Roma ethnic minority [Reference Földes and Covaci6, Reference Rodriguez and Derecho34]. Poverty was reported as the main barrier in accessing healthcare by almost 50% of the Roma population, compared to only 5% of the majority population [Reference Sedláková35]. The health status of animals in settlements is also often poor; dogs and cats are usually not treated and dewormed. In a study by Pipíková & Papajová [Reference Pipiková, Papajová, Oros and Vasilková36] more than 90% dog faecal samples contained eggs of at least one endoparasite species and T. canis eggs were found in 41·28% of samples. Prevalence of T. canis in dogs from selected settlements in the Košice and Prešov regions of Eastern Slovakia reached 45·2% [Reference Rudohradská, Papajová and Juriš37]. The soil in settlements is also heavily contaminated by propagative stages of pathogens. Rudohradská et al. [Reference Rudohradská, Papajová and Juriš37] found parasite eggs in 79·2% of 106 soil samples collected in five segregated settlements in Eastern Slovakia and the contamination by Toxocara spp. eggs ranged between 41·2% and 78·1%, with average prevalence of 57·3%. In a study by Štrkolcová et al. [Reference Štrkolcová, Goldová, Halánová and Prokeš38] Toxocara eggs were present in 30% of soil samples collected in a Roma settlement in the Košice region (Eastern Slovakia). By comparison, Toxocara eggs were not detected in any of 15 soil samples from urban area of Eastern Slovakia inhabited by non-Roma populations [Reference Pipiková, Papajová, Oros and Vasilková36]. These factors contribute to higher prevalence of human toxocarosis within the community and increase the possibility of repeated infections. We assume that besides the high prevalence of toxocarosis other parasitic and communicable diseases will also be more prevalent in populations living in segregated settlements.
CONCLUSION
The Roma populations of segregated settlements live in close contact with an environment contaminated by propagative parasite stages. In the present study, a significantly higher seroprevalence of Toxocara infection in the Roma minority than in non-Roma population was confirmed. Positivity was not influenced by gender, level of education or poverty of the Roma people, but age, lack of sanitary facilities and using wood for heating significantly increased the risk of infection. Factors such as lack of hygiene, high number of domestic animals and inadequate treatment of animals and humans contribute to the high prevalence of infectious diseases in the Roma population. This is connected not only with a negative impact on their health status and higher costs of treatment but also with an increased risk of spreading communicable diseases, particularly in view of the increased rate of travel of this ethnic minority observed throughout the European Union.
APPENDIX. HepaMeta Team
Peter Jarčuška, Andrea Madarasová Gecková, Mária Mareková, Daniel Pella, Leonard Siegfried, Pavol Jarčuška, Lýdia Pastvová, Ján Fedačko, Jana Kollárová, Peter Kolarčik, Daniela Bobáková, Zuzana Veselská, Ingrid Babinská, Sylvia Dražilová, Jaroslav Rosenberger, Ivan Schréter, Pavol Kristian, Eduard Veselíny, Martin Janičko, Ladislav Virág, Anna Birková, Marta Kmet'ová, Monika Halánová, Darina Petrášová, Katarína Cáriková, Viera Lovayová, Lucia Merkovská, Lucia Jedličková, Ivana Valková.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This research was supported by Slovak Grant Agency VEGA, project no. 2/0127/13 and partially supported by the Research and Development Support Agency, contract no. APVV-00-032-11; the Agency of the Slovak Ministry of Education for the Structural Funds of EU, project CEMIO-ITMS: 26220120058 (20%) and CEEPM-ITMS: 26220120067 (20%). This paper was also partially funded within the framework of the project ‘Social determinants of health in socially and physically disadvantaged and other groups of population’ (CZ.1·07/2·3·00/20·0063) and by Roche Slovensko, s.r.o.
DECLARATION OF INTEREST
None.
