Hostname: page-component-77f85d65b8-8wtlm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-03-29T21:19:02.237Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 February 2025

Bilal Hamamra
Affiliation:
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences, An-Najah National University, Nablus, Palestine
Fayez Mahamid*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences, An-Najah National University, Nablus, Palestine
Dana Bdier
Affiliation:
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences, An-Najah National University, Nablus, Palestine
Mai Atiya
Affiliation:
Psychological and Educational Counseling Department, Al-Quds Open University, Gaza Branch, Palestine
*
Corresponding author: Fayez Mahamid; Email: mahamid@najah.edu
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Israeli escalation of violence and oppression in Gaza, particularly following the events of October 7, 2023, has deepened the trauma and exacerbated the already grievous conditions of dispossession and exploitation faced by Palestinians. The present exploratory work sought to analyze war-related traumatic experiences among Gazans following the recent Israeli genocide against Gazans. Thirty participants (mean age for males = 32.45 years, SD = 10.13; mean age for females = 30.28 years, SD = 9.15; range 19–57) were recruited via snowball sampling. Interviews were analyzed through thematic content analysis. Thematic content analysis of the interview transcripts led to the identification of five main themes: (1) challenges and difficulties faced Gazans, (2) traumatic experiences related to war, (3) feelings and emotions among Gazans living in refugee camps, (4) how do Gazans perceive the future and (5) survival coping employed by Gazans following the on-going genocide against the Gaza Strip. The findings of this study highlight the profound humanitarian crisis in Gaza, calling for urgent attention to the ongoing crisis in Gaza and advocating for comprehensive humanitarian support and psychological interventions to address the deep-seated trauma and help rebuild lives shattered by conflict.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press

Author comment: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR1

Comments

Dear Editors,

We are glad to submit our paper entitled “War-related Trauma in Narratives of Gazans: Challenges, Difficulties, and Survival Coping”. The present exploratory work sought to analyze war-related traumatic experiences, challenges, difficulties, and survival coping among Gazans following the recent Israeli war on the Gaza Strip. Hoping the manuscript can be interesting for the readers of Global Mental Health Journal. All authors declare no conflicts of interest and agree for submitting to the journal.

Thank you for your gentle support,

Yours Sincerely,

Fayez Mahamid (on behalf of the co-authors).

Review: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR2

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

This paper is exceptionally well-executed and of immense interest. The scientific literature greatly benefits from publications that provide insight into the situation in Gaza following these 11 months of what can be described as genocide. The work is written in a clear, concise, and thoroughly structured manner. The introduction is comprehensive, up-to-date, and deeply explores the complex connections surrounding colonial trauma. The interviews presented are highly compelling, and I eagerly anticipate the publication of this work so that I can reference it in my own research. I commend the authors for undertaking such a challenging project.

There are, however, two minor suggestions for improvement. First, it might be valuable to include a brief paragraph regarding the authors' positionality. Are they Palestinian, or are they from other countries with a focus on Palestine? This information would be beneficial to the reader. Lastly, two very small issues: please review the punctuation and formatting (occasionally there are capitalizations where they shouldn’t be, or inconsistent line spacing), and on page 6, line 36, there is a missing reference.

Review: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR3

Conflict of interest statement

no competing interests

Comments

This paper is a well-written and methodologically sound contribution to the scientific literature. The insights it provides into the situation in Gaza are particularly valuable, especially given the context of recent and ongoing conflicts. The work is clear, concise, and well-structured overall. The introduction offers a comprehensive and current exploration of the complex connections surrounding colonial trauma. However, due to the density of the material, the introduction could benefit from the addition of one or two paragraphs with subheadings to help guide the reader more effectively.

I suggest renaming the initial section from “Theoretical Background” to “Introduction.” The current section does not present compelling theories that directly lead the research; instead, it provides a foundational overview that better fits the role of an introduction.

The interviews included in the study are compelling and add significant depth to the research. However, the discussion section could be improved by emphasizing the novelty of the work more prominently at the beginning. Highlighting the uniqueness of this research, especially considering it was conducted during an active conflict, will underscore its contribution to the field. It is crucial to clearly articulate how this study stands out and the new insights it provides in the context of ongoing conflict.

The value of this work is substantial, particularly in its timely and important examination of the situation in Gaza. The study is worthy of publication not only for its contribution to the academic discourse but also for its role in promoting Palestinian research and solidarity during such a challenging period. Emphasizing these aspects will enhance the recognition of the research’s significance and its impact on the field.

Additionally, the discussion and conclusion sections would benefit from incorporating more literature to support their statements and interpretations. Specifically, many articles—both empirical and theoretical—have been published regarding the suffering of Gaza’s population after October 7. Including references to these sources will strengthen the arguments and provide a more robust context for the findings.

More information about the sample selection process would also be helpful. Understanding how participants were chosen, especially in such a challenging environment, is crucial for assessing the study’s validity. Given the difficult circumstances surrounding data collection in Gaza, it would be beneficial for the authors to discuss how these challenges were addressed and managed during the research process.

While the description of the findings is concise, it could be expanded to provide additional context and analysis. In particular, incorporating research on the consequences of the events of October 7 on the Palestinian population would add further depth and relevance to the study.

In terms of ethics, the paper would benefit from a more detailed reflection on the principle of “do no harm.” This should include considerations of how the research design and implementation have safeguarded participants' well-being and minimized potential risks, given the sensitive nature of the topic and the context in which the study was conducted.

I also have a few minor suggestions:

It would be helpful to include a brief paragraph on the authors' positionality. Clarifying whether the authors are Palestinian or come from other countries with a focus on Palestine would provide important context for the reader.

Please review the punctuation and formatting, as there are instances of unnecessary capitalizations and inconsistent line spacing.

Additionally, I recommend checking the consistency between references cited in the text and those listed in the reference section, as it seems that some references might have been missed.

Finally, I suggest using the terms “displaced” or “internally displaced people” instead of “refugee” where applicable, as these terms may more accurately describe the population discussed in the study.

Overall, these are mild suggestions meant to enhance the clarity and impact of an already valuable contribution. The paper’s worthiness for publication, especially in such difficult times, underscores its importance in advancing Palestinian research and fostering solidarity.

Review: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR4

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

Great article and very relevant in this context.

Please review the keywords again.

Please ensure that the references are APA.

Recommendation: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR5

Comments

Please pay attention to all three reviewers' comments and kindly improve the manuscript, considering their input.

Decision: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R0/PR6

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Author comment: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R1/PR7

Comments

Dear Editors,

We are glad to submit our paper entitled “War-related Trauma in Narratives of Gazans: Challenges, Difficulties, and Survival Coping”. The present exploratory work sought to analyze war-related traumatic experiences, challenges, difficulties, and survival coping among Gazans following the recent Israeli war on the Gaza Strip. Hoping the manuscript can be interesting for the readers of Global Mental Health Journal. All authors declare no conflicts of interest and agree for submitting to the journal.

Thank you for your gentle support,

Yours Sincerely,

Fayez Mahamid (on behalf of the co-authors).

Review: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R1/PR8

Conflict of interest statement

no competing interests to disclose

Comments

The authors have addressed all the points raised in the previous review comprehensively and effectively. This paper is a well-written and methodologically sound contribution to the scientific literature. Its insights into the situation in Gaza are particularly valuable, especially given the context of recent and ongoing conflicts.

The introduction has been improved with the addition of subheadings, which enhance the structure and guide the reader more effectively. Renaming the initial section to “Introduction” was a good decision, as it now aligns better with the content’s purpose.

The discussion section now emphasizes the novelty of the work and its unique contribution, particularly given the challenges of conducting research during an active conflict. The inclusion of recent literature and references related to the events of October 7 has strengthened the analysis and contextualized the findings more robustly.

Additionally, the authors have clarified the sample selection process, addressed challenges related to data collection, and provided an expanded discussion of ethical considerations, including the principle of “do no harm.” The inclusion of a paragraph on the authors' positionality adds transparency and further contextualizes the study.

The formatting and reference inconsistencies have been resolved, and the terminology has been refined, ensuring greater accuracy and precision throughout the paper.

Overall, this study is a timely and significant contribution, advancing academic discourse and promoting Palestinian research during a critical period. I am pleased to recommend this work for publication.

Recommendation: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R1/PR9

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Decision: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R1/PR10

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Author comment: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R2/PR11

Comments

Dear Editors,

Thank you for your great efforts and constructive comments concerning our article entitled “War-related Trauma in Narratives of Gazans: Challenges, Difficulties, and Survival Coping”. These comments are valuable and beneficial for improving this article. We have tried our best to modify the manuscript to meet the requirements of your journal. In this revised version, changes to this manuscript within the document were all highlighted using red-coloured text. Point-by-point responses to the editors are listed below. If there are any other modifications we could do, we would like to modify them, and we appreciate your help

Comments

GMH-2024-0128.R1 entitled “War-related Trauma in Narratives of Gazans: Challenges, Difficulties, and Survival Coping” which you submitted to Cambridge Prisms: Global Mental Health, has been reviewed. The comments of the reviewer(s) are included at the bottom of this letter. The reviewer(s) have recommended publication, but also suggest some minor revisions to your manuscript. Therefore, I invite you to respond to the reviewer(s)' comments and revise your manuscript. In addition I recommend that you reduce your introduction to 1000-1500 words and instead share some of the challenges you faced in carrying out this research in that environment- you could touch on issues around adhering to your study protocol in the face of conflict and what mitigation strategies you had to put in place. I believe the readers will be interested in learning more about the practical issues around the study.Please also upload both clean and tracked changes versions of the manuscript.

We greatly appreciate your feedback and have reduced the introduction section, we also added to the methods section some challenges we faced in carrying this research (see pp. 12-13).

Reviewer: 1

Comments to the Author

The authors have addressed all the points raised in the previous review comprehensively and effectively. This paper is a well-written and methodologically sound contribution to the scientific literature. Its insights into the situation in Gaza are particularly valuable, especially given the context of recent and ongoing conflicts.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

The introduction has been improved with the addition of subheadings, which enhance the structure and guide the reader more effectively. Renaming the initial section to “Introduction” was a good decision, as it now aligns better with the content’s purpose.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

The discussion section now emphasizes the novelty of the work and its unique contribution, particularly given the challenges of conducting research during an active conflict. The inclusion of recent literature and references related to the events of October 7 has strengthened the analysis and contextualized the findings more robustly.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

Additionally, the authors have clarified the sample selection process, addressed challenges related to data collection, and provided an expanded discussion of ethical considerations, including the principle of “do no harm.” The inclusion of a paragraph on the authors' positionality adds transparency and further contextualizes the study.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

The formatting and reference inconsistencies have been resolved, and the terminology has been refined, ensuring greater accuracy and precision throughout the paper.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

Overall, this study is a timely and significant contribution, advancing academic discourse and promoting Palestinian research during a critical period. I am pleased to recommend this work for publication.

We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s positive feedback concerning our article

With best regards

Recommendation: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R2/PR12

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Decision: War-related trauma in narratives of Gazans: challenges, difficulties and survival coping — R2/PR13

Comments

No accompanying comment.