Introduction
The World Health Organization (WHO) has declared the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) disease caused by the novel coronavirus as a pandemic on 11 March 2020 3 months after it was initially detected in Wuhan, China, in December 2019. In India, it was initially detected in Kerala on 30 January 2020 among the students who returned from China and subsequently the number of positive cases as on 29 April 2020 has risen to 30,000 with 940 deaths. 1 At the same time, it had affected over 3 million people around the world with over 210,000 deaths. 2
The current pandemic has led to many fundamental patient safety issues. Most importantly, the patients with cancer must leave their homes to visit the cancer clinic and thereby possibly expose themselves to infection. Another issue is these patients are susceptible to the infections as they are at an immunosuppressed state due to malignancy and anti-cancer therapy. Hence, patients with cancer are more predisposed to get infected with COVID-19. The question that we need to answer is should patients risk exposure to the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome novel Corona Virus 2 (SARS-nCoV-2) in order to receive treatment for cancer? The available evidence is limited, but suggests that the symptoms of COVID-19 are probably more severe in patients with cancer than for those without. Reference Hanna, Evans and Booth3
It has also been shown that the mortality among the cancer patients is relatively high when compared to the normal population. Reference Wu, Nethery, Ma and Braun4 The case fatality rate for cancer patients in that cohort was notably higher than non-cancer patients at 5.6% versus 2.1% in the whole sample. Reference Wu, Nethery, Ma and Braun4 In another study by Liang et al., the patients with cancer were observed to have a higher risk of severe events (a composite endpoint defined as the percentage of patients being admitted to the intensive care unit requiring invasive ventilation, or death) compared with patients without cancer (39% vs. 8%), and the patients with cancer deteriorated more rapidly than those without cancer (median time to severe events, 13 days vs. 43 days). Reference Liang, Guan and Chen5
Tumours of the central nervous system (CNS) constitute about 1–3% of all malignancies, and they are a heterogeneous group as they differ widely in genetics and biology and they have various presentations and different clinical outcomes, depending on age, performance status, histology, surgery and postop adjuvant therapy received. Radiotherapy is an integral part in the management of brain tumour, either malignant or benign. Hence, it is vital to have guidelines on how to manage these patients.
We had decided to look at the impact of COVID-19 pandemic in neurooncology setting as it constitutes about 30% of our department clinics. Moreover, there are limited data in management of these tumours in the current scenario. Brain tumours usually require longer duration for surgery, require postop ICU care and these are the patients who are most likely to be neglected during the pandemic.
This article is to elucidate the radiotherapeutic management of patients with brain tumours during this COVID-19 pandemic. The various aspects about when to treat, when to safely avoid, how to triage and safety precautions to be taken during this period are detailed.
Our manuscript is intended to serve as a tool for consideration and certainly not as a strategy for permanent change in treatment patterns. The goal is to share options, as gathered collectively by our team, in both the management and surveillance of patients diagnosed with brain tumours during this time of global crisis in India.
In considering management of disease, we must recognise that in many centres across India and the globe, access to routine visits and surgery may be either completely restricted or significantly reduced. We must, therefore, formulate new options that we can offer our patients to address their disease limiting risk of exposure to the patients and healthcare workers.
Universal Precautions
Current evidence suggests that COVID-19 is spread by droplets and has an incubation period of 1–14 days. In a situation, such as now, when WHO has declared COVID-19 as a pandemic, even though India has not entered into community spread phase, it is necessary to consider each and every patient whom we treat to be as potentially positive until and unless it has been proven. Hence, it is imperative that we take necessary steps and precautions while providing care to all our patients.
The guiding principle of radiation safety is ALARA which stands for ‘as low as reasonably achievable’. This principle means that even if it is a small dose, though it may not have much chances of obvious effect, one should try to avoid it. 6 The same ALARA principle needs to be applied for patient care too during this scenario. Screening by front desk staff upon check-in and triage with nursing and physicians is necessary in order to protect the patients and to prevent possible exposures in both waiting rooms and treatment vaults from infected individuals.
Time
We need to reduce the number of patient visits to the hospital and time spent in the treatment facility. This could be achieved in the ways mentioned below.
-
1. Hypofractionated schedule whenever safely possible.
-
2. Avoid radiation (RT) whenever possible.
-
3. Do image verification on a necessity/protocol basis and not every day.
-
4. Maintain time and schedule patients for treatment to avoid crowding at waiting room.
Distance
-
1. Follow social distancing norms as advised by the government while making patients wait for their radiotherapy schedule.
-
2. Limit the number of staff/healthcare personnel in the treatment console area.
Shielding
-
1. Wear appropriate personal protective equipments (PPEs) as per the national standards; the patients should wear mask during waiting time.
-
2. Provide disinfectant/sanitisers/soap and water with hand wash facility for the patients at the entrance of treatment facility.
-
3. Clean/disinfect the treatment couch and common immobilisation devices at regular intervals (after every patient) and immediately when it appears soiled. This is important as the treatment machine is shared by many patients.
-
4. Do not place immobilisation masks one over another and make arrangements to keep them separately in separate pigeon holes whenever possible.
Specific scenarios
The recently published rapid COVID-19 NICE (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) guidelines say that the patients should be treated with radiotherapy only if it is ‘unavoidable’, and even then the ‘shortest safe form of treatment’ should be used. The guidance also advised that radiotherapy should be avoided if the evidence suggested that there would be ‘little to no benefit or if an alternative treatment is available’ or should be deferred if clinically appropriate. Reference Mahase7
We also recommend discussing the patient’s overall prognosis, survival estimates and goals of care with the patient and his/her family and neurosurgeon prior to determining a radiation plan with validated prognostic models available in the literature. For patients with an estimated life expectancy of days to weeks, best supportive care with medical therapies alone is encouraged. The treatment decision-making algorithm proposed during the COVID-19 pandemic is given in Figure 1. The suggested treatment options for brain tumours Reference Mulvenna, Nankivell and Barton8–Reference Combs, Thilmann, Huber, Hoess, Debus and Schulz-Ertner23 are enlisted in Table 1.
Treatment decision-making algorithm for patients with brain tumours during COVID-19 pandemic.
Suggested treatment options for brain tumors during the COVID-19 pandemic
Care of patients during treatment and follow-up
For patients requiring care while receiving RT, visits could be arranged with the designated rotating radiation oncology healthcare providers during the day. Whenever face to face outpatient consultations are done, we need to ensure that all patients, caregivers and healthcare professionals adhere to institutional policies on social distancing, hand washing, using appropriate PPE to reduce the risk of exposure of staff and patients.
We also recommend teleconsultations and use of photographs sent via emails to assess the skin reactions and if needed could send drug prescriptions to patients. Reference Hollander and Carr24 The patients who are on routine follow-ups need to be advised to postpone their follow-up visit by another 3–4 months. Our experience on such methods showed that the patients were extremely happy and were relieved of the stress that they do not need to come to the hospital unless it is necessary.
Corticosteroids Usage
Steroids are most commonly used among brain tumour patients receiving radiotherapy. There have been reports stating that non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and corticosteroids may exacerbate symptoms in COVID-19 patients. But some evidence has also showed that corticosteroids may be beneficial if utilised in the early acute phase of infection. Given the current availability of literature, we should exercise caution while using corticosteroids until further evidence emerges. Reference Russell, Moss, Rigg and Van Hemelrijck25,Reference Kaiser, Mirmira and Stewart26
Conclusion
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, it is important to support our patient’s emotional wellbeing and ensuring that adequate psychosocial support systems are in place would be more important than ever. We should also not forget that safety is of foremost importance and all measures to prevent spread/transmission of COVID-19 disease such as provision of adequate and appropriate PPEs to the healthcare workers and ensuring availability of hand sanitisers. Treatment decisions made during the COVID-19 pandemic rely on the safety first/do no harm principle and evidence-based prioritisation of cases for triage. The 2019-nCoV outbreak in India is ongoing at the time of writing, with lockdown procedures and border controls being employed by the Indian government, as well as neighbouring countries. We are continuously reviewing our measures in response to the dynamic situation, in order to provide efficient and safe care for our patients.
Acknowledgements
None.
Financial Support
None.
Conflicts of Interest
None.
Open access
